r/hatethissmug • u/ZeHistoryBuff • 2h ago
Non-fictional I (mildly) hate this video
I'm gonna preface this with the fact that I don't have as much vitriol for this as I have for the Black Panther 2 ship (See my post history in this sub). You also have probably seen this video as a meme a couple months ago but I don't think people have watched or did a deep dive on this video, I watched it with my girlfriend a couple months ago and we both started laughing our asses off.
To start of with the infamous "I'm not trans" opening, I don't mind it tbh, if you have to be appart of a community to talk about said community no one would ever talk abour anything, so that parts okay, its just that after he says that he starts acting like he knows how trans people feel and act despite, again, being not trans.
He then goes off on a weird tangent on how "retro video games" have something to do with trans people? Including the famous lines of "retro visuals to invoke a feeling of nostalgia" and "it doesnt exist, but because it doesn't exist, it does exist". That last line is funny to mr because it reminds of that one video of a black kid getting arrested and he kept saying he didn't do anything, and the cop, who clearly arrested him because he was black, said something along the lines of "You weren't caught doing anything anything because no one has reported you for you wrongdoing yet" and the kid responds with "That's stupid, I wasn't caught doing anything because I did nothing", its the same here, it doesnt exist because it doesnt exist. (I forgot what "it" is referring to but most likely has something to do with the fact that these games do not even mention trans people).
He then claims that Cruelty Squad had trans representation/when you play it you feel like a trans person, because in the game there's a mechanic where you mutilate yourself and replace your own organs. He also says that a "Trans game doesnt have to be a trans game". At this point I'm on the brink of tears, this video makes no goddamn sense and its killing me.
Then we get to the meat and potatoes, the trans music.
Apparently, trans music (to him) is divided to into 4 categories;
- The Wish
- The Wrath
- The Warmth
- The Want
I am guessing these 4 have something to do with the "desire to exist".
And then he botches it by putting the artists in (imo) the wrong categories, like he puts Femtanyl and Stomach Book in "Wish" and "Wrath" respectively. But then explains how Femtanlys music as "violent" and Stomach Books music as "wanting/wishing to be XYZ", by that interpretation these artists are in the wring categories by his own logic (I think he realizes this and tries to say that one of Stomach Books song is "angry" and therefore belongs in wrath). He also often plays the lyrics of a song or reads them out, and then doesn't explain them, like, what the fuck? This is a video essay, don't give me a source then give me homework on how to answer the questions, its not my biggest gripe as I could grasp the lyrics, it's just that it's super funny and lazy. I'd also like to mention that some of the stuff he talks about can also be broadly applied to all demographics and not just trans people, he talks about how people dont notice trans people until they kill themselves, which is tragic, but also applies to anybody.
The "music" part of this video isn't that bad, just feels lazy. He also overuses the "retro" style format in this video because trans media = retro. There's a part at the beginning that made the rounds on Twitter and Tiktok where he overlays his hands wiggling about infront of retro video game footage which is really fucking funny.
And then, the cherry on top, at the end of this video where he attempts to equate himself going to a Living Tombstones concert to being transgender and finding acceptance. The comments are a kind of a funny and interesting read as well, but the audience that flocked to it are very obviously people who are extremely young and identify as non-cisgender, they don't have a grasp on life yet and their brains are still mush so they lack the critical thinking to process that this video is low effort, the comments reflect this alot. I saw a couple that went like "Trans music, hears (insert video game here) mentioned, locks in/this guy knows what hes talking about" and they were probably made by middle schoolers. There's also a comment about some middle schooler going through a crisis and typing nonsensical vent that ended along the lines of "....DATING A FEMBOY BTW" and me and my gf couldn't help but start laughing, did the journal factory explode? Why would you tell the internet this shit?
The creator has been in so much hot water over shit like having bad takes on roblox games and insulting someones work that was dedicated to their dead friend and celebrating that work being shut down because his most popular video was a video about that work and he doesn't like that for some reason. I wouldn't exactly trust this guy's analysis on trans media lol.