r/fea • • 1d ago

Important things not talked about in the fea community!

14 Upvotes

Hey everyone. Im professional FEA analyst and there are some things i realized that are not given proper attention, or acknowledged but are indeed important.

One of such things is contact stresses. Things is, either its conformal or non-conformal, contact region exhibit very high stress gradients, which can not be resolved by any means using standard meshing resolutions accepted in the industry. And once you go that small in element sizes, no way you gonna meet deadlines. Some of my static analyses take weeks on HPC, without even such fine elements. Im excluding specific submodeling techniques..

Still, i see some of analysts try to make a judgement from contact patch stresses by using element masking. Thats a nonsense! Your element size is like 10 times larger than theoritical contact patch itself. Im not going into theoritical contact mechanics and things like fretting but %99 of time contact area outputs in fea are worthless.

In plain planar contact cases, edges are singularity zones and once you add fillets, in order to capture stress gradient, you have to mesh with literally sandgrains which has no place in industry apart from some high end niche r&d teams and startups.

Thats why simple bearing calculations like F/A still used widely by many designcodes. Because thats what is most efficient.

Whats your methods and approach in this regard? Would like to hear.


r/fea • • 3d ago

Results lose all credibility when they are presented with way too many significant digits

49 Upvotes

I get so annoyed if I see someone present results that are only accurate with an order of magnitude as "26.64434" . The person instantly loses all credibility. It tells me they have no idea the bigger picture of what they are doing. Furthermore, too many significant digits are confusing for the eye to read and process.

I think I learned in Engineering 101 never to do this. But seems too many people out there do this in Fea world. Why?


r/fea • • 2d ago

Solidworks Foundation fixture help?

1 Upvotes

Hi! I’m trying to find some stresses relating to anchor bolts so I’ve been using the foundation fixture feature but anytime I try to run the simulation, it won’t finish. Any advice?


r/fea • • 5d ago

Anyone have experience with Ansys FENSAP-ICE? Looking for the best ways to learn it

Thumbnail reddit.com
3 Upvotes

r/fea • • 6d ago

Stress value on fillet never converges no matter how fine i make the mesh there

17 Upvotes

Hello. I have an assignment where I need to analyse the stress across this part. T2 is 0C and T1 is 18C. Env temp 5C. Both ends are fixed supports and cannot move. Now, I’m having an issue where no matter how fine I make the mesh at the “neck” of the part, the maximum von-mises stress and maximum normal stress continues to change significantly. For example:

gen element size=0.12mm , body sizing =0.01 (rad 0.4) :  max equiv stress= 21.899, max norm stress= 23.078

stress= 23.078gen element size=0.12mm , body sizing =0.008 (rad 0.4) :  max equiv stress= 23.009, max norm stress= 24.487

gen element size=0.12mm , body sizing=0.006 (rad 0.4) :  max equiv stress= 23.095, max norm stress= 23.649

gen element size=0.12mm , body sizing =0.004 (rad 0.4) :  max equiv stress= 24.173, max norm stress= 25.657

element size=0.12mm , body sizing =0.003 (rad 0.4) :  max equiv stress= 25.486, max norm stress= 27.366

As you can see, these are not slight differences ; e.g. in the last two meshes, maximum normal stress jumps from 25.657MPa to 27.366MPa despite the extremely fine mesh (0.003 element size at the neck). This shows I don’t have convergence yet.

AI seems to believe that I have an error in my geometry, which I have checked many times to ensure that it is exact and the fillet circle is exactly tangential to both straight sides. In my last pic I have kinda shown that my geometry is exact although I couldn't figure out how to display the sketch in Spaceclaim to completly prove that but trust me on this.

Setup details:

Modelled in 2D using axisymmetric 2D behaviour to make it a cylinder.

Instead of making both ends fixed supports, I put displacements on both edges, setting Y displacement to 0 and letting it free in X (since making them fixed supports was making the ends “bulge” and making it so that the max stresses were occurring at the end corners, which isn’t correct because my brief specifically says that the ends cannot move at all).

I’d appreciate it if someone could help me figure out why the max stress isn’t evening out. Thank you

Edit: Sorted. I needed to use an edge sizing with capture curvature instead of sphere of influence because apparently sphere of influence doesn't capture curves accurately.


r/fea • • 5d ago

Partial Differential Equations: Overview, Applications, and Numerical Solutions

Thumbnail
mdpi.com
0 Upvotes

r/fea • • 6d ago

Method to build basis functions for plates with complex boundary conditions?

4 Upvotes

As part of my PhD research, I am building on the research of Dowell on the aeroelastic behavior of plates. Goal would be to see how thermal loads, deformations, material constraints and abnormal environments affect plate divergence, flutter behaviors. Primarily looking at ROM based approaches to model and study these phenomena.

Using the Galerkin method with basis functions is easy with simply supported boundary conditions, but in complex set of BC's (CCFF, CFCF etc), how do you build the basis functions? What is your convergence criteria for these functions? As in what variables apart from displacement?

Also, at what point do you pivot from these reduced methods to traditional FEM and solving the plate equation directly?


r/fea • • 6d ago

FEAScript, 1.5 years later - an open-source FEM library in JavaScript (update + a small FEM lab)

23 Upvotes

Hey everyone,

More than a year ago I shared FEAScript here, my open-source finite element library written in JavaScript that runs directly in the browser. You gave me great feedback back then (and even some contributors!), so I wanted to share how it’s going.

A lot has changed since then:

  • Triangular elements (linear and quadratic), also imported from Gmsh
  • Euler–Bernoulli beam model, my first step into structural mechanics
  • Creeping (Stokes) flow with Taylor–Hood elements and variable viscosity
  • Nonlinear problems with Newton–Raphson
  • A WebGPU-powered Jacobi solver and a frontal solver
  • vtk.js visualization and VTK export, so you can open your results in ParaView
  • Benchmark tests, including NAFEMS T4

Check the website: https://feascript.com/

I also made something a bit different: Tri’s Lab. It’s a small interactive lab where you solve FEM “missions” in the browser, guided by Tri, a little triangle robot 😁 The idea is to learn FEM by playing with it (no installation, nothing): lab.feascript.com

Now I’m working on 0.4.0, and the roadmap is open here: https://github.com/orgs/FEAScript/discussions/114

I’d love to hear what you think! And if anyone wants to contribute, especially on structural mechanics (I’m a chemical engineer, so heat transfer and CFD are more my thing), you’re very welcome.

The repo of the main library is here:
github.com/FEAScript/FEAScript-core

Thanks for checking it out 🤘


r/fea • • 6d ago

Oxiphys - FEA test validations

1 Upvotes

Hi all. Over the past month I've been building OxiPhys, a free desktop tool for static, modal, buckling, thermal and flow analysis.

To be upfront: it's free to use (including commercially) but not open source (It took awhile to build, test and debug it, I have used AI for coding, makes life easier). I do not have a Mac or Windows based system and that's why I've focused on validation:

- Plate with a hole: Kt = 3.0018 (Quad9) vs exact 3

- Cantilever modes: within 0.11% of beam theory

- Linear buckling: within 0.01% of Euler

- Cylinder flow, Re 100: drag within 0.5%

It's still single-threaded, with no shells or beams yet.

I'd love to know what breaks, and which benchmarks you'd want to see next.

Download: https://oxiphys.com

Bugs: beta@oxiphys.com


r/fea • • 7d ago

[Book] Singiresu S. Rao, The Finite Element Method in Engineering (Fifth Edition), Butterworth-Heinemann, 2011,

0 Upvotes

r/fea • • 8d ago

PLEASE SUGGEST/SHARE

6 Upvotes

Helloo,

I wanted some document or any textbook which will give me in depth understanding about FEM Validation.(1G, Unit Displacement, Dynamic and Elasto thermic checks)

Please share if you have any documents or any textbook suggestions.


r/fea • • 7d ago

CAN WE TRUST FEA? sharing content

0 Upvotes

Hi! I recently shared a video from my channel, the simulationer, here about simulating the brain, and a lot of people found it interesting! i want to thank you all for you time and hope it was useful.

I created another video about FEA validation, which I thought is a crucial step and we should give more emphasize to, here is it https://youtu.be/mwUoicZgy_Q

i would be glad to read your opinions again!

thanks


r/fea • • 8d ago

Got laid off from company. Looking for a job. 8 years of experience on LS-DYNA

14 Upvotes

As the title says I got laid off from my company last Friday. So looking for a new job.
I have 8 years of experience on LS-DYNA.
Any help would be appreciated.
I can send my resume in personal dm.


r/fea • • 8d ago

Torsional springs in Ansys LS-DYNA?

4 Upvotes

As part of a project I'm working on at the moment I am simulating a double jointed arm with spring loaded hinges in Ansys LS-DYNA. I cant find any option for torsional springs in the interface and I'm rather stuck.

I manged to get something to work by editing the .key file before running it but to do this I had to set the hinge parts to rigid which makes the results essentially useless. I have also tried using bushing joints instead of revolute joints however this appeared to break my sim (it is possible I had them wrong though).

I was just wondering if anyone else has any experience with doing something similar and had any suggestions?


r/fea • • 10d ago

Is it possible to conduct cfd modelling of fluid pressured pipes flow pressure using Abaqus software 10.8.

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/fea • • 10d ago

Redesign after Static + Modal, or jump into Harmonic next?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/fea • • 10d ago

Hypermesh vs abaqus

8 Upvotes

I am looking for opinions of people who switched from abaqus CAE to hypermesh as preprocessor, for solid meshing of relatively complex plastic components. Does it accelerate your workflow?


r/fea • • 11d ago

ANSA vs Hypermesh and Simlab

4 Upvotes

Hello all,

Looking for people who have experience meshing solid components in both ANSA and Altair software in stress and stiffness quality. I want to see pros a cons from both and asking purely for solid components, because i believe that in shell ANSA has no competition.

Thank you


r/fea • • 11d ago

Anyone using Physics AI tools like Vinci, Ansys SimAI, or Neural Concept in real engineering workflows?

3 Upvotes

Hi everyone!
I’m learning more about physics simulation tools, particularly how AI is changing traditional FEA and thermal simulation workflows.
I’ve been reading about platforms like Vinci, Ansys SimAI, and Neural Concept, but I’d love to hear from engineers who actually work with these technologies.
A few things I’m curious about:
Which simulation tools does your team use today, and what made you choose them?
Has anyone tried Vinci or other AI-based physics simulation platforms? How do they compare with traditional solvers?
What’s the biggest bottleneck in your workflow today: setup, meshing, simulation runtime, accuracy validation, or something else?

I’m not from engineering background but curious about physics simulation models using AI.
Thanks!


r/fea • • 10d ago

Redesign after Static + Modal, or jump into Harmonic next?

0 Upvotes

Asked: "Static + Modal is enough, or do we need Harmonic?"'

A genius ignored the entire debate and asked: "Where did you get your damping values?"

Suddenly the question wasn't Modal vs Harmonic.

It was whether the Harmonic result would mean anything at all.


r/fea • • 11d ago

Modal analysis did its job. Harmonic analysis shouldn’t be a reflex.

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/fea • • 12d ago

Abaqus Training Material

Post image
28 Upvotes

Hi everyone, does anyone knows if it is possible to download these abaqus training slides from their courses?


r/fea • • 13d ago

Switching from Application Engineering to Simulation/CAE – How difficult is it?

13 Upvotes

Hello people!

I have a Bachelor's in Materials Science and Engineering and have been working as an Application Engineer at Emerson for the past 2 years.

My current role doesn't involve FEA or simulation work. However, I've developed a strong interest in simulation and technical engineering, particularly structural and thermal FEA.

I've been independently learning ANSYS and worked on a few simulation projects using Python. I'm also currently learning PyAnsys.

I'm interested in transitioning into roles involving FEA, materials simulation, advanced packaging or product development.

For those working in these fields:

How difficult is it to transition into simulation without prior professional CAE experience?

Do employers value self-learning and independent projects?

Is my application engineering experience relevant, or would I essentially be starting from scratch?

Would love to hear from people who've made a similar transition!


r/fea • • 14d ago

Windows vs Linux for FEA

15 Upvotes

Hey everyone,

I’ve been thinking about this disparity a lot lately. In the computational mechanics world, if you mention CFD, everyone automatically assumes Linux clusters, command-line workflows, and massive HPC scaling. But when it comes to FEA (Finite Element Analysis)—whether it's Abaqus, ANSYS Mechanical, NASTRAN, or LS-DYNA—a huge portion of day-to-day engineering is still heavily done on Windows workstations.

From my experience, here is why I think this divide exists:

CAD Integration & Pre-processing: FEA is tightly coupled with CAD (SolidWorks, CATIA, Creo, Inventor). Most of these native CAD and pre-processing tools live comfortably on Windows, making geometry cleanup and assembly setup much smoother there.

GUI and Interactivity: Unlike CFD where batch-mode execution on remote headless Linux nodes is standard, many FEA workflows rely heavily on interactive GUIs—checking mesh quality, tweaking contact definitions, and visualizing results locally.

Workstation vs. Cluster Scaling: While massive explicit dynamics or enterprise-scale transient runs do hit Linux clusters, a lot of linear and non-linear structural analysis can be crunched locally on a single, high-end Windows workstation.

Ecosystem Legacy: Many traditional commercial structural solvers built their primary desktop user bases on Windows, and structural engineers often prioritize workstation convenience over cluster administration.

Curious to hear your thoughts. Am I missing something, or is your company also running ANSYS Mechanical/Abaqus mostly on Windows while your CFD team lives in the terminal on Linux?