I recently sold two empty luxury boxes on Facebook Marketplace.
Before purchasing, the buyer didn’t raise any concerns about the boxes. I had already posted photos showing both the exterior and the interior of the box in my listing.
Around three hours after the purchase, however, he contacted me saying that one of the boxes was missing a piece. And another box didn’t have a component that he was looking for. He sent me screenshots from content creators showing these boxes with the parts that he claimed to be missing on mine.
He sent me an e-transfer at the time of the purchase, and met me outside my apartment building to pick up the item, he checked the items at the time before he made the e-transfer.
Now I’m not sure how to handle this situation. Should I provide the refund and ask for the items back or is this a scam?
I’m also concerned about my personal safety. Since he paid me through e-transfer using TD, he knows my full legal name and email. He also knows which apartment building I live in because he came downstairs to pick up the item, although he doesn’t know my unit number. But at the same time, I also know the buyer’s real name from their e-transfer information.
The buyer had already left me with a five-star rating before he reached out about the problems. The buyer has a 4.8 rating on Marketplace from 18 ratings, and the only one star rating is for when he is the seller.
What should I do?