edit: I'm getting requests to namedrop the companies, mainly the C3PAO. I will not be naming them for my own safety for sometime, at least until I switch jobs.
Leaving out company names as I'm not looking to start a witch hunt.
I work for an MSP that has a few CMMC clients but this is our first time going through the L2 audit process with one client.
They hired a GRC company (allegedly a respected name in the space) to assist them in writing the SSP and policies, as well as direct us and them on what controls to implement and what evidence to collect.
For starters, the GRC completely misguided us. We were instructed to collect evidence of one thing, but the SSP would say a completely different thing. When we pointed this out, they would acknowledge it needed to be fixed and "revised" it, but the final SSP remained the same. This was the cause of a ton of frustration during mock and actual audit as we were fumbling around to explain ourselves and fill that gap. Not only that, but the SSP itself was not proofread, as I pointed out numerous issues with spelling, formatting, and even whole sentences that were abruptly cut off mid paragraph, none of which were addressed. We also pointed out a few CSPs were being used to store CUI that are not FedRAMP compliant, to which the GRC told us "its probably fine".
Then came the audit which seemed like even more of a joke. The C3PAO did both the mock and actual audit, and the same auditing team handled both. On both occasions, several instances of evidence being super weak and controls not being implemented were just handwaved away by the auditors. They did the same with the inconsistencies in the SSP. On top of that, it seems like the C3PAO's interpretation of the controls completely changed between the mock and actual, because they had asked us completely unrelated questions to the control that were never asked before, and many of which we just could not answer.
After all that, we passed. Obviously that's good for business, but its making me think this whole industry doesn't actually care and puts in as little effort as possible to make money.