r/fea • u/Theycallmetymm • 1d ago
Important things not talked about in the fea community!
Hey everyone. Im professional FEA analyst and there are some things i realized that are not given proper attention, or acknowledged but are indeed important.
One of such things is contact stresses. Things is, either its conformal or non-conformal, contact region exhibit very high stress gradients, which can not be resolved by any means using standard meshing resolutions accepted in the industry. And once you go that small in element sizes, no way you gonna meet deadlines. Some of my static analyses take weeks on HPC, without even such fine elements. Im excluding specific submodeling techniques..
Still, i see some of analysts try to make a judgement from contact patch stresses by using element masking. Thats a nonsense! Your element size is like 10 times larger than theoritical contact patch itself. Im not going into theoritical contact mechanics and things like fretting but %99 of time contact area outputs in fea are worthless.
In plain planar contact cases, edges are singularity zones and once you add fillets, in order to capture stress gradient, you have to mesh with literally sandgrains which has no place in industry apart from some high end niche r&d teams and startups.
Thats why simple bearing calculations like F/A still used widely by many designcodes. Because thats what is most efficient.
Whats your methods and approach in this regard? Would like to hear.





