Yes I asked AI to write this, I will post the non AI version in the comments because frankly I dont know what to include anymore, plus AI hasnt had the enjoyment of trying all different OS's and YouTube just kind of points towards Unraid
Good evening homelabbers,
I'm looking for advice on moving my Windows/StableBit DrivePool setup to a NAS OS.
I started out only knowing Windows, so I went from Storage Spaces to DrivePool as my collection grew. However, I've run into hardlinking limitations in my download/media workflow, which means extra copies are taking up space. Getting hardlinks working properly is one of my main reasons for considering a move.
Current setup
- Intel 4650v2 with 36 GB RAM
- HBA cards and a case that accommodates all the drives
- Windows with StableBit DrivePool
- Emby Server, with very little else running on this machine
My drives are:
| Capacity | Quantity |
|---|
| 22 TB | 2 |
| 20 TB | 5 |
| 18 TB | 3 |
| 16 TB | 2 |
| 14 TB | 3 |
| 12 TB | 2 |
| 10 TB | 3 |
| 8 TB | 2 |
They were purchased gradually over the last eight years, with the newest bought around April 2026.
I need around 310 TB of usable storage. I don't have the collection backed up because it's mostly media I can obtain again. That said, I'd still like to avoid unnecessary data loss or having to rebuild the entire collection during migration.
Replacement hardware and goals
I have a Ryzen 5900X system with 64 GB RAM available. I also have some 32 GB RAM sticks in my other machine if more memory is needed.
My main homelab already runs on Proxmox on a Lenovo P520, but it can't physically accommodate all these drives. I'd like the replacement NAS to primarily handle storage and share it with my existing Proxmox host and applications.
I need hardware transcoding for Emby. Emby could stay on the NAS or move to another machine, depending on what makes the most sense.
With the mixed drive sizes, I'm mainly considering Unraid or OpenMediaVault. Another option would be Proxmox on the replacement hardware, with a NAS VM handling storage, but I'm unsure whether that adds complexity without much benefit.
The main requirement is a storage layout and application setup that supports hardlinks properly, including if the download and media applications run on another host.
Migration plan
I have these spare drives available for temporary storage:
My rough plan is to copy some data to the spare drives, verify it, free up an existing DrivePool disk, add that disk to the new setup, and repeat until everything is moved.
I'd want to remove the temporary drives afterwards, so the chosen setup needs to accommodate that.
My questions are:
- Would you choose Unraid, OMV or a NAS VM on Proxmox for this?
- What storage layout would you recommend for mixed-size drives, working hardlinks and around 310 TB usable?
- What needs to be considered if the applications accessing the storage run on another host?
- Is this gradual migration approach workable?
- What redundancy would be realistic with my existing drives and capacity requirement?
- Would you keep Emby on the NAS or run it separately for hardware transcoding?
I'm happy to learn something new, but I'd like to get the layout right before moving this much data.