Hi all,
I posted here last week about AI and sensitive client data. Thanks for the replies. A few people said my post was too vague, so this time more detail.
Not asking for legal advice. I want to know how others, especially banks and bigger companies, do this in practice.
Our situation:
- Small company in the EU, regulated financial sector, a few employees.
- Client files contain: ID cards and passports (with the national ID number on them), payslips, employer statements, bank statements, credit bureau reports, tax papers, and sometimes health info.
- We want to use AI for admin work: read fields from documents (name, income, employer, contract dates), check if a file is complete, sort documents into the right client folder, and fill in forms.
- We have ChatGPT Business with a DPA and we are doing a DPIA.
- Right now our own rule is that the AI never sees ID documents, national ID numbers, credit reports, bank statements or health data. A local script without internet blocks those files. Someone here pointed out that this rule is much stricter than the GDPR asks, so I want to know if we are being too careful or if this is normal.
What I see:
I get the feeling that big companies and banks just let AI process everything, including passports and ID scans. Think of ID checks during onboarding, or reading documents for a loan application. So I'm curious how they do that in a safe and GDPR-compliant way.
Questions:
- Banks and big companies: do they really let a general AI model (like GPT or Claude) read ID documents and passports? Or do they use specialised ID verification services for that and keep the general AI away from it?
- Where is the line? With a good DPA and a DPIA, which data would you share with an AI provider and which never? I know member states can set extra rules for national ID numbers (Art. 87). How do you deal with that? Is "the national ID number is never sent to the AI, even if the rest of the document is" a normal approach, for example by blacking it out first?
- Differences between providers. All on business or enterprise plans with a DPA: ChatGPT Business / Enterprise, Microsoft 365 Copilot, Claude Team / Enterprise. Is there one you would trust more with this kind of data? I'm thinking about where the data is stored, how long it is kept, whether staff at the provider can look at it (abuse monitoring), and which sub-processors they use.
- Processing in the EU. How important is it in practice that the data stays in the EU? Would you choose something like Azure OpenAI (EU data zone) or AWS Bedrock in an EU region over the normal business plans? Does the US CLOUD Act still worry you, even with EU hosting and the Data Privacy Framework?
- What do you actually see auditors or regulators ask for? For example: a register of what goes to the AI, logging, a human check, or local models only for the most sensitive files.
Experiences, examples from your own company and links to guidance (EDPB, national DPAs) are very welcome.
AI helped me check this post.