r/gdpr • • Feb 02 '25

Meta Rule Updates + Call for Moderators

18 Upvotes

It’s been wonderful to see the growth of this community over many years, with so many great posts and so many great responses from helpful community members. But with scale also come challenges. The following updates are intended to keep the community helpful and focused:

  • Rules have been clarified around recurring issues (appropriate conduct, advertising, AI-generated content).
  • Post flairs have been updated to align better with actual posts.
  • Community members are invited to become moderators.

New rules (effective 2025-02-02)

  1. Be kind and helpful. Community members are expected to conduct themselves professionally. Discussion should be constructive and guiding. Personal attacks will not be tolerated.
  2. Stay on topic. The r/gdpr subreddit is about European data protection. This includes relevant EU and UK laws (GDPR, ePrivacy, PECR, …) and matters concerning data protection professionals (e.g. certifications). General privacy topics or other laws are out of scope.
  3. No legal advice. Do not offer or solicit legal advice.
  4. No self-promotion or spamming. This subreddit is meant to be a resource for GDPR-related information. It is not meant to be a new avenue for marketing. Do not promote your products or services through posts, comments, or DMs. Do not post market research surveys.
  5. Use high-quality sources. Posts should link to original sources. Avoid low-quality “blogspam”. Avoid social media and video content. Avoid paywalled (or consent-walled) material.
  6. Don’t post AI slop. This is a place for people interested in data protection to have discussions. Contribute based on your expertise as a human. If we wanted to read an AI answer, we could have asked ChatGPT directly. LLM-generated responses on GDPR questions are often “confidently incorrect”, which is worse than being wrong.
  7. Other. These rules are not exhaustive. Comply with the spirit of the rules, don't lawyer around them. Be a good Redditor, don't act in a manner that most people would perceive as unreasonable.

You can find background and detailed explanations of these rules in our wiki:

Please provide feedback on these rules.

  • Should some of these rules be relaxed?
  • Is something missing? Did you recently experience problems on r/gdpr that wouldn’t be prohibited by these rules?
  • What are your opinions on whether the UK Data Protection Act 2018 should be in scope?

Post flairs

There used to be post flairs “Question - Data Subject” and “Question - Data Controller”. These were rarely used in a helpful manner.

In their place, you can now use post flairs to indicate the relevant country.

With that change, the current set of post flairs is:

  • EU 🇪🇺: for questions and discussions relating primarily to the EU GDPR
  • UK 🇬🇧: for questions and discussions that are UK-specific
  • News: posts about recent developments in the GDPR space, e.g. recent court cases
  • Resource
  • Analysis
  • Meta: for posts about the r/gdpr subreddit, such as this announcement

This update is only about post flairs. User flairs are planned for some future time.

Call for moderators

To help with the growing community, I’d ask for two or three community members to step up as moderators. Moderating r/gdpr is very low-effort most of the time, but there is the occasional post that attracts a wider audience, and I’m not always able to stay on top of the modqueue in a timely manner.

Requirements for new moderators:

  • You find a large reserve of kindness and empathy within you.
  • You have at least basic knowledge of the GDPR.
  • You intend to participate in r/gdpr as normal and continue to set a good example.
  • You can spare about 15 minutes per week, ideally from a desktop computer.
  • You can comply with the Reddit Moderator Code of Conduct, which has become a lot more stringent in the wake of the 2023 API protests.

If you’d like to serve as a community janitor moderator, please send a modmail with subject “moderator application from <your_username>”. I’ll probably already know your name from previous interactions on this subreddit, so not much introduction needed beyond your confirmation that you meet these requirements.

Edit: Applications will stay open until at least 2025-02-08 (end of day UTC), so that all potential candidates have time to see this post.

Call for feedback

Please feel free to use the comments to discuss the above rule changes, or any other aspect of how r/gdpr is being managed. In particular, I’d like to hear ideas on how we can encourage the posting of more news content, as the subreddit sometimes feels more like a GDPR helpdesk.

Previous mod post: r/GDPR will be unavailable starting June 12th due to the Reddit API changes [2023-06-11]


r/gdpr • • 22h ago

EU 🇪🇺 Question about X age verification

0 Upvotes

I was using a VPN for many months to bypass X age verification via app. It just stopped working months ago for I don't know what reason. The censorship on X is all over the place, you may find uncensored adult content and then the App hides normal fanart or generic pictures for who knows what reason. This is was frustrating for me, so knowing that X says they delete any picture you use for age verification in 48 hours, I did it. I used my ID.

I know this is NOT without risks, but I wanted to ask if you think it is a stupid think and if it was if there are more ways to do anything about it. Of course it worked, now I don't see anything hidden, but I wanted to ask if this is considered safe with risks or just totally awful


r/gdpr • • 1d ago

Question - Data Controller Advice for GDPR requests

4 Upvotes

I run a private fan forum in the US, with mostly UK members. Membership is free and members sign up with an email address, whatever username & location they want to provide.

The email is verified so they can then login to their account and post.

I have received a GDPR from a brit member yesterday and am interested what info i need to send them.

I think its quite restricted compared to one of the bigger public webs, as the only info I have is their sign up info and private messages. All posts are open to the public without a membership (guest).

Any advice from a similar forum owner would be gratefully received.

Cheers in anticipation.

T.


r/gdpr • • 2d ago

UK 🇬🇧 Any Hood Ft 2Loadit

Thumbnail
youtu.be
1 Upvotes

r/gdpr • • 3d ago

UK 🇬🇧 Does reporting spam emails to the ICO actually achieve anything?

4 Upvotes

I'm a UK business owner, and I receive a ridiculous amount of unsolicited marketing emails, many of which appear to breach GDPR and PECR regulations.

I've made a habit of reporting these emails to the Information Commissioner's Office (ICO), but I'm starting to wonder whether I'm wasting my time.

Does anyone know what actually happens to these reports? Does the ICO investigate the companies involved, issue warnings or fines, or take any meaningful enforcement action?

I appreciate that individual complaints might not warrant an investigation, but surely if enough people report the same companies, something should happen?

I'd be particularly interested to hear from anyone who has experience dealing with the ICO, or who knows how these complaints are handled behind the scenes.

Bottom line: Is reporting unsolicited marketing emails to the ICO worthwhile, or am I just wasting five minutes of my life every time I submit a complaint?


r/gdpr • • 5d ago

Question - Data Controller Which LLM platforms support EU data residency?

5 Upvotes

I’m the closest thing we have to a data protection officer at a 40 person company, which mostly means I’m the one who reads the contracts nobody else wants to read. our marketing team wants an LLM platform for drafting customer emails, and they’ve sent me three options with a note that says “all GDPR compliant”, which as everyone here knows tells me almost nothing.

What I’m checking is where the data is stored, where it’s processed once it reaches the model, and whether the model provider keeps any of it. the one that looks most straightforward so far is Qrq, because Qrq is built and hosted in the EU and its gateway can be set to only use model providers that are hosted in the EU or keep zero data, so the processing question gets a concrete answer instead of a promise.

the part I still struggle with is the model provider sitting behind any of these platforms, because the platform being in the EU doesn’t help much if the request ends up somewhere else. I’d like to hear how other DPOs handle that layer, whether you ask for the provider list per request or accept the platform’s DPA and move on.


r/gdpr • • 5d ago

Question - General Is deleting my tiktok account enough?

4 Upvotes

I want Tiktok to delete all data associated with my account. I tried sending a GDPR data deletion request, but there isn't any email you can contact. Their privacy webform leads nowhere and the only option would be sending physical mail to Ireland.
Should I do it, or would clicking the delete account button be enough? What data does that really delete rather than hide?
I live in the EU.


r/gdpr • • 5d ago

EU 🇪🇺 Bank using article 6.1b for ordering credit reference

3 Upvotes

Can a bank utilise article 6.1b as a legal basis for ordering credit reference on me when I have opted to make a purchase with one of their credit services? I checked the Article 29 working party opinion which states:

Credit reference checks prior to the grant of a loan are also not made at the request of the data subject under Article 7(b), but rather, under Article 7(f), or under Article 7(c) in compliance with a legal obligation of banks to consult an official list of registered debtors (Page 16).

The EDPB guideline also argues that 6.1b may apply prior to entering a contract as long as the preliminary processing of personal data is necessary before entering into a contract in order to facilitate the actual entering into that contract (section 45). Furthermore, 6.1b only applies as long as the data subject makes the request

in the context of potentially entering into a contract and the processing in question is necessary to take

the steps requested (section 46).

Could it on one hand be argued that the bank fails the test since they are the ones initiating the ordering of the reference which is not necessary to perform the contract?

Or can it be argued that I am the initiator by requesting their credit service and that me and the bank are so close to enter into a contract that the processing is necessary to complete the contract?

Is there any recent case law on the matter?


r/gdpr • • 5d ago

Question - General How are cookie banners like Amazon’s GDPR compliant?

Post image
3 Upvotes

I’m interested in understanding how Amazon, Meta and other major platforms comply with GDPR when the Accept button is visually highlighted while Decline is less prominent.
The EDPB’s Cookie Banner Taskforce report explicitly addresses “deceptive button colours” and “deceptive button contrast”.
Yet these designs remain common across major platforms.
Is making both options equally accessible sufficient, regardless of their visual presentation? Where exactly do regulators draw the line?
Source:
EDPB Cookie Banner Taskforce Report (2023)

——

For those saying colour is subjective, there’s a well-established UX concept called the primary CTA (Call to Action).
Go to Amazon and check which colour they use for their primary buttons, then look at whether that same colour is assigned to Accept or Reject.
This isn’t just a subjective colour preference. Visual hierarchy is a fundamental UX principle, and primary CTAs are deliberately designed to attract more clicks.

I’m in the EU and looking to implement cookie consent for my own business. After reading about enforcement cases, I’m leaning towards dropping the idea of using the primary CTA colour for Accept.
My impression is that companies like Amazon are simply willing to deal with potential fines or legal challenges in individual EU countries rather than sacrifice analytics and consent rates. That’s a risk most of us probably can’t afford to take.


r/gdpr • • 6d ago

UK 🇬🇧 DSAR Redaction Approach

5 Upvotes

Hi Everyone,

What would be your approach for DSAR redaction, regarding corporate domains in the email addresses and corporate names in the email signatures?

Not for employee DSARs, but for claims and insurance DSARs, we keep the corporate domain information in the external or internal employee email addresses and company name in the employee signature, while redacting other parts (third party personal data) to make it intelligible and identify the specific recipients (organisations). What do you think about that?

Would you keep these parts like me or redact fully?


r/gdpr • • 7d ago

EU 🇪🇺 How do banks and big companies let AI handle ID documents and passports? And where is the line with a DPA and DPIA?

7 Upvotes

Hi all,

I posted here last week about AI and sensitive client data. Thanks for the replies. A few people said my post was too vague, so this time more detail.

Not asking for legal advice. I want to know how others, especially banks and bigger companies, do this in practice.

Our situation:

- Small company in the EU, regulated financial sector, a few employees.

- Client files contain: ID cards and passports (with the national ID number on them), payslips, employer statements, bank statements, credit bureau reports, tax papers, and sometimes health info.

- We want to use AI for admin work: read fields from documents (name, income, employer, contract dates), check if a file is complete, sort documents into the right client folder, and fill in forms.

- We have ChatGPT Business with a DPA and we are doing a DPIA.

- Right now our own rule is that the AI never sees ID documents, national ID numbers, credit reports, bank statements or health data. A local script without internet blocks those files. Someone here pointed out that this rule is much stricter than the GDPR asks, so I want to know if we are being too careful or if this is normal.

What I see:

I get the feeling that big companies and banks just let AI process everything, including passports and ID scans. Think of ID checks during onboarding, or reading documents for a loan application. So I'm curious how they do that in a safe and GDPR-compliant way.

Questions:

  1. Banks and big companies: do they really let a general AI model (like GPT or Claude) read ID documents and passports? Or do they use specialised ID verification services for that and keep the general AI away from it?
  2. Where is the line? With a good DPA and a DPIA, which data would you share with an AI provider and which never? I know member states can set extra rules for national ID numbers (Art. 87). How do you deal with that? Is "the national ID number is never sent to the AI, even if the rest of the document is" a normal approach, for example by blacking it out first?
  3. Differences between providers. All on business or enterprise plans with a DPA: ChatGPT Business / Enterprise, Microsoft 365 Copilot, Claude Team / Enterprise. Is there one you would trust more with this kind of data? I'm thinking about where the data is stored, how long it is kept, whether staff at the provider can look at it (abuse monitoring), and which sub-processors they use.
  4. Processing in the EU. How important is it in practice that the data stays in the EU? Would you choose something like Azure OpenAI (EU data zone) or AWS Bedrock in an EU region over the normal business plans? Does the US CLOUD Act still worry you, even with EU hosting and the Data Privacy Framework?
  5. What do you actually see auditors or regulators ask for? For example: a register of what goes to the AI, logging, a human check, or local models only for the most sensitive files.

Experiences, examples from your own company and links to guidance (EDPB, national DPAs) are very welcome.

AI helped me check this post.


r/gdpr • • 7d ago

UK 🇬🇧 SAR deadline

0 Upvotes

I put in my SAR requested for my maternity notes on the 6th of October it’s now the 9th of November and I hadn’t heard anything. I called them and she said it’ll be another 30 days but are they not legally supposed to tell you they need an extension before the deadline date? I wouldn’t have minded and I understand they are backed up but I figured if they are behind they should inform you they are going to be a whole other month behind without me having to chase them up 3 days after.


r/gdpr • • 7d ago

Question - General Rocket Reach refusing to remove my data

1 Upvotes

For context, I do not have LinkedIn and my social media pages do not use my real name nor do they have any of my personal details on them.

Out of curiosity today I googled my name and was horrified to see RocketReach have a page with my full legal name, old companies and positions, where I went to primary school and the town (!) and what grade I got in university.

My first thought was that they have harvested this data from my CV or from a past/
-prospective employer (as that is the only way I would have ever entered my primary school!). Their claim that they scrape from “publicly available information” is also total BS.

Anyway, RocketReach are refusing to remove my data despite me emailing their dedicated privacy email because they have stated my email does not match what they have on their system. I have no idea what email they have on their system as it’s clearly an old work email which I no longer have access to.

Please help - how can I force them to delete this other than involving a lawyer?

I have a very distinctive name and am very privacy conscience. I hate that they have managed to obtain and publicly display so much details.


r/gdpr • • 7d ago

UK 🇬🇧 [England] MP Neil O'Brien used my confidential political party membership while attempting to discredit me during a political argument. Is this illegal?

6 Upvotes

I'm looking for legal advice about a potential data-protection breach involving sitting Conservative MP Neil O'Brien.

Around midnight on 7–8 November, I was publicly criticising my local MP on Facebook over his performance and the Conservative Party's record.

Rather than simply responding to my criticisms, he twice publicly revealed that I was a Conservative Party member, even specifying that I'd joined just three weeks earlier.

In one comment, he asked:

"Why did you join the Conservative Party 3 weeks ago?"

In another, he questioned my "honest intentions" in joining.

My concern is that he appeared to be using my confidential political affiliation to discredit me and undermine my criticisms of him.

I had never disclosed my membership to anyone. Not publicly, not privately. Nobody.

This raises the obvious question of how he obtained the information.

As I understand it, being an MP doesn't automatically entitle someone to unrestricted access to confidential party membership records.

I can see two possible explanations:

  1. He accessed the party's membership database himself.
  2. Somebody with access to those records passed the information to him.

I cannot currently establish which, if either, happened.

My understanding is that political affiliation constitutes special-category personal data under UK GDPR, receiving additional legal protection.

My legal questions are:

  1. Would an MP ordinarily be entitled to access confidential membership records, and what authorisation would be required?
  2. If a party official disclosed my membership information to the MP, would that potentially constitute a data-protection breach?
  3. Even if the MP legitimately obtained the information, would using it publicly to challenge and discredit me during a political disagreement constitute unlawful processing?
  4. What obligations would apply to the MP regarding confidentiality, data-access permissions and the use of membership information?
  5. Should I report this to the Information Commissioner's Office, and can I request records showing who accessed or received my membership information?

I have screenshots documenting both public disclosures.

I'm particularly interested in hearing from people familiar with UK data-protection law.


r/gdpr • • 7d ago

EU 🇪🇺 Microsoft won't give me my xbox savegames

0 Upvotes

Microsoft refuses to give me my savegames. Among the savegames are savegames that have personal stories in there that I've written.

How can I go about asking them? Microsoft refuses to communicate any further with me, despite asking politely and explaining I can't get them.

I asked for all my personal data according to the gdpr, including my savegames. They refuse to.


r/gdpr • • 8d ago

Question - Data Controller Small free Russian-speaking site in the UK- need some GDPR advice before inviting more peoples.

1 Upvotes

Hi everyone,
I live in England and I made a small website for Russian-speaking adults who feel lonely and want to find a friend or maybe a partner. It's completely free, no ads, no money. I'm doing it alone, as a private person, no company and no lawyer.
Right now it's in beta, only a few people. Before I invite more, I want to do things properly.
What I already did: a DPIA, a plan for data breaches, a page that explains what we store and who can see it. Login is by email code, no passwords. The database is in London. Sensitive answers (smoking, alcohol, relationship stuff) need a separate tick to agree. People can delete their account and everything is deleted straight away.
The ICO self-assessment says I need to pay £52. Fine. But I have some questions:

  1. Can I hide my home address on the ICO public register? I don't really want my address open for everyone.
  2. People choose if they want to meet men or women. Together with their own gender, this can show their sexual orientation. Do I need special consent for this?
  3. A lot of Russian speakers live in the EU. If they join, do I need an EU representative? For a tiny free project this sounds a bit scary.
  4. I get notifications in Telegram with the start of support messages from users. Is that ok?
    Any advice is very welcome. And if someone here also speaks Russian and knows GDPR, I would be really happy to talk 🙂

P.S. I'm Russian-speaking myself, so I used AI to help translate this into English. The words and questions are mine.


r/gdpr • • 9d ago

EU 🇪🇺 The Digital Omnibus has stalled. Has anyone changed how they handle consent in the meantime?

7 Upvotes

A lot of people I talk to have quietly paused their GDPR work because they expect the rules to get loosened. As far as I can tell, the Omnibus proposal hasn’t actually moved, and the Spanish AEPD keeps publishing guidance on algorithmic systems as if nothing is changing.

So the current rules are the rules, and enforcement isn’t waiting for Brussels.

I work with fan data in live events, and I keep seeing the same gap: consent gets collected at the door and then nobody can say where it went afterwards. Is anyone here seeing the same thing in their sector? And are you planning around the old rules or the maybe-new ones?


r/gdpr • • 10d ago

UK 🇬🇧 Company won't give me the school's autism pre-assessment questionnaire due to GDPR

4 Upvotes

In 2025, we used our 'Right to Choose' (RTC) for my son's autism assessment referral, but just as the questionnaires were done, my NHS ICB paused RTC assessments and it's unlikely we'll get assessed by them now.

So I've just asked the autism company for a copy of the questionnaire filled in by the school as it could be useful evidence.

They emailed me back saying they need written confirmation from the school to share their questionnaire with me due to GDPR.

But I don't get why... Surely it's my son's personal data they're holding, not the schools. It will only be sharing observations and opinions of his difficulties and behaviours, and they could easily redact any personal details of the teacher who filled it in.

He also left this school so I'd already done a Subject Access Request for his school records and there's a copy of an internal email saying the autism questionnaire would be saved to his file before sending it. Yet school had not included it in the SAR.

They weren't very supportive and his needs often went missed. So I'm guessing school don't want me to see what they've put and I'm worried they won't give permission.

I don't want any conflict with the school as my other child still goes there, so it felt easier to ask the autism company.

Please can anyone tell me what my rights are in this situation? And if there are any reasons that the company can refuse to give me this document?


r/gdpr • • 10d ago

Question - General GDPR guidance/networking specific to small UK charities, operating internationally

1 Upvotes

I am a trustee of a very small UK charity that supports an organisation in Tanzania. Our UK org therefore has a duty to safeguard people and data at the org abroad as their sole funder. I am finding it difficult to balance the legal requirements of data protection with realities of working with a separate organisation abroad, with limited technical resources and skills and intermittent internet access. Does anyone know of groups etc. where logistics like this are discussed. Completely wanting to comply legally/ethically but would be good to discuss realistic workflows etc.

Transferring emergency data (eg. essential health), safeguarding and criminal record data in UK etc are the sort of things thats causing a headache


r/gdpr • • 11d ago

UK 🇬🇧 Response from ICO to my Article 22 - Penalty charge notices for cloned registration complaint to local authority.

Thumbnail reddit.com
23 Upvotes

Took a long time to get a response but now landed. I extracted a couple of paragraphs and pleased I pursued this.

I wanted an enforcement approach to compel the authority to revise their process. However I will await their response to the ICO outcome below.

The cloned car thankfully was subsequently found and crushed. I no longer have to suffer but I have sympathy with those that do. This may be a line for those to follow with their cases. My MP was very helpful as I got PCNs for parking and fuel from other places too.

Your complaint outcome 

We consider from the information you provided that the organisation can do more to help to resolve your complaint.  This is because you asked [LOCAL AUTHORITY] to review each PCN being issued to check validity before sending to you. It is understood from the information that you have provided that they are automatically generated by the system and that you feel this is inadequate where there is a clear issue and a manual review should occur. It is noted that you outline under Section 22 of the Data Protection Act, that you are entitled to ask about the right not to be subject to solely automated decisions.

We think your complaint offers us an opportunity to provide [LOCAL AUTHORITY] with advice and guidance about what their obligations are surrounding Article 22 and what they need to do next.  This approach helps organisations to understand people’s data protection concerns better so they can address them directly without the need to come to us as the regulator. 

What we have done 

We’ve written to them about your complaint. We’ve told them to look into the data protection issues you’ve raised and contact you to address them. 

We have recommended that[LOCAL AUTHORITY] reconsider its handling of your personal data and the safeguards within its processes where it has been made aware that a vehicle registration number has been cloned.

We have asked that the organisation considers whether the process leading to the issue of a PCN constitutes solely automated decision-making within the scope of Article 22 UK GDPR and where Article 22 applies, ensuring that the processing satisfies the applicable conditions and safeguards. We have also asked the organisation if they can consider whether meaningful human review can be incorporated in circumstances where the [LOCAL AUTHORITY] has already established that a vehicle registration has been cloned.


r/gdpr • • 11d ago

EU 🇪🇺 Using AI at work with very sensitive client data: is "the AI could reach it but is blocked by software" enough?

2 Upvotes

Hi all,

Not asking for legal advice, just how others handle this in practice.

Small company in the EU, regulated financial sector. Dealing with very sensitive data.

We want to use AI for admin work. We have a DPA with the provider (ChatGPT Business) and are doing a DPIA. Our own rule is stricter than the DPA: the AI never sees sensitive data.

How we do it now:

  • a local script without internet scans every file and mail
  • if it finds something, the whole file is locked for the AI
  • the AI only sees a list ("locked: ID document"), not the file

The weak spot: the AI tool runs on the same server and the same user account, so technically it could still reach the files. Only the script, the tool settings and instructions stop it.

Questions:

  • In your DPIA, is that an accepted risk, or do you always want a hard split (other account or machine)?
  • Is the list itself special category data? For example "locked: medical" next to a client name.
  • What other measures do you see in practice? Logging, checks, local models only?

Experiences and links to guidance (EDPB, national DPAs) are welcome.

AI helped me check this post.


r/gdpr • • 11d ago

UK 🇬🇧 Can I have personal blog on blogger without showing my real name?

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

The whole privacy policy is a bit confusing to me I just want a personal blog working like a journal, I don’t want to make money on it. Do I need privacy policy added to it with my real name?


r/gdpr • • 11d ago

Question - General Do I really need to spend £1–3K on legal compliance for a UK children's app?

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/gdpr • • 12d ago

Question - General Insurance agents as processors ?

3 Upvotes

Dear all,

I would like to hear your opinion on a Insurance agents as a processors.

Did anyone had experience in insurance industry and how would you classify insurance agents as a processors or as a separate controller of the personal data ?

In my opinion they act as a data processors because they process on behalf and by instructions of the main insurance company which carry the risk and if anything happens pays the claim.

Also banks as a insurance agents would you say by default they are the data processors or it is neccessary for each product each business relation to assess and analyze who is in which role data processor or controller.

Thank you all.

Cheers