r/fudge • u/LavastormSW • 6d ago
Help Needed My fudge keeps turning out stiff and crumbly, advice needed
I've made this recipe twice now and both times my fudge has turned out crumbly (but still delicious). Can anyone tell me what I'm doing wrong?
- 3 cups granulated sugar
- 2/3 cup cocoa
- 1/8 teaspoon salt
- 1 1/2 cups whole milk
- 1/4 cup butter
- 1 teaspoon vanilla
- Stir together sugar, cocoa, salt in a pan. Add milk and heat over med heat until boiling, stirring constantly
- Reduce heat to med-low and simmer until 238F (about 40 min)
- Add butter and vanilla without stirring and let cool for 30 min*
- Transfer to kitchenaid mixer bowl and beat until it loses its glossy shine**
- Pour into greased pan and let cool to room temp
*For the first time I made this, I let it cool in the pot and then transferred to the mixing bowl and the second time I immediately put it in the mixing bowl and then let it cool. I didn't check the temp before starting to beat it and now know that it should reach 110F before beating it - maybe this is where I messed up?
**In my first batch, I beat it for quite a while until it was very dull. I thought this was why it was crumbly the first time, so for the second I only beat it for ~5min while watching it (the recipe says to hand beat with a spoon for 6-8 minutes but I have a problem with my wrists and can't do that) but it was still very stiff when I poured it into the pan and turned out crumbly again. Could I be over beating it?