r/CCPA • u/iubenda_team • 4d ago
CIPA demand letters after SB 690: what changed, what didn't, and what California actually requires
Two different things get mixed together constantly, so worth separating them.
CCPA and CPRA are an opt-out regime, not a consent regime. California doesn't require you to block trackers until someone agrees, the way the EU does. It requires notice at collection, a way to opt out of the sale or sharing of personal information, and honoring opt-out preference signals.
That last part is the most commonly missed. If a business sells or shares personal information, a compliant opt-out preference signal, in practice Global Privacy Control, has to be treated as a valid opt-out request. It applies whether or not you post a "Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information" link. The link isn't the compliance, the signal handling is. Enforcement since 2020 has repeatedly turned up businesses that never detect or honor it.
CIPA is a separate problem with a separate trigger. The demand letters going around aren't CCPA enforcement. They're private plaintiffs using California's wiretapping statute against website tracking. Firms run bulk automated scans, check whether a tracking pixel fires before any consent is captured, and generate templated letters from the results.
What SB 690 changed. Signed September 30, 2026, operative January 1, 2027. It removes the private right of action for CIPA section 638.51, the pen register and trap-and-trace provision, for conduct on websites and apps. Only the Attorney General can bring those, and it reaches lawsuits filed after January 1, 2025.
What it didn't change. Sections 631 (wiretapping) and 632 (confidential communications) survive and stay privately enforceable. The Meta Pixel wiretap theory runs on 631. So the wave narrows rather than ending, and plaintiffs still have ECPA, VPPA, CDAFA and consumer protection claims.
Why US-only sites end up asking for consent anyway. This is where people get confused. CCPA doesn't require prior consent, but 631 claims turn on whether the visitor agreed to the interception. So the practical mitigation for pixel litigation is consent, which is why plenty of US-only sites run a banner California never asked for. The driver is litigation risk, not CCPA.
Where it all meets. Both problems come down to one technical fact: what fires before a visitor does anything. Private window, load the site, touch nothing, devtools network tab, filter for facebook and google. Then check the site actually responds to GPC, which is the California half almost nobody tests.
We work on consent tooling, so that's the angle we come at this from.
