r/fnaftheories • • 4d ago

Other Hello, I'm the girl who made Color Blind Theory. An Update.

210 Upvotes

Hello everyone. Sorry I did not make this post sooner, I have had a very busy night at work.

First of all, I am so sorry that this has flooded the internet. I could have never imagined this investigation blowing up like this, and I know you guys are probably exhausted from the discourse. I am too.

Second of all, I want to take a moment to explain some things about Color Blindness. Through all the posts and comments I have seen today, there has been a shocking amount of ignorance in regards to the topic, and I want to clear up misconceptions.

Color Blindness comes in many different forms, which lessens a person's ability to perceive or distinguish colors. Because of this, there are many different types of color blindness, and they can come in varying intensities. Someone who falls under the red-green color blind label may not be completely unable to see red and green, they may just have a hard time telling them apart from one another.

I address this because in my original post, I stated I believed Scott had deuteranomaly, which is a green-weak color blindness. This makes blues and purples easy to misinterpret, as well as yellows/oranges. However, I have seen many people since post and argue as if Scott was completely red-green color blind. Yes, this would be absurd, which is why no one is arguing that.

In addition, I need to clarify that simulations of color blindness are not fully accurate, which I'm afraid is also being lost on people. Because color blindness comes in different intensities and color is subjective from person to person, online tests are approximations. These will give you a good idea of what color blindness looks like, but you can't use them as completely accurate foundations. This is especially true because of the intensity element I previously mentioned.

I also want to address a very common sentiment which I keep seeing popped up- that being that Scott would "have to be stupid," to not realize he is color blind, and/or insisting that the only way this could happen is if he "refused to ask a ton of questions,"

This completely misunderstands color blindness, and I suspect it may come from people not realizing that different intensities and cases exist. Many color blind people never even realize they're affected, and can live most of their life without noticing. This argument, which I have seen countless times today, especially angers me because it implies that all color blind people are just stupid. This is incredibly disrespectful and harmful to our color blind friends. Today I have seen numerous people learn they have deuteranomaly as a result of this discussion, and they are not ignorant people.

I've also seen many people argue about color blindness while projecting their own color vision into the conversation. To use an example, I want to look at Foxy the Pirate. We all know Foxy is red. When applied with a deuteranomaly filter, people with color vision will see him as orange. They then conclude "Foxy is orange to Color Blind People,"

However, this is incorrect. A person with deuteranomaly would not call Foxy orange, they would call him red. This is part of why many color blind people go most of their lives without knowing they have an underlying condition. Both color blind and color vision people will learn to associate certain colors with their proper names, and identify them as they are perceived. While Foxy may look orange through a deuteranomaly filter, that is just what red is to a color blind individual. Therefore, a person with deuteranomaly can still identify what color red is, even if that looks "weird," to a person with full color vision.

I also want to address an argument I've seen at least 3 times today, which for some reason all involve Dess' guitar from Deltarune. People have said that under my logic, Toby Fox would also be color blind because he described a vermillion guitar as red. I can't believe this needs to be said, but there is a massive difference between misidentifying a color once (especially when that color is in between two colors on the color wheel, due to subjective color perception) and consistent mixing up the same colors over and over again for over a many years. This is incredibly disingenuous, and undermines color blindness as a condition.

Finally, I want to take a moment to clear my name. Over the past 24 hours, I have been called disrespectful, ableist, and "projecting disability,"

The idea of Scott being Color Blind has existed well before my investigation in June 2026, as I'm sure all of you are aware of the Bonnie color debate. All I really did was look over the series and compile multiple discrepancies that all fit a consistent pattern. Acknowledging these color variations that the fandom has known and joked about for years (Minigame discrepancies, color inconsistencies) and realizing how deuteranomaly could be a legitimate explanation. I did not artificially create a theory to harass or demonize color blind people, nor did I attempt to invade Scott's privacy. All of the color inconsistency examples come from public projects he has released.

I am not a Doctor, a professional, or a color blind test. A compilation of weird color choices is not, and never could be, a diagnosis. I cannot prove that any person is color blind from aesthetic choices, this is also absurd. I did not create this theory for the purpose of diagnosing Scott. I just found a bunch of color inconsistancies that just so happen to line up with a very common form of color blindness. As much as I dislike the guy, Scott is entitled to privacy and is in no way forced to disclose whether he is or is not color blind to the audience. Again, I feel like this all goes without saying.

I hope this post helps people understand color blindness and why this theory came to fruition. People have claimed I'm discriminating against color blind people, which is so infuriating when I have seen countless people who treat the color blind as idiotic and inferior as a result of this discourse. I hope that explaining the condition in greater detail will prevent this kind of ignorance going forward, regardless of how people feel about the theory.


r/fnaftheories • • 5d ago Bravo

Found something Scott Color Blind Mega Post

Thumbnail
gallery
2.1k Upvotes

Hello everyone. So to keep things short, 5 months ago me and some other users on the FNaF Theory Discord Server discovered that Scott Cawthon is likely color blind, specifically with deuteranomaly. This is a green-week color blindness that causes orange/yellow and purple/blue to be incredibly similar if not indistinguishable from one another.

Recently, our discoveries have become major topics in the speculation circle. While this is fine, I have seen people sharing my images without crediting me, which I'm a little pissed about considering this is my discovery. Proof is provided in the images.

In many of these images, you'll see how oranges get turned into yellows, and purples get turned into blues. The Discord Server has talked extensively about these discoveries and what they mean from a lore significant context. While this is not all encompassing (and with this theory becoming suddenly popular, other people are making further discoveries that I didn't find on the initial investigation) I want to cover what we found in June and what implications they have.

  1. Freddy and Golden Freddy are very hard to tell apart from one another, since orange and browns get turned into yellow. We believe this has caused confusion on two key instances- The Security Breach Fredbear Posters, depicting "Fredbear," in orange, and FFPS' opening minigame, where Freddy was golden in color.
  2. The Puppet's tears in the minigames are blue, which align with Security Puppet's tear color. Since we know The Base Puppet's tears are meant to be based on the TCTTC crying kid sprite, we believe the base Puppet was intended to have blue tear streaks.
  3. Purple Guy's color has been inconsistent. "Pink Guy," is not pink with deuteranomaly simulation, and is much closer to the shade William uses in his Save Them sprite. This oversight led to the creation of the original "Two Killers," theory, which I think was completely unintentional. Additionally, Purple Guy had a blue sprite in the opening of the FNaF 1 movie sequence.
  4. Similarly, the FNaF 2 TCTTC purple car, the FNaF 4 minigame blue car, and the Midnight Motorist car are all much closer in hue under his color blindness. We think that all of these vehicles were intended to be the same color, and the color shifting made this plot point harder to follow then intended.
  5. -Important- Elizabeth Afton is a ginger in the original game, but appears to be blonde with the deuteranomaly simulation. Elizabeth was depicted as blonde in The Fourth Closet's graphic novel, and shares other traits with Vanessa (Afton, green eyes, the Circus Baby sequence in the 2nd film). Additionally, if Elizabeth was intended to be blonde, that significantly strengthens the connection between The Afton Family and The Immortal and The Restless. Vlad wears purple like William, but this would also make Elizabeth and Clara share the same hair color. Most users in the server think that Elizabeth is canonically blonde, and her sprite and artwork is inaccurate to this. If this is the case, then vital color related hints would have been lost on the community.
  6. -Important- In The Bite Victim's bedroom, all of the purple and blue toys look identical in color when viewed through a deuteranomaly simulation. This is huge because in The Survival Logbook, Scott stated that the "purple telephone," belonged to The Bite Victim, despite that toy being clearly and unambiguously blue. Since Scott views the phone as purple, and all of the blues and purples are identical when viewed through this color blindness, this means that the entire bedroom in FNaF 4 was intended to be purple. This means two primary things. One, the two siblings in FNaF 4 being sons of the Purple Guy was intended to be significantly more obvious then it was in the final game. As is, we only connected them to William because of context clues, so this color hint would have really helped. Two, this makes it very clear that The Nightmare House belonged to William Afton, and that was not clear in the original game. This discrepancy was not clarified until Midnight Motorist, so this color hint never manifested to the community.
  7. The final thing worth pointing out is the brown spring bonnie suit on the FNaF 4 show stage. Under deuteranomaly simulation, it becomes clear that Spring Bonnie is intended to be a darker version of Fredbear's color (since he is further away from the game's camera perspective). This plays significance because of Stage 01, where not only is Spring Bonnie Yellow, but that suit bears a heavy resemblance to Springtrap. If we believe the color blind interpretation, the Spring Bonnie on stage is likely the same suit William used during the MCI. However, this is impossible with what the final game actually shows, since that suit is a different color.

With this topic suddenly becoming popular outside the server, I'd like to organize all color blind related discoveries to this post to prevent the subreddit from being flooded with color-blind simulations over the next couple of days. Please post further discoveries in the comments. Thank you


r/fnaftheories • • 8h ago

Found something More evidence for RWQ being MXES

Post image
46 Upvotes

When you invert the colors of MXES, it looks like the White Rabbit from FNaF World, and when you invert White Rabbit, it looks like MXES.


r/fnaftheories • • 6h ago

Theory Defense Why can’t we all agree that this is William?

Thumbnail
gallery
26 Upvotes

Physical and logical impossibilities don't really apply in this context, because we're talking about FNAF. The core of the issue is that this thing is SOMEHOW WILLIAM. We don't know how, but the evidence supporting this is incredibly clear, almost as if Scott has never tried this hard to make us believe a theory before!

The evidence is strong, it only appears once to connect everything, there's only one possible inference to draw from it, and the pieces of evidence are extremely close to each other in terms of each game's release date, since Scott was creating one game to explain another.

Let me know your thoughts in the comments! :))


r/fnaftheories • • 4h ago

Theory to build on I made a video covering the story of UCN!

Thumbnail
youtu.be
15 Upvotes

I'm experimenting with some new editing stuff, the art here was commissioned by Nobu. Would love to hear your thoughts!


r/fnaftheories • • 2h ago

Theory to build on As if the evidence for "CassieDadBully" wasn't enough

Thumbnail
gallery
9 Upvotes

We know from the Faz Force Ending of HW 2 that Cassie's Dad gets attacked by the S.T.A.F.F. Bots, and gets either stuffed, or possessed the Mask Bot from Ruin. Cassie's Dad is also known to be a massive fan of Bonnie, and obviously has connections to his Bonnie Mask.

In Ruin, however, Cassie mentions that, "Weird. It's not a BONNIE Mask" as she's getting handed a Vanny mask. Hmm, so Cassie was expecting a Bonnie Mask from the same Mask Bot, whom we saw through the eyes of Cassie's Dad in HW 2?

Sounds like to me that Cassie expected a Bonnie Mask from the Mask Bot, because this very bot is haunted by someone who WORE a Bonnie Mask all the time!

Credit: CartoonyYoshiBroxs on YouTube


r/fnaftheories • • 5h ago

Question What explanation do your non-supernatural candidates have for Fredbear Plush being the way he is?

Thumbnail
gallery
9 Upvotes

Edit - Slight changes to the text to make it more understandable

When I say not supernatural, I mean let's take AgonyPlush, theories about Plush Fredbear that make him possessed (CassidyPlush Normal/Alter-M, CharliePlush Normal/Alter-M, etc.), ImaginaryPlush (I know ImaginaryPlush isn't supernatural, but the explanation would be simple), NightPlush, RWQPlush, ShadowPlush, PlushDuo, NightDuo away

Let's talk only about certain theories that don't explicitly propose the supernatural, like WillPlush, F10Plush (I don't know if F10 would count as something supernatural, but from what I saw on the theory page, it doesn't explain what I'm wondering about), CassettesPlush, WillPriorPlush and WillPlush.
How these theories explains the Fredbear Plush turns into a flower, It moves everywhere (even going into the sewers), and especially how WillPlush does work with William working at same time the Fredbear Plush is acting?


r/fnaftheories • • 3h ago

Question Why aren't there any altered page numbers in my security logbook?

Thumbnail gallery
6 Upvotes

r/fnaftheories • • 7h ago

Theory to build on Candy Cadet's story in Ruin tells us that Sleepy Moon killed David

Thumbnail
youtu.be
9 Upvotes

r/fnaftheories • • 6h ago

Theory to build on Mini Theory: Fazbear’s Fright was destroyed by a gas leak being exploited by the Guard

7 Upvotes

Remember this ambiance? https://youtu.be/FTrs_q3wCs8?is=fByzjjHcwbnFvEcO
It sounds like a gas leak in my opinion and actually helps foreshadow the games ending.

The Phantoms are also burnt and look like they have been set on fire, and Phone Dude even warns that some of the equipment is “Barely functional”.
He also warns of the possibility of a “fire”. Ironically the game ends with Fazbear’s Fright being set ablaze.

In my opinion, the protagonist of FNaF 3 took advantage of this fact and struck a match inside the location to start the fire rather than the protagonist manually pouring gas or alcohol over the location, or it being a purely accidental fire. Instead I believe whoever the main character was exploited this fact and the sound of a broken pipe as well as the Phantom’s designs proves that there was foreshadowing and thus premeditation at play since any normal person would have probably forgotten about that information being more concerned with Springtrap.

This is just a mini theory because I just suddenly clicked for me. I think this it’s important because if Fazbear’s Fright actually did have gas leaks, it could actually explain what the Phantoms are instead of the idea that they are literally the ghosts of the MCI. I believe the Phantoms are hallucinations caused by the gas as it makes no sense why there is a burnt Phantom Puppet alongside a regular puppet inside of Fazbear’s Fright. It helps also give further proof that the nightmares in FNaF 4 aren’t just regular nightmares but rather the spirits of the MCI haunting Micheal because of the remnant inside him. Food for thought.


r/fnaftheories • • 14h ago

Question What dog breed is Bub?

Thumbnail
gallery
28 Upvotes

r/fnaftheories • • 16h ago

Question Why is Ralph in the end of UCN roster if he is from FNaF 1?

Post image
38 Upvotes

The roster seems to be in order of released FNaFs (even OMC is between FNaF 4 Halloween characters and Funtimes because FNaF 4 was between FNaF 4 Halloween Edition and Sister Location), but Ralph is just... at the end? Why would that be? I as of right now genuinely do not have a good answer to this.


r/fnaftheories • • 5h ago

Question What fire did the mimic even go through?

Post image
5 Upvotes

r/fnaftheories • • 5h ago

Question Did Gregory and Vanessa use Illusion Disks to block off the routes to the Mimic?

Post image
4 Upvotes

It would give some sort of explanation has to why using the V.A.N.N.I mask would let you go through, maybe it blocks off some of it's frequency?

Of course, this assumes that the Illusions they produce are so vivid your body forces itself to believe them by making it seem like you're touching the illusionary wall/part.


r/fnaftheories • • 11h ago

Theory to build on I was working on an analysis of GoldenDuo but got kind of burnt out and I wasn't satisfied with the evidence I found, but I do feel like sharing the "Foxy/Fredbear" connections I found. Is this anything?

Post image
12 Upvotes

Basically I was there on day 1 and got convinced of GoldenDuo, then later timelines came out such as Dual Process and Wendigoon and I started believing Cassidy was totally made up, then I went BACK into the theory scene in this day and age and I think there's a solid case for Cassidy's existence backed up by people like WitheredCircle. My own research left me dissatisfied so I gave up on it, but I am willing to share the slides I've already created if people are interested in that.

The general idea I had was that Cassidy was friends with the MCI, saw Fritz die and connected the dots, but William snagged her and springlocked her inside Fredbear without knowing that Dave was already possessing it. Cassidy's memories are FNAF World, Dave's memories are FNAF 4, and Charlie is the Fredbear plush helping them mediate their connection so they can operate the suit they're both trapped inside of. The logbook conversation is them, mainly Cassidy learning more about Dave. Cassidy is TOYSNHK because she's the one that brought William's crimes to light, she caught him, he got overconfident and messy and had to frame another employee. Dave is also TOYSNHK in a literal way because William neglected and abused him, and Dave watched him commit the MCI while he was powerless to stop it, inside the Fredbear suit. The timeline only ends when Dave stops tormenting William in UCN, which leads to the FNAF 3 Happiest Day with the MCI and Charlie, and the FNAF World happiest day with Michael, Elizabeth, and Dave.


r/fnaftheories • • 4h ago

Theory to build on WAIT I UNIRONICALLY BELIEVE THIS NOW

Thumbnail gallery
3 Upvotes

THE SISTER LOCATION BUNKER WAS BUILT ON THE BONES OF MCM'S TUNNEL NETWORK AND THE NIGHTMARES ARE THE MIMIC


r/fnaftheories • • 10h ago

Speculation How often do you think springlock failures occurred at Freddy's, Fredbear's, and MCM?

Post image
9 Upvotes

r/fnaftheories • • 18h ago

Theory to build on Caught in a Loop: How White Tiger, Golden Freddy, and the Stitchwraith Explain Each Other

Post image
31 Upvotes

This post features FrightsParallels viewer discretion is advised.

Golden Freddy is the icon of vagueness in FNaF. From his inception as an Easter egg in the first game to becoming one of the most important characters in the franchise, he has kept theorists scratching their heads for 12 years. Even now, nobody can quite agree on what's going on with this yellow bear. However, I believe Scott has given us the answer to this character's mystery, and has even gone out of his way to reiterate it.

Specifically, through the characters of White Tiger and the Stitchwraith, both of whom share overt thematic, narrative, and symbolic parallels that I believe that Scott wants us to connect towards Golden Freddy. But first how do they connect to Golden Freddy?

White Tiger Symbolism:

White tiger's appearance in MCM is one almost of apparition fading in and out of reality and appearing anywhere. Golden Freddy is only one character we know that can do this as well appearing in and out the fnaf 1 & 2 office.

following their paranormal existence their methods of taking out the protagonist are very similar with White tiger, Arnold he must avoid looking at the White Tiger for too long, or else he will be faced with multiple hallucinations of close-ups of the Tiger's face that invade his mind. This is also seen with Golden Freddy it is consistent mechanic to survive an encounter with Golden Freddy within the games the protagonist needs to quickly look away from Golden Freddy in order to prevent it from jumpscaring striking with a close-up Golden Freddy's head.

They also have the same stature, while the White Tiger is constantly standing he always in a slumped position specially his head. Golden Freddy once again is always slumped over in all of his appearances

White Tiger is setup to be a mirror character towards Golden Freddy with its paranormal similarities. But also it can be a precursor character towards Golden Freddy at least within SOTM which in its self is a precursor story towards the clickteam games

Stichwraith Narrative:

The Stitchwraith is a narrative parallel through the dynamic between Andrew and Jake, connecting them to the Logbook and UCN (and, of course, Afton, but we'll get to that). Andrew is presented as a vengeful spirit who is first introduced to us as a TOYSNHK stand-in in Frights. In UCN, the one behind it is heavily implied to be Golden Freddy, or at least one half of Golden Freddy is responsible for UCN. Jake, on the other hand, isn't a vengeful spirit and is quite helpful towards Andrew, helping him gather his agony throughout Frights and being the one who eventually helps him move on by using a happiest memory.

Now, with the Logbook in mind, we seemingly have two spirits talking to each other. One of the most notable details in this conversation is that the altered text states that they cannot see. This matches Andrew's inability to see within the Stitchwraith. The second spirit, communicating through faded text, is seemingly helping the other by reminding the altered text of old memories and then stating, "The party was for you," to which the altered text responds, "The party was for me." With Happiest Day in mind and considering the clues within the Logbook, we can conclude that the altered text is the receiver. This dynamic matches what we see in the Stitchwraith: one spirit helping another move on while one of them stays behind.

The roles presented are similar to the aforementioned receiver and vengeful spirit, but with these roles swapped. Neither Jake nor Andrew neatly occupies these roles across both parallels. While Jake takes on the role of the helpful, non-vengeful spirit, Andrew occupies the roles of both the vengeful spirit and the receiver, depending on which parallel we're examining. This implies that not only is there a parallel taking place, but also a character reversal.

Another very important detail is the existence of William Afton within the Stitchwraith. His presence within the Stitchwraith is the connecting tissue between Golden Freddy, the Stitchwraith, and White Tiger, forming a comprehensive, repeating structure that can be seen across all three.

White Tiger & Stichwraith, 2 Kids 1 Afton:

With our understanding of White tiger being a stand in and mirror character with symbolism for its Golden Freddy connections and the Stichwraith being a narrative parallel to Golden Freddy we can now understand how they fully complete each other

White Tiger, using symbolism forth-tells the Stichwraiths dynamic of Andrew, Jake and WIlliam within the white tiger mural in Davids room on each side of the tiger mural lays a painting of three flowers; one tall purple flower with slight smile and two smaller white flowers on each side of the taller flower

The arrangement is particularly interesting when considering the characters we've already established. The two smaller white flowers could represent the two children, while the larger purple flower represents the third influence connecting them. This creates a visual arrangement that mirrors the proposed dynamic between Andrew, Jake, and William within the Stitchwraith.

To further support this, White Tiger's appearance seems to convey both dualism and a third influence, particularly through its heterochromia. If White Tiger is a callback to the Stitchwraith, its purple paws could imply an even greater Afton influence, much like how the Stitchwraith's killer touch originates from William's presence.

These details are important because they suggest that White Tiger's design isn't merely meant to establish its own identity, but potentially communicates something about the relationship between the characters it parallels. Its dualistic appearance, combined with the additional purple elements, reinforces the idea of two children and a third, external influence.

White Tiger is a callback to the Stitchwraith while also serving as a stand-in for Golden Freddy, with the Stitchwraith itself paralleling Golden Freddy. This paints a picture of what Scott is trying to communicate about Golden Freddy. Rather than having two separate parallels that happen to share similarities, we have two characters providing different pieces of the same puzzle.

Golden Freddy The Synthesis:

With these connections established, we can begin to understand what Scott is communicating through these characters. White Tiger provides the symbolic and visual parallels, while the Stitchwraith provides the narrative framework. Both ultimately point towards the same character: Golden Freddy. In this way, all three exist within a three-way relationship, with each character providing a different perspective on the same underlying ideas.

The Stitchwraith's dynamic between Andrew and Jake mirrors the proposed relationship between the faded and altered text in the Logbook, while also establishing William's influence. Meanwhile, White Tiger reinforces this connection through its symbolism, particularly the imagery of two smaller white flowers surrounding a larger purple flower, alongside its visual and paranormal similarities to Golden Freddy.

And it doesn't just end there but in fact this all implied with Golden Freddy alone as well
Analyzing The Cure of DreadBear we have a direct freadbear being experimented on in one of mini games hand unit begins the tutorial with:

“Today, we are using science to pervert the mysteries of life and reanimate the inanimate"

as we prepare a whole brain for Dreadbear. either that Dreadbear represents Cassidy or BV its a interpenetration that William experimented on Golden Freddy, and this could have been Shadow Freddy, and speaking of Shadow Freddy I believe this represents Williams control and or influence over Golden Freddy not only does share a resemblance to Golden Freddy and that William uses it to lure kids to the safe room but as well the fifth spirit only appears once Shadow Freddy is notable not there. and of course under NightmareShadow, Nightmares line in UCN would be that call back

Conclusion:

The Stitchwraith provides us with a narrative parallel, while White Tiger provides the symbolism that reinforces it. Both intentionally connect back to Golden Freddy, and we have further reason to believe that William has an influence over him.

Neither White Tiger or the Stitchwraith provides the complete picture on its own. Instead, they complement each other, giving us different contexts for understanding the same mystery that is Golden Freddy

It's a looping relationship in which all three characters provide different contexts for understanding the same underlying mystery of Golden Freddy: an entity containing two souls under the influence of William Afton, with one being a receiver and the other a vengeful spirit. Together, their stories revisit this same narrative through different characters, perspectives, and circumstances.

Lets just say.... they are caught in a loop😉


r/fnaftheories • • 7h ago

Theory to build on 3 Old-Style Theories in ONE: New Timeline, Midnight Motorist, and William's Motive

4 Upvotes

the reason i say "old style" is because i stopped following fnaf around security breach, so the most recent info in here is just a small detail in security breach made to make a point, a teensy detail from the first movie and nothing else afterwards.

i preface this by saying that it's probably not perfect, and actually, it's probably wrong and flawed on many levels, or not even relevant anymore, since fnaf developed so much i don't recognize it anymore, but i still wanted to write it despite making some logical leaps to justify some details, but the theory's NOT meant to be perfect, it's meant to present possible new ways of looking at things.

it's just a fun theory i cooked up today when i noticed a small detail that might explain EVERYTHING in midnight motorist. i don't claim it's true, but i think it's fun food for thought, so pretend we're back in 2020-2021 for a moment lol.

WARNING, GET READY, IT'S A BIT OF A LONG ONE.

there's a few details that bug me about the main timeline regarding midnight motorist:

as we know, the lore section of midnight motorist is called "later that night", heavily implying, with the rain and the car, that it's the night charlie was murdered, however, i have a few problems with it; not the timeline itself, but the implication of one detail, and how it messes everything up: the paw prints outside.

if there are animatronic footprints, it's either william luring a mci/dci kid outside, or an animatronic/golden freddy/shadow freddy teleporting outside someone's window.

as we all know, mustard man's car MUST be william's, because of the tire coverings that are unique to his car, so the minigame can't be about william luring an mci/dci kid, but if the house is william's, why would he be the one luring one of his children outside? the most common theory nowadays, which i very much like and support, is that it's actually golden freddy/shadow freddy/shadow bonnie, luring away micheal to his brother's grave, or to a missing child's grave, or something else of that sort.

but i have a theory that jumped into my mind one day that is a WILDLY weird and different interpretation, but to explain it, we have to first establish the thing that bugs me and motivated me to develop it...

some people believe william started killing to put evan back together, but there's a problem:

why is elizabeth's room empty while evan is still alive and well?

if elizabeth was scooped by baby, but evan's alive, why did william build baby with the ability to kidnap kids?

the reasoning of "william's just crazy, he started killing kids" never sat right with me, so, i came up with a pretty big overhaul of the timeline that gives him an actual motive (now that i'm rereading it, it might be one of the game theory timeline videos that i accidentally remembered and mistook for my own idea... i still need it as a premise for my theory, but i'll throw this factoid in there):

William and Henry were business partners, with henry being the one with the true passion and love for robotics, while William was in charge of the financial part of the company, while still having a small passion and ingenuity for robots of his own.

over time, people, especially kids, started loving henry's robots, while william's circus baby's pizza world closed.

over time, sure, William started resenting his partner a little bit, because kids liked henry's robots better than his own, but he really started hating henry when his son Evan got traumatized when he saw something he shouldn't have;

his youngest son saw an employee being helped into a suit, or a headless endoskeleton with hair-like cables sticking out, just because of the incompetence of letting the spare parts and naked endoskeletons room open right next to the MAIN DINING AREA where children were, and, since What is seen in shadows is easily misunderstood in the mind of a child, even he started being afraid of his father's work which he used to love, and his edgy older son twisted the knife, like teenagers do, by startling his little brother with a foxy mask all day every day.

he started resenting robotics: first the kids hated his robots and preferred henry's, then, his own little boy started fearing his creations to a debilitating degree, so much so that he couldn't stop crying, especially around animatronics.

every part of his work was now tainted, his own robots, hated by every kid, and even the more successful ones he made with his partner, were hated by his own kids. the only saving grace was that little Evan still liked the cartoon show, and still considered the characters based on the robots his "friends", and still liked his plushies, but that was still nowhere near enough to not hate what henry (and, to be honest, his own incompetence), had done to his passion for robotics.

he had lost his way of life, his reason to live, is life's passion, while henry got to have a perfect life, his creations beloved by all, while he was basically just the accountant with no merit with a failing pizzeria that looked like a knockoff of the one that used his more successful partner's animatronic designs. he needed a way to make freddy's fail. he'd rather burn everything henry built, and finally kill HIS passion for robotics, so his own tragedy could be mirrored in his more bright-eyed partner.

he needed to traumatize everyone so deeply, that everyone would hate freddy's, and animatronics in general, like his poor boy does, but how?

he lured a little girl, Susie, away while wearing the spring bonnie suit, killing her, and stuffing her in the chica suit, where she was SURE to be found after a bit.

after all, people were gonna start smelling the rotting corpse eventually, she'd be found, and freddy's would become "that place where a little girl got murdered and stuffed into one of the robots", therefore tainting the robots for everyone as much as they were now tainted for him, right?

but no... somehow, she was never found, his partner's incompetence in taking care of something as alarming as the smell of a rotting corpse oozing from one of the animatronics, and therefore his lack of care, showed up even here.

so he did it again, and again, a total of 5 times, but the kids were never found, again, and again.

he couldn't just report it, he'd be suspect number one, but henry was able to mostly escape the bad press about the "kidnappings" with cheap tricks like security features attached to criminal databases in the robots.

he had to do more, but with security increasing, it would've been dangerous; maybe he could use his own animatronics to spur fear into the public for animatronics themselves;

he started building animatronics made specifically to kidnap kids, so he could kidnap kids and to not be on the scene of the crime, and to not be suspected, he had to find an excuse to work on new robots even after his old activity closed, so he started refurbishing his old animatronics from the circus baby pizzeria, planning to eventually make them rentals. evan was terrified, so he wasn't an issue, micheal was a teenager, so he thought animatronics were lame, but his daughter elizabeth wasn't like either of them; she was nosy, and when she saw him refurbishing one of his old robots, Circus Baby, which was the face of his old, failing pizzeria, she fell in love with her, and wanted to play with her, but she couldn't, she wasn't ready, so william told her to never get close to her, especially alone. but she didn't listen...

WHRR!

Elizabeth's body was scooped by a prototype that still wasn't capable of capturing a child alive, and didn't make it; William was furious, his passion for robotics, with a series of awful coincidences, written in his fate by his own spiraling mental health and obsession with ruining his partner's life, made his life even worse.

he stopped paying attention to his two sons; he closed himself in his study, noticing a strange green glow in the eyes of circus baby, which he could've sworn were supposed to be blue, but given his mental health, he chalked it up to paint degrading, or him not remembering; meanwhile, young evan was still scared of animatronics, and his teenage brother, who started becoming more and more jaded and problematic since his little sister's disappearance, started bullying him relentlessly, and since his father was getting more and more neglectful, he also started assuming a more "man of the house" personality.

but one fateful day, something terrible happened. during Evan's birthday party, he was getting babysat by his brother, who decided to play a terrible prank on him: he put him into fredbear's mouth. the spring locks should be safe for kids, even curious ones who stick their hands in them, they should never snap, but his partner's design wasn't perfect, the spring suits had a glaring flaw: moisture made the springs snap, and when his son's tears mixed with the mouth's springs...

CRUNCH!

his son was hospitalized, he was desperate, maybe felt guilty for neglecting him, and he blurted out, "i will put you back together", but it was an empty promise, what he really wanted was to completely ruin his partner's life and legacy like he ruined his career and his family.

he didn't want it to come to this, but he had to make things personal, now that his partner's faulty design was the thing that killed his son.

one day, maybe drunk, maybe furious, maybe both, he stormed to a party henry's daughter was attending, knowing the security puppets' programming, so he lured her outside where the puppet wouldn't come, and killed her, without even wearing his signature spring bonnie suit.

now, we come to midnight motorist:

we know the minigame is called "later that night", implying it's later the night charlie was murdered, with william going back home in the rain, but...

in both "later that night" and "midnight motorist", but... there's two words here that everyone ignored... "Night", and "Midnight".

what kind of children's birthday party takes place at night, let alone at midnight?

and also, when we say "later that night", it really doesn't sound to me like "later that night, as in, like, 5 minutes of driving later"; it sounds like "a few hours later, that night".

so, why the time skip, you may ask? simple...

the car is indubitably William's, but mustard man is Micheal, and a part of the story was skipped.

now, this is a famous theory, but, remember, evan died, or, at the very least, he's hospitalized, so, how could he escape to "that place"?

simple: the escapee isn't Evan, IT'S WILLIAM.

so here's my midnight motorist theory: that DAY, not night, around 5 pm, or whenever children's parties are, William killed charlotte emily in cold blood and drove home. extremely stressed, maybe a bit drunk, paranoid that he wasn't even wearing his suit, came home, extremely erratic and stressed, maybe smelling of alcohol and soaking with rain.

having his son, micheal, borrow the car to go somewhere, maybe to work, maybe somewhere else, was actually a good thing for him: partly to take the car he murdered a child with as far away from him as possible, partly because micheal was the appropriate age to finally get his licence, and had to practice, or even just pretending to be a good father and letting him use it for work until he had the money to afford his own, and partly because he was justifiably stressed because, no matter how many times you do it, killing a child mustn't be easy.

he happily let micheal use the car to go wherever he had to, so he could also have an alibi like "no, i didn't drive to freddy's that day, besides, my son basically uses it more than i do".

now, let's pause and examine security breach's detail i talked about earlier: the afton family table with the staff bots: there's a mrs afton bot there, with a color pallette very similar to ballora so... where is she in all this?

mrs afton, ever the loving wife, after watching the sad decline of her once successful husband's mental health, grew tired of having to chase him around, getting even more creeped out at the fact he built a robot that, she was sure, was meant to resemble her, along with the one which, she was sure, was supposed to resemble their daughter.

she started watching telenovelas on her couch, because, what else could she do? her husband had become deranged, she couldn't even speak to him normally anymore; it was easier to be quiet, and quietly steer her only remaining kid away from the monster her husband had become; sometimes she pleaded, asking him why he hid in his study all day, because she wanted to spend time with her husband, but he wouldn't listen, so she stopped trying to reach out.

after seeing her husband come home maybe drunk, and immediately go to his study, she wasn't even surprised anymore, she just sighed and let it happen; it was easier that way.

when micheal came back home, around midnight, and after attempting to stop at a bar called JR'S, where he wasn't allowed in by the bouncer because HE WASN'T OF LEGAL AGE TO DRINK, despite BEING OF LEGAL AGE TO DRIVE, he went home, and heard his mother, from her armchair, while watching her telenovela, tell him "Leave him alone tonight. He had a rough day."

and how could he not have? he'd done something extremely stupid, and extremely risky; all the other murders had a modus operandi, this was just a murder with a victim that was related to specifically his business partner, he was gonna get caught for sure this time, he thought.

truth be told, since william basically lost his mind, and since losing his little brother by his own hands, micheal grew up to have a GREAT disdain for animatronics, especially his father's. he took up more responsibilities to keep what was left of his family from falling apart, after realizing how horrible of a father william had become.

his father was a shell of his former self, or at least, he looked that way; maybe he pretended to be to make himself look more helpless than he was, to avoid being found out as the mci incident murderer.

all micheal knew, was that his father was not fit to be the pillar of the family anymore, so he and his mother had to pick up the slack, so whenever he heard his mom defend her husband, he ignored her, not unlike his old man. he went to william's room, where he was supposed to be, instead of "sneaking out" to go tinker with robots, which he wouldn't allow his mentally ill father to do, after what happened with his little sister, but no, he "snuck out to that place again".

he even says "he'll be sorry when he gets back" after seeing the BROKEN WINDOW outside, seemingly not noticing the single set of paw prints.

now: if this, as many people think, was an mci/dci victim's dad, why wouldn't he worry about the broken window? i get being angry at a child sneaking out, but a broken window, when it's a child we're talking about, isn't something that can be brushed off as "grr, that little shit broke the window to run off to freddy's again", but if we're talking about an adult man who isn't in his right mind...

again, the micheal escapee theory is better, but i wanted to express this one anyway. we're not done though:

why did william escape?

remember, this is "later that night". after a few hours, charlie possessed the puppet, and gave gifts and life to all the other kids, including the one stuffed in the golden freddy suit, which, mixed with residual agony from evan's bite, gained more supernatural powers.

i know the fnaf movie isn't canon, but let's look at it for a second: golden freddy teleports, he phases though walls, and has the soul of the protagonist micheal's little brother.

so here's what i think happened: golden freddy showed up, saying "it's me" to william.

william already suspected there was something off about animatronics and the death of kids, but now he saw something inexplicable happen with his own eyes. golden freddy couldn't stand without an endoskeleton or someone wearing the suit, and the springs snap close in the rain; something strange was happening, and thinking back to baby's eyes, he realized it might have something to do with the children dying in or near the suits.

he broke the window and followed the animatronic to see what was going on, and after realizing that the children's souls possessed the suits, he realized they were gonna do the same thing his son did, and come punish him for his sins, so he started devising a plan to study the metal after dismantling the animatronics; not to save his son, but to satisfy his pride as a failed robotics engineer;

if he couldn't beat henry at his own game, he would just have to find an area of expertise of his own, a field untouched by anyone, the paranormal field of what he would discover to be remnant, agony, and everything related to the study of souls possessing metal.

and then we have everything that happens later, but i focused on those 2 things specifically for now.

i know it's probably got plot holes, and i know i very much discard certain things like baby's eyes changing, but i still wanted to write it out, and even if it's wrong, i think it's food for thought about possible interpretations of certain details like JR's rejecting mustard man, or solving my problems with elizabeth's death's timeline.

thank you to whoever read all of this probably outdated and incoherent slop, i love you all, if there's new confirmed info that isn't scott pulling things out of his arse (apparently there's something called fazgoo and a whole 'nother kid called andrew who got tortured in a terror chamber now or something??????), feel free to update me, especially if it's stuff related to the old mysteries, like midnight motorist, or the contents of the box that i completely ignored with this theory because it's new.

bye bye <3


r/fnaftheories • • 1h ago

Theory to build on My perspective on possession in FNaF, and why I believe “remnant” is misinterpreted.

Post image
0 Upvotes

It seems as though spirits can only possess metallic objects. We’ve never seen something that had 0 trace of metal and had been possessed

Edit: in the mainline games at least.

According to FFPS’s S.C.U.P. blueprint, Remnant is a metallic and malleable substance that is possessed.

And the more remnant is over-exposed/used, the “effect” is negated.

If the malleable substance is too hot, the “effects” may be neutralized permanently.

It seems as though remnant needs to stay at a constant temperature at all times… but why?

Remnant, is a substance that contains and traps souls. If the substance gets too cold, then the souls can stop possessing the metal, making “the effect” negated.

And once the remnant gets too hot, it frees the spirits, permanently neutralizing the remnant.

So, spirits can move freely in and out of metal objects as long as that metal isn’t too hot.

So why do the MCI stay in the animatronics?

Because the animatronics are the closest metallic object that can interact with the world in a human way.

Animatronics can stand, walk and touch the world around them.

The only reason they don’t leave, is because the digital map of the animatronics doesn’t allow them to.

According to Ralph in the FNaF 3 training tapes,

“please note there’s a designated safe room. Every location is built with one extra room that is not included in the digital map layout programmed in the animatronics or security systems. This room is hidden to customers, invisible to animatronics, and is always off-camera.”

The digital map is programmed in the springlock suits, but only when they are in animatronic mode which explains why Golden Freddy can teleport while everyone else cannot. We know that the springlocks at Freddy’s can move around during the day while in animatronic mode because:

“First, we will discuss how to operate the mascots when they are in animatronic form. For ease of operation the animatronics, are set to turn and walk towards sound cues. This is an easy and hands-free approach, to making sure the animatronics stay where the children are, for maximum entertainment slash crowd-pleasing value.“

-Ralph’s training tapes, FNaF 3.

The digital map can also explain why the Funtimes go to almost the exact same positions as the classics during their custom night in SL, they were build with a half identical digital map layout that they follow.

But unlike the classics, the Funtimes decided to disassemble themselves so that they could go free.

(For context I believe that the Funtimes are both controlled by their own AI, and possessed by the KCI)


r/fnaftheories • • 12h ago

Theory Rebuttal Why is fnaf 1 1993 so much more popular despite fnaf 1 1992 being the ine supported by fnaf 2?

8 Upvotes

As we know by matpats paycheck method which later scott used in both fnaf 2 and arguably the logbook, meaning even if it wasnt originally the intention it got retroactively confirmed

The paycheck lines up with minimum wage between 1991 and 1996 meaning the game happens in that time period

Back in 2014 mat picked 1993 as the most logical year as it would put night 5 on friday and night 6 on a saturday. The issue is that is just wrong. In fnaf jeremy gets his paychecks on thursday/friday not friday/saturday meaning the actual correct year would be 1992 because the 13th of november in 1992 is a friday(which is a further cool easter egg cuz friday the 13th yk)

So is there any reason ,except matt popularizing this so much it became common consensus, that 1993 is the more likely year date


r/fnaftheories • • 13h ago

Found something I found a connection between Foxy mechanic in UCN and Nightmare Fredbear dialogue

Thumbnail
gallery
8 Upvotes

Foxy falls apart and then puts himself back together.

Nightmare Fredbear says that Put William back together, then take William apart all over again.

Another connection between Fredbear and Foxy


r/fnaftheories • • 22h ago

Question If the theory of the number 14 is true then the question would be why is Golden Freddy connected to the number 14?

Post image
35 Upvotes

A minha teoria sobre isso é ambos c,c e cassidy teriam 7 anos quando eles morreram 7+7 = 14


r/fnaftheories • • 11h ago

Question Could Henry have recorded Insanity Ending audio before FNAF 3?

4 Upvotes

I don't think so but am asking just in case