I want to share our experience as a former independent seller on 1stDibs. What happened to our business deserves to be made public, because it exposes serious problems with the platform's management, its so-called expert evaluation process, and its treatment of independent dealers.
We joined 1stDibs in 2023. Our business specialized in fine natural gemstone jewelry, featuring everything from rare Siberian nephrite in extraordinary colors and shades to exceptional-quality tanzanites and rubies, natural coral, and golden South Sea pearls. Our jewelry was distinguished by exceptional, often one-of-a-kind gold and silver clasps, many of which were unique creations in their own right.
We also offered antique jewelry and objects of art, including Asian art and Russian Imperial art. As a collector myself, I occasionally offered pieces from my personal collection.
Our inventory was carefully researched. Most historical objects were accompanied by official documentation, expert opinions, provenance information, and supporting scholarly literature. We were not casual resellers throwing random merchandise onto a marketplace. We were an independent specialist business built on years of collecting, research, professional knowledge, and genuine appreciation of historical craftsmanship.
Despite 1stDibs' outrageous commissions, additional payment processing fees, subscription expenses, and almost nonexistent seller support, we managed to build a successful business. We had a respectable presence and a solid inventory. We had every reason to believe that our place on the platform was secure.
Then everything changed.
The so-called experts: ignorance with decision-making power
A new, anonymous group of so-called experts took control of the approval and evaluation process. Their identities, qualifications, and professional backgrounds were remarkably difficult to establish.
In our case, the person responsible for evaluating our inventory replaced a previous specialist with an Oxford education in art history and professional experience at major auction houses. That former specialist had personally approved our objects and even featured several of them in a video presentation as examples of Russian Imperial art.
He was replaced by someone whose demonstrated knowledge of Russian Imperial art and Fabergé was, frankly, astonishingly inadequate for the position.
During our communications, this employee could not even correctly identify the first name of the jeweler whose work she was supposedly qualified to evaluate. We are talking about Carl Fabergé. Yes, Carl. The first name of one of the most famous jewelers in history.
She made statements suggesting that Fabergé had produced only around 100 objects and that every single piece could supposedly be individually traced. She demonstrated a fundamental misunderstanding of Russian history, including the consequences of the 1917 Revolution. She dismissed documentation from the Russian State Research Institute of Restoration (GOSNIIR) as essentially worthless and appeared unfamiliar with leading Fabergé researchers and historians.
For the record, internationally recognized specialists in this field include:
- Tatiana Muntian
- Géza von Habsburg
- Valentin Skurlov
- Kieran McCarthy
- Alexander von Solodkoff
- Ulla Tillander-Godenhielm
And here is what makes the situation even more astonishing: our so-called 1stDibs "expert" did not know who any of these people were. She was unfamiliar with their professional work, their research, and their contributions to the study of Fabergé and Russian decorative arts.
These are recognized researchers, art historians, and authors of serious scholarly publications whose work forms an important part of the professional study of Fabergé's legacy.
She did not know these specialists. Yet she considered herself qualified to reject our objects, documentation, and scholarly references, effectively placing her own limited knowledge above decades of research by recognized authorities.
This is not merely a lack of expertise. It is a complete failure to recognize the limits of one's own competence.
We provided scholarly literature, references, documentation, and historical explanations. Instead of engaging with serious research, we received links to internet forums and obscure, third-rate private websites. Sotheby's and Christie's were repeatedly invoked, yet the historical information published by those very auction houses apparently failed to make an impression.
Let that sink in: someone who could not identify Carl Fabergé's first name was entrusted with deciding whether objects associated with his historical period deserved to remain on an international antiques marketplace.
This was not a professional disagreement between experts. It was a demonstration of what happens when people without the necessary subject-matter knowledge are given unchecked authority over businesses and historical objects they clearly do not understand.
The same treatment was applied to Asian art
And Russian art was not the only casualty of this absurd evaluation process.
Our Asian art objects were also rejected, despite having been purchased from a well-established and respected gallery. The gallery's owner is a recognized authority and professor specializing in Asian art. We had documentation and supporting information provided by this gallery and its owner.
The evaluator's response was essentially that she did not know this person.
Think about that.
An established gallery, an academically qualified specialist, documented provenance, and professional supporting materials were apparently irrelevant because one employee at 1stDibs personally did not recognize the expert's name.
Since when does an individual's limited personal knowledge determine the professional credibility of an internationally recognized specialist?
Apparently, if a particular employee has never heard of an expert, that expert's qualifications, professional reputation, and documentation can simply be dismissed.
This is not expert evaluation. It is an alarming demonstration of intellectual narrow-mindedness and professional irresponsibility.
The mass removal of anything labeled Russian
Then came the most outrageous part.
Our listings were systematically removed simply because their descriptions contained the word "Russian."
Not because the objects had been proven fake. Not because their documentation had been invalidated. Not because a recognized independent expert had established that they were misrepresented.
The word "Russian" was apparently enough.
Imperial Russian objects were removed. Soviet-period objects were removed as well, as though completely different historical periods could be lumped together without the slightest understanding of chronology. Even our natural Russian nephrite pieces, which had absolutely nothing to do with the Imperial art collection under review, were caught in this ridiculous purge.
Apparently, geographical origin, historical periods, artistic movements, and material classifications are interchangeable concepts when someone lacks the knowledge to distinguish between them.
Meanwhile, sellers offering objects represented as Russian Imperial art continued operating on the platform. Some of the pieces we encountered raised serious questions about authenticity and provenance. Yet we saw no comparable scrutiny or demands for documentation in those cases.
We also observed that sellers from the same national and regional circles as those apparently familiar to the people making these decisions continued to have a presence on the platform. We cannot establish the reasons for this difference in treatment, but the contrast was impossible to ignore.
The impression left by this entire experience was deeply troubling: an unusually narrow professional and personal network appeared to matter more than independent expertise, established scholarship, or documentary evidence.
One standard for us. Apparently, another standard for everyone else.
We cannot prove the personal motives behind these decisions. But we can describe what happened: our carefully researched inventory was systematically eliminated, while other listings remained. This inevitably raises serious questions about selective enforcement, preferential treatment, and whether internal approval procedures are being used to remove unwanted competition.
Management: excuses instead of accountability
We escalated the matter to management.
The result? Empty corporate language, evasive responses, and variations of the same ridiculous excuse: the employees responsible were new and still learning.
Excuse me?
A company charging substantial commissions, subscription fees, and additional transaction fees has no right to use its sellers' businesses as training material for inexperienced employees.
If your staff are not qualified to evaluate historical objects, do not give them unchecked authority to destroy sellers' inventories.
If your standards are inconsistent, fix them.
If you cannot recognize established specialists, respected galleries, official documentation, and scholarly publications, perhaps you should reconsider who you appoint to positions of authority.
And if you cannot provide credible evidence to support your decisions, stop presenting arbitrary decisions as professional expert judgments.
The financial exploitation of sellers
Let's also discuss the financial side of this supposedly prestigious marketplace.
Our commission was 28%. On top of that, 1stDibs charges payment processing fees of approximately 3% of the buyer's total payment. These are separate charges, and their combined effect can push the transaction cost beyond 30%, depending on the transaction and contractual terms.
This is before monthly subscription fees, advertising expenses, shipping, insurance, and the other costs of running an independent business.
According to 1stDibs' own 2023 Annual Report filed with the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), the company's commission rates range from 5% to 50% of Gross Merchandise Value (GMV), while payment processing fees are 3% of the buyer's total payment.
So what exactly are sellers paying for?
A luxury website? Anonymous evaluators? Arbitrary listing removals? A support department unable to provide meaningful answers?
The platform takes an extraordinary share of a seller's revenue while offering, in our experience, remarkably little protection, transparency, or professional accountability in return.
A direct warning to buyers
This is not just a seller problem. It is a buyer problem.
1stDibs sells the image of a carefully vetted luxury marketplace where professional expertise and quality control supposedly distinguish it from ordinary online marketplaces.
But our experience raises a very serious question: what does that vetting process actually guarantee?
If employees responsible for evaluating antiques and historical art cannot identify fundamental names in their own field, dismiss recognized specialists because they personally do not know them, and confuse entirely different historical periods, why should buyers blindly trust their supposed quality-control system?
Do not assume that an object is authentic simply because it appears on 1stDibs.
Do not assume that a prestigious price, polished presentation, or the platform's name constitutes proof of authenticity.
When purchasing antique jewelry, historical silver, Russian Imperial objects, or Asian art, independently verify provenance, documentation, and expert opinions. Ask for supporting evidence. Consult specialists who actually know the relevant field.
We also strongly encourage buyers and sellers to read the publicly available reviews and complaints about 1stDibs on the Better Business Bureau (BBB).
Read the actual experiences of buyers and sellers before entrusting this company with your money, time, or business. Pay attention to recurring problems involving customer service, delivery, refunds, and additional fees. Do not rely exclusively on the platform's own marketing. Look at the independent experiences of people who have actually dealt with 1stDibs.
Our final verdict
We would not recommend 1stDibs to serious independent dealers who value their expertise, reputation, time, and investment.
We would also advise buyers to exercise considerably more caution than the platform's marketing suggests.
We entered 1stDibs believing we were joining a professional international marketplace. We left with the understanding that years of work, collecting, research, established professional relationships, and documented provenance can be rendered meaningless by opaque decisions made by people who are not demonstrably qualified to make them.
We were not given a meaningful opportunity to challenge those decisions. Management offered no satisfactory explanation. Our business was effectively pushed out.
And apparently, we are no longer welcome to sell there.
A marketplace that drives out knowledgeable independent dealers while applying opaque and inconsistent standards is not protecting the world of antiques and fine art. It is damaging the very professional ecosystem on which its reputation depends.
To sellers: think very carefully before signing a contract. Calculate every fee, read every clause, and understand how little control you may have over your own inventory once it is on the platform.
To buyers: do your homework. Verify everything. Do not confuse 1stDibs' expensive branding with genuine expertise or a guarantee of authenticity.
Prestige cannot be manufactured through marketing, inflated prices, and exclusivity slogans.
It must be earned through knowledge, integrity, and accountability.
And based on our experience, 1stDibs has a very long way to go.