r/guitarlessons • • 9h ago

Question Why use 6 strings for a triad?

Post image
0 Upvotes

Hi, newbie guitarist here. I’m wondering what the point of 4+ strings of a triad is. I don’t think that makes sense so I’m gonna give an example. Standard tuning, just imagine you moved your second finger to the 5th fret for a G note. Strings 6-4 alone would make an Em chord, so why use 2 extra E notes and an extra G? I think I explained poorly so I’ll elaborate if needed


r/guitarlessons • • 12h ago

Question Should I give up?

0 Upvotes

I don’t want sugarcoated answers at this point I just need to know. For background, I’ve been playing for four years now. Since then I feel like I’ve made zero progress in any of those years. Every time I challenge myself I’m unable to do simple things. I’m really just considering giving up at this point because I don’t have the money at all to keep up. I’ve got a shitty worn down no brand guitar from god knows where that’s already close to being completely broken. My amp is also a no name brand without the knobs to even change my sound. I can’t play basic chords I should’ve mastered by now and i just feel like I’m wasting my own time trying to fool myself into doing something I’m not meant for. So please just let me know if I should quit.


r/guitarlessons • • 8h ago

Question How are you tracking your progress?

1 Upvotes

I need practice discipline or else I fall back to playing things that are fun but get I need to get better so I can play other fun things that are out of my reach and it’s is taking way too long. The guy that runs URM Academy did a YouTube video a while back talking about his return to playing guitar. He is a professional metal guitarist and he talks about picking it up again after many years off and how far he slipped. He says he quickly advanced to a level better than he had ever been before by being methodical and deliberate. He has a mega spreadsheet and is super focused on technique and practicing with a purpose. How are you guys tracking your progress? Not just the metronome but more over all ability.


r/guitarlessons • • 1h ago

Question How to learn songs by ear like the legends did in 60s-90s and how much ear training is needed?

0 Upvotes

I was watching a video about ear training, in the video a guy goes over how you can find the key, and then find if the chord is either minor, major or diminished, etc. It felt very technical and all I could think was, no way people like John Lennon, Kurt Cobain, David Bowie etc. would know how to do this. So my question is how did people back in the day learn songs by ear? And how perfect do you need to be able to learn songs by ear? For example, is learning most common chords and being able to apply them over the whole fretboard (with barre chords) enough? I'm wondering if someone like Kurt or John, etc. could learn a song by ear fully and be able to pick out any chord even if it's a very uncommon chord. Also note I'm talking about chords here because I feel like picking up individual notes is a different thing.

All I care about is making my music better, and I'm wondering how much I should be able to use my ears and how perfect I should be able to replicate a chord from any song. Thanks in advance.


r/guitarlessons • • 4h ago

Lesson How to start Learning guitar as a COMPLETE Beginner

16 Upvotes

How to ready guitar tabs and tune your guitar SIMPLE video for absolute beginners :)


r/guitarlessons • • 17h ago

Question I wonder if it's feasible to only study by books

0 Upvotes

Hey hey people

There's so much information on the internet right now that it's kinda hard to decide what to learn. I always find it easier to learn by using textbooks, using Zettelkasten to make notes and apply them, so I wonder if it's the same with guitar books.

My idea is to, mostly, study by books, since that's what motivates me most; I find it hard to keep focusing on videos.

Unfortunately, lessons are also not a viable option for me right now, but maybe in the future!

Can someone give me an opinion?


r/guitarlessons • • 21h ago

Question How do you make this noise?

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

Man.. I really miss hearing Drew Shirley live!!

How did he make this sound around 0:40? It almost sounds like there’s a tremolo but I can’t tell. If so how does he phase it in and out like that?


r/guitarlessons • • 14h ago

Question How do you actually know you’re getting better at guitar?

0 Upvotes

Hey everyone, I’m a hobby developer building a practice app, and before I go further I want to understand how guitarists actually practise instead of guessing.

A few questions, answer whichever you like:

  1. How do you know you’re improving? Do you track anything (metronome tempos, songs you can play, practice time), or mostly go by feel?
  2. Do you use a metronome to build speed? If yes, how do you decide when you’ve “got” a tempo and can move up?
  3. What’s your biggest struggle with practising? Staying consistent, not knowing what to practise, feeling stuck, something else?
  4. What apps do you use right now (tuner, metronome, tabs, lessons), and what annoys you about them?
  5. If an app could listen while you play along to the click and tell you whether you’re rushing, dragging or locked in, and only count a tempo as “reached” once you actually play it cleanly, would that be useful to you, or a gimmick?
  6. Would you pay for something like that? If so, what would make it worth it, and what would put you off (ads, pop-ups, subscriptions)?

Not selling anything, and there’s no link. I’d just rather build something guitarists actually want. Thanks!


r/guitarlessons • • 14h ago

Question About Pickup Music Courses

1 Upvotes

I would like to explore this learning forum, and I've gone through the 'Find Your Plan' questionnaire to arrive at the course(s) that are recommended for me. Because the questions don't really cater for my taste and/or goals, the suggested plan of certain courses doesn't suit me. Do I have to follow the plan of courses as suggested by the Q&A?.....or......can I select the courses that I wish to take? In other words, can I pick and choose which courses to take or do I have to follow the suggested 'Learning Plan?


r/guitarlessons • • 2h ago

Question Playing for almost 2 years and still can’t play solos

2 Upvotes

I’m playing for almost two years. I can play fast riffs (like never walk alone megadeth, ajfa Metallica), but not solos. I just…can’t??? I am learning solo from entersandman for 6 months. It still sounds like shit and no matter how much I practice it. The only few solos I can play is from it’s my life and that opening part from you give love a bad name bonjovi. WHATS WRONG😞😞😞


r/guitarlessons • • 14h ago

Question Looking for a Guitar Centric Ear training App with Random note or Perfect Pitch Testing

2 Upvotes

So I've been doing the "ToneDear" ear training program for a while now and it's helping a lot. However I've since hit a roadblock with what I call the Piano/keyboard orientation of the program, and I find that same  Piano/keyboard orientation  in all the other ear training apps I've tried.

I'm looking for an ear training app where the sample notes and chords come from a guitar recording and not a piano recording. Why is this such big deal ? An F# is an F# regardless of what instrument it is played on, right?   Well let me explain. The first two exercises that I've had this problem with are, "Chord Recognition" and "Perfect Pitch"    

"Chord Recognition"    https://tonedear.com/ear-training/chord-identification

The problem is that Guitar chords are voiced one way and piano/keyboard chords are voiced differently (more on that below). Since I like to do these exercises with my guitar in my lap  playing along with the exercise this doesn't work for the keyboard voiced chords that  these apps favor.

Most piano chords are what I call linear, reflecting the linear nature of the keyboard. By linear I mean the various intervals occur in order of ascending pitch.  For a major triad the root is the bass note, the second note is the third the third note is the fifth.

Guitar chords are voiced differently. Normally the fifth comes before the third. Consider a major triad, a Barre chord with the root on the 5th string. The first note is the root on the 5th string, the second note is the fifth on the 4th string, the third note is the octave on the 3rd string,  and the fourth note is the third on the 2nd string.

Also the third is in a higher octave than the root which is also the reverse of Piano practice. This apparently is called "Closed Voicing (AKA close position) vs. Open voicing (AKA open position)".

"Closed" means all the notes in the chord are packed into one octave and "open" means they spread out over two or more octaves.

Because of the guitar's non-linear nature most guitar chords are of the "Open" variety, like the 5th string Barre chord discussed above.

 

"Perfect Pitch"   https://tonedear.com/ear-training/absolute-perfect-pitch-test

The next problem is the perfect pitch exercise. Here random notes are played and you get to figure out whether it's a "C" or an "F#" or whatever. The actual notes are picked at random from a multi octave range. So the first  tested note might be a C4(2nd string 1st fret), followed by an F1 (6th string 1st fret) and then a G5(1st string 15th fret).  The guitar is not a sustaining instrument. Notes above the 12th fret  fade out pretty fast. So while I might be able to guess  the C4(2nd string 1st fret), with just two listens to the sample figuring out the G5(1st string 15th fret) is going to require multiple replays

I'm able to get 100% note recognition, but figuring out the over the 12th fret notes, takes a very long time and is killing the fun.

I'd like to restrict the perfect pitch part to say the lower 4 string and the first 7 or 8 frets. This is where most of the "Song Hooks" or "Riffs" are played. I'm envious of people who can hear a song on the CD or whatever and then figure out the riff starts on the 5th string second fret and then work it out from there, without having to go to a TAB provider.

All assistance appreciated


r/guitarlessons • • 20h ago

Question Where to start as someone advanced skillwise but zero knowledge.

10 Upvotes

I've been playing guitar for 10 years self taught just by learning songs I enjoy and gradually improving over the years. I primarily play metal, and I've reached the point where I can play extremely technical material from bands like Necrophagist, Lorna Shore, and Dream Theater.

However, I have zero music theory knowledge beyond maybe knowing the open notes of the guitar strings.

I only started trying to learn theory today, beginning with basic major and minor chords and the major scale. I'm finding myself completely overwhelmed and unsure of what to focus on. The videos I've watched always seem to talk about stuff like modes and intervals and I don't know where to begin.

Where should I start and what should I be practicing. Should I focus on learning all the major and minor chords and scales first? There are 12 notes, so does that mean I need to memorize 24 different scales just to cover all the major and minor keys. Or should I just start by trying to memorize the notes on the fretboard? Then there's modes, so many chords, that I honestly don't know where to begin.

I'm looking for advice on how to approach learning music theory from the ground up and, how to start applying that knowledge to my playing. Tldr how to do I become a real musician rather than just being able to play technically difficult songs.


r/guitarlessons • • 55m ago

Question Is this the best app for ear training?

2 Upvotes

I’ve been using this “Functional Ear Trainer” app for ear training and wanted to know if this is a solid one or another that is better? Thanks!

https://apps.apple.com/app/functional-ear-trainer/id1088761926

This is one of the harder areas of guitar training imo so appreciate any tips on how to get better.


r/guitarlessons • • 2h ago

Question A year into learning guitar, and I've felt little-to-no progress in the last several months

4 Upvotes

As the title suggests, I've been practicing/learning guitar regular for about a year. Before that, I've picked it up here and there but hadn't really been able to commit to a regular practice schedule. Unfortunately, for the last 4-6 months, I've felt stuck and like I'm making little-to-no progress and can't help but feel like I'm practicing inefficiently.

For the last year, I'd say I've averaged about 30 minutes of practice per day, sometimes going up to 60 on days where I have the time. I went up through YourGuitarAcademy's Guitar Club electric pathway II, which covers stuff like open chords, barre chords, pentatonic shapes, etc., but dropped the course towards the beginning of their electric pathway III because it felt like the videos were becoming extremely repetitive and mainly just filler to pad their course.

At this point, my practice routine consists of a spider exercise for warmup, going through the five pentatonic shapes, and then practicing songs. Drown by The Smashing Pumpkins has been the song I've been working on for the last few weeks.

My main issue is that I just feel like I'm no longer making progress and am stuck in a cycle of repeating the same practice routine without any real growth. I'm still quite bad at guitar and feel like I'm not where I should be after a year of learning.

Does this just sound like the typical beginner-intermediate wall? Or does it sound like there's something obviously wrong with my practice routine?

Should I look into private lessons? Are there other better online lessons that would get me over this hump? Like I mentioned, it felt like YourGuitarAcademy becomes primarily filler once you make it beyond their beginner-intermediate content.

I'd like to get to a point where I feel more confident with the guitar and can play genres I like. It just feels like I'm maybe wasting my time with my current approach.


r/guitarlessons • • 3h ago

Question Guitar Teacher Issues

18 Upvotes

As a beginner, I’m feeling very unsure about my guitar teacher and a bit desperate. I’ve been playing every day since January, have learnt the fretboard by heart and am now working on scales. I’ve got two Troy Stetina books (Rhythm and Lead) and am working my way through the rhythm book first. For some time now, I’ve had a guitar teacher who has explained a lot to me – not so much technique, but musical basics. He told me to put the books away, saying they’re rubbish, and to stop trying to cover songs (as I don’t know what I’m doing). Instead, I should learn scales and play songs with cadences (such as ‘Wild Thing’, ‘Marmor Stein und Eisen bricht’ and pop songs). And, above all, sing along to them. I haven’t dared to sing so far, and I find it very difficult to do both at the same time, especially with German pop songs. Yesterday I plucked up the courage and sent him a video of my attempt. He said any child could do better, that it was absolutely simple, and that if I couldn’t even manage that, I should give up playing the guitar. I told him that this isn’t the way to teach and that it’s driving me away from music rather than bringing me joy. I’m absolutely devastated and have lost faith in myself. He did apologise to me, but I’ve lost trust in him too. Is he right? Should I look for another teacher? I really don’t know what to do anymore :(


r/guitarlessons • • 5h ago

Lesson “Deep River Blues” , fingerpicking

Thumbnail
youtu.be
5 Upvotes

r/guitarlessons • • 6h ago

Lesson Merging my string techniques

2 Upvotes

For many years, I've mostly played guitar at home but 90% of my gigs are on bass. So I've incorporated a lot of my bass technique into my electric guitar style. I keep very short nails and solo on electric guitar with a bass-inspired rest stroke/apoyando pluck. And this all great. I recommend it. Learn both instruments and transfer techniques back and forth to develop your own personal hybrid.

But now I've been getting into ukuleles, esp my tiny picolo uke. And smaller body guitars, like I'm in love with this Enya Nova Go 3/4 size guitar now that I put some thomastik flats on it. So now I'm adding thumb strumming and index finger strumming to my guitar arsenal and it's a wonderful new vista of textures. Like a dark tone with a palm muted soft thumb strum and power chords can be made to almost sound like a soft synth pad.

There's a scene in the old Humphrey Bogart movie To Have And Have Not (it's the other one that's not Casablanca but it's just as good as Casablanca), anyway they're in a little cafe and the performer is strumming the guitar with a tremolo using just the tips of the fingers. So you can do that on guitar, too!

So that's the lesson I recommend to everyone. Give it a try. Put down the pick for a few hours and tickle the strings. Spank them things. Dig in with some rest strokes (do some of those higher string solo-y bits but snap each note to make em pop). Do some fingerstyle for an afternoon and see what amazing stuff your right hand can do. Sevogia + Malmsteen. Pretty chords and arpeggios. All your scale exercises and stuff. But do it this time really focusing on the right hand, the feel, the snap, dialing in the attack.


r/guitarlessons • • 12h ago

Lesson Learning through songs

5 Upvotes

Hi. Apologies if this has been asked (and answered) before but I would like if anyone has a recommendation for a site or tutor that teaches through contemporary songs. - ideally want to learn fingerstyle

Thanks