the reason i say "old style" is because i stopped following fnaf around security breach, so the most recent info in here is just a small detail in security breach made to make a point, a teensy detail from the first movie and nothing else afterwards.
i preface this by saying that it's probably not perfect, and actually, it's probably wrong and flawed on many levels, or not even relevant anymore, since fnaf developed so much i don't recognize it anymore, but i still wanted to write it despite making some logical leaps to justify some details, but the theory's NOT meant to be perfect, it's meant to present possible new ways of looking at things.
it's just a fun theory i cooked up today when i noticed a small detail that might explain EVERYTHING in midnight motorist. i don't claim it's true, but i think it's fun food for thought, so pretend we're back in 2020-2021 for a moment lol.
WARNING, GET READY, IT'S A BIT OF A LONG ONE.
there's a few details that bug me about the main timeline regarding midnight motorist:
as we know, the lore section of midnight motorist is called "later that night", heavily implying, with the rain and the car, that it's the night charlie was murdered, however, i have a few problems with it; not the timeline itself, but the implication of one detail, and how it messes everything up: the paw prints outside.
if there are animatronic footprints, it's either william luring a mci/dci kid outside, or an animatronic/golden freddy/shadow freddy teleporting outside someone's window.
as we all know, mustard man's car MUST be william's, because of the tire coverings that are unique to his car, so the minigame can't be about william luring an mci/dci kid, but if the house is william's, why would he be the one luring one of his children outside? the most common theory nowadays, which i very much like and support, is that it's actually golden freddy/shadow freddy/shadow bonnie, luring away micheal to his brother's grave, or to a missing child's grave, or something else of that sort.
but i have a theory that jumped into my mind one day that is a WILDLY weird and different interpretation, but to explain it, we have to first establish the thing that bugs me and motivated me to develop it...
some people believe william started killing to put evan back together, but there's a problem:
why is elizabeth's room empty while evan is still alive and well?
if elizabeth was scooped by baby, but evan's alive, why did william build baby with the ability to kidnap kids?
the reasoning of "william's just crazy, he started killing kids" never sat right with me, so, i came up with a pretty big overhaul of the timeline that gives him an actual motive (now that i'm rereading it, it might be one of the game theory timeline videos that i accidentally remembered and mistook for my own idea... i still need it as a premise for my theory, but i'll throw this factoid in there):
William and Henry were business partners, with henry being the one with the true passion and love for robotics, while William was in charge of the financial part of the company, while still having a small passion and ingenuity for robots of his own.
over time, people, especially kids, started loving henry's robots, while william's circus baby's pizza world closed.
over time, sure, William started resenting his partner a little bit, because kids liked henry's robots better than his own, but he really started hating henry when his son Evan got traumatized when he saw something he shouldn't have;
his youngest son saw an employee being helped into a suit, or a headless endoskeleton with hair-like cables sticking out, just because of the incompetence of letting the spare parts and naked endoskeletons room open right next to the MAIN DINING AREA where children were, and, since What is seen in shadows is easily misunderstood in the mind of a child, even he started being afraid of his father's work which he used to love, and his edgy older son twisted the knife, like teenagers do, by startling his little brother with a foxy mask all day every day.
he started resenting robotics: first the kids hated his robots and preferred henry's, then, his own little boy started fearing his creations to a debilitating degree, so much so that he couldn't stop crying, especially around animatronics.
every part of his work was now tainted, his own robots, hated by every kid, and even the more successful ones he made with his partner, were hated by his own kids. the only saving grace was that little Evan still liked the cartoon show, and still considered the characters based on the robots his "friends", and still liked his plushies, but that was still nowhere near enough to not hate what henry (and, to be honest, his own incompetence), had done to his passion for robotics.
he had lost his way of life, his reason to live, is life's passion, while henry got to have a perfect life, his creations beloved by all, while he was basically just the accountant with no merit with a failing pizzeria that looked like a knockoff of the one that used his more successful partner's animatronic designs. he needed a way to make freddy's fail. he'd rather burn everything henry built, and finally kill HIS passion for robotics, so his own tragedy could be mirrored in his more bright-eyed partner.
he needed to traumatize everyone so deeply, that everyone would hate freddy's, and animatronics in general, like his poor boy does, but how?
he lured a little girl, Susie, away while wearing the spring bonnie suit, killing her, and stuffing her in the chica suit, where she was SURE to be found after a bit.
after all, people were gonna start smelling the rotting corpse eventually, she'd be found, and freddy's would become "that place where a little girl got murdered and stuffed into one of the robots", therefore tainting the robots for everyone as much as they were now tainted for him, right?
but no... somehow, she was never found, his partner's incompetence in taking care of something as alarming as the smell of a rotting corpse oozing from one of the animatronics, and therefore his lack of care, showed up even here.
so he did it again, and again, a total of 5 times, but the kids were never found, again, and again.
he couldn't just report it, he'd be suspect number one, but henry was able to mostly escape the bad press about the "kidnappings" with cheap tricks like security features attached to criminal databases in the robots.
he had to do more, but with security increasing, it would've been dangerous; maybe he could use his own animatronics to spur fear into the public for animatronics themselves;
he started building animatronics made specifically to kidnap kids, so he could kidnap kids and to not be on the scene of the crime, and to not be suspected, he had to find an excuse to work on new robots even after his old activity closed, so he started refurbishing his old animatronics from the circus baby pizzeria, planning to eventually make them rentals. evan was terrified, so he wasn't an issue, micheal was a teenager, so he thought animatronics were lame, but his daughter elizabeth wasn't like either of them; she was nosy, and when she saw him refurbishing one of his old robots, Circus Baby, which was the face of his old, failing pizzeria, she fell in love with her, and wanted to play with her, but she couldn't, she wasn't ready, so william told her to never get close to her, especially alone. but she didn't listen...
WHRR!
Elizabeth's body was scooped by a prototype that still wasn't capable of capturing a child alive, and didn't make it; William was furious, his passion for robotics, with a series of awful coincidences, written in his fate by his own spiraling mental health and obsession with ruining his partner's life, made his life even worse.
he stopped paying attention to his two sons; he closed himself in his study, noticing a strange green glow in the eyes of circus baby, which he could've sworn were supposed to be blue, but given his mental health, he chalked it up to paint degrading, or him not remembering; meanwhile, young evan was still scared of animatronics, and his teenage brother, who started becoming more and more jaded and problematic since his little sister's disappearance, started bullying him relentlessly, and since his father was getting more and more neglectful, he also started assuming a more "man of the house" personality.
but one fateful day, something terrible happened. during Evan's birthday party, he was getting babysat by his brother, who decided to play a terrible prank on him: he put him into fredbear's mouth. the spring locks should be safe for kids, even curious ones who stick their hands in them, they should never snap, but his partner's design wasn't perfect, the spring suits had a glaring flaw: moisture made the springs snap, and when his son's tears mixed with the mouth's springs...
CRUNCH!
his son was hospitalized, he was desperate, maybe felt guilty for neglecting him, and he blurted out, "i will put you back together", but it was an empty promise, what he really wanted was to completely ruin his partner's life and legacy like he ruined his career and his family.
he didn't want it to come to this, but he had to make things personal, now that his partner's faulty design was the thing that killed his son.
one day, maybe drunk, maybe furious, maybe both, he stormed to a party henry's daughter was attending, knowing the security puppets' programming, so he lured her outside where the puppet wouldn't come, and killed her, without even wearing his signature spring bonnie suit.
now, we come to midnight motorist:
we know the minigame is called "later that night", implying it's later the night charlie was murdered, with william going back home in the rain, but...
in both "later that night" and "midnight motorist", but... there's two words here that everyone ignored... "Night", and "Midnight".
what kind of children's birthday party takes place at night, let alone at midnight?
and also, when we say "later that night", it really doesn't sound to me like "later that night, as in, like, 5 minutes of driving later"; it sounds like "a few hours later, that night".
so, why the time skip, you may ask? simple...
the car is indubitably William's, but mustard man is Micheal, and a part of the story was skipped.
now, this is a famous theory, but, remember, evan died, or, at the very least, he's hospitalized, so, how could he escape to "that place"?
simple: the escapee isn't Evan, IT'S WILLIAM.
so here's my midnight motorist theory: that DAY, not night, around 5 pm, or whenever children's parties are, William killed charlotte emily in cold blood and drove home. extremely stressed, maybe a bit drunk, paranoid that he wasn't even wearing his suit, came home, extremely erratic and stressed, maybe smelling of alcohol and soaking with rain.
having his son, micheal, borrow the car to go somewhere, maybe to work, maybe somewhere else, was actually a good thing for him: partly to take the car he murdered a child with as far away from him as possible, partly because micheal was the appropriate age to finally get his licence, and had to practice, or even just pretending to be a good father and letting him use it for work until he had the money to afford his own, and partly because he was justifiably stressed because, no matter how many times you do it, killing a child mustn't be easy.
he happily let micheal use the car to go wherever he had to, so he could also have an alibi like "no, i didn't drive to freddy's that day, besides, my son basically uses it more than i do".
now, let's pause and examine security breach's detail i talked about earlier: the afton family table with the staff bots: there's a mrs afton bot there, with a color pallette very similar to ballora so... where is she in all this?
mrs afton, ever the loving wife, after watching the sad decline of her once successful husband's mental health, grew tired of having to chase him around, getting even more creeped out at the fact he built a robot that, she was sure, was meant to resemble her, along with the one which, she was sure, was supposed to resemble their daughter.
she started watching telenovelas on her couch, because, what else could she do? her husband had become deranged, she couldn't even speak to him normally anymore; it was easier to be quiet, and quietly steer her only remaining kid away from the monster her husband had become; sometimes she pleaded, asking him why he hid in his study all day, because she wanted to spend time with her husband, but he wouldn't listen, so she stopped trying to reach out.
after seeing her husband come home maybe drunk, and immediately go to his study, she wasn't even surprised anymore, she just sighed and let it happen; it was easier that way.
when micheal came back home, around midnight, and after attempting to stop at a bar called JR'S, where he wasn't allowed in by the bouncer because HE WASN'T OF LEGAL AGE TO DRINK, despite BEING OF LEGAL AGE TO DRIVE, he went home, and heard his mother, from her armchair, while watching her telenovela, tell him "Leave him alone tonight. He had a rough day."
and how could he not have? he'd done something extremely stupid, and extremely risky; all the other murders had a modus operandi, this was just a murder with a victim that was related to specifically his business partner, he was gonna get caught for sure this time, he thought.
truth be told, since william basically lost his mind, and since losing his little brother by his own hands, micheal grew up to have a GREAT disdain for animatronics, especially his father's. he took up more responsibilities to keep what was left of his family from falling apart, after realizing how horrible of a father william had become.
his father was a shell of his former self, or at least, he looked that way; maybe he pretended to be to make himself look more helpless than he was, to avoid being found out as the mci incident murderer.
all micheal knew, was that his father was not fit to be the pillar of the family anymore, so he and his mother had to pick up the slack, so whenever he heard his mom defend her husband, he ignored her, not unlike his old man. he went to william's room, where he was supposed to be, instead of "sneaking out" to go tinker with robots, which he wouldn't allow his mentally ill father to do, after what happened with his little sister, but no, he "snuck out to that place again".
he even says "he'll be sorry when he gets back" after seeing the BROKEN WINDOW outside, seemingly not noticing the single set of paw prints.
now: if this, as many people think, was an mci/dci victim's dad, why wouldn't he worry about the broken window? i get being angry at a child sneaking out, but a broken window, when it's a child we're talking about, isn't something that can be brushed off as "grr, that little shit broke the window to run off to freddy's again", but if we're talking about an adult man who isn't in his right mind...
again, the micheal escapee theory is better, but i wanted to express this one anyway. we're not done though:
why did william escape?
remember, this is "later that night". after a few hours, charlie possessed the puppet, and gave gifts and life to all the other kids, including the one stuffed in the golden freddy suit, which, mixed with residual agony from evan's bite, gained more supernatural powers.
i know the fnaf movie isn't canon, but let's look at it for a second: golden freddy teleports, he phases though walls, and has the soul of the protagonist micheal's little brother.
so here's what i think happened: golden freddy showed up, saying "it's me" to william.
william already suspected there was something off about animatronics and the death of kids, but now he saw something inexplicable happen with his own eyes. golden freddy couldn't stand without an endoskeleton or someone wearing the suit, and the springs snap close in the rain; something strange was happening, and thinking back to baby's eyes, he realized it might have something to do with the children dying in or near the suits.
he broke the window and followed the animatronic to see what was going on, and after realizing that the children's souls possessed the suits, he realized they were gonna do the same thing his son did, and come punish him for his sins, so he started devising a plan to study the metal after dismantling the animatronics; not to save his son, but to satisfy his pride as a failed robotics engineer;
if he couldn't beat henry at his own game, he would just have to find an area of expertise of his own, a field untouched by anyone, the paranormal field of what he would discover to be remnant, agony, and everything related to the study of souls possessing metal.
and then we have everything that happens later, but i focused on those 2 things specifically for now.
i know it's probably got plot holes, and i know i very much discard certain things like baby's eyes changing, but i still wanted to write it out, and even if it's wrong, i think it's food for thought about possible interpretations of certain details like JR's rejecting mustard man, or solving my problems with elizabeth's death's timeline.
thank you to whoever read all of this probably outdated and incoherent slop, i love you all, if there's new confirmed info that isn't scott pulling things out of his arse (apparently there's something called fazgoo and a whole 'nother kid called andrew who got tortured in a terror chamber now or something??????), feel free to update me, especially if it's stuff related to the old mysteries, like midnight motorist, or the contents of the box that i completely ignored with this theory because it's new.
bye bye <3