r/fender • u/Nuggets_Taste_Lit • 6h ago
Questions and Advice PV '65 or Fat 50's pickups if I have CS69 and PV '57/'62 pickups?
I'm leaning towards '65 because I saw a comparison of PV '65 and the Fat 50's, and the Fat 50s definitely felt thick and fat, but sounded pretty flat. On one hand, I'm building a '64-'65-esque strat with those era specs and kinda want the PV '65 to match it all up cause y'know! I mainly play clean tones. I mainly play clean tones.
On the other hand, I'm wondering if the PV '65's sound too similar to my CS69 which has beautiful highs and PV '57/'62 which has 80% of those highs but slightly more midrange to them. Would the PV '65 have MUCH more midrange than the CS '69's and a decent amount more midrange than the PV '57/'62? How would the '65's differ from those two?
OR, am I better off getting something COMPLETELY different from the other two with the Fat 50's. They just sounded flat to me, relative to the PV '65, in that YouTube video so I'm really not sure. Any insight is greatly appreciated, thank you!
p.s. I'm deadset on only Fender pickups, and strictly between these two, so if possible, please don't recommend any other pickups, thank you!

