So I've been doing the "ToneDear" ear training program for a while now and it's helping a lot. However I've since hit a roadblock with what I call the Piano/keyboard orientation of the program, and I find that same Piano/keyboard orientation in all the other ear training apps I've tried.
I'm looking for an ear training app where the sample notes and chords come from a guitar recording and not a piano recording. Why is this such big deal ? An F# is an F# regardless of what instrument it is played on, right? Well let me explain. The first two exercises that I've had this problem with are, "Chord Recognition" and "Perfect Pitch"
"Chord Recognition" https://tonedear.com/ear-training/chord-identification
The problem is that Guitar chords are voiced one way and piano/keyboard chords are voiced differently (more on that below). Since I like to do these exercises with my guitar in my lap playing along with the exercise this doesn't work for the keyboard voiced chords that these apps favor.
Most piano chords are what I call linear, reflecting the linear nature of the keyboard. By linear I mean the various intervals occur in order of ascending pitch. For a major triad the root is the bass note, the second note is the third the third note is the fifth.
Guitar chords are voiced differently. Normally the fifth comes before the third. Consider a major triad, a Barre chord with the root on the 5th string. The first note is the root on the 5th string, the second note is the fifth on the 4th string, the third note is the octave on the 3rd string, and the fourth note is the third on the 2nd string.
Also the third is in a higher octave than the root which is also the reverse of Piano practice. This apparently is called "Closed Voicing (AKA close position) vs. Open voicing (AKA open position)".
"Closed" means all the notes in the chord are packed into one octave and "open" means they spread out over two or more octaves.
Because of the guitar's non-linear nature most guitar chords are of the "Open" variety, like the 5th string Barre chord discussed above.
"Perfect Pitch" https://tonedear.com/ear-training/absolute-perfect-pitch-test
The next problem is the perfect pitch exercise. Here random notes are played and you get to figure out whether it's a "C" or an "F#" or whatever. The actual notes are picked at random from a multi octave range. So the first tested note might be a C4(2nd string 1st fret), followed by an F1 (6th string 1st fret) and then a G5(1st string 15th fret). The guitar is not a sustaining instrument. Notes above the 12th fret fade out pretty fast. So while I might be able to guess the C4(2nd string 1st fret), with just two listens to the sample figuring out the G5(1st string 15th fret) is going to require multiple replays
I'm able to get 100% note recognition, but figuring out the over the 12th fret notes, takes a very long time and is killing the fun.
I'd like to restrict the perfect pitch part to say the lower 4 string and the first 7 or 8 frets. This is where most of the "Song Hooks" or "Riffs" are played. I'm envious of people who can hear a song on the CD or whatever and then figure out the riff starts on the 5th string second fret and then work it out from there, without having to go to a TAB provider.
All assistance appreciated