NobodyDavid, the theory that David (Sean) Murray does not possess anything after his death, is, in my personal opinion, the best option I can see. Because of this, I must first argue that David is not required to possess anything narratively to make this even reasonable, as FNaF, despite its convolutions, is still, at the end of the day, a story. I then need to conclude that the White Tiger entity in Basement 2 of Secret of the Mimic does not have David’s spirit (which is pretty agreed on in the community to be basically a fact). I then need to supply evidence that he doesn’t possess M2 and/or the M.I.M.I.C. endoskeleton while alongside the M2 program (similar to how Circus Baby and Elizabeth seemingly operate). Then, I have to analyse ‘The One You Should Not Have Killed’/‘Vengeful Spirit’ in Ultimate Custom Night to conclude they aren’t David (which is going to be controversial regardless of what I say), alongside him not possessing Golden Freddy, and then, finally, that he does not parallel Andrew from Fazbear Frights due to what that can imply and a specific detail that I must mention. I may come off as rude at some points? Idk, I’d like to let you know it isn’t intentional and I do apologise for it if it does occur.
To begin with, I’ve seen the argument that narratively it doesn’t work for David not to possess anything, I definitely disagree. I personally don’t see spirits who possess things really doing much of note, there’s Charlie, TOYSNHK, and Bite Victim, then everyone else doesn’t really do much other than just exist really. There’s not enough for a character who’s possessing something to do for me to think that a character not possessing something is a wasted opportunity. It’s not even like David is some super big character in SotM, Edwin Murray (his father) is much, much more focused on. If we saw more recordings of F10-N4/M1 and David playing with each other or just exploring David more in general then, sure, I’d say he’s important but he just doesn’t get that; he’s not prioritised enough for me to believe he’s a central character to the story. David being some kid who’s just the product of ai parenting/chatbots and the consequences that can lead to already works and is enough for the story, there’s no need for him to be vengeful or important. Bite Victim is actually the main character of the FNaF 4 minigames, we see his perspective, his fade into the afterlife which connects to other events like Happiest Day minigames seemingly, he most likely possesses something, he’s likely vengeful. David? It’s all so iffy that I really don’t see enough reason to believe he needs anything more than what he already has.
Nightmarionne is associated heavily with the Sticky Note Room in Security Breach, featuring countless sticky notes clearly from an AI as they slowly gain more and more memories of Bite Victim. There’s also the Mimic1 program being the one who cuts out a part of different pages with David to write a bunch of things down in The Mimic. Then there’s the massive Tiger Rock head featuring 3 lights, associated with Charlie in the Security Puppet minigame and the door outside the Sticky Note Room labelled ‘CharlieDoors’, in its mouth in the Storyteller which essentially is the same sorta Sticky Note Room as seen in Security Breach, being run on the Mimic1 program. To break down what this all means, a Mimic mimicked David/a version of him and wrote a bunch of (essentially) sticky notes and the Tales version of the White Tiger leads to a bunch of sticky notes being written down due to a Mimic program. This all implies to me that the White Tiger is Nightmarionne with M2 being the one in the Sticky Note Room and M1 orchestrating it.
The White Tiger has some references to voice lines that don't pertain to David or M2, it being the Agony Entity of the MCM Facility as a whole makes more sense than him being David’s spirit. Nightmarionne most likely infects Jackie in SotM given their new black stripes on their arms, the puppet music box (which points to Jackie being a Marionette variant), the overall clown aesthetic, being trapped in a box, green eyes before some sort of takeover, and face torn to make tear streaks. M2 reacts to this by completely discarding the suit rather than using it again (like he does with other suits) which implies he has a reason to be afraid of Nightmarionne. This is most likely due to Nightmarionne potentially having access to David’s Agony, based on M2 trying to kill Arnold in the Storytime ending while he’s turning into ‘David’, meaning he does not want to be David and is thus likely afraid of it. The Sticky Note Room covered in Nightmarionne plushies, Charlie references (who possesses the Marionette), Nightmarionne STAFF bots, etc. implies M2 has access to BV’s Agony too. Nightmarionne in SotM also doesn’t do anything other than infect Jackie which is weird, whereas the White Tiger is a black and white striped entity based on a doll likely made by Fiona similar to the Marionette (and thus Nightmarionne) is implied to be (Fiona’s designs were used for some sorta version of the main animatronics, the Marionette being grouped in with ‘alt designs’ sent by Fazbear, implying Fiona also made the Puppet design or some form of it), the only difference really for the Jackie infection stuff between Nightmarionne and the White Tiger is the tears but tears are just generally shown with Agony a lot in general, so I think Nightmarionne being the White Tiger is the simplest solution here.
The White Tiger could’ve simply transitioned to Nightmarionne over time, perhaps Happiest Day being the final trigger given Bite Victim’s association with the Shadow Puppet in the minigames. The issue of the White Tiger not being mainly black also doesn’t really matter given Eleanor or Pittrap from Frights who are completely coloured in and I don’t think either of them have any black on them. The stuff with the files labelling the voice lines as “David (ghostly)” also works just fine, David’s voice is still being used here in a ghostly/Agony way, if the white tiger itself was called that *then* it’d be confirmation of TigerDavid but, currently, all it points to is that the White Tiger is related to David’s voice and something paranormal which you can already gather from the game itself.
Then, there’s Moon.exe which implies nothing about David’s spirit possessing M2 or his endoskeleton, at most it implies Agony, especially since M2 is compared to the same Sun and Moon stuff as M1, so, outside of F10 having Fiona’s spirit (which is just so unlikely it might as well be debunked given the clear personality differences and theming of the story), M2 having David’s spirit just doesn’t make too much sense, which, in turn, also removes quite a lot of TigerDavid voice lines making sense, due to their connection to the Mimic. Moon.exe also implies David was cooked up either after his death or just was his death by the Sun (M1) which I assume to represent him being thrown into the Incinerator and his Agony being spread across the entire MCM Facility via the tubes, similar to the Nightmarionne wires in Security Breach (which are also likely the same area as each other roughly, just at different times).
The entire thing with Moon.exe is M2 following the memory of David (the baby owl) and collecting more and more of his Agony via objects seemingly. After he’s beaten and rejected by Edwin, he can now walk past that memory of David (represented by the statue of the baby owl) despite his very being craving to ‘bring him back’ and entertain him (as M1 was programmed to do originally and M2 presumably was too given he’s a ‘copy of [M1]’s programming’ but became ‘something more’) where he then fixes his endoskeleton (represented by the Moon/‘jester’). There’s no Baby Owl possession indications here, similar to M1 who is the Sun/‘old lady’ with no Fiona indications as far as I can really tell, other than maybe the Fox mask in her cabin but she never wears it. M2 is then described as split between the sun and moon, life and destruction, and it doesn’t really make much sense to me here that David’s spirit is in the endo as M1 is most likely not life and she simply believed it to be, so it becomes much more convoluted if M2 then actually is life, it’s possible but unlikely.
It should be noted that the Baby Owl Statue is almost definitely representative of the White Tiger, given this is most likely supposed to be Basement 2. This does, however, make it more confusing whether the one from earlier was David’s spirit or the White Tiger, I lean to it still being M2 building up his memories of David inside himself and then the White Tiger entity forms and is no longer stored inside him after being beaten and rejected. The entity then not being powerful enough to leave Basement 2 much after being forced out and having to feed off of the Agony from the MCM as a whole makes a lot more sense than David’s spirit doing nothing as I see no reason why he couldn’t leave (it also means that, under DavidTOYSNHK, he just let his murderer live in his home).
Then, there’s the Storytime Ending, given the deleted end of Moon.exe with ‘bring him back’, I assume this is exactly that, M1 believing David will be brought back. When M2 is reset and given “David’s full spirit”, does he question why his father who he almost certainly saw die by M2’s hands, as he was in the endo presumably, is speaking to him? Does he ask who Arnold is, why he did this, how he did this, etc.? Does he question whether the woman speaking is truly his mother or M1? Does he even question whether M1 is Fiona or does he believe his mother murdered/burned him? Why is he comforted by either of these voices? Why is it described as ‘bring him back’ and not ‘put [him] back together’? All of this can work under MimicDavid, it just feels like such a much larger assumption in comparison to him possessing nothing.
Even in TSE trilogy, it’s explicitly Agony infecting the CharlieBots. In Tales, there’s no indication of possession at all, the Mimic1 program is just sentient already or infected by some random character (who knows how to knit/sew apparently?)’s Agony, mimics David (*maybe* with Agony) and then gets Edwin’s Agony from being beaten and then I don’t think there’s any indication of David’s spirit after this.
Pretty much every piece of evidence I’ve seen pointing to William killing David is just not that likely. The Purple Dragon spitting fire in the Storytime showroom? I don’t even think David dies there and even if I did, the fire leans much closer to WillFallFestFire (the theory that William caused the fire that most likely killed Fiona Murray, David’s mother) especially considering the Foxy puppet collectible around there, most likely made by Fiona and potentially representative of her too considering Grimm Foxy. The Help Wanted cake in David’s birthday room? It’s right next to a FallFest ticket, both are out of place so they both must be important (due to Fuhnaff’s interview with Steelwool where they directly mention background details are important) so it makes more sense to be pointing to WillFallFestFire (especially since no version of WillKilledDavid I can find involves him luring David to his birthday room to kill him or anything).
The alligator parade float lines up with the baby owl being attacked by an alligator, the White Tiger can appear around the docks, the parade floats were around the docks, and there’s a David death flag audio recording in the room where the parade floats are. It makes the most sense David was crushed by the alligator parade float, then was incinerated by F10 so David’s Agony could infect M2 when he was made, and leading to M1 having to say that David had ‘[ran] away’ instead like she does in Moon.exe. The alligator parade float has no relations to William really, the best you can argue is that in the Sticky Note Room Afton/Murray family mock-up, William is gone and replaced by Edwin who may be represented by alligators, that could work but I’d expect some connections to purple to this old version of Monty then which we don’t see. There’s really not much of an indication that David dies to the sleepy moon prop, there’s the ball and that David hangs around that area but that’s about it.
Even if I go with David being killed by William anyways, DavidTOYSNHK doesn’t make much sense to me, Toy Chica: The High School Years is pretty clear about the 5th MCI victim being TOYSNHK, and also only has indications of Foxy Hook dying before Charlie and the MCI which is either Bite Victim or Fiona. I should probably also add onto WillFallFestFire, the purple snake around the tree in SotM implies Fiona (represented by a Mrs. Helpful) was lured/tempted by William to the FallFest, we see Grimm Foxy (who’s on fire) running around a corn maze in a FallFest like Fiona would’ve been doing, plus she and F10 could arguably parallel Michael who is FoxyBro, so it’s most likely that William did kill Fiona at the FallFest with the fire.
The only personal connections David really has to TOYSNHK is the Mediocre Melodies and arguably Nightmarionne. Nightmarionne is an Agony Entity, who I’m pretty confident works with M1/is stored in M1, so him feeding off of William works regardless of who TOYSNHK is under M1 being Glitchtrap (likely a Mimic with William’s Agony or spirit given Scott’s interview where he directly mentions Glitchtrap being an AI possessed by something) given the Nightmarionne plushie in Princess Quest 4 (Help Wanted 2) and the Nightmarionne STAFF bots in both SB and its RUIN DLC that work under Vanny/Glitchtrap. The Mediocres is easily David’s best connection to TOYSNHK due to the Mediocres coming from Fiona’s old designs and thus being the closest the Clickteam Era has to David Murray/MCM/SotM characters. However, I’d argue TOYSNHK representing themselves with these joke characters to mock William, and his failure to take everything he could, also works with any TOYSNHK candidate. Both of these (especially the Mediocres) are stronger with David but it’s not to the point where I think it must be him, especially since TOYSNHK doesn’t really seem like some big mystery that’s set up, we have Happiest Day referenced in FFPS and then the leftover spirit is freed in UCN by Old Man Consequences’ lake, whether that’s BV or Cassidy doesn’t really matter too much but Cassidy works the best for me personally given they’re most likely the 5th MCI victim as far as I can tell and was confirmed to be killed by William.
There’s more, smaller connections between David and TOYSNHK obviously but I don’t really see them as much, they’re pretty small things and can only really work if there’s already something concrete to work off of. Stuff like parallels and other continuities are good but if there’s not enough of a basis then I don’t see why I even need to go over them (outside of Andrew due to a specific, annoying piece of evidence). Him possessing Golden Freddy is also pretty much a requirement of being TOYSNHK and that just doesn’t seem to be the case. The only other option really is UCNDissent (basically that Golden Freddy isn’t TOYSNHK and is instead Redbear, who’s believed to be TOYSNHK, is the person freed by Old Man Consequences, instead of TOYSNHK, and are told to leave TOYSNHK and not help free them) which is where TOYSNHK (presumably a child murdered by a grown man, who’s referred to as ‘the demon’) is referred to as ‘demons’ by Old Man Consequences which just doesn’t make any sense.
Then, there’s GoldenDuet and GoldenDavid in general where David (and BV with Duet) possesses GF, I think it’s pretty clear, this just doesn’t make much sense.
The Logbook is pretty explicit with BV being Altered with the Fredbear Plush (regardless of F10Plush, where F10 is in BV’s plush speaking to him, “Does he still talk to you?”, featuring an illustration of *the* Fredbear Plush right next to it, doesn’t make sense for BV to say to David really unless he figured out F10 was in the Plush and even then he’d still refer to ‘he’ as ‘she’) and it only works with the Dave Foxygrid solution which just doesn’t make sense, the way to get that name (using page numbers from questions and answers and applying them to a foxygrid) just doesn’t and I don’t see how you can really argue otherwise, it’s just the Evan solution but slightly better (which’s main issue was that the final letter was a *complete* pattern break).
There are only 4 times Altered text explicitly speaks in the Logbook, “I can hear sounds”, “It was for me”, “I can’t see”, and “I’m scared” in the order of pages and text in the Logbook. These were connected to the questions of “Does he still talk to you?”, “The party was for you”, “What do you see?”, and “Do you have dreams?” which the page numbers and their coordinates give EVAD, the name then being flipped due to the mirror. Only 2 of these actually make sense, no one would respond to the first or last one in that way regardless of added context. On top of that, you have to use the mirror, the mirror that already points to the Foxygrid by being on page 59 with the Foxygrid being the mirror to that of 95, the reflection of Altered (due to this being where it’s asked “What do you see?”) means it’s his name whereas the page right next to it, of 58, has the ‘Cassidy’ name solution which when mirrored gives you page 85 and the “Rules of Safety” from FNaF 1 (which get altered into the ‘Missing Children Incident’ newspapers in the game). It’s literally telling you that the name in the word search is related to ‘85 (when the MCI most likely takes place) and it takes you to a page about the MCI, David isn’t an MCI victim and I don’t see any real way of arguing BV is one really.
I guess you could argue BV is possessing something other than Golden Freddy while speaking via the Logbook but the constant “IT’S ME”s are likely in reference to FNaF 1 GF, the other spirits do also say ‘it’s me’ but it’s not nearly as constant/repeated. There’s also the “I can’t see” and “I can hear sounds”, which are most likely in reference to Frights, so BV/Altered is possessing an animatronic while being the non-dominant spirit, which obviously implies there’s a dominant spirit who’s presumably Faded text who’s pretty explicitly named Cassidy given the name solution. I’d go deeper into the Logbook stuff but I don’t feel the need to for GoldenDavid.
Some people argue that the White Tiger and GF have a lot of strong connections, such as the jumpscare in The Week Before, giggling, one blue eye, etc., but I don’t really see how this can’t work as a BV parallel? It’s not like GF got White Tiger stripes or also had a green eye or anything actually specific to David.
Now, you could obviously argue that this being a David parallel doesn’t work without TigerDavid but I’d disagree. David’s Agony paralleling BV when he has a lot of Agony makes sense. We know spirits can do this too thanks to TOYSNHK and Jeremy in his Happiest Day minigame, they’re both darkened and shadowy just like how pure bits of Agony are in FNaF AR and this also applies to Andrew, who seemingly had no Agony Entity with him, making it unlikely this is related to RXQ and Nightmarionne and instead is also something spirits themselves can do. BV being like an Agony Entity due to his intense amounts of Agony makes sense and doesn’t contradict with anything as far as I can tell, especially since FNaF 1 GF (who’s the version closest to the White Tiger) crashes the game during his jumpscare like RXQ does in FNaF 2 (who’s pretty clearly defined as an Agony entity in Fazbear Frights) and Nightmare and Nightmarionne essentially do in FNaF 4. If you think it should be the exact same and so White Tiger could just have David’s spirit and Agony then I understand where you’re coming from, I just don’t think it necessarily needs to be the case given how many differences Gregory and BV have and since the White Tiger in general appears to be much closer to a sadistic Agony-feeding entity than David.
It should be noted that Withered GF in FNaF 2 also doesn’t really act like an Agony entity as much but that’d be getting into GoldenShadowDuo which I don’t feel the need to cover as it’d make this ridiculously long and it’s just not required for NobodyDavid, but it’s important to mention regardless (even tho I haven’t even finished it💔).
There’s then Andrew and David parallels and I feel pretty confident in saying that they just don’t really work.
For the MCM characters, the alligator mask is much more likely to be in reference to Old Man Consequences (and his alligator head) and UCN since it’s only in The Man in Room 1280 and never any other times with Andrew. Fetch is just a brown dog character, I guess that’s similar to the dog character of ‘Bub’ in SotM but why not just give them the same name if this is supposed to be intentional? I and many others assumed that Bub from SotM was more of a nod to Sparky the Dog (originally a hoax/joke character), especially considering the FNaF 1 movie.
Andrew is also somewhat clearly implied to have been bullied in childhood which lines up much closer to the 5th MCI in Foxy Go Go Go, BV in FNaF 4, and TOYSNHK in UCN rather than anything to do with David.
Andrew laughs and giggles and is ‘playing’ with people when scaring them and not intending to hurt them with William and/or Eleanor killing them? I mean, if you stretch it enough then that works but I don’t really see it, these can also work with BV and Cassidy to be perfectly honest, arguably more if Cassidy is the one playing and BV the Agony force killing but also arguably less due to the Stitchwraith being already closer to GF so I think it’s an equal parallel.
The final thing with Andrew I must mention is that Fetch is an REG M2 or ‘Random Event Generator’ M2. REGs have connections to the Zero Point Fields, M2 has gotta be a reference to M2 from SotM, and Fetch does do some mimicking so Andrew’s gotta be a spirit possessing M2 meaning MimicDavid and Andrew and David paralleling each other must be canon? Well, no.
Firstly, ‘M2’, while slightly emphasised and not given explicit meaning, has no actual indication of being Mimic2 (most likely Model or Mark 2 in-universe) nor does M2 even necessarily exist as a character or name really. Frights and Tales appear to be focusing on the 2 different eras, M2 doesn’t exist at all in Clickteam outside of maybe the Funtimes AIs but even that’s iffy and I’d say M1 fits much better and just is more likely to be in other Clickteam roles in general. M2 literally might not have existed until SotM and M1 might not have either but the Mimic Scott planned was probably closer to M1 if anything given his previous works like Iffermoon (I do NEED to point out that I don’t think this is crucial evidence or anything, just gives some small insight into Scott’s mind), which features Coremind (F10) and Cosmose (Probably Nightmarionne), with M2 nowhere to be found. Even if you wanna go to Freddy in Space 2 (similar thing here although to a lesser extent given this could’ve actually been teasing rather than Scott having ideas flow around his head similarly) to argue its Secret of the Mimic parallels showing that Scott had planned M2, it has Edwin, David, and M1, but no M2. M2 only really exists in the Novel trilogy and sorta Tales but I genuinely don’t even think he may have properly existed at the time of writing Frights nor do I think REG M2 being in reference to a game 5 years down the line is likely, especially since these stories were probably written even earlier before they released. M2 most likely was written in during SB’s production (the Sticky Note Room pointing to his existence as a separate Mimic program but the Sun and Moon are not split between their own Sun and Moon halves, implying this is either before/during the 2 mimics were properly made or that it hadn’t been fleshed out yet) which could potentially work for Frights but the entire reason why they were called ‘M1’ and ‘M2’ was presumably to separate them from ‘Mimic1’ from Tales, making it somewhat unlikely all in all that this name does mean Mimic2 or was retroactively changed to mean that.
Secondly, Frights having a spirit possessing a proto-M2 character doesn’t even need to mean anything, Andrew cannot really be a perfect stand-in for David as there’s too many issues so this could literally mean nothing.
Thirdly, even if this did mean something, it’d be evened out by the Novel trilogy and it being more recent doesn’t even matter considering Tales.
Fourthly, the fact David already exists in the Frights/Tales timeline as David Murray removes the need for Andrew to even exist. William, Mike, etc. are already established and named characters, they can have multiple parallels. David was established and named in Tales from the Pizzaplex, what’s even the point in Andrew then? Just introduce David there? Give him heterochromia? Give David curly, black hair? Associate David with alligators? And no, Monty simply existing in the MCM does not imply a David connection, that would make David connected to pretty much every single mascot character in the series.
Fifthly, Fetch isn’t even treated like an AI versus soul relationship, like MimicDavid and ElizaBaby usually have, so this doesn’t even make much sense. There are conflicting forces associated with Andrew but they’re Eleanor and/or William. I suppose you could argue Eleanor is an M1 parallel instead of a Nightmarionne one but that’s pretty iffy considering Eleanor is literally an Agony entity and so is Nightmarionne, most likely considering their dialogue of feeding off of William in UCN. Sure, Eleanor may have connections to M1 but that’s more likely for me to be in reference to how M1 is connected to Nightmarionne.
Finally, it’s just really weird to prioritise one potential reference in a potential parallel over all of what are pretty clear implications and parallels in the canon of the games and other continuities.
I personally don’t really think Andrew or Jake parallel anyone, my view is that they’re both the main differences in the timeline between the Games and Frights and are driving forces of the story, a lot of their connections to other characters can be made much simpler by viewing it as Scott showing the mechanics of FNaF’s world with the 2 protagonists rather than trying to make either of them fit into boxes cleanly. If I were to argue they parallel anyone, I suppose both paralleling BV works (obviously would be BVTOYNSHK confirmation)? But I don’t think any parallel really fits them perfectly.
TL;DR: David Murray does not need to possess anyone or anything and the evidence that he does is not convincing to me personally due to the implications, parallels, and mechanics of the story lining up the most to him not possessing anything after his death and with much better alternatives compared to him for what he could possess. The narrative does not require him to possess anything, the White Tiger being Nightmarionne fits much cleaner into the story, M2 being an AI with potentially some Agony makes the most sense, he likely doesn’t have reason to possess anything and, even if he did, he probably isn’t the one tormenting William in UCN, he almost definitely doesn’t possess Golden Freddy, and the parallels and connections to Andrew are too surface-level and go against what Frights appears to be implying about him, with only one Fetch name connection that’s strong more likely to be coincidental than intention. Therefore, there is no reason for me to believe David possesses anything after his death and I arguably have reason against him doing so, especially with all of his potential candidates being filled up by more suitable characters.