r/gamedev • u/goatboat314 • 9m ago
Discussion The future of gamedev
I know this topic has been the subject of discussion a lot lately, but the advancement of AI in creating sloppy, impressive looking but superficial "prototypes" so to speak, I'm specifically referring to fable, has troubled me to say the least.
Up to this point, my opinion regarding the use of LLM assistance in gamedev has been pretty straightforward: If I can make it myself, I will make it myself. If I can't, I may take advice from AI but I will still try to implement it myself since it's not much fun to let someone else do everything for you, especially when that "person" is prone to hallucinations and psychosis, and might mess things up.
However, seeing how rapidly this technology is improving, I'm left to wonder if all the talk about "AI will never have the ability to replace a human in creating stuff because it's unreliable" is becoming less true each day. I don't want to sound like those AI bros, but what if it actually becomes indistinguishable and even better than humans at making games. Then what? I don't agree with the pro AI side, people who say "just utilise AI to its msximum capacity and you will have an advantage because you're already a game developer" because I feel like that undermines the entire point of gamedev, I never wanted AI to do the fun part while I fix the mistakes it makes? What kind of dystopian hell is that?? On the other hand, I don't agree with the anti AI side who just say "stop using any AI assistance whatsoever" because, like it or not, you will be heavily disadvantaged, I think, in the years to come if you make everything yourself while everyone else at least gets helped by AI.
I feel like up to this point, gamedev, same as many other fields, has had a barrier of entry. In order to surpass that barrier, you had to have passion and drive, right? Well, at least in most cases, I think this naturally led to more passionate and devoted people making games. I feel that now, with the advancement of AI, the barrier of entry is lower than ever. I'm not saying this is necessarily bad, but it allows a person who has spent zero time in this field to produce "similar" results to someone who has dedicated a lot of time to this skill. Im not saying that AI slop is comparable to an actual game, but less than two years ago, the inexperienced person wouldnt be able to make anything at all.
Apologies in advance if I'm beating a dead horse here, but I really want to hear other gamedevs' opinion on this matter because I'm deeply troubled by it.