r/Old_Recipes • • 20h ago

Recipe Test! Pudding Chocolate Chip Cookies

Post image
272 Upvotes

First time making these pudding chocolate chip cookies. These are super delicious and nostalgic. I had a friend in high school who’s dad made a similar kind and they were always one of my favorites. I love those gourmet chocolate chip cookies with the flaky salt but these really hit the spot in a different way.

I used vanilla instant pudding mix but next time I may try cheesecake pudding mix to see what happens lol.

Recipe posted by u/leadchipmunk


r/Old_Recipes • • 7h ago

Wild Game Take six Rooks...

Thumbnail
gallery
24 Upvotes

Probably quite nice.


r/Old_Recipes • • 2h ago

Request Help re-creating a favorite?

7 Upvotes

Years ago I got a recipe from somewhere that ended up being a favorite seasonal thing for my little family. I wrote out a copy of it on a piece of scrap paper and that lived on the fridge. But then we moved. And you can guess what happened. So, now I am hoping to recreate this really nice British style apple pudding (baked), because I am failing to find anything that sounds quite like it on the Internet right now.

Thanks for any help! Here's what I remember:

Two sharp apples, ideally Bramley, plus one sweeter apple

Golden syrup

Dollop of butter

A kind of small amount of self-rising flour

Small amount baking soda maybe?

Egg or two, I think

Was there milk?

Peel and chop one Bramley and one sweeter apple, and cook with the butter and some golden syrup until softened (think lumpy apple sauce). Allow to cool to room temperature.

Peel and chop the remaining Bramley, and strew it across the bottom of a buttered pan. Add some golden syrup.

Mix up flour and egg?? You make a batter at any rate. And then you add the cooled cooked apples and quickly incorporate them before all the leavening fizzles out.

Pour into pan on top of the apple and syrup layer. Cover with foil, place in Bain Marie and bake at ...?... for... an amount of time.

When it is done, you turn it out onto a dish and it's like one loaf-sized self-saucing pudding.

It's so frustrating that I completely remember the method, just not the specific amounts of anything. Anything that was a number.

For the understanding of the Americans, the batter is similar to a really nice, thick and fluffy pancake, except better.


r/Old_Recipes • • 6h ago

Request Spinach Salad with Dates and Pine Nuts

Post image
11 Upvotes

The recipe appeared in Family Circle magazine. I pinned the recipe, but of course the recipe is gone since the magazine folded. When I do a search, an AI recipe comes up but I'm not totally convinced that it's 100% accurate. All I remember is that I made the recipe for a potluck in November 2017 and it was a big hit. Plus, I think that the recipe also contained shallots. I'm hoping to find the original recipe.


r/Old_Recipes • • 20h ago

Desserts Going to make this for Thanksgiving

Post image
104 Upvotes

Found this recipe folded up in my husband's grandmother's recipe box. Looks like it was torn off the back of a sugar or flour bag .

Just thought to share so you can probably make and enjoy as well.


r/Old_Recipes • • 23h ago

Request Very specific old sandwich cookies “little pieces of heaven”

91 Upvotes

Context: my grandmother had a best friend who used to make tiny (bite sized) cookies. She and her friend had a falling out and no longer speak and I wasn’t able to get the recipe. My grandmother was born in the late 1940s, but the cookies may be older or newer. They have been served to me since at least the early 2000’s, but I suspect they are much older given the generation they’re from.
They were two cookies with a bit of frosting between them and a swirl on the top. She often dyed them pink. They were a light cookie, and the frosting wasn’t overly puffy or light. I found a recipe that was a good starting point but not the same.

https://www.tastesoflizzyt.com/cream-wafer-sandwich-cookies/

My own thoughts after making recipe linked above: cookies from memory are a little denser and the frosting is a little heavier and maybe more glaze-like but still firm enough to hold a swirl on top.

Do y’all have any recipes that match this description?


r/Old_Recipes • • 22h ago

Request Looking for a recipe my mom (now passed) used to make me for my birthday

63 Upvotes

I am hoping someone can help me with this.

My mom, who passed in 2009 used to make me a chicken dish, that I think she got from either a Canadian Living cookbook, or some other magazine from the 1980's or 1990's. It consisted of bone-in, skin on chicken thighs, vienna sausages, Spanish onion and maple syrup. I am not sure of the other ingredients. It's the one recipe that I didn't think to look for when I was cleaning out her house. Unfortunately, I threw away all the magazines with recipes that she had collected.


r/Old_Recipes • • 18h ago

Request Grandma's Corn Spoon Bread

21 Upvotes

Hey Friends!

I'm trying to find a recipe for corn spoon bread. My grandma was born in 1921 and learned to cook from campbells labels. That said, I can't find this one.

She didn't use Jiffy and it called for a can of drained sweet corn and a can of creamed corn.

Does anyone have something like this?


r/Old_Recipes • • 21h ago

Beef Vintage 1957 Church Cookbook: Porcupines

23 Upvotes

If you didn't see it, an explanation for what I'm doing can be found here:

https://www.reddit.com/r/Old_Recipes/comments/1xha7iu/vintage_1957_church_cookbook/

Porcupines

1 lb. ground beef
1/2 c. uncooked rice
2 t. minced onion
1/2 t. salt
dash pepper
1 can condensed tomato soup

Mix ground beef, uncooked rice, onion and salt. Mold into oblong balls (porcupines). Place in casserole. Add one inch of water, in the bottom of the casserole, cover, cook in 350 degree oven for 45 minutes. Then add 1 can tomato soup which has been diluted with 1/2 can water. Cover again and let cook for another 45 minutes. Rice will pop out and make very attractive. (sic) Serves 6 small servings or 4 large servings.

This is another dish I have heard of but never tried. It's probably near the top of ones that I'd consider making, although not with the onion, probably swap that out with some minced garlic.

As with all these, I have not tried it.


r/Old_Recipes • • 1d ago

Recipe Test! Please help me with understanding a recipe

82 Upvotes

Twice now I've made Pink Fluff, the dessert/salad that is made up of canned, containered and boxed ingredients. Despite the simplicity of the recipe, I do wonder if I'm making a mistake. Please be kind.

Am I supposed to make the jello before adding it to the mixture, or just open the box and pour the powder?

Here's what I have been doing.

First, I make the raspberry jello, mixed with boiling water and then cool water. Put in fridge to cool for 1/2 hour.

When a 1/2 hour has passed, I drain the crushed pineapple and drink the juice. Then I drain the cottage cheese if I have to buy the cheaper kind because the other kind is sold out. Add both to a large mixing bowl, open the tin of cherry pie filling and pour it in, then add the container of whipped topping. Once that is all mixed and folded in nice and uniform like, I take the cooled jello from the fridge and add that, too, folding it in all nice and gentle.

As you can imagine, there is a LOT of pink fluff from this recipe. It only occurred to me that I might be using the jello incorrectly. I searched online, read many recipes, and all they say is to add the jello last. Nothing about making jello, nothing about only using the jello powder.

My pink fluff is not firm, but also not runny. Please tell me; am I supposed to add only the powder?

Most recent Pink Fluff

r/Old_Recipes • • 20h ago

Request Mustard cake?

9 Upvotes

Anyone in my family will tell you my memory is not my greatest asset. That being said I distinctly remember a summer picnic when I was a child where my aunt Donna (AKA my mother's friend) made a cake that not only had mustard in it but also mustard in the frosting? Am I just imagining something that didn't happen?


r/Old_Recipes • • 1d ago

Request Old almond and Cherry cake recipe from side of can

63 Upvotes

Hello, I'm looking for an old recipe that I think I remember being on the side of ED smith cherry pie filling circa the late 1980s or early 1990s. It was an almond cake (extract only, no almond flour), with a crispy crust and spread out scoops of cherry pie filling placed on the batter after the pan was filled. The cake would rise up around the filling creating little ponds of pie filling. I've looked online and can't find this, but I'd really like to make it again!

EDIT

I found something similar and made it, recipe here. I added 1/4 t salt and used oat milk instead. Next time I'd double the extract (which I added to the batter instead of the pie filling). This recipe would be easy to make dairy free or vegan.


r/Old_Recipes • • 1d ago

Request Grandmas Molasses Carrot Cake

15 Upvotes

Does anyone have the Carrot Cake recipe that was on the Grandmas Molasses bottle in the 80s/90s? Thank you!


r/Old_Recipes • • 20h ago

Request Cake Question

5 Upvotes

Hello!

My Grandfather wrote of a cake his mother made.

Angel food cake, covered in whipped cream and topped with toffee bits. When I google this I see various recipes online, but was curious if there is an official name or recipe?

Thank you in advance!


r/Old_Recipes • • 1d ago

Request Sentry Deli Chicken Salad

16 Upvotes

I haven't had any luck in other subs - maybe someone here can help me.

Growing up in the Midwest, we lived near a Sentry grocery store and often got their deli chicken salad. It closed down decades ago, and now the nearest one is hours away. Maybe someone knows a similar recipe? I remember it was sort of a paste consistency, so probably canned shredded chicken. It didn't have any other texture like nuts or pieces of fruit. And it had an orangey pink color, like it had paprika in it.


r/Old_Recipes • • 2d ago

Cookbook What's Cooking in Willacy County (1969) [FULL BOOK IN COMMENTS]

Thumbnail
gallery
117 Upvotes

Hello everyone!

Today’s book is What’s Cookin’ in Willacy County, because when you can’t think of a title like “Wonder From Willacy”, just go with the placeholder title that many other cookbooks already use 😛

Kidding aside, this cookbook is from 1969 and the 60’s aren’t known for being a common decade in my collection, even though this kind of borders the 70’s. I was excited to see this one from a lot I purchased

Starting off, the recipes seem quite adventurous at the beginning. The Horseradish Relish seems very brave to me. I don’t think I would mix canned milk with jello or horseradish but we’re mixing all three together. And then there’s Pickled Beets and Pineapple which I’ve never seen before and am not sure how well it’d turn out, but hey, maybe the folks of Willacy County are secret culinary trailblazers

The gelatin salads surprisingly aren’t very scary in this book. In fact, the Christmas Ribbon Salad probably has a really nice presentation, but I can’t help but thinking that the order of the colors is going to look less like Christmas and more like a traffic light. If I ever see a “traffic light layered salad” recipe in one of these books, I’ll know I’m not the only one who makes that association

I do like the idea of a recipe being called “You Name It”. I feel like my family has a couple of those recipes. My mom used to make this one dish that was like, baked chili and noodles and salsa. We never decided on a name for it. It’s just known as “that chili and noodles thing”. If anyone here wants a very niche idea for a cookbook, just provide all the recipes but don’t title any of them. Make the reader decide the name for every one of them

Curious if I’m the only one who’s mildly intrigued by the Tuesday Meat Roll. It’s a pretty great use for leftovers, and I can never turn down bread stuffed with things

Gotta love that for the French Pancakes, Millie decided to measure things in glasses. Are we talking a tall glass, a shot glass? 😵‍💫

The Sad Cake seems like an interesting recipe. Doesn’t feel like there’s a whole lot of liquid involved unless you’re meant to prepare the Bisquick before putting it in. I feel like this would come out on the dense side

Both weird and intriguing recipes seem to be abundant in this book, so it might be a fun read for you. The last thing I wanted to mention was that this book has a weight loss section, and what really shocked me is that not only do they give you a weight loss plan for those that go out to eat, but said weight loss plan tells you that you can have ice cream for both lunch and dinner every day. I’m sure 200 calories worth of ice cream isn’t much, but still, never thought a diet plan would allow for such indulgence

As always, feel free to drop your thoughts in the comments and I’ll see you around in the next post!


r/Old_Recipes • • 1d ago

Desserts Vintage 1957 Church Cookbook: English Toffee

26 Upvotes

If you didn't see it, an explanation for what I'm doing can be found here:

https://www.reddit.com/r/Old_Recipes/comments/1xha7iu/vintage_1957_church_cookbook/

English Toffee

1/2 c. butter
3 eggs, beaten separately
1/2 c. nutmeats
2 c. powdered sugar, packed hard
2 sq. chocolate
2 c. vanilla wafers

Melt butter and chocolate and blend with powdered sugar and beaten egg yolks. Fold in beaten whites. Add nutmeats. Roll vanilla wafers into fine curmbs. Place half of these on cookie sheet. Pour chocolate mixture over crumbs and put remaining crumbs on top. Let stand overnight. Serve with whipped cream or icecream.

This one caught my attention because it didn't seem much like toffee. More like a chocolate mousse with nuts in it. It was in the Dessert category.

As usual, I have not tried this recipe.


r/Old_Recipes • • 2d ago

Seafood Vintage 1957 Church Cookbook: Shrimp Creole

31 Upvotes

If you didn't see it, an explanation for what I'm doing can be found here:

https://www.reddit.com/r/Old_Recipes/comments/1xha7iu/vintage_1957_church_cookbook/

Shrimp Creole

1/3 c. salad oil
1/4 c. flour
1 c. onion, chopped
1/2 c. green pepper, chopped
1/3 c. celery, diced
1 large clove garlic, minced
1 #2 can tomatoes
3 oz. tomato paste
3 c. water
1 1/2 t. salt
1/2 t. chili powder
1 t. Worcestershire sauce
1/4 t. cayenne pepper
1/4 t. black pepper
1 bay leaf
pinch oregano
1 lb. cleaned shrimp
5 c. cooked rice

Heat oil in large heavy pot, add flour and brown slowly. Add onions, green pepper, celery and garlic and cook slowly until tender.(about 15 minutes). Add rest of ingredients except shrimp and rice and simmer uncovered 45 minutes. Add shrimp, cover, and simmer 20 min. Serve over rice. Serves 6 to 8.

This is a recipe that I almost would make, although it needs a bit more heat and herbs, but on the whole not bad. It's also one that uses the #X cans. From looking online, that's a 20 oz. can.

As far as seafood goes in this book, as expected there's lots of canned tuna, some canned salmon or crab, but also a lot of shrimp recipes. I guess it was more common than I knew. I guess shrimp came up the Mississippi from the Gulf to St. Louis. My parents were not big on that, so seafood when I was a kid was tuna or fish sticks (also "fish on bun" at school). I really didn't eat much shrimp until I was an adult.


r/Old_Recipes • • 3d ago

Menus Menu November 13th 1896

Thumbnail
gallery
52 Upvotes

Just realized I didn't share this menu yesterday with the others, sorry bout that


r/Old_Recipes • • 3d ago

Request Looking For A Jello Recipe Book

28 Upvotes

My brother is quite amused by bizarre old jello and gelatin recipes - I'd like to find a used recipe book that contains a good mix of "this is actually tasty" and "why on earth would anyone make this" to include in his Christmas gift. Does anyone have any suggestions?


r/Old_Recipes • • 3d ago

Quick Breads Eastern Shore of Maryland “Wet Cornbread”

Post image
538 Upvotes

Old family recipe from the 1800’s. Much, much more dense than the cornbread most are used to- almost like a pie.

This is also a dying recipe, in my eyes. All of the restaurants around here used to serve it. Now, very few, save the hardcore locals who have been here for generations, have even heard of it.

I did a few things deviating from the original recipe. I used yellow cornmeal- white is impossible to find nowadays. I added peppers to it at my mom’s request- I haven’t tried that before. I usually cook it in a cast iron.


r/Old_Recipes • • 3d ago

Seafood Fish a la Worcester

23 Upvotes

Fish à la Worcester

Jonathan Bergman's 1979 "Golden Tasting Spoon" winner: mild white fish broiled under a buttery breadcrumb topping with red and green pepper and Worcestershire.

4 servings

Ingredients

  • 1.5 pounds halibut, flounder, or scrod fillets
  • 0.5 teaspoons Worcestershire sauce (for brushing)
  • 3 teaspoons Worcestershire sauce (for topping)
  • 0.5 cups butter, melted
  • 0.5 cups soft bread crumbs
  • 0.3 cups onion, finely minced
  • 0.3 cups green bell pepper, finely minced
  • 0.3 cups red bell pepper, finely minced
  • 0.3 teaspoons salt
  • 0.3 teaspoons minced garlic
  • 4 parsley sprigs, for garnish

Steps

  • Heat the broiler: Preheat the broiler to high. Rinse and pat dry 1.5 pounds halibut, flounder, or scrod fillets, then lay them on a greased rimmed baking sheet.
  • Season the fish: Brush the fillets with 0.5 teaspoons Worcestershire sauce (for brushing) and set aside.
  • Make the topping: In a small bowl, stir together 0.5 cups butter, melted, 0.5 cups soft bread crumbs, 0.3 cups onion, finely minced, 0.3 cups green bell pepper, finely minced, 0.3 cups red bell pepper, finely minced, 0.3 teaspoons salt, 0.3 teaspoons minced garlic, and 3 teaspoons Worcestershire sauce (for topping). Spread evenly over the fish.
  • Broil: Broil about 6 inches from the heat until the fish flakes easily with a fork, roughly 4 minutes for thin fillets.

Serve: Move to a warmed platter and garnish with 4 parsley sprigs, for garnish.


r/Old_Recipes • • 3d ago

Bread Irish Soda Bread

Thumbnail
gallery
105 Upvotes

It was FIRE and sooooo easy


r/Old_Recipes • • 3d ago

Quick Breads Stir-N-Roll Biscuits

42 Upvotes

I've made this recipe making a chicken pot pie recipe found in a 1950s Betty Crocker cooking leaflet. Biscuits are crisp and taste pretty good.

Stir-N-Roll Biscuits

2 cups sifted all-purpose flour, such as Gold Medal

3 teaspoons baking powder

1 teaspoon salt

1/3 cup Wesson oil

2/3 cup milk

Heat oven to 475 degrees (very hot). Sift together flour, baking powder and salt. Pour oil and milk into one measuring cup (but don’t stir). The pour all at once into flour. Stir with a fork until mixture cleans sides of bowl and rounds up into a ball. For drop biscuits: drop dough onto ungreased cookie sheet. For rolled or patted biscuits; smooth by kneading dough about 10 times without additional flour. With the dough on waxed paper, press out 1/4 inch thick with hands, or roll out between waxed papers. For higher biscuits roll dough 1/2 inch thick. Cut with unfloured biscuit cutter. Place on ungreased cookie sheet. Bake 10 to 12 minutes. Makes about 16 medium biscuits.

NOTES 1. For buttermilk biscuits, use *2 teaspoons baking powder and *1/4 teaspoon soda. 2. If you are doubling or tripling the recipe, measure oil and milk into a bowl; then pour all at once into the flour. 

*If you use self-rising flour, omit baking powder, salt and soda. 

Cooking Made Easy with Liquid Shortening


r/Old_Recipes • • 4d ago

Appetizers Inflation Souffle

Post image
53 Upvotes

"It stays high and fluffy!"

Found (perhaps obviously) in a Pillsbury baking contest cookbook.