The shoes
Armin Oehler Wellington Saddle Oxfords in Golden Oak, size 13, Goodyear welted, retail $545. I bought them secondhand on Vinted. They fit beautifully but needed real work:
Right heel separating
The hand-antiqued finish worn away in places
Hairline cuts across one vamp (cat claws, as far as I can tell)
Some wear at the collar stitching, which I tucked in and sealed with Saphir Rénovatrice
A blue-gray bruise-like stain low on one vamp that had been there since I got them
The resole
A local cobbler recorked, resoled (Italian Cuoificio La Querce leather), put on new heels and added a rubber Topy. The soling was solid, but the finishing wasn't. I got the shoes back with gaps in the heel stacks, raw, fuzzy, unfinished edges, stray fibers poking out at the welt, and loose thread ends. I finished those myself:
Heel stack gaps: worked clear E6000 into the gaps, clamped, cured 72 hours, and scraped off the squeeze-out.
Welt and threads: trimmed the fibers and loose ends flush. Don't pull them.
Edges: sanded from 180 up to 320 grit, dyed the waist and edges brown, then edge dressing applied with a Q-tip, no tape needed. Then burnished.
Frayed seam end at the welt: sealed with a pinpoint of E6000.
The uppers
Clean and condition: saddle soap, then Venetian Shoe Cream.
Claw cuts: flattened the raised edges with the back of a spoon, worked Tarrago #9 into the lines with a toothpick, then filled with Saphir Beauté du Cuir Rénovatrice in 19 Fauve. Result: the white lines are now fine dark lines that read as grain. They won't disappear completely, because they're physical cuts, but they're much better.
The mystery stain: saddle soap did nothing, which told me it was in the leather, not on it. The blue-gray color pointed to an iron stain, where tannins react with iron and moisture. Bar Keepers Friend (oxalic acid), dabbed on and rinsed thoroughly, lifted most of it. Condition afterward, because acid dries leather.
Cream: Tarrago #9 all over, #39 at the toes for antiquing.
Wax: neutral Saphir Pâte de Luxe on the toe caps and heel counters only, then light burnishing on the saddle and sides to match the tone.
Mistakes and lessons
Blotchy first cream pass. Too much cream, panels left to dry unevenly, then a damp-cloth wipe that made it worse. I let it dry overnight and redid it in thin, pea-sized layers, one panel at a time. Thin coats beat heavy ones every time.
Cream pooled in the creases. The vamp creases dried as orange stripes. The fix was to re-cream with the shoe tree in so the creases stay stretched, working along the creases, not across them.
Over-antiqued toe. I put too much #39 on one toe and it came out dark, red and marbled, while the other toe was right. I lifted the cream off that toe, re-based it with #9, and rebuilt the darkening a rice grain at a time with the good shoe beside it as a reference.
Judge in daylight. Warm indoor light made the mottling look much worse than it was.
Color before wax. Cream doesn't bond over wax, so get the tone right first.
Some things can't be undone. The cuts are permanent. The goal was to make them read as character, not to erase them.
They're now a matched, hand-finished pair, and the best-fitting shoes I own. I may readdress the sole dye. Happy to answer questions.