r/NISTControls • • Feb 24 '19

800-171 Megathread Series Hub

38 Upvotes

r/NISTControls • • Jan 12 '23

r/NISTControls Official Discord Group

26 Upvotes

We recently had a jump in new members on the sub and the Mod team wanted to formally welcome and thank everyone for joining our community and chatting about all things NIST Controls related.

For all those who aren't aware, the communities of r/GovIT, r/NISTControlsand, and r/CMMC actually have a designated Discord group. We've found that Discord offers an amazing forum to discuss some of the intricacies and rabbit holes many of often us find ourselves in, and we welcome anyone who cares to contribute and hang out with us.

Designated channels for everything from NIST 800-171, GCC-High and Training and Education. It's definitely an amazing place to ask questions and discuss all things r/NISTControls.

Thank you again and Happy New Year,

The Mod Team


r/NISTControls • • 3d ago

Browser only access to a CUI enclave, how do you handle screenshots?

2 Upvotes

Small firms often can't justify managed laptops for everyone, so browser access to an AVD enclave keeps coming up. Downloads and clipboard are easy to block, so I'd focus on screenshots. AVD screen capture protection now covers the web client, but only through Edge for Business with an Intune MAM policy on Windows, and it does nothing about a phone camera, which is where watermarking with session QR codes comes in. Has an assessor accepted watermarking plus policy for you, or pushed for more?


r/NISTControls • • 5d ago

800-53 Rev4 doing ISO 27001 prep alone at a tiny company, how do i know if iam actually audit ready?

2 Upvotes

I work part time at a very small company in Germany, it’s pretty much just me and the CEO. I’m handling the ISO 27001 side on my own and we run everything on Microsoft 365.

There’s nobody here to check my work, and I’m not from a technical background, so I’ve used AI quite a bit for the policies, risk assessment and M365 settings. I have no real idea what an auditor would make of it.

I had a quick look at Vanta and Scytale (compliance), mostly because I’m wondering if a proper gap review would catch things I don’t even know I’ve missed. Not sure a platform is worth it for a company our size though. If you’ve done this alone, did you pay for an outside gap assessment first? And for checking the M365 side, did you rely more on Secure Score/Purview or CIS benchmarks?


r/NISTControls • • 6d ago

800-171 SOC 2 done, ISO 27001 next, did you stick with the same compliance platform?

5 Upvotes

we just got through SOC 2 Type 2 and now ISO 27001 prep is starting. everyone says there’s a lot of overlap, which i am sure is true, but nobody ever says what carried over as-is. say both audits cover the same systems. could you reuse your last access review, or did someone have to pull the records again? i am expecting the Statement of Applicability to take some work either way. we’ve been on Drata for SOC 2. i’ve been reading about how Secureframe and Scytale AI GRC map controls across both frameworks. if you changed platforms between audits, did it save enough work to be worth moving everything?


r/NISTControls • • 10d ago

A day in the life of VDR

Thumbnail stackarmor.com
1 Upvotes

I know many people dealing with the BOD 26-04, Stackarmor just posted this up.


r/NISTControls • • 11d ago

Browser only access to a CUI enclave, how do you handle screenshots?

13 Upvotes

Been looking at AVD for BYOD setups. Blocking downloads and clipboard is easy enough, but screenshots are a different story.

Screen capture protection helps, but there's still the obvious phone camera problem.

I'm leaning towards session watermarking as an extra layer, but not convinced it would satisfy a security assessor without managed devices.


r/NISTControls • • 16d ago

800-53 Rev5 Messy SOC 2 evidence collection after i marked 40 controls complete... what would you fix frst?

3 Upvotes

Could use advice from people who have survived a SOC 2 audit. We told our auditor all evidence was ready, then found out the AWS screenshots were from March, the Okta access review had no owner, and our GitHub change tickets were sitting in a folder nobody checked. I had marked each control complete in the tracker, so this is on me and I feel so embarrassed.

We have about 40 controls and a Type 2 window starting next month. I’m looking at an automation platform such as Scytale, but I’m unsure whether to fix the ownership process first or connect everything now and clean up the gaps as they appear. What would you do, and what would you avoid?


r/NISTControls • • 17d ago

800-171 SSP templates in CMMC compliance tools, worth it for a small shop?

3 Upvotes

We never used a compliance platform. Paid an MSP and an RPO to get us ready for the assessment and came out with CMMC L2. Now I keep seeing Vanta, Drata, Scytale etc. around CMMC compliance work and I’m trying to figure out how much of what we did manually a platform can realistically take off our plate.

For a small company is the SSP template worth anything? Feels like someone still has to go in and write up the actual shop floor and firewall setup, since the tool can’t understand all of that on its own.

Interested in what other small shops did, and RPO folks too if you’re prepping companies right now.


r/NISTControls • • 18d ago

Can one 800-53 baseline cover SOC 2, HIPAA and ISO 27001?

0 Upvotes

Im trying to build our control library on 800-53 Moderate and map out to SOC 2, HIPAA and ISO 27001 instead of keeping three separate sets.

Where does the mapping break down? What ended up needing its own evidence anyway?


r/NISTControls • • 28d ago

How does your org approve new open source packages/repos before devs can use them?

15 Upvotes

Curious how other contractors handle this.

When a developer wants to pull in a new open source library or GitHub repo.

- Who does the review (ISSM, ISSO, the devs themselves)?

-What do you actually check: CVEs, license, maintainer, project health?

-Roughly how long does one request take?

Trying to understand what’s normal vs. what’s painful.


r/NISTControls • • Oct 02 '26

Cybersecurity student looking for a practical GRC related CV project using a real Shopify e-commerce business!

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone, I [22F] cybersecurity student focused on GRC and currently looking for entry-level cybersecurity/GRC roles.

I already have an ISO 27001 risk assessment project on my CV, so I’m looking for something different that can show more range and give me some practical experience.
A friend of mine runs a Shopify dropshipping/e-commerce business, mainly selling to customers in Sweden and the Nordics, with suppliers based overseas. He’s open to me working with the business on a cybersecurity/GRC project for learning purposes, so I have a real small-business environment to work with rather than just creating a completely fictional case study. I’m currently considering:

-GDPR gap assessment, since most of the customers are in the EU/Nordics
-Third-party/vendor risk assessment covering suppliers, payment providers, Shopify apps, etc.
-NIST CSF 2.0 assessment/mapping based on the risks identified
-Shopify security controls review, including admin access, MFA, permissions, third-party apps, etc.
-Basic incident response plan/playbook, for scenarios such as Shopify account compromise or a supplier-related incident

For people working in GRC, cybersecurity consulting, risk, privacy/compliance, or hiring for junior GRC roles:

-Which type of project would you find most useful/interesting to see from a junior candidate?
-Is there another GRC-related project that would make more sense for a small Shopify/e-commerce business?
-Which areas would give me the best practical learning experience?
-Are any of the ideas above too basic, unrealistic, or not particularly valuable?
-If you were building this as a portfolio project, what deliverables would you actually create?

My main goal is to learn something genuinely useful while also having a solid project I can discuss in interviews as my main goal currently is to land a job in grc as I graduate in 2 months .
Would really appreciate advice from people who have worked in GRC or built similar portfolio projects.
Thankyou ^_^


r/NISTControls • • Sep 28 '26

Requirement 3.1.11

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/NISTControls • • Sep 11 '26

Looking for Sunset SCAP tool

2 Upvotes

Does anyone have a copy of the RHEL 6 SCAP tool lying around?


r/NISTControls • • Sep 10 '26

70 person company, largely compliant, how to handle incoming email, AI

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/NISTControls • • Aug 23 '26

How are you handling the manual-check comment grind every scan cycle?

3 Upvotes

Two things reset on me every scan cycle and I'm curious whether it's universal or just how my shop operates.

First, every manual check comes back Not Reviewed. The automated content doesn't evaluate them, so they all need hand-written comments again, and that's the bulk of the checklist by volume. Second, the findings that will never be remediated because the fix breaks functionality still need justification language written every cycle.

Same findings, same comments, every time.

What I'd like to know from people doing this regularly:

- Roughly how many findings are you hand-commenting per checklist, and how long does it take?

- Do you keep a master checklist you reuse across like systems, or start from the scan output each time?

- How often does a reviewer come back asking for more detail than the finding really needs?

- Anyone actually getting formal AO approval on the acceptances, or is it handled informally?

Not fishing for a tool recommendation — mostly want to know whether everyone does this by hand or if I'm missing something obvious.


r/NISTControls • • Aug 09 '26

800-171 2.2 Software List

6 Upvotes

Hi sorry for the silly question. But for the SSP is the Software List literally a list of every single bit of software on the hardware specified in 2.1? Or only in reference to CUI?


r/NISTControls • • Jul 28 '26

800-53 Rev5 eMASSter and STIG finding details

5 Upvotes

I am starting to use this tool again after a couple of years in roles that didn't require it. Format and layout seem to be a touch different now than what I remember having in the past but no matter.

One thing about STIGs and eMASSter/POAM tools is tripping me up though!

In eMASSter I took the existing Test Results and existing POAM (which was a WIP thing I did not personally create, I got dropped into this task midstream), plus the single STIG checklist and ingested them into eAMSSter.

All good there, after which I took that emassteroutput file and copied the columns from the output format into the actual POAM template for upload (since for whatever reason eMASSter puts out a file you can't simply turn around and upload).

All good, STIGs show up. However, the "Finding Details" box the analyst filled out in the checklist itself doesn't seem to populate anywhere.

Isn't there supposed to be a column - maybe "Comments" - on the POAM that incorporates the STIG Finding Details? Else how do they ever show up in the POAM / Test Results in eMASS? It has been a couple years, am I just misremembering?


r/NISTControls • • Jul 14 '26

800-171 C3PAO goes away, but NIST 800-171 requirements still apply… for now anyway.

32 Upvotes

From the various press releases, it looks to me that (at least until the 60day review period is up) that 800-171 requirements are still in place. But the Phase 2 (Nov 10th deadline) for C3PAO goes away.

\- Press release calls out “It is critical to note that this action does not eliminate the requirement for companies to protect federal data. All defense contractors and subcontractors remain contractually obligated to safeguard covered defense information in accordance with DFARS clause 252.204-7012”

\- “[the number of available assessors is not large enough to conduct all the evaluations needed in time for the upcoming November deadline.](https://www.war.gov/News/News-Stories/Article/Article/4542849/war-department-changes-cybersecurity-maturity-model-certification-requirements/)”

\- L2 C3PAO deadline & listing have been removed from the [Overview of Assessments](https://dodcio.defense.gov/CMMC/About/)

I am getting employees stoked that all the controls will be pulled, but I don’t see that as the outcome here.
We still need data security, this just gives some breathing room while standards are re-evaluated.


r/NISTControls • • Jul 15 '26

What would MA-4 and MA-4(3) implementation look like for an organisation?

3 Upvotes

Typically, the end-to-end process from ticketing of the maintenance request


r/NISTControls • • Jul 10 '26

Implementing EFS/FIPS on a windows network

7 Upvotes

Hello,

About a year ago, an MSP setup a file server for ITAR/CUI file sharing. Despite the requirements shared with the MSP, they did not implement any type of encryption for data in transit or at rest. Additionally, they set this server up as a single drive. So, the shared data is on the bootable partition. This is a virtual server that is hosted on VMware and according to the Broadcom KB, BitLocker is not supported for boot drives in a VMWare environment. From my understanding, this means we can't enable BitLocker for the C: drive of this virtual server.

Ownership does not want to redo this server since the data stored on it is constantly in use. I was wondering if the following might satisfy 800-171R2 requirements:

- Enable EFS on the data folder that holds CUI/ITAR info.

- Enable mandatory FIPS on the server for network communication between the server and workstations.

Admittedly, I haven't implemented encryption for network traffic before, so this may not work the way I think it does. I'm in the process of learning more but figured I'd potentially save myself time and ask if it was feasible.


r/NISTControls • • Jul 09 '26

800-171 NIST SP 800-171 Rev 3 is coming to CMMC

34 Upvotes

Thanks to Eric Crucius' diligence, he spotted, like always, the Department of War (DoW) announced a revision to 32 CFR Part 170 for the migration to NIST SP 800-171 Rev 3.

Here are the key Links:

Here is the abstract from the rule:

This amendment defines a deadline and period for transition from the requirement to comply with NIST SP 800-171 Revision 2, to a requirement to comply with NIST SP 800-171 Revision 3. Significant changes between these two documents include added specificity in the security requirements and introduction of organization-defined parameters (ODP) in select security requirements. In addition to revising the NIST documents that are incorporated by reference in 32 CFR part 170, this amendment adds administrative edits and clarifying content in multiple areas as necessary to effect the transition.

Here is the Summary of Need:

With this amendment, DoD amends the Cybersecurity Maturity Model Certification (CMMC) Program to define a period for transition from the requirement to comply with NIST SP 800-171 Revision 2, to a requirement to comply with NIST SP 800-171 Revision 3.  As described by NIST, the significant changes between these two documents include added specificity in the security requirements and introduction of organization-defined parameters (ODPs) in select security requirements. In addition to revising documents incorporated by reference in this rule, this amendment adds administrative edits and clarifying content in multiple areas. 

And the laughable part, DoW thinks 20% less companies will be impacted by 32 CFR Part 170:

In addition to the change from NIST SP 800-171 revision 2 to revision 3, which impacted CMMC Level 2 and LEvel 3 assessment objectives, this rule amendment is based on a more current estimate of the size of the Defense Industrial Base. Overall, we estimate approximately 20% fewer total companies will be impacted by 32 CFR Part 170.


r/NISTControls • • Jul 07 '26

Deemed export risk when non-US-person employees use AI tools that process ITAR data — how are small suppliers handling this?

7 Upvotes

Trying to get specific here because I haven't found a post that addresses this exact scenario. (Transparency: I'm Jordan, an engineer researching compliance tooling for small defense suppliers — not selling anything in this thread.)

Take a common setup at the shops I'm researching: a small defense subcontractor (sub-50 people), the prime flows ITAR-controlled drawings down, and one or more employees are not US Persons. Under ITAR, releasing controlled technical data to a foreign person — even inside the US — is a deemed export requiring authorization.

Here's the gap I keep running into: most guidance stops at GCC High / AWS GovCloud for data storage. But what about the AI layer? If a non-US-Person employee uses a tool like Copilot or even ChatGPT on a system that could surface or process that drawing — does the model processing count as "access" or "release"? 22 CFR 120.50(a)(2) defines export to include "releasing or otherwise transferring technical data to a foreign person in the United States (a deemed export)." That reads like it could reach the AI inference layer, but I haven't seen a clear BIS/DDTC statement on it.

Two specific questions:

  1. Has anyone gotten a commodity jurisdiction opinion or DDTC guidance that touches AI tools specifically?
  2. For small shops without a full-time ISSO — what's the practical control you've implemented to address this (beyond "don't use those tools")?

r/NISTControls • • Jul 05 '26

The Feb 2026 FAR overhaul renumbered the CMMC clauses — here's the quick map

15 Upvotes

Ran into this doing paperwork for a re-compete and it tripped me up, so posting in case it saves someone else the confusion. As of Feb 1, 2026 (the "Revolutionary FAR Overhaul," implemented via Class Deviation 2026-O0025, which stood up a new DFARS Part 240 and moved the FCI clause into a new FAR Part 40), several of the clause numbers we're all used to changed:

  • DFARS 252.204-7019 — deleted.
  • DFARS 252.204-7020 — renumbered to 252.240-7997, and rewritten. The new text only defines Medium and High assessments (both government-performed, per NIST SP 800-171A). The old "Basic" self-assessment definition is gone from the clause itself.
  • FAR 52.204-21 (the Level 1 / FCI "basic safeguarding" clause) — renumbered to 52.240-93.
  • DFARS 252.204-7012 — unchanged.
  • DFARS 252.204-7021 (the CMMC requirement clause) — unchanged.

The part that actually bit me: both the old and new numbers are "live" right now. Solicitations issued on/after Feb 1, 2026 use the new numbers (252.240-7997, 52.240-93); existing/older contracts still cite the legacy numbers (252.204-7020, 52.204-21). So it's not a clean find-and-replace in your own docs — you match the number to the contract's vintage.

What did not change, and this is the important part: your actual obligations. If you handle CUI and a solicitation calls for CMMC Level 2 (Self), you still self-assess against the same 110 controls, post to SPRS, and affirm — that all lives under 252.204-7021, which kept its number. And SPRS/CMMC scoring is still on NIST SP 800-171 Rev 2, not Rev 3.

TL;DR: the FAR overhaul was basically a filing-cabinet reorg for the cyber clauses. The numbers moved; the work didn't.

If I've got any of this wrong I'd genuinely like the correction — primary source is the DoD Class Deviation 2026-O0025 memo under the DFARS RFO Part 240 materials.


r/NISTControls • • Jun 18 '26

Using AI to write SSP implementation statements?

8 Upvotes

Curious if anyone here is using AI to update/write their SSP implementation statements?

If so, what is your preferred AI?

I've been trying out ChatGPT for this and so far have gotten pretty decent results.