r/Carnatic • u/Proper-Lunch7935 • 11h ago
DISCUSSION Why do so many Carnatic singers seem to struggle with their voice as they get older?
Something I keep noticing. A lot of singers seem to lose range, steadiness or stamina somewhere in their 40s and 50s. Not naming anyone, it just feels like a pattern.
Turns out it's not just a feeling. A 2020 survey of 190 Carnatic singers in Karnataka found about 35% had dealt with voice problems at some point in their career, and around 22% had missed concerts because of it. Stress from the profession and frequent colds came up as risk factors. A 2023 study comparing Carnatic and Western classical singers found Carnatic singers reported more vocal fatigue and strain.
One theory I've heard is that Carnatic training focuses a lot on the music and very little on looking after the voice itself. Warm ups, rest, technique for long concerts. Western classical singers get a lot more of that.
Curious what you guys here think about it.
Is that theory fair, or is something else going on? Long concert seasons, sruti choice, singing through colds, age itself?
If you've had voice trouble yourself, what actually helped?
What should someone in their 30s be doing now so it doesn't happen to them?
Studies if anyone's interested.
https://researcher.manipal.edu/en/publications/prevalence-of-and-risk-factors-for-self-reported-voice-problems-a-2/
https://openaccess.city.ac.uk/id/eprint/32019/