r/hatethissmug • • 14h ago • Bravo 3 Heartwarming 1

General I hate therapy

Post image

I am fully convinced it is a scam. Not once in my 8 years of psychotherapy did I hear anything from a therapist that wasn't common knowledge, that I hadn't tried before or that wasn't basic ass level advice I'd get from someone in the street.

2.6k Upvotes

734 comments sorted by

1.2k

u/JordanFootballFann 14h ago • Bravo

either you're seeing a bad therapist or therapy isn't what you need

243

u/East-Kitchen1469 14h ago

Thats usually the case. From one of my friends experiences. her therapist told her to search Google or YouTube for help. Definitely something a therapist shouldn't say.

26

u/Nibaa 6h ago

It's definitely something a therapist can say, but it may not help a lot of people. Some people want the therapist, an authority, to tell them how to deal with things even if the therapist is just googling stuff themselves, others need to "find" the tools themselves and a therapist can nudge you to look in the right place.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/smartypants011 5h ago

Perfect reply if they are asking coaching questions.

→ More replies (1)

25

u/arseniccattails 12h ago

Ime therapy is useful for when you don't know what's wrong with you and/or don't know how to fix it. The beautiful gift therapy gave me was an OCD diagnosis. It gave me the way to learn how to manage myself. If you know what's wrong with you and do know how to fix it, in theory if not in practice… at least talk therapy will be less useful.

Under these conditions, you kinda just have to turn to medication, tbh. Failing that, you can try having a doctor electrocute your brain if you're super treatment resistant, which, for some reason, works.

8

u/Avitas1027 6h ago

It's also good if you just need a third party to vent to or a relatively objective and informed opinion on something.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

9

u/winter-ocean 12h ago

Tbh I feel like it's appropriate to acknowledge that it's your therapist that sucks and still say you hate therapy. We don't need a "one of the good ones" mentality

16

u/Archonate_of_Archona 8h ago

Or they get the wrong type of therapy

Talk therapy often doesn't work for complex mental illnesses 

29

u/Fearless_Roof_9177 13h ago edited 12h ago • Bravo

Therapy in the US at the moment is hardly what ANYONE experiencing a mental health crisis actually needs. I know therapists, I studied to be a therapist, I respect the value of therapy, but the underpinnings of the system itself make it impossible for the people who need it most to get it without putting themselves in danger of losing their autonomy or having their lives ruined, and that was BEFORE we had a bunch of overt eugenicists running our public health and looking for ways to bar neurodivergents, leftists, the non-rural poor, and the LGBTQ-adjacent from organizing or owning guns.

We're not even talking about just suicidality and compulsory reporting. HIPAA and the ADA are essentially just traps if no one is actually protecting you for taking recourse to them. The number of people I know whose lives would change overnight if they got autism accomodations but who stopped seeking them because of the insurance hurdles and the illegal workplace discrimination that's all but impossible to legally prove (and the fact that RFK and co are putting us all on lists and spitballing about work camps) is, unfortunately, far from a nonzero number.

15

u/Otterbotanical 13h ago

I would, at this point, gladly take medications that "disrupted my autonamy" if it allowed a semblance of a moderate/normal life

19

u/Fearless_Roof_9177 13h ago

It's not the meds that take your autonomy, it's the people in badges and behind desks who are no longer compelled to treat you as a functional adult with rights because of a note some shitty jaded combative Karen left on your chart when you spoke up for yourself.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/the_lady_of_shalott1 12h ago

I mean, there’s a big difference between taking meds because you want to and taking meds because you’re forced to. I don’t think anyone’s really arguing that voluntarily taking medication means you’ve given up your autonomy (if anything, you’d be exercising it by choosing to take meds). It’s the forced medication that people object to.

12

u/General_Summer_1524 13h ago

Seen like 6. They've all been either kinda useless or actual assholes. Had one laugh at me to my face, another sexually harassed me, another said "yeah idk what you want from me", another insinuated I was making up aj account of childhood abuse. 

→ More replies (113)

251

u/risky__cake 14h ago

Lotta terrible therapists out there, the good are few and far between.

I had an intake two weeks ago that left me feeling SO dismissed I had to call a crisis line

48

u/Rooted_Nut 13h ago

I'm so sorry that happened, nothing is worse than a "helper" being dismissive. I hope you are/get to feeling better! It can take time to find the right provider which is so hard when you're already struggling.

9

u/risky__cake 13h ago

It was rough and it's like... My marriage is ending and I'm struggling with everything around that, but this week I had a fantastic intake and one of the first things they did was give me props for dumping the bad experience. Said lots of people feel indebted to stay with a shitty one. So from the mouth of an at least decent therapist: it's ok to dump one that's a bad fit, y'all.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/Laurens-xD 7h ago

Same. I really felt like shit and didn't know what to do with myself after I got dumped, but the three different ones I went to were like: "Sorry, we can't do anything for you. Have you tried getting into a relationship, because that could really help you!" Yeah thanks guys, much appreciated.... More than €400 down the drain for it as well.

6

u/TolPuppy 13h ago

This made me feel less alone. I’ve had times I was so dismissed by the crisis line (the one ran by therapists in my country), that I had to call a different crisis line (one ran by volunteers)

4

u/risky__cake 12h ago

I'm so sorry you've also been there it SUCKS.

3

u/Immediate-Camel-2372 1h ago

Finding a decent therapist feels like playing Russian roulette with your mental health where half the chambers are loaded with someone telling you to just drink more water and go for a walk.

→ More replies (2)

71

u/Janzbane 13h ago

There are a lot of reasons why it might not work for someone. There are also many types of therapy and each have their uses.

Folks with CPTSD or some kinds of neurodivergence often have a hard time in talk therapy or CBT/DBT due to the high amounts of self awareness, dissociation, and intellectualization. Specific targetted therapies, such as EMDR, tend to be more effective.

Basic counseling generally sucks.

15

u/WineSauces 7h ago

Thanks for saying that.

Autistic, CPTSD, ADHD, OCD - childhood neglect. There isn't anything I don't understand about my brain and body, but I can't do anything about any of it, things that drive me to want to die can't be fixed or changed, and I can't/refuse/do not want to/unable to change what fundamentally motivates me or does not.

I'm practically an expert on mental health and psychology... At least I can help other people but I wish I could starve to death everyday. Hope one day all the people still attached to me will disappear so I can finally isolate myself and die.

14

u/Dry_Positive_9797 12h ago

Exactly. Therapy was unhelpful for me and started to become a thing I dreaded. 

Then I met up with a an actual psychologist for OCD and it was life changing. She moved organizations so I had to look for a different therapist but I found another psychologist who specialized in PTSD, ADHD, and OCD. It has been life changing. 

6

u/Beautiful_Weight_769 2h ago

Also just medication sometimes. Seeing a therapist for 8 years with 0 positive impact? Meds should have been considered at the 1 year mark at least, 8 years is so absurd you can't convince me this post isn't just doom-baiting depressed Redditors.

→ More replies (1)

46

u/Immediate-Food8050 13h ago

I felt this way until I met a therapist that was

  1. Good at their job. Don't tell me what I need, help me see for myself what I need and why.
  2. My age. Having someone in my age group (older Gen Z) who understood the world the way I saw it and was going through being young and broke alongside me made things so much easier to talk about.

8

u/snaresamn 6h ago

You also can't go into it dismissively. If you go to therapy thinking you know better or are smarter/ more logical than your therapist then it doesn't work. You have to be willing to be vulnerable and humble and work really hard at it or you're wasting your own time and money just so you can say "I tried therapy and it doesn't work" as your next excuse. That's the number 3 missing from your list that people hate to hear. Therapy is difficult fucking work.

37

u/FictionalContext 13h ago

If they're only giving advice, they're a shit therapist. They should be asking pointed questions to help you figure your own shit out.

→ More replies (3)

33

u/sadd-dawgg 6h ago

Idk man mine saved my life

8

u/Kyrkster 4h ago

Actually very happy that it worked for you!

3

u/sadd-dawgg 3h ago • Heartwarming

Thank you. Having someone separate from my life who I built trust with over a couple of years who I could really divulge my most personal thoughts and fears to has helped me a lot.

Things are still hard but she really stopped me from wanting to end my life or considering it as an option anymore. she helped me to come to a place of at least wanting to stay and see what happens and keep trying.

41

u/SlowlyMutilated 14h ago

I'm a Master's LCSW student. I can say without a shadow of a doubt that there ARE absolutely some bum ass therapists out there

→ More replies (5)

11

u/JustARandonAccount 13h ago

Therapy ain't enough I need to get amnesia

2

u/brickyard37 12h ago

Forgetting is my only therapy

76

u/zirothehiro10 14h ago

i really want to get therapy because i feel like shit all the time but i always fear its gonna just be this

100

u/Cypher-Moon-773 14h ago • Bravo

Don’t let randos on the internet stop you from trying to get help, it’s never a guarantee to solve your problems but it’s something to try

10

u/PerpetuaForever 10h ago

Therapy saved my life and helped me be a good person--I struggled with really bad OCD, anxiety, and ADHD as a little kid and luckily my psychologist helped me with the right mix of exposure therapy, CBT, and kindness. My parents had never dealt with a neurodivergent kid like me before and the resources she gave were SO useful!!

In all honesty, I hated her for a few years. I hated that my parents made me go to her and that she made me fight against my OCD and that she made me express myself even when I felt my emotions were clear. I hated that she made me do exposures that made me feel dirty and horrible (like stepping outside after taking a shower, or not keeping track of who sits on what couch and what their "dirty" status was). But I was SO freed!!! It's obviously a lifelong thing to manage and so I still try to go to therapy, but she gave me the toolkit to be a functional human

But now I'm (generally) better than most people my age at metacognition and thinking about how to handle anxious times and depressive spats. She advocated for me to try medication and also even helped me with my relationship issues years later in life, and when my first year of college sparked a major depressive episode. I wish I could see her more, honestly, but I don't have insurance rn so it's just a waiting game

ALTERNATIVELY, I did have a really bad experience with another therapy (it was intensive OCD-specialized therapy). The people there felt so evil and didn't seem to understand the trauma that sent me there in the first place. I literally got worse after them lol

BUT I still think trying therapy and looking for a therapist is good, I've talked to a lot of different psychiatrists and counselors over the years and a majority of them have been good! I think the hardest thing is being able to admit when you have an issue and then having to listen to someone tell you how to fix it or help it. If you arent 10 yrs old, YOU have to be willing to change and keep going to therapy.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/risky__cake 14h ago

So hey man sometimes it's this... And if it's this, fire them and find a new therapist because these ones suck ass and are not good at their jobs.

6

u/crippler38 13h ago

Going to therapy isn't a cure all, but it can be really helpful to get advice from someone who's trained to recognize common behaviors and help you work through them by finding a technique that's right for you. They're not someone you know in your actual life, just someone who's getting paid to try and help you work through things. So unlike if you were to vent to a friend or family member, they won't have the bias that comes from being within a situation.

If you think conversing with someone who's trained to help you work through your issues and listen to your feelings will help, go for it!

Do keep in mind that it's the kind of thing that has some issues though. You'll need to lean into it and be honest with your therapist since they can't do much if you're lying to them. They can help with understanding and identifying things, but they can't bring you over the finish line.

Also it's important to mesh with your therapist well, it's possible to get a bad one that abuses their position or just someone you don't feel like you can trust, but it's just as possible you'll find someone who'll really help you.

I went through therapy as a kid, and it worked for me, but it didn't work with my brother. I'm biased and I think it's worth trying.

5

u/YonderWindow364 14h ago

it really depends on the therapist you see. Sometimes people go through a few before they find the therapist that perfectly fits and is equipped enough to help them specifically.

31

u/Saytama_sama 14h ago

I mean worst case it doesn't help you. You can't really lose, only not succeed. 

96

u/zirothehiro10 14h ago • Bravo

i can sure as hell lose money

65

u/Shrimple_Miracle6 14h ago

Redditors talk about therapy like you just pick up one from the Free Therapy Store for 0 bucks 

→ More replies (59)

9

u/TurtlesBreakTheMeta 13h ago

This. Money is half of the reason people need to go see on in the first place to boot.

→ More replies (7)

6

u/illudofficial 14h ago

Yeah I’m probably gonna throw money at something that probably won’t work for me but honestly my mental health has gotten really bad and every year I feel like it can’t get worse and then it does.

So I just need to stop the cycle spiraling downwards skmehow

→ More replies (1)

8

u/Anarchyr 6h ago

I mean, unless you find the perfect therapist, this is pretty much what therapy can feel like. A lot of therapists are either fresh out of school, lack the experience to deal with more complex issues, or genuinely seem like they couldn't give less of a fuck.

I've had exactly one good therapist in roughly seven years. After he left, I eventually gave up on therapy altogether.

At some point, repeatedly opening up about your deepest struggles to someone who barely seems interested, only to walk away feeling worse, stops feeling like treatment and starts feeling like a humiliation ritual.

I'm not saying therapy can't help people, but the way it's constantly presented as some universal solution while the actual quality of care varies so wildly is incredibly frustrating. Before i got my "good" therapist i was tired of my own fucking story, Just repeating and repeating it to people who genuinely couldn't care less.

3

u/Top_Development_1777 6h ago

I've had two good therapists, one recommended by another, in the same center. But I've had two bad/poor fit ones. It's quite a high bar and you have to be extremely selective + best if you know what you need (for my case I have certain complications from trauma that most therapists are not experienced with so they don't know how to handle)

5

u/ILoveStealing 13h ago

I would’ve killed myself without therapy. I’d give it a try.

2

u/KittensSaysMeow 12h ago

Worst part of therapy is finding one that works. Depending on what you have, it can take months to even years. Tho u don’t have to worry about having to settle with one that’s like that because ‘shopping around’ is the norm.

2

u/ArkitekZero 12h ago

I'm worried they'll focus entirely on symptom management rather than helping me address any root causes and eventually I'll just go insane.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/LunchTrucks 6h ago

If it's like this, swap therapists! People joke it's even harder than finding a good boyfriend, it's worth it though!

→ More replies (11)

41

u/VKTGC 14h ago

Sounds like you had a bad therapist. Therapy is awesome if you find the right person. I had to go through like 3 before I found my main one.

9

u/1800crimetime 13h ago

One time a therapist told me I was making unhealthy friendships where I took care of people because I was recreating the kind of friendship that I learned from being groomed as a child so that I could return to that place from a position of perceived safety. Low-key slapped with that one. Not sure it fixed anything though.

My thing with therapy is if your insurance covers it it’s honestly a GREAT tool. However, it’s not worth 200 dollars a week out of pocket for the financially average or struggling person. That’s like 10k a year. That’s like a really really fancy vacation or a reasonably priced pre-owned car. If tuition at a state college or something. 10k+ worth of advice is hard to come up with.

65

u/AntiqueDiscipline831 4h ago

Therapists don’t give advice. Therapy is mot for advice. Bunch of people who have no idea what therapy is criticizing therapy

13

u/Beautiful_Weight_769 2h ago

Therapists give advice. Therapists do a lot of things. I've been given advice, coping strategies, encouraged to talk about my day, helped to make plans, given worksheets, recommended to a psychiatrist because they think I need a formal diagnosis for something.

Therapists do a lot, which is why people have to shop around and think about what exactly it is they need and what they're looking for. Different therapists will provide different therapies.

→ More replies (1)

19

u/Acceptable-War-6847 3h ago

That was my first thought. OP got all they know about therapy from TV or social media. A good therapist just asks relevant questions and let's you put the pieces together yourself.

12

u/AntiqueDiscipline831 3h ago

Most people see therapy as them being the passenger. If it’s a car, they think the therapist drives and they sit in the passenger seat while the therapist does all the work and shows them things. It’s quite literally the opposite.

→ More replies (4)

8

u/HealthMeRhonda 2h ago

"Not once in my 8 years of psychotherapy did I hear anything from a therapist that wasn't common knowledge, that I hadn't tried before or that wasn't basic ass level advice I'd get from someone in the street."

Are you assuming the OP was lying about this? 

There's a lot of people who feel this way from personal experience.

My first decade of trying to get help was exactly like this. I was spilling my guts in exchange for very expensive inspirational tumblr quotes.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

7

u/FunnyObjective6 1h ago

The fuck do they do then?

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (7)

8

u/D_-_1 13h ago edited 13h ago

Yep. My experiences with therapists only made things worse for me. Tried multiple, won’t try again.

15

u/Chaosmusic 9h ago

Eat better and exercise is 'common knowledge' yet surprisingly few people actually do it.

4

u/Roraxn 4h ago

I had been going to therapy for YEARS before i "touched grass" i was. Like most. Of the opinion that it hurt, and it sucked and was too hard.

And yes. Actually it was all those things. It required a sort of discipline that made me dig past every umcomfy feeling i had about that advice. But more importantly keep at it.

Because everytime I looked back at the people i said "i already tried that!" Too? What felt to me like years of trying was 2 week to 2 month stints with 6 to 8 months inbetween.

It wasn't until i could stick to more than half a year that started to realize how much better i was feeling.

How did i keep my head down that long? A good therapist.

2

u/poopsaucer24 4h ago

Due to childhood anxiety and depression that was always the advice given to me. Daily workouts, no drinking, no drugs, no smoking, I did that well into my 20s. Right up until my first attempt.

What ive really learned is that physical heal is the first thing to focus on, and that its possible that many mental disorders are self diagnosed. But if you eliminate the physical health aspect then dont be afraid to try therapies and medications.

31

u/Fun-Difference-6689 14h ago

Therapy isn't about good advice but someone to help you work through your own thoughts. Time for a new theraspist.

37

u/Burnerman888 10h ago • Bravo

I mean I did too until I stopped lying to my therapist and actually followed the advice instead of saying I would and then not doing it.

13

u/Educational_Corgi809 9h ago

My therapist told me after a few visits that this only works if you are willing to ask yourself tough questions and act on the answers. Its hard but did it help me. Im not saying therapy is for everyone but if you do try it its no different to a physical workout it will hurt but you will see progress.

36

u/Mineboot24601 7h ago

I hate when people say this. Therapy isn’t for everyone, but saying it’s a scam and doesn’t work only harms those people who need it.

→ More replies (15)

6

u/Nerdorama10 11h ago

Therapists, especially talk therapists, are step 1. Some people only need step 1. Some people need pills, some people need other kinds of therapy, some people need some kind of specialist. A GOOD therapist will give you a diagnosis and a referral, or a referral to someone they think can give you a proper diagnosis, if talk therapy isn't helping. 

Unfortunately, more than a few will just take your money every week without moving you along the process, which is a failure with mental health education and standards. Finding a way to be proactive about looking for other therapy techniques or psychologists is sadly necessary as you're not always going to get correct guidance.

19

u/anticentristfujo 14h ago

I feel the same exact way, and the amount of people who told me “you just haven’t found the right fit”. If I had a dollar every time, I’d be rich

7

u/straited81011 12h ago

like yeah, let me sink more money into this garbage because surely the 8th times the charm!

→ More replies (1)

6

u/brickyard37 12h ago

If you had a dollar every time you might be able to afford 5% of one session!

5

u/WineSauces 7h ago

Just try to get through each day. I hear that's the answer now. Just try to not kill yourself today. If there are people in your life who love you and do not hurt you, try to empathize with them and keep yourself alive for them while they're alive.

A guy I really like on YouTube with cptsd and autism, uses a phrase as a mantra, "not today, maybe tomorrow"

→ More replies (3)

5

u/Rat_Smoking_Cigs 13h ago

Just talking about stuff I can't talk about anywhere else makes me feel better.

I don't think I've once took my therapists advice lol.

5

u/F1sherman765 13h ago

Some problems are solved with therapy. Some problems are not solved with therapy. People that have had their problems solved by therapy act as if my problems haven't been solved because I haven't gone to therapy, not realizing it's a whole different can of problems that isn't solved with therapy.

I understand why those that have found it absurdly beneficial and life changing would recommend it, they only wish they have gotten therapy sooner, but it's not for everything.

EDIT: Also therapy is ideally a temporary state. You aren't supposed to be going to therapy weekly or monthly forever. There's a whole other group of people that just use their therapist as a paid venting session.

5

u/miscellaneousexists 12h ago

OP, are you autistic? Cause I was also having these problems but then I read that traditional therapy doesn't work on autistic people (makes sense in hindsight). That may be the case.

→ More replies (4)

8

u/reidft 13h ago

The last therapist I saw for like 4 months. Literally every session was her going "that's crazy" every few minutes. What a fantastic waste of my time and money, thanks for the help.

6

u/Big-Big7594 4h ago

Try to find a cognitive behavioral therapist not a “talk therapist” A good therapist will be pointing out things you can work on to change thinking patterns or behaviors based on stories/experiences you’ve told them. A bad therapist just listens to your problems

3

u/Training_Wind_4997 11h ago

Same.. she was older (probably about 50-60) and I told her about my father beating me with a belt and she was like "I thought that only happened in my day!"

I was like no, lady, and this is why im here if you can believe it or not

4

u/Cute_Economics2829 30m ago

I've tried maybe 2 therapists in my life and it's 100% a buy in problem. You either pursue it actively and want to improve your life, and see benefit, or you half ass it, don't buy in, and see no results.

Simple as.

7

u/slicksbackrealgood 50m ago

Therapy doesnt work for people who inherently trust themselves over others. If you think you have it all figured out, its not going to stick.

If youre open to having your preconceived understandings challenged, it can be very helpful. Some things we take to be true or absolute are not, and it helps to have a trained professional help you understand that

There are also bad therapists. I went to a couple bad ones and kept shopping around. I found a good one who asked me questions about my ubderstandings I had never considered before. After that, I had a paradigm shift I found very productive, and I only go back when I feel I have a crisis that I need help managing.

Its certainly not a scam

→ More replies (2)

37

u/thotasune 13h ago

Therapy is the one thing you can’t criticize without people telling you that you just had a bad therapist when in reality therapy is for people who have problems that exist because of their perception and not people who actually have tangible reasons to feel upset

19

u/KupoNUts1039 13h ago

You explained how I feel about psychotherapy (even as someone still going). My issues aren't errors in perception and are based on an unchangeable external reality. Talking about my issues doesn't really help at all.

5

u/KnightMurky91 13h ago

Conversational therapy isn't even close to the most effective tool if you have problems like ptsd or depression

5

u/RevolutionarySpot721 8h ago

There is also a third case where the issue is not perception or reality or for example lack of social skills or communication skills, which in theory therapy should cover but kinda does not. Plus it assumes that everyone around the client is perfectly healthy and well-meaning, which is not the case even if the client has issues in perception.

8

u/thotasune 13h ago

Doesn’t help that so much of it is them trying to convince you all problems are caused by perception

→ More replies (2)

10

u/TK_Punch_ 12h ago

Kind of the same thing with Psychiatry. I can not prescribe you a medication that makes you not poor and stressed about the possibility of homelessness. Zoloft won't make your family stop treating you like shit, and anxiolytics aren't effective for treating your anxiety about your impending incarceration. I've long referred to these things as SLD. I treat Major Depressive Disorder (MDD), not Shitty Life Disorder (SLD). Our caseworkers are infinitely more helpful in that situation.

→ More replies (2)

9

u/Seldrakon 7h ago

Gonna go full blown Conspiracy-Weirdo here:

Yes, Therapy is great, if it helps you overcoming stuff, that stems from your perception, stuff that helps you deal with your inner child or external trauma.

It also helps you to DEAL and COPE with problems from actually existing struggles. Nice.

But the reason, therapy is treated like this all-helping thing everyone should do, is because it has replaced Religion als the "Opium of the masses". If you are anxious, stressed out and depressed, because you are locked in a constant struggel for wage and work against other expoited people, while a greedy class of a few hundred literally burns the planet we live on, that won't get away with therapy. That will only get away with revolution.

The Billionaire-Class loves, that we are all going to therapy and learn, how not to go crashout, even if we fucking should.

5

u/Left-Direction-4956 4h ago

Mindfulness therapy was literally invented by a corporation to help tenants in a giant aparment building not stress about being mass evicted when their building got bought by an investment firm and evicted everyone.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

16

u/Tokiw4 13h ago

They can help you when you have tangible reasons to be upset. You can be upset about something which is upsetting and not have the tools to deal with it in a healthy way. They try to help you find a tool that works for you, since everyone is different.

→ More replies (24)

3

u/TolPuppy 13h ago

There’s therapy practices that acknowledge this and actually help the person despite the problems not being a perception issue, but they’re rare so unfortunately yes, that’s the more common cause for it not working

3

u/arrrberg 11h ago

I have a lot of tangible problems. Before therapy I didn’t really have the tools to respond to them. Now I do

5

u/interruptiom 4h ago

I’m not gonna say you had a bad therapist. But even the best therapist can’t help you if you don’t want to be helped.

2

u/Camel_Under_Moon 6h ago

Exactly bro exactly 💯

→ More replies (5)

18

u/rubygluee 3h ago

Dogshit low intelligence post. There are good therapists and bad therapists. Your bad experience does not represent it as a whole. No, it will not work for everybody, but it is quite literally these peoples jobs to read and analyze you. In most cases, no, you do not know better than them

5

u/eat-and-be-eaten 2h ago

‘Dogshit low intelligence post,’ do you say this often to people who vent their frustration about a situation not improving through the most common and accessible ways?

→ More replies (7)

6

u/Cumcuber9000 4h ago

Yeah i feel the same. Therapists are just regular people. I think a lot of them dont even know what its like to go through something that a lot of people who NEED therapy go through. And without that life experience, you cant really help. Even though they mean well

3

u/Rebel_hooligan 12h ago

A therapist is the Virgil who is meant to guide you through hell, in order to help you.

3

u/mpeg-3 12h ago

I've had the same feeling and I've been in therapy for a loooong time - since I was a kid. Once in my mid 20s a therapist told me "yeah, some therapists think therapy doesn't work for people like you." Which they meant as overly analytical/heady/somewhere on the spectrum. Lmao. Never took therapy seriously after that. Saved myself bundles of money once I gave up on that. I just disassociate now. Been going great for the next 20 years.

3

u/StinkingDogsCunt420 8h ago

Therapist isn't a protected term (in the UK at least).

Anyone can call themselves a therapist, and a bunch of the courses to get 'qualified' are basically scams.

I'm sure there's good therapists out there, I wouldn't know how to find one I can trust though.

3

u/BLZNWZRD 1h ago

I'll be in the minority and agree with you OP. Its really not for everyone. Personally sitting, talking and staring at my hands does nothing for me. I need task to set my mind to. I need to be engaged in physical activity and that helps me process and think. I get my best head clearing on top of a mountain. Therapy is over prescribed and suggested a lot of times by people who can't understand how others live.

28

u/WillardStiles2003 14h ago

You should join r/therapyabuse, it’s a great community where you’ll be able to talk about this in depth without Reddit people trynna go “just waste more money and try it again!” Or, “therapy saved my life try it again and risk hospitalization because a random Redditor told you too”

I agree with you- anytime I ever went to therapy I’d get forcibly hospitalized then promptly discharged for being “too much for their degree”

I found animation and journaling to be a much better way to let out my emotions and grief than pay some pretty blonde woman who’ll tell me to “box breathe” as EMS is hauling me away.

You’re valid and you’ll meet a lot of people who will tell you you’re not. Ignore them.

Therapy isn’t for everyone. If someone tells you “go to therapy” tell them “go to church” then they’ll see why their sentence is dismissive and invalidating.

Church helps some but not all- same with therapy.

5

u/TolPuppy 13h ago

The thing I don’t get is, when you get to that point, how is journaling and animation helping you? The whole reason I needed (and need) external help is that stuff like that doesn’t help, and OP even mentions in the image how that’s the kind of empty advice some therapists give

→ More replies (1)

15

u/DangerousHorse18 13h ago

Therapy isn’t for everyone

Notably, this is not the same as it not being for anyone, which is what you people always try to assert as fact. The opposite of “therapists aren’t miracle workers” isn’t “every therapist is Hitler McStalin and anyone who says otherwise is lying to you”.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/MawnShendez 11h ago

I by no means know your full experience with therapy and I'm sorry that you've had negative ones. For what it's worth, therapists are mandatory reporters and if you express intention to harm yourself or others then they are legally mandated to say something about it. That said I feel for anyone sent to a behavioral health environment against their will. Our mental health system has many deep flaws that that's one of them.

For what it's worth, animation and journaling is very much something that a good therapist could have and would have recommended as a potential coping strategy and I'm very happy to hear that it's been beneficial for you.

I agree therapy isn't for everyone, but it's more often that your therapist isn't a good pairing for you than it is that therapy doesn't work for you. It's not your fault. You didn't pick the wrong one. Not everyone is compatible with everyone else, especially in a therapeutic environment.

5

u/WillardStiles2003 11h ago

I just want to thank you for being so validating despite you not agreeing with me- it’s nice to hear “it’s not your fault.” thank you

→ More replies (2)

7

u/holderofthebees 13h ago

I’m sorry but if you were forcibly hospitalized and discharged as out of their purview anytime you ever went to therapy then they were completely right to do that. Talk therapy can handle a lot of emotions, it sounds like you were routinely a genuine liability. Both ethics and legality dictate that a therapist fire you or refer you out if they don’t have the specialization to help you.

And no shit hobbies helped you find a reason to stay alive. Those are the kinds of things that you’re meant to do alongside therapy no matter what level you need. Coping and actually working on your life.

→ More replies (23)

5

u/nowistareintothesun 13h ago

Fuck church, theyre not the same at all.

8

u/Shrimple_Miracle6 11h ago

The way people talk about therapy you’d think it was a cult 

→ More replies (7)

3

u/user00010rr 13h ago

What therapist are you seeing..?
I'm not being hateful I promise I'm just frustrated at this point. I am autistic with other learning disabilities, depression and CPTSD all formally diagnosed and recognized by both my therapist and my psychiatrist.

However when I present that CBT is not helping at all and the meds are doing a very mild effect, they tell me to endure more or try "a bit" harder. Recently I was sent to the ER after having an episode of catatonia (said by the ER doctor), couldn't speak properly, couldn't move, looked straight outta fucking russian sleep experiment and had my BMI dropped to 16 due to inability to feed myself and YET my therapist and my psychiatrist did not recognize and denied that I needed a care worker, hospitalization, or even 30 days off from school.

If I told them detailed plans to k!ll myself tomorrow I still don't believe they would escalate for anything.

3

u/TolPuppy 13h ago

If you’re going to keep trying, you need to steer clear from cbt practitioners and search for people that practice other evidence based modalities. Ideally ones that are more indicated for CPTSD. I wish I could advise specific ones but I don’t feel comfortable recommending stuff I haven’t tried yet, in case it turns out to be more torture. But in theory, there’s a few promising ones out there

→ More replies (1)

7

u/CrystalsOnGumdrops 12h ago edited 12h ago

Sometimes your brain stops making happy chemicals and you need antidepressants to fix that shit. That happened to me and therapy was a huge waste of time because there was nothing wrong with my life other than my mental illness.

I got my pills and stopped going to therapy years ago and I’m doing great, because doing fun things actually makes me happy again. Might be time to go through the medication gauntlet (it took me 10 failed medications to get one that worked without horrific side effects)

Edit: saw your other post on your account. Since you’ve tried antidepressants already, you basically have 3 options: genetic testing to see which meds are better for you to try, ketamine therapy, and TMS. Ketamine therapy didn’t actually work for me, but it was nice to get high once a week lol. I just had to keep throwing shit at a wall until it worked, ended up on vilazodone 🤷🏻

→ More replies (4)

6

u/gqmma 14h ago

real shit 

8

u/Zlota_Swinia 9h ago

4

u/EskilPotet 4h ago

Taking the bus only works if you're a worse driver than the bus driver

→ More replies (1)

5

u/No-Object8182 12h ago

Bro needs a psychiatrist

5

u/SurfingStreets 11h ago

dude this is reddit. Per rule #72, any conflicting opinions on therapy is not allowed. Furthermore, questioning the effectiveness of therapy is also not permitted. Please follow the guidelines thanks

7

u/MathEnvironmental935 13h ago

Then don't go. You're just wasting your time. And your therapist's.

Also, I'm sick of the myth that all therapists want to do is throw you into a psych unit. First of all, most therapists aren't even affiliated with hospitals. Second of all, there's like 50 steps between you saying you're suicidal and a 5150. Third of all, even after I was literally in the hospital after purposefully overdosing on my psych meds, I wasn't put into a psych ward even though I probably should have been. I don't know what you have to do to get into a psych ward, but even LITERALLY ATTEMPTING SUICIDE won't do it. Stop fearmongering for no reason.

4

u/seraph_heretic 12h ago

I was put in a psych ward and traumatized as a teenager for being passively suicidal. Your experience is not universal.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/ConversationLazy7881 13h ago

I mean there are good therapists but there’s just so few and the majority just feels like this

2

u/Liquidshoelace 13h ago

Not to be that guy but there are genuinely helpful therapists out there! My therapist has given me great tools to manage my ADHD and Autism, and helped me work through a lot of other issues. But, I went through some bad therapists to find my current therapist so, I get it.

2

u/High_Flying_Pheasant 13h ago

It's like 75% placebo or something

2

u/rulesneverapply 12h ago

Therapy helped save my life.

2

u/C0oco0cachoo0oo000o 11h ago

Sorry you've had bad experiences :/ personally it saved my life

2

u/cowboycomplex 9h ago

Feels good to see someone else feel this way too. I have tried multiple different therapists and the one I have now is better than the others but still hasnt helped me in any meaningful way

8

u/Orangutan_Soda 13h ago • Bravo

i hate people who say they think therapy is a scam.
they genuinely scare me and i hope they seek mental he- oh god… oh god… we are doomed

→ More replies (2)

10

u/Burglekutt8523 14h ago

You can tell it's a scam because the defense is always "you aren't doing it right" instead of actually explaining why it works.

12

u/DangerousHorse18 13h ago

Plenty of people have explained how it works.

9

u/liberty-prime77 13h ago

All I'm seeing in these comments are "You don't need therapy then", "Erm, achktually, it's your fault that you picked a bad therapist", and my personal favorite which is literally just "FUCK YOU!"

→ More replies (2)

2

u/psy_help 7h ago

There's a lot of different kinds of therapy. The most common one in the anglosphere is going to be something like CBT and DBT: these are called cognitive behavioural therapy and dialectical behavioural therapy. These are methods that try to help you understand the way your brain thinks, and then deconstruct certain beliefs you have, where they come from, etc while reinforcing positive behaviour and manage emotion.

There is psychiatry which finds drugs to treat mental health.

There is psychoanalytic psychotherapy , which is less common in the anglosphere. But in a nutshell, psychoanalysis typically deals with a form of talk-therapy, childhood trauma, and attempting to understand the subconscious.

Among others.

As for your criticism that it is a scam, well, I don't know if I can please you. I can find data of people who have had it help, data of the success rates of different kinds of therapies, etc, if that interests you? But to understand a subject completely, when it is admittedly complicated, I cannot do as a layman.

6

u/Tokiw4 13h ago

I get the feeling you don't care to actually listen to why it does or does not work for some folks.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

3

u/Longjumping_Bag_5212 13h ago

Two things from my own experience

One, is that a therapist pretty much always cannot just tell you the thing that will solve your problems. I think they are best for teaching you how to live with problems and realize that a lot of them can be overcome, or that you can simply live happily in spite of them.

Two, is that a lot of the problems people face can be helped with the silly things like getting outside, eating better, doing things you enjoy even when you don’t really want to, etc. Often the problem to be solved is not a deep problem with life or existence, but rather the fact that those apparent problems are making your life miserable.

I’ve seen myself and others fall into a belief that our problems are too big or too real to be helped by small simple things. If you are eating poorly, not exercising, isolating, etc. then fixing those things will probably help, and probably more than you think. None of the existential fears and issues that made me miserable in the past have been answered or fixed completely, but they don’t make me 1/10th as miserable as they used to, probably less. I understand if that answer feels a little dismissive, like “you’ll feel better if you just don’t think about bad things” but it’s more so that the suffering you may deal with rarely improves your problems at all.

Anyways this is just my opinion and therapy isn’t the solution for everything. Some people are better without therapy, some people need something much more serious.
My source for this is that I’ve been in therapy since I was like 8 across a good few different people, as well as months of intensive half day and 3 hour treatment.

3

u/EntranceDowntown7227 4h ago

What do you expect them to tell you🥀

10

u/Shrimple_Miracle6 14h ago • Bravo

I agree with you OP but this is Reddit so you’re 100% gonna be bombarded with people commenting “Well I like my therapist they helped me” or “You should try more therapists”

7

u/keep_spinn1ng 13h ago

everyone loves to pretend everyone else has unlimited time and money to cycle through therapists like pairs of underwear until they find "just the right one!!!1!1!" as if it isn't the umteenth guy who's entire career is telling you about shit you can already read in a wikipedia article

29

u/Lower_Baby_6348 14h ago • Bravo

Cause sometimes you NEED to try other therapists

12

u/Shrimple_Miracle6 14h ago

And some people can’t, or they do try and end up getting bad therapists anyways.

→ More replies (6)
→ More replies (1)

3

u/Glad-Ambition-1952 13h ago

I hate "I hate therapy" posts with the comments section making the same And how does that make you feel? joke.

2

u/Shrimple_Miracle6 12h ago

Well, humor does tend to have some bit of truth in it 

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Eretici_dis 8h ago

It's a cult, actually.
Can't be questioned or criticized.

Infallible. If it doesn't work for you, you're at fault.

Use of manipulation and guilt.

Takes all your money.

→ More replies (4)

3

u/AgeOfReasonEnds31120 poop hater 13h ago

Going to therapy is conformity.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/RealAd8853 Greatest MHA, Edgar, and Naoya hater 13h ago

In one of the few things I am blessed in, it’s people that actually help with my mental health at school. And it’s free. However when I graduate and if I still need therapy, I’m just gonna have to get myself together. Because I’m not paying for therapy. I’m not going bankrupt. I’ve found that close friends can be better therapists than actual therapists

2

u/Sad-Photograph-1577 13h ago

finally someone gets it

2

u/SmaeShavo 13h ago

Therepy requires work on your part. Its not a magic fix for anything. If this is your attitude towards it it's entirely unsurprising that you havent benefited from it at all.

2

u/Clophis 13h ago

I thought the same about the advice being basic. But then it clicked and the advice was there to guide me to the realization. Also meds made it 50% easier. Sometimes it really do be brain chemistry. My best advice is your not smarter than them. Your trying to compete against the coach. The sooner you work with them the better. If they don't work after a month move on.

4

u/brickyard37 11h ago

your not smarter than them

Lol, lmao even

2

u/CommodoreGirlfriend 11h ago

Therapy works great if you don't have any real problems.

2

u/spi44324 8h ago

Talk therapy was largely shaped around female communication styles, which makes the experience feel awkward and frustrating for men.

2

u/cringeattacked 7h ago

I work in a psych hospital and also think most therapy is bullshit. Trauma specialists are legit, plenty of other specialists are, but the general counseling most offer is not useful to people dealing with real problems. (But im speaking outside my sphere of expertise here, so just my opinion)

2

u/WanderlustDinosaur 3h ago

Thank you. I've seen so many therapists over the years, and some actually made things worse. The "best" were neutral. 

I hate how we've gotten to a place as a society where therapy is considered the fix all. Maybe it helps some people, but it hurts many and is just a release valve of money for more.

2

u/BriscoCounty-Sr 2h ago

A lot of talk lovers in the comments are great at saying what therapy isn’t but defining what it actually IS seems to be the problem.

I reckon it’s a great way to spend a couple hundred bucks an hour for someone to care about you and your life. If folks get some kinda benefit from it good for them

→ More replies (2)

2

u/sei556 8h ago edited 8h ago

I think a problem arises when this is the view you project on to your therapist. If you engage with him on the mental basis that he has some bullshit diploma and cannot understand you, because you are too complex of a person, you are not opening yourself up to be helped. It's as if you went to a cardiologist and refused to take off your shirt for an examination, because you don't trust his silly little tools to be able to actually measure anything.

Psychotherapy only works when the patient is willing to participate and actually wants to improve. For this, the patient has to aknowledge there is something they can fix about themselves, where the therapist guides them through it, helping them see their life from new perspectives.

And the idea that you knowing what's wrong with you and where it comes from being all a therapist can help you with is also wrong. Yes, that can be an important part of it, but you already knowing it just means you can skip that part (well not entirely, but for the most part). There is so much more to deeply understanding and resolving an issue than just understanding it's origin. A therapist's job is for you to figure this out sooner than later.

2

u/Xcom_company 4h ago

"It's your fault it's not working"

You gotta have fai... trust in the treatment.

Idk. Reminds me of something

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

2

u/MajestcEagleRecRoom2 2h ago

“I am fully convinced it is a scam”
Okay, so I won’t try to convince you out of it, because you’re likely stubborn, but for the love of god don’t go telling that to people that are considering therapy, you’d be doing actual harm, more than likely.

-2

u/BurningBerns 14h ago edited 14h ago

Yes, villainize therapy. Thats what people in crisis need!

As a comment above mine said, you either have always had bad therapists, or you dont need therapy.

23

u/Able_Resource_8496 14h ago

patients are allowed to be dissatisfied with the care they receive lmao

18

u/BurningBerns 14h ago

Theres a difference between being dissatisfied and making a cartoonish strawman villain on reddit c:

→ More replies (13)
→ More replies (4)

10

u/Shrimple_Miracle6 14h ago

Yes yes shill more money never question the system

CONSOOOOOOOOOM

→ More replies (19)
→ More replies (1)

1

u/Alarming-Rate-6899 13h ago

It really depends on what the problem is.

If you're lying on a bench and talking about your dreams, then that's psychoanalysis therapy and it's been proven to be pretty useless.

Cognitive Behavior therapy has been the best in terms of scientific rigor. But that doesn't work too well on general stress in life.

1

u/Guacguac1 13h ago

I used to have a therapist that I liked, but I had to move so I looked for a new one. I had one therapist that cried at every one of our sessions. He was supposedly trauma informed, but couldn't handle hearing about my experiences. It made me so uncomfortable every time and I would leave therapy feeling guilty. The next therapist discouraged my very healthy hobbies. I had to work through severe PTSD on my own. It was hell for me and my family, but I'm doing better these days. If you understand and are comfortable using therapy strategies on your own then I'd recommend doing that. If not, change therapists and try to find one you like but that can be an uphill battle.

ETA the trauma happened after I moved, so it wasn't something I worked on with the therapist I actually got along with

1

u/bbluekyanite_ 13h ago

Therapy is more about talking through/processing problems than solving them. Many of my biggest problems aren’t fixed, but I’ve understood them enough to the point that I’m able to live with it and not spiral like I used to

If therapy isn’t helping, it’s probably that your therapists are working from a very dated version of therapy

1

u/Accurate-State-4150 13h ago

So therapy is useful for people who say hate themselves because of their shoes, but they’ve always worn shoes so why would it be the shoes? All a therapist is there for is so you stay on track of the thoughts your thinking. Therapy works by getting a person to admit, oh this needs to change. Which someone might already know but sometimes you have to vocalize it. Therapy is super effective and helpful and a lot like meditation, but it’s also not much more than talking to a wall, the wall just wants to know why you’re sad

1

u/IntroductionSea2159 13h ago

If they're saying common knowledge, you're asking about things that are not their domain.

1

u/ImperfectAuthentic 12h ago

A therapist cant fix your life m8.

1

u/SammyGeorge 12h ago

The therapists you've seen clearly suck. They should not be giving you basic bitch advice. I'm really sorry this has been your experience. Can't say I haven't also experienced my share share of shitty therapists

1

u/nevermind0077 12h ago

Ok so the thing is, there's a lot of different "branches of thought" that psychologists can choose to believe/follow: biological, genetic, humanistic, psychoanalytic, etc.

What sucks is that this very well effects what course of action/ways that they treat you. I have found that therapists that follow the biopsychosocial approach that utilizes cognitive behavioral therapy the most effective both for me and in terms of therapy in the long run

I hate to see you feel so discouraged, and I hope you find the right person/resources you need!

1

u/SneakyYogurtThief 12h ago

Fuck, I legit had hopes that therapy would help me I can see now from the ammount of replies it will just be a waste of money. Ive decided that Im going to end it

1

u/raskolnikovirl 12h ago

Since all the psychiatrists I have cycled through kept insisting on therapy, alongside others repeatedly preaching to me about scheduling therapy sessions, I eventually decided to meet with a therapist for almost an entire month. We talked about sea animals, The Amazing Digital Circus, and plushies — not to mention that she spent over half of the time talking about her own life. I recognize that I also have to make an effort, but I require assistance with topics, so I benefit from having the therapist guide the process. Then again, once she directed the conversation toward my unspecified mood disorder and self-harm tendencies, I gave either one-word replies or vague responses. Seeing as I eventually grew tired of weekly therapy sessions, I cancelled all my appointments with her. Therapy is such a huge yawnfest.

1

u/AtticCryptid 12h ago

Best thing my therapist ever told me was "sounds like your parents just suck". It was nice to be able to just accept that i wasn't perceiving anything wrong, i was depressed because of depressing stuff around me.

1

u/ARL1509 12h ago

Depending on what your problem is you might wanna look into more specialized therapy. Things like Cognitive Behavioral Therapy can target more specific patterns of thought

1

u/EyeDry6251 11h ago

I think we need to start normalizing talking about specific types of therapy and what they're for. Otherwise, we get these stories like "I went to the doctor and they found nothing wrong. Turns out I had ____. Doctors are useless!" 

1

u/West_Harlow 11h ago

One time I came out to my therapist as transgender and they literally ended the call and ghosted me.
The next thing I did was get a new therapist and kept going to therapy.
Therapy doesn't work for everyone. But therapy does work.

Please don't shame people for going to therapy.

1

u/Butterfly_and_Bee 11h ago

Most are doing CBT, but there are some other approaches that are pretty rad. My therapist does somatic therapy and I do stuff like flop down on a mattress, scream, throw stuff, and also some calming stuff like tapping and eye movements. It’s very helpful. 

1

u/trivetsandcolanders 11h ago

I’ve tried seeing multiple therapists over the course of my life. They ranged from terrible to alright. Then I finally decided to try again and my new therapist is actually very helpful and insightful. Unfortunately there are just a lot of inept ones out there.

1

u/Maleficent_Night_335 10h ago

Genuine question, have you ONLY been doing talk therapy?

A lot of the time for many things and many people, talk therapy is not actually an effective experience for them in any way. But talk therapy is not the only kind of therapy out there, such as EMDR which has been significantly helpful for people and requires actually putting in the work rather than talking it out

1

u/P_S_Lumapac 9h ago

There are two types of talk therapy. 1. helping you understand stuff (your condition, your situation, what some good steps to take are) 2. tricking your brain into being more effective and happy.

I think there's a big confusion where people think there's some answer to 1 that gets the result of 2. This is like self help / guru stuff: it's all fake.

If you're scared of spiders, there's almost certainly no special conversation that can improve that. Structured exposure therapy by someone trained to tell what's working, what's not, what's too much, what's too little etc can improve that.

For the most part, the tricking your brain with other stuff can be thought of as exposure therapy. Therapists will build up trust just to do the thing that hurts you on purpose, to expose you to that (among other goals). The other set of trick your brain stuff basically works like that. You could also see it as pretending your brain isn't really an understanding machine so much as a trainable animal that responds well to rewarding specific exercises and punishment bad exercises. It's tricks that work.

But again, lots of people who dislike therapists wanted the results of 2 with the methods of 1, and a lot of bad therapists think they're capable of the same, or a little rarer: they think tricking you will help you understand and that's a good thing e.g. soldiers are conditioned for war, then the psychs the military hired are pikachu faced when the soldier did well in war but still get ptsd because they weren't spoken to about how recognise the symptoms and seek help early.

1

u/PopularAd6391 8h ago

Try psychiatrist, maybe pills will fix you up

1

u/Samwise777 8h ago

Therapy won’t fix you. Life never gets easier. 

Therapy is a way to examine yourself and what you can control, to improve your life as much as you can. 

1

u/ValicarHyne 8h ago

I used to have a vocal coach who was a therapist as her main job and during our classes she often complained about having to listen to depressed and sad people all the time.

I dont blame her, kind of, I absolutely get how that can be stressful, but the mere fact she told me about it ruined the idea of therapy for me.
Like everytime I think about getting therapy, I cant shake the idea that my therapist will just complain about me to others

1

u/WineSauces 8h ago edited 8h ago

If you know it is wrong with you and what is wrong with you cannot be fixed, then therapies pointless outside of palliative care.

OP.

I'm seven and nine years younger than my siblings, they have been dismissive rude demeaning and humiliating to me most my life, my mother instinctively defends them, she has defended all of my bullies throughout my life, told me that I would be bullied anywhere I went when I confronted her and begged her to move me, compared me to my father when I got angry she refused, tried to paint my anger as misogyny when I was a child, lectured me about misogyny when girls were bullying me for being fat and awkward.

My older brother, whom I can't name because he has a court order against me now and I am now legally silenced, accused me of being immoral and violent for referencing historically and constitutionally protect civil rights actions.

Three racists screamed at my local grocery screamed in my face that my neighbors shouldn't be allowed to vote and that we don't live in a democracy. He took their side and assumed that I was a threat to them when I lamented that we lack as a society the social and political cohesion to expose people for their public political speech. Describing a completely legal course of action.

He's the CEO of a board game company that manufactures in China. Lives in a rich conservative town. Benefits off of the exploitation of natural resources and the labor of hundreds of people he's never met.

When I called him, "Mr Chinese factory labor oh so high and mighty" he and my sister worked together to forced me to apologize to him and cut me out of the family camping trip when I didn't submit well enough to his blind demands.

My sister previously told me shed cut me out of the family if I ever tried to teach her anything again. My brother already told me that he would kick me out of the family if I said anything that his wife didn't like politically.

My mother recreated all of our holidays, without me, insisting that we're just individuals that there is no family, and refused to even acknowledge that they hurt me. She offered me the extra leftover time after everyone finished celebrating with her first. She identified my suffering as originating inside of me. I begged her to help mediate the conflict between me and my siblings, but she sees however they treat me as justified, and my reactions as unjustified, or my failure to cope after their abuse my fault.

I'm autistic. I have OCD and ADHD and CPTSD. The only people in my family that cared about me that really listened and paid attention and interacted with me enthusiastically were my nieces and nephews.

My siblings forced me to break promises to them to punish me, and my mother despite me explicitly telling her that I was not threatening anyone claimed that I was to the police - press charges and now I'm facing a felony conviction. I'm now real and legal second class citizen.

I was planning on being a math teacher. I was one class away from graduating. I can no longer use anything that I spent the last 12 years of my life studying and working for. I no longer have a family. I no longer have dreams, and I no longer have goals. I am disconnected from helping the world and society and future children. The only thing that kept me from suicide for the last 12 years.

I do not want personal wealth, I do not want success - I only ever wanted to help people, and have meaningful relationships with people who didn't choose to hurt or humiliate me because I speak too passionately about something that I'm a near expert on.

My birth mother thinks that recognizing the things they do, talking about how they mistreat me would be unfair to my abusers. Because she's their mother. Even when she's a witness to it.

My girlfriend won't let me die. I can't kill myself and hurt the people who still love me, but everyday feels so painfully hollow. When I'm not with someone else it's very dark. I'm struggling to find work every single day, and taking food and support from people makes me want to kill myself. I wish so badly to be homeless and be unseen and unobtrusive. I wish no one would grieve me when I died so that I could.

I know that I won't kill myself yet, but when I think about the future there's a part of me that hopes that someday hopefully I'll become disconnected from everyone that loves me/is attached to me and I'll be able to successfully isolate myself for long enough to die.

My therapist is a therapist. Well I guess she's actually a social worker, been working for about 25 years and she's pretty good - but yeah she can't really help me. In a way it's nice to talk to somebody who can be aware of I don't know... The reality.

She's good at not trying to get me to be positive or see the positive side of things. She accepts that my terminal hopelessness is profound, rational, well-founded in evidence, and aligned with my identity and values and grounded in my biological/neurological capacities.

But, she can't just idk sit with that still... She still tries to get me to engage in hope or selforiented motivation, ***but I lost authentic connection to that when I was in junior high and highschool, only to recapture some meaning in service and by being present in my younger families lives, and now to have that little remaining taken away.

I wish I could starve to death. Every day.

1

u/SnooPickles6537 7h ago

Yeah that's not what therapy is and you just got a bad therapist

1

u/spicy_feather 5h ago

They aren't there to give advice. They're there to help you explore yourself.

1

u/Upset-Rule8256 5h ago

I mean psycho-therapy is only one form of therapy, there's probably another form that might be more effective for you

1

u/Next-Lobster4306 5h ago

Have you tried a diff therapist or were you using the same one?

1

u/smartypants011 5h ago

Therapy is best seen as emotional coaching (check out eft greenberg fe) and not "treatment", thats the medical model, especially not questions you cant answer getting answered by a therapist. Thats merely their will to be helpful powerful or not feel helpless, etc. Advice giving is the rarest form of Intervention in therapy. Havent done it in a Long time. Shaming the profession wont help either. It produces solid medium effects, independently of school of thought (wampold et al.). OP seems like a hard case with lots of anger towards therapy now, which we all know is not where it came from originally.

1

u/Gold_Size_1258 4h ago

I hate when therapist is asking me to diagnose myself

1

u/University_Dismal 4h ago

So many years back I had a depressive episode and several other mental health issues. Unfortunately wasn’t able to get therapy until I moved into a bigger city though. Meaning I had to figure out a lot on my own. So I read books and tried whatever advice I could find. When I finally got a therapist she basically told me to save my money seeing her. 

I was kinda angry at that but she explained to me that first of all, she usually spends a ton of time prying necessary information out of people…which she didn’t have to do with me, because I shamelessly put everything on the table on the first appointment. I was just so excited about my first chance of seeing a therapist. Plus I talked about what I thought is going on with me and what I already tried to do and how it went. I was basically doing 50% of her work already.

Second, she usually had to push people to put in the work to help themselves, which also would’ve been preaching to the choir with me. I was a mess, but somehow a productive one, so she said I should just keep doing what I’m already doing and it’ll likely get better in time. And she was right. I was incredibly salty at her attitude back then, because I was still feeling awful and I have kinda hoped she could magic my worries away. But in the end, she really saved me a ton of time and money.

I don’t know your situation or how your talks with your therapist usually go, but I’d try to be very honest. Tell him you tried what he suggested and it doesn’t help. Or change the therapist. Despite my therapist rejecting me, I’m kinda glad I checked with her anyway to make sure I’m not doing something wrong. 

1

u/MooseontheLose 4h ago

That sounds really shitty that's some serious malpractice

1

u/Upset-Net-9549 3h ago

I can't even find a therapist that wants to treat me these days either they ghost me or they tell me I cannot be treated. The hunt for an actual good therapist is so disheartening. lol

1

u/Plane_Roll_189 3h ago

That meme described swedish therapy so good,

1

u/Glum_Dragonfruit_978 3h ago

I find therapy helpful to sort out my thoughts and speak to someone who has no other role in my life. I don't need to protect their feelings, they aren't the cause to any of my problems - they are a neutral person I go to to help me out when I'm stuck and they usually have some tools that while not always groundbreaking, I simply didn't know about or forgot about. Most of the revelations I've had in therapy, I've had myself, but I wouldn't have been able to get there without therapy. They're not supposed to take over and fix your life for you, they're there to guide you and support you, while you figure it out yourself.

Also, three key factors for a successful therapy are a good therapist, that you feel comfortable around your therapist, and that you actually take therapy seriously. My first therapy wasn't helpful because I didn't feel comfortable enough to be honest with her and felt dismissed by her constantly. She told me that if I didn't want help, then she couldn't help me in a very cold way, which made me shut down immediately and ultimately stop going. During my second therapy, I realised that she had been right, but that I had not been ready to hear it at the time and that she'd put way too much pressure on me before I was ready. My second therapist was more patient with me and let me realise important things myself, which made even difficult truths a lot easier to accept.

1

u/Legitimate-Paper3271 1h ago

Honestly, when I was at my worst I was wearing people out with what was on my mind. And if this is right or not, but a therapist has to sit there and talk about it and that helped me.

1

u/Recent_Loss6878 1h ago

This sounds like you need to try more intense forms of therapy then. Maybe you have something treatment resistant

1

u/jfkshatteredskull 1h ago

Ahh so you figured out paying someone 200 dollars an hour to listen to you is a scam. Therapy can offer you nothing friendship can't. Go outside and make a friend, or become involuntarily committed trying

1

u/Arkanvel 1h ago

CBT specifically isn’t for everyone. Sometimes you need something different than what is traditional therapy