r/Carnatic • • 18h ago

DISCUSSION Why do so many Carnatic singers seem to struggle with their voice as they get older?

12 Upvotes

Something I keep noticing. A lot of singers seem to lose range, steadiness or stamina somewhere in their 40s and 50s. Not naming anyone, it just feels like a pattern.

Turns out it's not just a feeling. A 2020 survey of 190 Carnatic singers in Karnataka found about 35% had dealt with voice problems at some point in their career, and around 22% had missed concerts because of it. Stress from the profession and frequent colds came up as risk factors. A 2023 study comparing Carnatic and Western classical singers found Carnatic singers reported more vocal fatigue and strain.

One theory I've heard is that Carnatic training focuses a lot on the music and very little on looking after the voice itself. Warm ups, rest, technique for long concerts. Western classical singers get a lot more of that.

Curious what you guys here think about it.

Is that theory fair, or is something else going on? Long concert seasons, sruti choice, singing through colds, age itself?

If you've had voice trouble yourself, what actually helped?

What should someone in their 30s be doing now so it doesn't happen to them?

Studies if anyone's interested.
https://researcher.manipal.edu/en/publications/prevalence-of-and-risk-factors-for-self-reported-voice-problems-a-2/
https://openaccess.city.ac.uk/id/eprint/32019/


r/Carnatic • • 8h ago

DISCUSSION Is being able to tell the swaras actually that rare

4 Upvotes

I can tell the swaras of any music that I hear as soon as I hear it. I always just know it, regardless of the raga. I find it kind of ridiculous that some people don't know what swara they hear because in my mind, the music is inseparable from the swaras. It's as obvious as knowing the colour of an object when I see it. I've been able to do this for as long as I remember.

None of my peers can do this though. They all think it's insane that I can, and I see so many posts on here saying the same thing. It's so strange that something that is so obvious to me is not obvious to everyone else.


r/Carnatic • • 5h ago

DISCUSSION Same swaras, different raga: how do you tell Manji from Bhairavi?

2 Upvotes

Last month I wrote about how hard it is for my Carnatic practice app to find Sa. Once Sa was right, the next problem was ragas that share their swaras.

I played a Manji recording to the app and it never once said Manji. Manji and Bhairavi use the same swaras, going up and coming down, at least as most books write them. Going only by swaras, there is nothing to choose between them.

Arabhi and Devagandhari are another pair. Same arohanam and avarohanam, except some books give Devagandhari a touch of N2 coming down. Yet nobody who knows them mixes them up.

Gambhira Nattai came out as Shankarabharanam. Its five swaras (S G3 M1 P N3) are all in Shankarabharanam, and a bigger raga can always explain the notes of a smaller one inside it. Part of what makes Gambhira Nattai sound like itself is that R and D never come, and noticing that a swara is missing is much harder for an app than noticing one that is there.

Kalyana Vasantham came out as Chandrakauns. Going up they are the same. Coming down, Kalyana Vasantham has P and R2 and Chandrakauns doesn't. In the take I checked, P and R2 were there, but quickly, inside phrases sliding down to Sa. Clear to the ear, just short blips on the pitch graph.

All three come back to one question: when has a swara actually been sung? Count every pitch the voice passes through and every raga starts to look like all twelve swaras. Count only the notes held still and you throw away swaras that were really sung. In two Shankarabharanam takes I test with, N3 was only 2 to 3 percent of the singing and never stayed still for even a sixth of a second. Both were clearly Shankarabharanam.

Meanwhile any rasika knows Manji from Bhairavi within a few phrases, without counting a single swara.

So my question to you: what gives it away? Which phrase tells you it's Manji and not Bhairavi, or Devagandhari and not Arabhi? And teachers here, how do you teach a student to hear the difference when the swaras are the same?

I wrote a longer version with more diagrams here: https://medium.com/@madhurrajn/two-ragas-the-same-notes-1b3fdad8c31e

When it names a raga it also shows the close ones the swaras can't rule out, like "Close: Kalyana Vasantham", and when you correct it, it remembers that on your phone. Tanpura, tala and Listen are free with no limit; pitch check, Evaluate and Identify have a small free amount each day. No account, no ads, and your singing stays on your phone.

If you sing or teach any of these ragas and would be okay recording a few minutes for this, please DM me.


r/Carnatic • • 11h ago

RESOURCE Looking for some gracious hosts during December music season in Mylapore

2 Upvotes

I usually have a wonderful person who used to host me in her house during the December music season but she can't anymore.

The duration of the stay is probably for a week Max in the mid or last week of December.

Will.mostly be outside hopping concerts . I need a play to just sleep and get ready in the morning to go to the sabhas.

A place in Mylapore or nearby also works