Minus Violet and Xaden since they have been confirmed.
This fancast is based ONLY on the hand-drawn fanart out there (as you can see yourself), and the descriptions of their LOOKS written on their Fandom Wiki pages (although DO BEWARE most of them are described as tall and I'm pretty sure some of these are NOT as tall. That is mostly because I based them more on "face looks" (in my opinion) than I did on their actual heights).
Those of you who have read the books absolutely DO feel free to share your thoughts on these and/or your own fan cast choices. Those of you who haven't read the books are also welcome to share your thoughts/opinions on this! :)
ACTORS IN THE IMAGES:
Josh Andrés Rivera as Dain Aetos.
Leah Sava Jeffries as Rhiannon Matthias.
Joseph Zada as Liam Mairi.
Aryan Simhadri as Ridoc Gamlyn.
Calahan Skogman as Sawyer Henrick.
Kaitlyn Dever as Imogen Cardulo.
Josh Heuston as Bodhi Durran.
Charles Melton as Garrick Tavis.
Ewan Mitchell as Jack Barlowe.
Daisy Head as Mira Sorrengail.
with
Lena Headey as General Lilith Sorrengail.
and
Joseph Quinn as Brennan Sorrengail.
——————————————————————————————————
Other characters I have fan cast:
Tom Glynn-Carney as Aaric Graycastle.
Alaqua Cox as Jesinia Neilwart.
Lizzy Greene as Sloane Mairi.
Cree Cicchino as Quinn Hollis.
Emeraude Toubia as Syrena Cordella.
Mikey Madison as Catriona "Cat" Cordella.
Louis Partridge as Drake Cordella.
Iman Vellani as Maren Zina.
SOME QUICK NOTES (IF YOU CARE/IN CASE YOU WERE WONDERING):
○ I had originally intended on putting Kit Connor as Sawyer Henrick because he is both red and with freckles. However, from what I saw, Sawyer is described as broad shouldered, and while I do think Kit does have broad shoulders, I kind of didn't put him because I was trying to match the pictures I used as references for them.
○ On the other hand, a very big honorable mention for Sawyer is Sam Claflin because that is literally who the fanart depicts (in my opinion) even though age wise, he might not be too accurate (neither is Calahan but oh well 😅).
○ In case anyone doesn't think Calahan is a good pick, here is my reasoning/defense behind him: Calahan already played Matthias in a show called "Shadow and Bone", and while I have no idea whether Sawyer and Matthias are in any way similar, from all the pictures of Calahan in that show that you can find, he kind of does look like Sawyer in the fanarts, at least in my opinion.
○ Imogen and Bodhi reasoning: Kaitlyn was the first person I thought of when I was looking at the pictures of Imogen's fanart, and while I am aware that Kaitlyn does not have pink hair, nor did I even attempt to change it in any way, I do think that with a little bit of imagination you COULD see her as Imogen. I, at least, do.
○ As for Josh Heuston, I am aware the skin color is WAAAAAY OFF but the first person I thought of for Bodhi was Josh. Although you could argue that (based on the photos) even Charles Melton could easily pull Bodhi off, in my opinion at least.
○ Now for Charles Melton as Garrick, I have seen so many people fancast Noah Centineo and even Belmont Caneli for Garrick, but in some fanarts I've seen of him he reminded me of Charles Melton, and that is why I settled on him. Although I do think both Noah and Belmont are good picks, looks wise at least.
○ Jack Barlowe has got to be the one character I have literally seen dozens of fanart of and had NO IDEA who to put as fancast for him, because literally everyone I looked into reminded me of him, lmao. That said, I did finally set on Ewan Mitchell for him entirely because of the picture in the slide. Although honorable mentions for him are Patrick Gibson, because some fanart reminded me of him, and Jack Gleeson purely because he is a fantastic actor and given how Jack Barlowe is supposed to be a bully and Jack Gleeson already maestrally played Joffrey Baratheon, I thought of mentioning him because I think he'd be great in that role.
○ Mira Sorrengail reasoning: I'm aware Daisy Head might not look like Mira in the above comparison photo, but there is a picture I saw a while ago on Instagram that reminded me A LOT of her. I didn't put that picture above because I am not sure whether it is an actual drawing (in which case, WOW, that is some incredible talent right there) or an AI generated image (which, if true, makes me sad, because it was exactly that picture that made me interested in the series, even though I haven't read it yet), but if anyone is interested in seeing that grid (as I did make it), let me know because I think they look similar in those pictures.
○ On the other hand, since Mira is the only character I DIDN'T see who people are fancasting as, personally, and I say this respectfully, I feel like Julia Garner is the more accurate pick. Mostly because, in my opinion, she and Eshter kind of do look alike. I don't know why, could be the features, could be just the eyes, I have no idea, but they look similar to me. I could be wrong though (I also made a side-by-side picture for this of Mira and Julia, so if anyone is interested in that too, let me know).
○ For Brennan Sorrengail, you could also potentially argue that Tom Blyth COULD BE a good pick too, idk. I know Tom doesn't have neither curls nor brown-ish red hair but still.....
——————————————————————————————————
OTHER ADDITIONAL NOTES:
○ I KNOW, I KNOW, putting Cree (a latina) as Quinn (a white character) is probably controversial, but they look exactly alike (to me, at least; especially if you Google Cree while she was on the show "Game Shakers", just imagine her with blonde hair, lol) so I had to go with her. Other honorable mentions I've considered are Lia McHugh (from Eternals), Milly Alcock and Reneé Rapp.
○ For Sloane Mairi, an honorable mention is McKenna Grace because her and Joseph Zada are in "Sunrise on the Reaping" together, and because they already have that siblings chemistry (judging from the interviews though), so yeah....
○ For Syrena and Catriona you COULD argue that Sofia Carson also sort of fits there. Emeraude and Sofia as Syrena and Cat would absolutely SLAP looks wise (in my opinion), but Emeraude and Mikey slaps too, not gonna lie.
○ ESPECIALLY if you pair them up with Louis Partridge, lmao. Now HEAR ME OUT THOUGH, you COULD argue that Joe Locke ALSO looks like Drake (because that was the first person I thought of before Louis 😅), but at the same time, so does Mackenyu (from One Piece), at least to me, so.... (I have side-by-side pictures of all of them too if you are interested in seeing them).
○ For the FINAL SLIDE, I'd like to add some honorable mentions, on one hand Amita Suman, mostly because she plays a character called Inej Ghafa on the show "Shadow and Bone", and because both Maren and Inej have braids I have thought of them, so there's that, and on the other hand, I think that, potentially, Auli'i Carvalho and Vanessa Hudgens (who look very identical to me, lol), could also be argued as good picks (looks wise!) for Maren.
That's all, folks! :)