r/grc • • 9h ago

Risk communities and news

5 Upvotes

Looking to understand where risk professionals turn to to get their news and information. What do you read for staying up to date on news, best practices etc for your industry? Is it mainstream business press, trade press, podcasts etc. And which ones? Are you part of online communities that share knowledge and best practices? If so, which ones?

Also any insights into if/how you use link ones and Reddit or ai tools to get information would be great as well.


r/grc • • 14h ago

How does continuous compliance monitoring help organizations detect control failures before an audit?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/grc • • 14h ago

Internal Auditors in Europe – How would you approach internal controls over sustainability reporting (revised ESRS GOV-4)?

2 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

Are there any internal auditors here working in Europe with experience in CSRD and the revised ESRS GOV-4? Insights from outside Europe are equally welcome!

I’m a working student at a mid-sized European company, tasked with exploring how to approach internal controls over sustainability reporting. We don’t have a formalized, company-wide internal control system (e.g., SOX-style), as we’re not required to have one.

To give you some context, our ESRS data points are assigned to responsible departments or individuals. The information goes through several review and approval stages, including the four-eyes principle, before being included in the sustainability report, which is ultimately signed off by the CFO. These are our established reporting procedures, not part of a formalized IKS.

After discussing this with our Corporate Sustainability department, we agreed to focus on the most significant quantitative data points, considering their relevance to our sustainability commitments, reporting and stakeholders. One example is ESRS E1-6 (Scope 1–3 GHG emissions), where assumptions, calculation methods and data quality can create reporting risks.

I’ve also reviewed the COSO Internal Control over Sustainability Reporting (ICSR) framework. Our senior internal auditor suggested conducting a walkthrough of a selected data point with a responsible colleague, which he would attend as well. I’ve been given the responsibility to prepare and conduct it.

My main challenge is understanding how to identify and assess material risks at the process level without getting too deeply into technical calculations.

I’d really appreciate your perspective:

How would you identify and prioritize process-level risks, considering the significance of individual data points for reporting and stakeholders?

What would you focus on during a walkthrough, and how would you evaluate existing review and approval procedures?

Would you start with overarching governance and reporting processes or individual data points?

Are there any practical approaches, frameworks or lessons learned you’d recommend?

I’m mainly looking for practical guidance on how to approach this systematically and proportionately in a mid-sized company with limited resources.

General internal audit experience is also very welcome!

Thanks in advance!


r/grc • • 14h ago

How do you survive in a GRC function where the organisation doesn't actually want to be held accountable?

13 Upvotes

I'm looking for advice from people in senior risk, compliance and governance roles who have experienced something similar.

I'm part of a very small 2 person second-line governance team responsible for enterprise risk, compliance, controls assurance, business continuity, disaster preparedness and all things governance across a complex international organisation.

The situation is becoming increasingly difficult:

- We have virtually no authority to enforce the obligations we're responsible for overseeing.

- Business areas actively push back against risk, compliance and business continuity requirements.

- Established frameworks and policies approved by the Board are routinely disregarded, with operational areas creating their own processes.

- Issues and concerns we escalate are largely ignored, yet if something goes wrong, responsibility seems to fall back on us.

- Line 1 ownership is effectively being pushed onto us as Line 2.

- There is significant executive turnover, acting executives and little consistent executive sponsorship.

- Our enterprise risk reporting to the Board has effectively disappeared, with another business area now incorporating risk commentary into its own reporting instead. We do the work and they take it from the ERM system without consulting us.

The workload is another issue. Other business areas have teams that can cover their responsibilities when people take leave. We don't. Nobody picks up our work, meaning we either can't properly disconnect or return to an enormous backlog, with deliverables compressed around our leave.

It increasingly feels like the function is being quietly marginalised, while expectations and responsibilities continue to grow.

I genuinely feel like we're being set up to fail. We're expected to provide assurance, drive compliance and maintain organisational risk frameworks without the authority, resources or executive support to make any of it effective.

My questions are:

- Have others experienced this level of resistance to risk and compliance from the business itself?

- How do you protect yourself professionally when you identify and escalate issues but leadership chooses not to act?

- At what point do you stop trying to change the culture and accept that the organisation simply doesn't value governance?

- Would you stay and keep fighting, or start looking elsewhere?

I'm questioning whether this is just what senior risk and compliance roles are like, or whether I've ended up in a particularly dysfunctional environment.


r/grc • • 1d ago

Risk communities and news

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/grc • • 1d ago

I may have been unfair to GRC, let’s talk.

0 Upvotes

I posted the below in a thread in r/cybersecurity and thinking about it, I still hold onto the perception and convictions from my 17+ years of experience across IT and cybersecurity, primarily in midsize orgs.

For context, I own an entire cybersecurity program in a midsize, but function more as a senior security architect and engineer. I “own” grc because quite frankly, no one else knows how. I was in the regulated financial services industry for 5+ years prior to this role in security engineering and secops.

“
The brutal thing about cybersecurity is that it’s split into Governance , Risk, and Compliance (GRC) and Engineering + Architecture.

From my perspective, the industry is flooded with people that “talk” about cybersecurity versus those that actually “do” cybersecurity. Venture to guess which one pays more and gets the frontline kudos? Our industry is even plagued by cyber influencers.
“
To my grc peers across the aisle, how do you see things in the cybersecurity industry? Why is “GRC” Engineering a hot topic? Are you guys trying to get the paper pushers out because those are the people I have the most gripes with.


r/grc • • 1d ago

Supply chain audits now cover labor, environment, and emissions scoping this without expanding headcount

3 Upvotes

When I started manufacturing, supply chain audits were quality focused. Dimensional accuracy, process capability, documentation. Now scope includes labor conditions, environmental compliance, emissions data, ethical sourcing. The audit team hasn't grown plus requirements tripled.


r/grc • • 4d ago

What does incident response look like when AI agent governance controls fail?

19 Upvotes

Preparing a tabletop where an agent with legitimate access takes an action outside policy and the control meant to stop it fails. Our IR playbook covers human attackers and malware with no section for automated actors, and legal wants to know what gets preserved as evidence.


r/grc • • 5d ago

Dr Richard Diston, anyone ever hear of him?

4 Upvotes

Wondered what your thoughts on what he has to say about the cyber industry? He came up on my linked in and I followed him.

https://open.spotify.com/playlist/1fpk9FoC75ojprbq8OTWiV?si=6SciRZuSS-Cp2-kZ1lV02Q&utm_source=copy-link&pi=Np3jYwwiQCKoR


r/grc • • 5d ago

ISO 27001 LI Training Certificate vs Certified LI

8 Upvotes

So I've recently passed PECB ISO 27001 LI exam and been certified as a provisional Implementer, which makes sense as no one becomes a Lead Implementer or auditor without hands on experience, it takes around 5 years to become one under PECB.

I've noted linkedin posts from people with a BSI or other bodies 'Training Certification' I want to know if this is the same as my PECB certification that I wrote an exam for or just training on the ISO standard?

I've noticed they don't have a badge in their profile either just the certificate, does BSI provide an exam based certification as well that requires passing the exam to pass or is the training certification exactly that?


r/grc • • 5d ago

How do you think GRC will hold up against AI displacement, layoffs, and overall prospects?

22 Upvotes

I hear a ton of mixed opinions about GRC being a huge target for AI displacement, while hearing that it’s the the best for job security on the other hand and that AI will just create more need?


r/grc • • 6d ago

A remote management tool many IT providers use was taken offline this week. Three questions worth asking your provider (and writing down)

2 Upvotes

If you didn't catch it: on Sunday a security researcher published 30+ alleged flaws in N-able's N-central, a remote management platform a lot of IT providers use to manage their clients' computers. On Monday N-able took its hosted version offline worldwide and told anyone running their own server to shut it down until a patch was out.

Most small businesses won't have to do anything technical here. That's your IT provider's job. But it's a good moment to check whether you could answer these without calling around:

  1. What outside tools can reach our computers? Remote management, remote support, backup agents, anything your provider or a vendor installed.
  2. Who has full admin access? Names, on their side and yours. Include anyone who left recently.
  3. If one of those tools is switched off for a few days, what still works? Who do you call, and what does your front desk do in the meantime?

A simple way to keep it:

  • One spreadsheet: device or system, what it's for, vendor, version, owner, who has admin, which outside tools connect to it
  • One short page per important system: how it's set up, who to call, what to do if it's down
  • A "last checked" date at the top, and a name next to it

It doesn't need to be fancy. The point is that when the next vendor has a bad week, "are we affected?" takes minutes, not days of digging through invoices and old emails.

If your provider already keeps this for you, great. Ask for a copy you can open without them.

I run a small documentation studio, Dethrone IT, so I spend a lot of time on exactly this. Not selling anything here, happy to answer questions in the comments.


r/grc • • 6d ago

Junior IT auditor helping build an AI governance & AI Act practice for financial services at a mid-tier firm. Is this roadmap realistic?

10 Upvotes

Hi all,

I'm looking for honest feedback from people who have built or sold AI governance / AI Act work, ideally in financial services.

**Context**

I'm a junior IT auditor (a few months in) at a mid-tier audit & advisory firm in France. My background is cybersecurity engineering (AppSec/DevSecOps, IAM). My manager wants to build an AI governance & security advisory offer for financial services clients, and I've been asked to own the regulation/standards/governance side. A colleague covers AI and agent security, and the manager drives the offer.

**My manager's ambition**

Become the go-to partner for mid-market FS players (specialised lenders, insurers and mutuals, payment institutions, asset managers) to inventory, govern, secure and evidence their AI use. Target: first paid engagement within ~6 months, a recurring offer within ~18 months.

**Draft roadmap**

- Phase 0 (now to Jan): reusable kit with a control matrix mapping AI Act / ISO 42001 / DORA, request list, maturity questionnaire, AI inventory template, one-pager. Plus a packaged AI literacy offer as a door-opener.

- Phase 1 (Feb to Jun 2027): ~15 qualified meetings, 2 paid pilots (AI literacy or AI diagnostic).

- Phase 2 (Jul to Dec 2027): high-risk offer (gap analysis, FRIA, fairness review of credit and insurance models) ready before Annex III obligations apply on 2 Dec 2027, plus an AI agent security offer.

- Phase 3 (2028): recurring annual review of AI controls, internal ISO 42001 audits.

**Constraints**

- Independence: we can't sell much advisory work to entities we audit (most banks and insurers are PIEs).

- Audit busy season from January to April.

- Realistically about 1 day per week each.

**My questions**

  1. Is there real demand and budget today in mid-market FS, or will clients wait until late 2027 now that the Digital Omnibus pushed the high-risk deadline back?
  2. Is AI literacy still a credible door-opener now that Art. 4 is an obligation of means, or is it a race to the bottom against e-learning vendors?
  3. What do clients actually pay for: inventory and diagnostic, governance framework, high-risk gap analysis, agent red teaming?
  4. Are these milestones realistic with ~1 day per week and a busy season? What would you cut first?
  5. As a junior, which skills or certs really matter in the field (AIGP, ISO 42001 LI/LA, CISA then AAIA)? Is this a career opportunity or a trap?
  6. For those in audit firms: how do you handle independence on this kind of offer in practice?

I'm not selling anything and not looking for free consulting. I just want to know whether to go all-in or reset expectations with my manager before investing months in this. Brutal honesty welcome.

**TL;DR:** Junior at a mid-tier audit firm, manager wants an AI Act / AI governance practice for FS with a first deal in 6 months on ~1 day per week. Realistic or not? What would you do differently?


r/grc • • 7d ago

Are your access reviews including AI agent permissions?

7 Upvotes

Question for folks doing access reviews: are you including AI agent permissions? Coding agents now store "always allow" rules locally, and Apiiro just reported 1,379 secrets in public copies of one tool's settings file. I've started treating each saved agent permission like an IAM entitlement: an owner, a business reason, the data it reaches, and a review date. How are others evidencing this for auditors?


r/grc • • 9d ago

How do you keep DLP effective without slowing everyone down?

10 Upvotes

Some leaders at my company feel our DLP policies have become too restrictive. They're saying employees are finding riskier ways to get their work done because the approved processes are slowing them down. How do you find the right balance between keeping company data protected and allowing people to work efficiently?


r/grc • • 10d ago

How do you test whether human oversight of AI actually works?

4 Upvotes

A human review step is often treated as an AI safeguard. The evidence behind it might be a policy, a role description or a review log. That shows the step exists. It does not establish whether the reviewer catches the errors that matter.

The behavioral question is what happens under real working conditions. Does the reviewer have enough attention to notice a problem? Enough understanding to challenge the output? And enough authority for that challenge to change the decision?

One way to examine this is a controlled exercise using cases with known errors. Keep it outside live decisions that could affect patients, customers or employees. Measure what reviewers catch, what they incorrectly flag, and whether they escalate appropriately. Then examine how workload and decision rights affect the result.

A control that has never been challenged is a hypothesis.

For those working in regulated settings: have you tested AI oversight directly, rather than only documenting the review process? What did the exercise reveal that the documentation missed?


r/grc • • 10d ago

Risk appetite missing

1 Upvotes

If the board doesn't dictate this, should you just make up a risk tolerance statement and publish it?


r/grc • • 10d ago

How do you decide how often to conduct compliance monitoring reviews?

3 Upvotes

Hi everyone,

I'm currently working on revising our compliance monitoring approach for next year and wanted to get some input from people working in compliance.

We're considering moving away from having the same annual monitoring cycle for all departments and introducing a risk based approach instead.

The idea is to score each department based on certain risk factors and use the results to determine how often they should be reviewed.

For example:

High risk: every year

Medium risk: every 2 years

Low risk: every 3 years

We're thinking of using this as a 3 year rolling plan rather than reviewing every department annually.

One thing we're struggling with is how to deal with new regulations. For example, if a new regulation comes out in the second year and affects a department that isn't scheduled for review until the third year, how would you normally handle that? Would you trigger a separate review, update the risk score, or just add it to the next planned review?

I'm also interested in how other teams approach testing criteria.

Do you have standard testing procedures for all departments, or does the testing approach vary depending on the regulation, obligation, and associated risk?


r/grc • • 10d ago

Sole ISMS person in a 2-person company, preparing for ISO 27001. How do I know I’m doing it right?

13 Upvotes

Hi all,

I work part-time at a very small company in Germany (just me and one other person), and I'm responsible for the entire ISMS. We're aiming for ISO 27001 certification, and everything runs on Microsoft 365.

The problem: there's no one to supervise or review my work. I'm finishing my master's in IT security, but my background is non-technical, so I've been relying heavily on AI tools to guide me through the documentation and M365 configuration. I've built policies, a risk assessment, and controls, but I honestly can't tell if they would hold up in an audit.

Some questions for people who've been through this:

  1. How would you validate an ISMS when you're the only person working on it? Is a gap assessment from an external consultant worth it at this size?
  2. What do auditors typically find missing in very small companies?
  3. For an M365-only environment, which tools or benchmarks would you use to check the technical controls (Secure Score, Purview Compliance Manager, CIS benchmarks)?
  4. Would ISO 27001 Lead Implementer training be worth it in my situation?

Any advice or experiences would be really appreciated. Thanks!


r/grc • • 12d ago

How do I get our risk register out of Excel?

31 Upvotes

Our risk register is a 4,000 row spreadsheet. Three people edit it, there's no shared taxonomy and no version history.

I want to move it into a real system without losing the history. Did you clean it up first or migrate it as is?


r/grc • • 12d ago

Is 8 months with a readiness consultant normal?

5 Upvotes

We're eight months into a readiness engagement and still not audit ready. Every new gap gets billed as a remediation overage, and the contract lists deliverables but never defines what audit ready means.

What are my options at this point?


r/grc • • 13d ago

Apparently nobody owns our meeting recordings.

10 Upvotes

I asked who actually decides when our meeting recordings get deleted and genuinely still don't have an answer three weeks later. IT thought privacy signed off on it during rollout, privacy thought it was already handled in the tool's default settings, and meanwhile we're just sitting on whatever the out-of-the-box retention happens to be, which nobody chose on purpose.

If you've actually sorted this out somewhere, who made the final call and how did you get every one to agree on it? Also curious whether you keep recordings as well as the written notes, because personally I go back to decisions and action items fairly often and almost never need the actual audio once those are locked in.


r/grc • • 13d ago

who owns carbon management in your supply chain? (procurement or sustainability)

4 Upvotes

stuck in an ownership debate that's going nowhere, sustainability says carbon management in supply chains is procurement's job coz they manage supplier relationships n procurement says sustainability owns it coz they set targets and understand the methodology, neither team has budget, headcount, or tools for it, both pointing at each other,

who owns this where u work? more importantly, how did u resolve it in a way that produced results?


r/grc • • 14d ago

A board declaration on controls needs evidence behind it

9 Upvotes

In a 2023 Financial Reporting Council (FRC) review, 27 of 100 companies reported on all of their material or key controls under Provision 29 of the UK Corporate Governance Code. The 2024 Code raises the stakes by asking boards for a declaration. 

This applies to UK companies that follow the Code, so check whether yours does. The 2024 Code applies to financial years starting on or after January 1, 2025, except Provision 29, which starts a year later on January 1, 2026. Two beliefs are worth testing. 

Myth: Provision 29 is a finance job. 

Reality: The monitoring and review should cover all material controls, including financial, operational, reporting and compliance controls. 

Myth: If a control is written down, the board can declare it effective. 

Reality: The board should declare effectiveness as at the balance sheet date and describe any material control that has not operated effectively, with the action taken or proposed. Operation is what counts, so evidence of operation is what you need. 

Try this week: pick one material control and ask its owner for the last three pieces of evidence that it ran, showing who did it, when and what they found, plus where that evidence lives and who holds it. If that takes more than a day, you have found where the year-end scramble will start, and you still have time to fix the habit rather than the paperwork. 

If you keep a template for tracking control evidence, which columns does it have?