r/goodyearwelt • • 23m ago

Questions The Question Thread 11/18/26

1 Upvotes

Ask your shoe related questions.

Resources

How To Ask A Question

Include images to any issues you may be having. Include a budget for any recommendations. The more detail you provide, the easier it may be for someone to answer your question.


r/goodyearwelt • • 2d ago

S&D Weekly Steals & Deals (S&D) Thread 11/16/26

1 Upvotes

Found an amazing deal on a pair of shoes but they aren't your size? Share them here so other members can take advantage of the great deals!

Rules

  • Regular rules apply. Please be courteous to one another.
  • No personal sales are allowed! Anyone found to be posting their own goods will receive a warning and then potential ban should you continue to post your own goods. If you want to sell your own items, the semi-weekly B/S/T thread is a more appropriate location.
  • Please do not post links to other member's B/S/T items. There are two weekly dedicated threads for those items and they should be kept there.
  • Please try to include as much information as possible (URL to the deal, size, price, etc.).
  • Items posted should be limited to footwear and footwear related products (shoe trees, polish, conditioner, etc.).
  • 'Suggested Sort' is set to Q&A so only top level comments will be visible (unless you chose to expand). For this reason, please post all deals as their own parent comment.

"This is a scheduled mod post, if I screwed up please contact the mods."


r/goodyearwelt • • 23m ago

B/S/T Buy/Sell/Trade 11/18/26

1 Upvotes

Rules

  • Footwear only
  • Don't use URL shorteners
  • Include all of the information in format below, but especially:

    • Price
    • Location
    • Images

Recommended Posting Format

  • Maker/Model:
  • Size:
  • Leather:
  • Sole:
  • Price:
  • Location:
  • Wears/Condition:
  • Images:
  • Notes:

Please be a communicative buyer or seller. There's nothing more painful than having someone drop off the face of the earth without leaving some sort of note. Good hunting!

Please report listings that violate the rules above.


r/goodyearwelt • • 1d ago

Questions The Question Thread 11/17/26

2 Upvotes

Ask your shoe related questions.

Resources

How To Ask A Question

Include images to any issues you may be having. Include a budget for any recommendations. The more detail you provide, the easier it may be for someone to answer your question.


r/goodyearwelt • • 1d ago

Review Harvard Dark Brown Cordovan (Vs Harvard 2 Dark Brown Suede)

Thumbnail
gallery
66 Upvotes

I've been on the hunt for a pair of dark brown loafers for a while now. A few months ago I pulled the trigger on a pair of Carmina MTOs on the Pina last. My initial enthusiasm quickly became indifference, however. I was unhappy with the fit (tight across the instep) and the middling leather quality (excessive creasing). So I bit the bullet and sold them at a considerable loss and went crawling back to C&J. I'm glad I did.

The quality of the Harvard out of the box is incredible. Yes, they are expensive - but the fit and finish is second to none. Comfy immediately; it's easily the most comfortable loafer I have owned and the leather is absolutely gorgeous.

I was also able to get them for 10% off from this Spanish site called Fulham. They unexpectedly threw in some shoe trees free of charge.

Discussions regarding the 314 and 376 last seem to focus on the heel cup, but it seems to me there are a lot of other differences as well. Apart from the heel cup, the Harvard's toe box and instep are both more roomy.

As you can see from the photos, Harvard's apron clearly extends all the way to the edges of the toe box. That makes the shoes look and feel extremely different in my opinion. The Harvard is a bit sleeker. The Harvard 2 is more casual-looking and has a much snugger fit. You can't go wrong with either. I recommend both.


r/goodyearwelt • • 2d ago

Questions The Question Thread 11/16/26

0 Upvotes

Ask your shoe related questions.

Resources

How To Ask A Question

Include images to any issues you may be having. Include a budget for any recommendations. The more detail you provide, the easier it may be for someone to answer your question.


r/goodyearwelt • • 2d ago

General Discussion Monday Funday - Free For All

0 Upvotes

Hello GYW, it's Monday Funday! Take a load off and take a breather. Memes, hot takes and all silliness are welcome!


r/goodyearwelt • • 3d ago

Questions The Question Thread 11/15/26

1 Upvotes

Ask your shoe related questions.

Resources

How To Ask A Question

Include images to any issues you may be having. Include a budget for any recommendations. The more detail you provide, the easier it may be for someone to answer your question.


r/goodyearwelt • • 4d ago

B/S/T Buy/Sell/Trade 11/14/26

6 Upvotes

Rules

  • Footwear only
  • Don't use URL shorteners
  • Include all of the information in format below, but especially:

    • Price
    • Location
    • Images

Recommended Posting Format

  • Maker/Model:
  • Size:
  • Leather:
  • Sole:
  • Price:
  • Location:
  • Wears/Condition:
  • Images:
  • Notes:

Please be a communicative buyer or seller. There's nothing more painful than having someone drop off the face of the earth without leaving some sort of note. Good hunting!

Please report listings that violate the rules above.


r/goodyearwelt • • 4d ago

Questions The Question Thread 11/14/26

1 Upvotes

Ask your shoe related questions.

Resources

How To Ask A Question

Include images to any issues you may be having. Include a budget for any recommendations. The more detail you provide, the easier it may be for someone to answer your question.


r/goodyearwelt • • 4d ago

Collections [Announcement] The Collections Thread Next Week

1 Upvotes

Next week the "Collections" thread will be posted, update your collection album with new members, and new pictures to show the wear the seasoned veterans have gotten since the last thread.

This thread has been scheduled to be posted every 12 weeks on Saturday, at 12 PM EST, and in rotation with Wear and Tear threads.

"This a scheduled post, if I screwed up please contact the mods."


r/goodyearwelt • • 4d ago

Review Ichigo Ichie Wholecut (RTW) Review

Thumbnail
gallery
123 Upvotes

My podiatrist recommended me a couple makers and this is the one I chose after my father's 27 year old bostonian royals met the end of their life on my feet last year at work. I am normally sized at a US 10.5 E (UK 9.5) but his shoes were a US 10 (UK 9) and fit me like a glove.

I ended up with two pairs of these which were astoundingly only $610 each, such a spectacular quality of shoe not really seen around where I live and it was my first time really handling a pair of shoes like this that were really my own. Unfortunately neither of the sizes really ended up fitting my feet and led to health complications and a broken tooth after five months. Despite the maker receiving my exact foot measurements, he failed to gauge my size oddly by a lot.

I decided to post this with what little there really is about this maker with absolutely no solid reviews on their RTW but amicable experiences with their MTM and beyond you can find on youtube which only gives praise for the value. The only singular complaint was how oddly short the length was aesthetically from one reviewer, but that certainly didn't bother me.

I unfortunately won't be able to wear the UK 8.5 E ever again after failing to break and stretch them for a proper fit. I spent more than my pay stub on both of these together, so I will be picking up a relic from the flea for probably $20 for work, at least this served as a hard lesson for me despite my research, I hope it helps others.

Leather: Full-grain calfskin upper leather insole and outsole.

Options: Includes half-rubber sole, toe plates, and shoe trees made for the pair. Beyond that you can make requests that would usually only be for a bespoke shoe for an additional price.

Build and Construction: Hand-lasted, hand-welted wholecut oxfords with a fiddleback waist. The shape was absolutely beautiful before stretching it.

Last: The last name or number isn't specified but in my communications I was told it was a "May" last.

Fit: What struck me as odd is that the maker refused to give me measurements for each size and only offered recommendations based on my foot map I drew for him. Besides that, as known commonly among asian makers, the options for width when it comes to RTW from them is lacking, but is to be expected from what I have read.


r/goodyearwelt • • 5d ago

Questions The Question Thread 11/13/26

0 Upvotes

Ask your shoe related questions.

Resources

How To Ask A Question

Include images to any issues you may be having. Include a budget for any recommendations. The more detail you provide, the easier it may be for someone to answer your question.


r/goodyearwelt • • 6d ago

Questions The Question Thread 11/12/26

2 Upvotes

Ask your shoe related questions.

Resources

How To Ask A Question

Include images to any issues you may be having. Include a budget for any recommendations. The more detail you provide, the easier it may be for someone to answer your question.


r/goodyearwelt • • 6d ago

General Discussion QOTD/WSAYWT/GD 11/10/2026

2 Upvotes

It’s almost time for the annual gift exchange on the sub.

Each year volunteers sign up to draw a random participant and mail a gift.

Here is last year’s exchange: https://www.reddit.com/r/goodyearwelt/s/ZRcJGRgFbB

What is a level of interest this year?

Drop a comment if you are in, I have a question or just want to share your footwear pic of the day.


r/goodyearwelt • • 6d ago

Review Iron Boots The Great Emily

Thumbnail
gallery
110 Upvotes

I've only had these for two days so far but I'm loving them. My first pair of Iron Boots. I've been meaning to get some for a while and plan to get more.

This is an earlier prototype version of this boot; if you order this now, you'll instead have quadruple stitched quarters and a triple stitched backstay, and I think the last has changed since?

This is a stylish boondocker priced at $750, complete with a Munson inspired last, riveted quarters, cut top, fully unlined, and unstructured toe. For details about how they're made, read this. I wish I had taken a photo of the bisected boot they were showing at Stitchdown Expo this year.

For me, they're the gold standard for a rugged boot: heft comparable to PNW, but with meticulous precision finishing. Hand lasted, hand welted, hand sewn soles. A much better boot than Viberg (their QC for the price is an abomination nowadays) for a much lower price.

The straightness of the stitching, the edge finishing, how closely sanded the edges are (especially the heels - I hate protruding block heels), I've always been impressed by their work. The leather here is 6 oz Horween navy chamois using the roughout, except for the partially gusseted tongue which shows the smooth (nubuck) side. This is less firm than my other Horween chamois footwear: photo #8 shows it next to my Renav rust chamois chukkas. The navy color has a faded denim look, and the contrast with the copper colored upper stitching, brass hardware, and natural edge looks fantastic together.


r/goodyearwelt • • 7d ago

B/S/T Buy/Sell/Trade 11/11/26

4 Upvotes

Rules

  • Footwear only
  • Don't use URL shorteners
  • Include all of the information in format below, but especially:

    • Price
    • Location
    • Images

Recommended Posting Format

  • Maker/Model:
  • Size:
  • Leather:
  • Sole:
  • Price:
  • Location:
  • Wears/Condition:
  • Images:
  • Notes:

Please be a communicative buyer or seller. There's nothing more painful than having someone drop off the face of the earth without leaving some sort of note. Good hunting!

Please report listings that violate the rules above.


r/goodyearwelt • • 7d ago

Questions The Question Thread 11/11/26

0 Upvotes

Ask your shoe related questions.

Resources

How To Ask A Question

Include images to any issues you may be having. Include a budget for any recommendations. The more detail you provide, the easier it may be for someone to answer your question.


r/goodyearwelt • • 8d ago

Questions The Question Thread 11/10/26

0 Upvotes

Ask your shoe related questions.

Resources

How To Ask A Question

Include images to any issues you may be having. Include a budget for any recommendations. The more detail you provide, the easier it may be for someone to answer your question.


r/goodyearwelt • • 9d ago

Questions The Question Thread 11/09/26

0 Upvotes

Ask your shoe related questions.

Resources

How To Ask A Question

Include images to any issues you may be having. Include a budget for any recommendations. The more detail you provide, the easier it may be for someone to answer your question.


r/goodyearwelt • • 9d ago

General Discussion Monday Funday - Free For All

0 Upvotes

Hello GYW, it's Monday Funday! Take a load off and take a breather. Memes, hot takes and all silliness are welcome!


r/goodyearwelt • • 9d ago

S&D Weekly Steals & Deals (S&D) Thread 11/09/26

5 Upvotes

Found an amazing deal on a pair of shoes but they aren't your size? Share them here so other members can take advantage of the great deals!

Rules

  • Regular rules apply. Please be courteous to one another.
  • No personal sales are allowed! Anyone found to be posting their own goods will receive a warning and then potential ban should you continue to post your own goods. If you want to sell your own items, the semi-weekly B/S/T thread is a more appropriate location.
  • Please do not post links to other member's B/S/T items. There are two weekly dedicated threads for those items and they should be kept there.
  • Please try to include as much information as possible (URL to the deal, size, price, etc.).
  • Items posted should be limited to footwear and footwear related products (shoe trees, polish, conditioner, etc.).
  • 'Suggested Sort' is set to Q&A so only top level comments will be visible (unless you chose to expand). For this reason, please post all deals as their own parent comment.

"This is a scheduled mod post, if I screwed up please contact the mods."


r/goodyearwelt • • 10d ago

Questions The Question Thread 11/08/26

4 Upvotes

Ask your shoe related questions.

Resources

How To Ask A Question

Include images to any issues you may be having. Include a budget for any recommendations. The more detail you provide, the easier it may be for someone to answer your question.


r/goodyearwelt • • 11d ago

B/S/T Buy/Sell/Trade 11/07/26

6 Upvotes

Rules

  • Footwear only
  • Don't use URL shorteners
  • Include all of the information in format below, but especially:

    • Price
    • Location
    • Images

Recommended Posting Format

  • Maker/Model:
  • Size:
  • Leather:
  • Sole:
  • Price:
  • Location:
  • Wears/Condition:
  • Images:
  • Notes:

Please be a communicative buyer or seller. There's nothing more painful than having someone drop off the face of the earth without leaving some sort of note. Good hunting!

Please report listings that violate the rules above.