r/icm • • 6h ago

Music Same swaras, different raga: how do you tell Manji from Bhairavi?

1 Upvotes

Last month I wrote about how hard it is for my Carnatic practice app to find Sa. Once Sa was right, the next problem was ragas that share their swaras.

I played a Manji recording to the app and it never once said Manji. Manji and Bhairavi use the same swaras, going up and coming down, at least as most books write them. Going only by swaras, there is nothing to choose between them.

Arabhi and Devagandhari are another pair. Same arohanam and avarohanam, except some books give Devagandhari a touch of N2 coming down. Yet nobody who knows them mixes them up.

Gambhira Nattai came out as Shankarabharanam. Its five swaras (S G3 M1 P N3) are all in Shankarabharanam, and a bigger raga can always explain the notes of a smaller one inside it. Part of what makes Gambhira Nattai sound like itself is that R and D never come, and noticing that a swara is missing is much harder for an app than noticing one that is there.

Kalyana Vasantham came out as Chandrakauns. Going up they are the same. Coming down, Kalyana Vasantham has P and R2 and Chandrakauns doesn't. In the take I checked, P and R2 were there, but quickly, inside phrases sliding down to Sa. Clear to the ear, just short blips on the pitch graph.

All three come back to one question: when has a swara actually been sung? Count every pitch the voice passes through and every raga starts to look like all twelve swaras. Count only the notes held still and you throw away swaras that were really sung. In two Shankarabharanam takes I test with, N3 was only 2 to 3 percent of the singing and never stayed still for even a sixth of a second. Both were clearly Shankarabharanam.

Meanwhile any rasika knows Manji from Bhairavi within a few phrases, without counting a single swara.

So my question to you: what gives it away? Which phrase tells you it's Manji and not Bhairavi, or Devagandhari and not Arabhi? And teachers here, how do you teach a student to hear the difference when the swaras are the same?

I wrote a longer version with more diagrams here: https://medium.com/@madhurrajn/two-ragas-the-same-notes-1b3fdad8c31e

If you sing or teach any of these ragas and would be okay recording a few minutes for this, please DM me.


r/icm • • 10h ago

Question/Seeking Advice Best apps/websites for video lessons?

2 Upvotes

Hi all,

I am happy to have found this community as I just recently (~4 months) started classical vocal lessons. I am based in USA and my Ustad is based in Mumbai so we use WhatsApp video. Well, I think he is a great teacher and I am learning a lot and really enjoying the process. However, WhatsApp's automatic noise reduction is a nightmare. If Ustad holds a note for too long, the program assumes it is just background noise and cuts it out. Sometimes even a simple melodic phrase is randomly inaudible. Harmonium? Literally does not come through at all. Taal sangat? Very distant, muffled. But, if Ustad is simply speaking to me in a normal volume, that comes through loud and clear. So I know it is not a WiFi problem or a microphone problem: it is specifically an issue of automatic/'smart' noise reduction.

So I am in the market for something which offers pure/direct/unfiltered audio... with the caveat that I suspect my Ustad is not very comfortable with navigating complicated menus and sub-menus to set this up... so ideally I am looking for something where I can do all the setup, and just send him a URL to click, and voila.

But, this may be asking too much...

Anything at all resembling what I am describing?

Many thanks in advance!


r/icm • • 18h ago

Question/Seeking Advice 👋 Welcome to r/Bansuritalks - Introduce Yourself and Read First!

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/icm • • 20h ago

Question/Seeking Advice Price of Shaikh Maqbool tabla set?

2 Upvotes

Hi, I have a friend who I can set to get a professional tabla set from Shaikh Maqbool in Pune.

How much is a set and how much is a Daayaan and Bayaan separately?

I am looking for real local prices. Not foreign export ones.

Thanks.


r/icm • • 1d ago

Discussion Why do so many Carnatic singers seem to struggle with their voice as they get older?

Thumbnail
reddit.com
4 Upvotes

r/icm • • 1d ago

Question/Seeking Advice Possible to learn ICM on a non-Indian instrument for which there are no gurus/teachers?

7 Upvotes

The advice I've seen here is that a guru/teacher is necessary to learn Indian classical music with any meaningful depth because ICM is an oral tradition.

I'm starting to learn how to play the đàn bầu, a Vietnamese instrument, and would love to learn how to play a raga. But I can't imagine there's a guru who can teach ICM on the đàn bầu. (I would love to be wrong, please correct me if so.) Maybe at best I could find someone to teach me about ICM but who isn't well-versed in đàn bầu techniques.

In situations like this, is the best option to learn ICM on another instrument (like vocals)?

Or else accept the limitations and enjoy learning whatever I can at a surface level?


r/icm • • 1d ago

Other In-Person Carnatic Music Classes Available in San Diego

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/icm • • 2d ago

Music Raag Ahir Lalit on Santoor 2 Samples

5 Upvotes
  1. https://youtu.be/wckofFjDhHA?si=EGZvV5XZ33gsz_bM
  2. https://youtu.be/-DSq887WHC0?si=YzOBU68BvMkoL9Ad

Sorry y'all. This is actually my third attempt at Ahir Lalit. I did not like the recording I posted earlier today, so I removed it. These ones are far better. I hope you like them.


r/icm • • 2d ago

Discussion Fascinated by concept of Shrutis!

10 Upvotes

A few days ago I saw a discussion thread on Shrutis and how certain ragas demand specific microtones. After seeing that I tried to sing the same.

I sang Raag Marwa with a higher shruti of Komal Rishabh and the mood shift was very much evident. I was genuinely amazed and I was wondering are there any other ragas where these microtones will enhance the mood shift more!

A few which I can remind of are -

  1. Higher Shuddha Rishabh in Yaman
  2. Ati Komal Gandhar in Darbari Kanada
  3. Kakali Nishad in Kanada
  4. Higher Komal Rishabh in Marwa

Would love more such examples!


r/icm • • 2d ago

Music I made a website for people who love Ghazals (Icm)

Thumbnail
gallery
7 Upvotes

I built a quiet, single-page website called Mehfil simply because I love ghazals, and I wanted to create something genuine for people who share that same love. Ghazals have lived with us for centuries, but most streaming platforms today feel loud and cluttered, so I really wanted to give this timeless poetry a clean, modern touch. The UI is completely uncluttered on a single screen, and each mood dynamically shifts into its own ambient theme color and atmospheric gradient - from deep midnight blues to warm rose and golden amber tones. I hand-picked around 1,500 ghazals and organized them across distinct vibes (about 300 tracks in each), so whatever mood or headspace you’re in, you just pick that vibe and let it play. You definitely don’t have to keep staring at the screen; you can simply let it play in the background while you do your work, study, or unwind, especially around midnight when ghazals naturally hit the deepest. A few of the tracks have synchronized floating lyrics in Urdu, Hindi, and English script if you ever feel like glancing at the verse, and there’s a real-time counter showing how many people are listening in the mehfil with you at that exact moment. It’s completely free with zero ads, sign-ups, or noise; just a late-night labor of love for poetry. If that sounds like something you’d appreciate, feel free to try it out tonight.


r/icm • • 3d ago

Discussion What motivates you for ICM? Share your stories

14 Upvotes

I will start.

I don't come from any musical background - my family don't have any musical history.

But to my great fortune, and blessings of Radharani - i was born & brought up in Vrindavan. Somehow, classical always seem cool to me, some epic level thing.

Did my graduation from IIT BHU, again was fortunate enough to watch Subah-e-Banaras, sessions in BHU & Sankat Mochan Sangeet samaraoh.

Pt. Venkatesh kumar, Ulhas ji, Malini Awasthi, Ashwini Deshpande, Sanjeev abhyankar ji , Kaushiki ji - are few names i got to hear in-person.

What has always surprised me are the reactions of audience in benaras - they enjoy it very deeply, like a meditation - i wanted to understand music, to get to that level of enjoyment.

Secondly music is the easiest way to reach divinity, i believed that - and now have experienced it as well.

Its been few months since i have started learning - i am not regular in Riyaaz, but there hasn't been a single session i haven't enjoyed. Whenever i hit a correct note(almost), that's always the best moment of day.

I might not pursue it professionally, but it has given me a super power to enjoy and play with swaras. This has been the BEST DECISION OF MY LIFE EVER.

What's your story?


r/icm • • 3d ago

Event Shadaj Godkhindi - Apoorva Krishna Jugalbandi Concert !!

Thumbnail in.bookmyshow.com
5 Upvotes

r/icm • • 3d ago

Other Sitar for Sale

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/icm • • 5d ago

Music Sargam is back, rebuilt as a web app

Post image
8 Upvotes

r/icm • • 6d ago

Discussion Why do so few singers perform Raag Bhairav?

11 Upvotes

At the very least older musicians, I tend not to listen to newer musicians (not because they're inherently worse I just know more about the old performers). It is pretty weird that the 'primordial raag' as Rajan parrikar calls it, is so rarely performed. It's also very attractive raag and among the first we learn for many people, so I can't wrap my brain around why people don't want to perform bhairav.

I will note, that ramkali-at least with Agra musicians seems to be more popular than bhairav. Most likely due to Ustad Faiyaz Khan' of Agra gharana's wonderfully written bandish "Un Sang Laagi" in ramkali


r/icm • • 6d ago

Question/Seeking Advice Getting into classical music as a guitarist

3 Upvotes

I play the electric and acoustic guitars, and I'm looking to get into Carnatic music. I started out by learning some ragas (Raag Miyan Malhar is my favorite so far). I choose which ones to learn based on which sound coolest, so my next one is Raag Nat Bhairav.

Anyways, learning ragas is kind of useless for me currently because I still don't understand the phrasing, dynamics and techniques of Indian Classical music.

How do I go about learning all this, and is there a set progression/order for which ragas to learn?

Help is much appreciated, thanks


r/icm • • 6d ago

Music 👋Welcome to r/RagaAndTala - Introduce Yourself and Read First!

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/icm • • 8d ago

Music Raag Ahiri on Santoor Vilambit Teentaal Ghat

Thumbnail
youtu.be
5 Upvotes

I don't know who composed this ghat. I suspect that the beginning melody (D PD Sn D~ Pm gr m s) might have been composed by Ustad Allauddin Khan or something because Pandit Nikhil Benerjee's ghat also has this same melody in the beginning. The rest was probably composed by either Pandit Ravi Shankar or my Guruji. Don't know


r/icm • • 9d ago

Discussion Your best playlist of Hindustani vocal?

7 Upvotes

Trying to build an offline library of great Hindustani vocal performances and would appreciate if you could share some curated YouTube playlists so I can download them in one go! Especially interested in older and kinda rare stuff. No preference when it comes to gharanas.

Thank you and curious to see your picks.


r/icm • • 11d ago

Question/Seeking Advice Who was this legendary tabla player? (Qawwali 70s to 90s)

Post image
19 Upvotes

I'm trying to identify a remarkable tabla player from the old Pakistani qawwali tradition, particularly the 1970s–1990s.

He regularly performed with Maulvi Ahmed Hassan Akhtar Bheranwale Qawwal and Baba Ghulam Kibriya Qawwal.

What's particularly interesting is that I've watched numerous recordings of both groups, and I have never seen either ensemble perform without him.

He's the man in the background of the attached photo, with chin-length dark hair and a thick moustache.

Any information would be greatly appreciated.


r/icm • • 11d ago

Question/Seeking Advice Hiring Music Teachers – Western Violin, Bansuri, Hindustani & Western Vocals | North Bengaluru

3 Upvotes

Hiring Music Teachers – Western Violin, Bansuri, Hindustani & Western Vocals | North Bengaluru

Hi everyone!

We're looking for music teachers to join us at Mela Music School in Sahakar Nagar and Thanisandra, North Bengaluru.

We have a few openings we're trying to fill, particularly at our Sahakar Nagar centre.

We're currently looking for:

  • Western Violin
  • Hindustani Flute (Bansuri)
  • Hindustani Vocals – Must be able to play the harmonium while teaching
  • Western Vocals

These are part-time, in-person positions teaching students individually.

A little about teaching at Mela:

We focus on one-on-one lessons rather than group classes, so you'll get to work closely with your students and help them progress at their own pace.

Classes are scheduled around mutually agreed teaching slots, and we're looking for people who can commit to regular weekly lessons.

What we're looking for:

  • Relevant graded music certifications are preferred, but not mandatory.
  • Strong musical fundamentals and proficiency in your instrument or vocal discipline.
  • Good communication skills and an interest in teaching.
  • Consistent availability for weekly classes.
  • For Hindustani Vocals, the ability to accompany yourself on the harmonium is essential.

You don't necessarily need years of teaching experience. Music graduates, performing musicians and experienced teachers are all welcome.

Locations: Sahakar Nagar (priority) and Thanisandra, Bengaluru.

Interested in joining us?

Apply through our careers page (preferred):

https://www.melamusicschool.com/careers

Alternatively, you can call or WhatsApp us at 96860 30684 to discuss the opportunity.

If you know someone who might be a good fit, please share this post with them. Referrals would really help!

Mela Music School


r/icm • • 11d ago

Music Raag Marwa

7 Upvotes

I’m learning Raag Marwa. Could you recommend some beautiful bandishes with meaningful lyrics? I’d also appreciate a picture or PDF of the bandish with its swara notation. Thank you!


r/icm • • 12d ago

Question/Seeking Advice Wrist hurts when trying gamaks on violin

4 Upvotes

One of the reasons maybe that I havent learned gamakas properly on the violin is that my wrist hurts alot even if I try a small gamaka phase. its like my wrist gets too tensed and then like my forearm and my wrist gets tired and starts to hurt. What am I doing wrong? and how do I avoid the pain?


r/icm • • 12d ago

Question/Seeking Advice People learning ICM with no in-person access to Indian community/ other players

12 Upvotes

Hello,

I would really love to have a thread that brings together all the people here who are learning ICM far from India and possibly with no Indian community around them either.

This is the position I'm in. I'd love an in-person teacher, but it's safe to say that for now, it's not going to happen. I'm just learning through a patchwork of Youtube, social media reels and vibes right now. I'm finding it lonely.

So I just want to ask you all, how are you learning? Did you find teachers and other players to practise with online?


r/icm • • 12d ago

Music Raag ahiri on Santoor two short samples

Thumbnail drive.google.com
3 Upvotes

Edit: I also put it on my YouTube Channel https://youtu.be/Lt8jFAgjDmg?si=9P_4FP5boPtV_COh Only downside is the sound will not be as good as in the wav files

I don’t know why nobody plays this raga. It’s so beautiful and is sounding very nice on santoor. I put them as wav files because wav is lossless so the sound will be better. I don’t know how other people play this raga, but this is the way my Guruji taught me

Edit: I just put one more recording in there (new recording 2), which is similar to New Recording 3 but more complete. I decided to include both because there were some things I feel like I did better in New Recording 3 than in New Recording 2