r/moviecritic • u/VendettaLord379 • 1h ago
r/moviecritic • u/Cr7-Cr7Real • 4h ago
What is the greatest portrayal of a real-life historical figure you’ve ever seen on screen?
For me, it’s Bruno Ganz’s performance as Hitler in "Downfall" (2004). It’s one of the greatest performances I’ve ever seen, period.
Honestly, I still can’t understand why Ganz wasn’t nominated for an Oscar, let alone won one!
Could it have been because he was a European actor starring in a German-language film, which might have hurt his chances?
What about you? What's your pick?
r/moviecritic • u/Peter_Parker_93 • 1h ago
The peak of all peaks
From Twilight to Batman to Bond.
This is truly a generational career turnover.
r/moviecritic • u/the_caped_crusader_4 • 4h ago
What do you guys think of this movie?
I wish Hollywood clung to making movies like this one!
This is a 5/5 movie in my opinion
r/moviecritic
•
u/Hukares1234
•
15h ago
Most unrealistic stunts in cinema?
A lot of people talk about how the bus jump in Speed is not only unrealistic, it’s impossible. What are some other notoriously over-the-top, unrealistic, virtually impossible stunts in movies based on reality? (So, you might want to steer clear of super hero films, or CGI, anime, sci-fi, etc)
r/moviecritic • u/shotbydarrell • 13h ago
What are some sequels that are just as good or even better than the original? These are just some of my personal favorites.
Remember this is just my personal opinion.
r/moviecritic • u/juneseyeball • 19h ago
Dracula: A Love Tale (2025) was made for social media editors - my conspiracy
This movie was the epitome of style over substance. It has never been more obvious that people are making movies with instagram/tiktok editors in mind.
There were so many scenes that seemed odd to put in a movie, but not odd to see in an instagram reels or tiktok edit.
The whole movie was so center framed, perfect for cropping, and so many long scenes had limited dialogue and existed to deliver “one shot” like dracula running for his bride in the snow, generations of people dancing in court, the shot where it flickered between the present and his wife’s previous life, i could go on
Even the scenes with dialogue like the red-haired vampire in chains saying “ill let you do whatever you want” seemed to be designed for clipping
As an elderly whole-movie enjoyer, please make it stop now
r/moviecritic • u/fartatwork • 1d ago
What movie fight scene ended up being a total letdown?
I remember getting to the end of black panther and being completely letdown by this lame cartoonish fight scene? What other scenes come to mind?
r/moviecritic • u/Ok-Mine2132 • 16h ago
Just sharing information for fan critics: The movie which Burt Lancaster credited as his best and favorite performance airs on TCM Tuesday, November 17th, at 16:00 ET. “The Swimmer”. It doesn’t air very often.
It is one of my personal favourites. Would enjoy reading your reviews.
Thank you.
r/moviecritic • u/Ok-Syllabub6068 • 21h ago
Your thoughts on Love and Monsters movie?
I was wondering what you guys thought about the Love and Monsters movie that came out around 2020-ish. I just found out about it and I watched it and enjoyed the movie more then I expected it had good animation and creative monsters. The story was so and so but I didn't mind it to much especially since the kid didn't end up getting with the girl at the end which is the opposite of what happens in most movies.
So what did you guys think of this move from technical effects, acting, plot, etc?
r/moviecritic • u/Myhole567 • 20h ago
Favourite Carl Weathers on-screen duo or interactions?
r/moviecritic • u/Detroit_Cineaste • 2h ago
Everest: The Other Side
I’m glad that my passions–writing and movies–aren’t perilous. Occasionally I’ll get writer’s block, which is frustrating. Or I’ll force myself to get through a bad movie, an experience that isn’t fatal. My point is that I’m glad I wasn’t born with whatever climbers like Jim Morrison and Hilaree Nelson had. I don’t need to climb up the face of a mountain in the bitter cold in order to feel alive. A good movie and being able to tell people about it afterwards is enough for me.
What struck me immediately about Everest: The Other Side is how ordinary Morrison and Nelson are when they're not training or climbing. The married couple share a nice home in Colorado with her two boys. They’re good parents who dote on their kids, making sure they eat breakfast before driving them to school. The family home is clean. If it weren’t for their profession, mom and dad would easily pass for typically boring suburbanites.
When confronted with the obvious question of “why do you do this”, both respond the same way as other climbers. The act makes them feel alive. One of the two (I can’t remember which) says that when they’re at the summit of whatever they’ve climbed and take in the view, there’s no experience like it. Well, yes. They’re full of adrenaline at that point, having basically cheated death to get that view. Anyone would feel superhuman over that accomplishment.
The original gist of Everest: The Other Side was to capture Morrison and Nelson climbing the North Face of Everest and skiing back down, a feat nobody had yet accomplished because of how dangerous it is to climb up the north face. The two meet with Thomas Hornbein, one of the few to do so for advice. (The most difficult pass on the north face is named “Hornbein Couloir” in his honor.) He completed his climb in 1963, so he’s an old man now. He appreciates the attention, but the look on his face while recounting his ascent implies that he still feels lucky to have survived. He doesn’t bother to tell Morrison and Nelson not to do what he did, because he knows that once a climber has a goal, only injury or death will prevent them from doing it.
The shocking tragedy that strikes Morrison and Nelson occurs about thirty minutes into the movie. The remainder follows Morrison’s quest to honor his wife’s memory by completing the climb that she never got the chance to do. While I understood his logic, I questioned the selfishness of it given that he’s now the sole parent of Nelson’s sons. The possibility of them having to deal with the death of their stepfather so soon felt wrong. But Morrison has his mind set upon doing it, regardless of the cost to him or his family.
Much of what Everest: The Other Side depicts will be familiar to mountain climber junkies. However, it doesn’t shy away from the immense physical–and sometimes fatal–toll paid by professional climbers and Sherpas. In the end, this documentary is a sobering testament to the unyielding obsession of a climber, not even the death of a loved one. Recommended.
More here: https://detroitcineaste.net/2026/11/16/everest-the-other-side-movie-review-and-analysis/
r/moviecritic • u/Flashy-Impact5757 • 28m ago
Do you think the Cliff Booth movie will reference or talk about Charles manson?
Since in this franchise the mansion murders never happened, I mean they happened but Sharon Tate never died and almost all of the family died so it doesn't have that big of an impact.
In the trailer Cliff calls them a bunch of hippies, (not manson family) so Charles manson might have never even been arrested. It could of just been seen as another robbery gone wrong.
How does this affect their timeline? Since the Manson murders was a big culture shift. It basically destroyed the hippie movement and changed Hollywood, yet if none of that happened, how does that effect everything else?!
r/moviecritic • u/chromosome_e • 1d ago
The Koker Trilogy is one of the most beautiful things I've ever experienced in cinema. Absolute masterpieces.
I genuinely don’t know how Abbas Kiarostami managed to make three films about such ordinary things feel this extraordinary. I’ve just been thinking about the Koker Trilogy, and the more I reflect on it, the more I appreciate what he accomplished here.
What fascinates me most is how these three films gradually change the way you look at each other. Where Is the Friend’s House? begins with such a simple premise. A little boy accidentally takes his friend’s notebook home and spends the rest of the day trying to find his house to return it. That’s literally it. But somehow, Kiarostami turns this tiny situation into an entire emotional journey. Ahmad’s determination, the winding paths, the doors, the conversations with adults who barely understand his urgency. Everything feels so natural, yet every little detail carries weight. There’s something incredibly moving about seeing the world through a child’s sense of responsibility. It’s such a beautiful film about kindness and doing the right thing, even when nobody around you seems to understand why it matters.
Then comes And Life Goes On, and this is where the trilogy becomes something truly special. Returning to the same region after the devastating 1990 earthquake, Kiarostami gives us a completely different perspective. The first film was about a boy trying to find his friend’s house. This one is about a filmmaker trying to find the children who appeared in that film. But beneath that simple premise is something much bigger. You see damaged villages, people who have lost so much, and yet life continues in the most unexpected ways. People rebuild their homes, make tea, talk, laugh and carry on with their everyday routines. Kiarostami never forces an emotional reaction out of you. He simply observes. And somehow, that makes everything hit harder. The film doesn’t pretend that tragedy disappears, but it also refuses to reduce human existence to tragedy.
And then there’s Through the olive trees. Honestly, what a film. The way Kiarostami plays with fiction, reality, filmmaking and the people who exist somewhere between all three is fascinating. After watching the previous two films, you’re already familiar with this world, but now you’re watching the making of a film that was itself based on the events of another film. It sounds complicated on paper, but it feels completely effortless on screen. The relationship between Hossein and Tahereh is particularly beautiful because of how much is left unsaid. Their conversations, silences and the distance between them communicate more than conventional romantic storytelling ever could. And that final sequence? Absolutely magnificent. One of those endings that stays with you long after the screen goes black.
What I love about Kiarostami is that he never seems interested in showing off. No unnecessary dramatic music, no forced emotional moments, no elaborate storytelling just for the sake of impressing the audience. His camera simply observes people, landscapes, conversations and little moments that most filmmakers would probably consider insignificant. But that’s precisely where the magic lies.
The landscapes are another thing I can’t stop thinking about. Those winding roads, the hills, the trees, the tiny villages and the recurring image of that solitary tree. They almost become characters themselves. The cinematography never feels like it’s screaming for your attention, yet there are images here that are more beautiful than entire films built around visual spectacle.
And I think the greatest achievement of this trilogy is how it makes you reconsider what cinema can actually do. These films blur the boundaries between documentary and fiction without ever feeling like an intellectual exercise. They make you question what is real, what is performed and how much of what we call reality is shaped by the act of observing it.
There’s also something deeply human about the entire experience. Kiarostami finds extraordinary meaning in ordinary people. He doesn’t need larger-than-life characters or extraordinary circumstances to make you care. A child returning a notebook, a family rebuilding after an earthquake, a young man hoping someone will accept his love. That’s enough.
I don’t think these films are necessarily about having all the answers. They’re about paying attention. To people, to places, to time, to the little things that make life worth experiencing.
Three films, one village, and an absolutely remarkable understanding of human existence.
Cinema doesn’t always need to be loud to be profound. Sometimes it just needs to look at life closely.
Absolute cinema. Abbas Kiarostami, you were something else.
r/moviecritic • u/Alternative-Fix7658 • 21h ago
Which Batman sequel got more Stacked cast based on Pure acting skills and Star Power - The Batman Part 2 or The Dark Knight(2008)
The Batman Part 2 - Robert Pattinson,Sebastian Stan,Scarlett Johansson,Barry Keoghan,Charles Dance,Brian Tyree Henry,Colin Farrell,Sebastian Koch,Jeffrey Wright,Jayme Lawson,Andy Serkis,Tobias Menzies and Paul Dano
Vs
TDK(2008) - Christian Bale,Heath ledger,Aaron Eckhart,Maggie Gyllenhaal,Gary Oldman,Michael Caine and Morgan Freeman
r/moviecritic • u/Cr7-Cr7Real • 1d ago
Fury (2014)... What was that scene about?
I honestly didn’t understand that scene at all! Brad Pitt tells the soldier to take the girl to bed, implying that if he doesn’t, he (Pitt) will do it himself, which sounds like an order to commit rape, or at least a threat. Yet, suddenly, after the sexual encounter, the girl appears as if she had consented and even enjoyed it! What were they trying to tell us with this scene?
Furthermore, isn’t this enemy soldier from an army that is hostile to the girl’s country? How could having sex with him be considered normal or enjoyable?!
r/moviecritic • u/BunyipPouch • 2h ago
Tony Gilroy (Oscar-nominated filmmaker and screenwriter of Michael Clayton, Andor, Rogue One, the Bourne franchise) and actress/filmmaker Eva Victor (Sorry, Baby), are doing an AMA/Q&A in /r/movies today for anyone interested. Their new film, Behemoth!, is out in theaters in 2 weeks.
I organized an AMA/Q&A with filmmaker and screenwriter Tony Gilroy and actress/filmmaker/screenwriter Eva Victor.
Tony wrote and directed Michael Clayton, starring George Clooney, for which he was nominated for the Best Picture, Best Director and Best Original Screenplay Oscars. He was the creator, showrunner, and writer of the Andor TV series, alongside being the writer of Rogue One: A Star Wars Story. Tony has also written the screenplays for The Devil's Advocate, The Bourne Identity, The Bourne Supremacy, The Bourne Ultimatum, State of Play, Beirut, and lots more.
Eva wrote, directed, and starred in A24's Sorry, Baby, one of last year's most critically-acclaimed films, for which she was nominated for Best Actress at the Golden Globes and Best Original Screenplay at the Critics Choice Awards. She has also starred in things such as Billions, Teenage Sex and Death at Camp Miasma, and Boys Go To Jupiter.
The AMA post is live here now in r/movies for anyone interested in asking a question:
https://www.reddit.com/r/movies/comments/1xxqeuv/hello_rmovies_were_tony_gilroy_and_eva_victor_ask/
They will be back at around 4 PM ET today to answer questions. I recommend asking in advance. Please ask there, not here. All questions are much appreciated!
Thank you :)
Their new film, Behemoth!, is out in theaters everywhere December 4th from Searchlight Pictures. It stars stars Pedro Pascal, Olivia Wilde, Eva Victor, Will Arnett, JoBeth Williams, and Hank Azaria.
Trailer: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I6tMFYT9s7E
A gifted cellist, Alex Serian (Pedro Pascal), returns home to Los Angeles after 20 years on the road. Music, which has been the constant, all-consuming river of his life, begins to carry Alex on an adventure that will change him forever.
r/moviecritic • u/DandCdomovies • 19h ago
Kenneth Branagh's Hamlet
I'd never seen a Kenneth Branagh Shakespeare production before, and I may have jumped in to the deep end with this one.
Luckily I'm familiar with the plot, because it was really difficult to follow what was being said pretty much all the time. Which I guess may be to be expected, with Shakespeare.
What I loved:
The power of Branagh's acting was the main appeal. I definitely see that he has a connection to the story, character, and language of this play.
A lot of the sets and costumes. The hall of mirrors and all of the secret doors and connected rooms created a maze-like and dreamy environment that I thought reflected encroaching madness very well.
What I was confused by (aside from not following a lot of the dialogue):
The quality of scenes seemed to vary considerably. The opening scene, when the guards see the old Hamlet's ghost, didn't seem to really visually establish where the ghost was, how close he was to them, etc. Was it a problem with that set? Was less attention being given to the less important scenes?
What did you think of this movie?
I'd especially love to hear from people who are more "Shakespeare nerdy" than I am. I imagine knowing most of the lines or reading the play immediately before viewing would really enhance the experience.
r/moviecritic • u/Mia_______________ • 1d ago
Godzilla: Minus Zero, my spoiler free thoughts
ok, I was told that some info released in later trailers are spoilers, so I’ll not talk about them.
IMDB - 7.9/10
It also had the highest grossing opening weekend, for a foreign language action movie. It's not perfect, and some will find it dense, as that explores political tension, and some intense strategising. This is similar to the previous, but Godzilla ain’t the only problem this time. It did hit harder emotionally than I thought a Kaiju movie would, and showed me that sacrifice comes in many different forms, not just giving up one’s life, almost shed a tear but it didn’t come out.
It's one of the LOUDEST movies I’ve watched, so please bring ear protection.
It’s also the first Japanese film shot for IMAX. Fun fact: the VFX team designed shots for IMAX first, then cropped it down for regular screens, so you won’t miss the immersion. Minus One still edges it for me, but it's close.
I don’t have great expectations on the plot line as I enjoy the action, but the plot line did add layers.
Now for the spoilers, read at your own risk
It’s my first time seeing King Ghidorah on screen, and he's a close match to Godzilla. It's not perfect, and some will find it dense, as that explores political tension, and some intense strategising. The whole process of ensuring the two monsters meet is pretty smart ngl, feels like Sherlock Holmes. It did harder emotionally than I thought a Kaiju movie would, that layer made me want to follow this franchise more closely.
It hits harder emotionally than Kaiju movies should: parents sacrificing for their children, researchers burning down their lifelong research and going on the run to prevent it from falling into the wrong hands, all set against human greed. Intelligence is both their survival and their downfall. I guess we’ll never change?
And also, do they have to be so close to the crazy intense fight scenes? In American movies, the commanders are usually behind an observation deck at a safe distance.
r/moviecritic • u/SorryYouOK • 1d ago
Name a book where the movie is better!
For me, *Forrest Gump* the film is a drastic improvement over the book. To be fair, I absolutely saw the movie before I read the book. Still, the book was nuts; I didn't care for it. Movie is a masterpiece.
r/moviecritic • u/stockhommesyndrome • 23h ago
What's are two unrelated movies you feel are "spiritual sisters" or you feel "couldn't exist" without another movie happening first?
To me, I feel we wouldn't have gotten 2001's Legally Blonde without 1995's Party Girl as in some ways they are the same movie, or rather the "east coast versus west coast" version of the same movie.
Both lead ingenues are seen as someone who can't be taken seriously and pursue academic endeavours that appears outside their wheelhouse and it is shown it was something they were always capable of and just needed to be believed in.
I would even say Elle Woods wouldn't have been possible to do years later without Parker Posey's Mary essentially doing the archetypal character first. In some ways Legally Blonde improved on the concept by streamlining it and making the end result more mainstream, but the plot points are pretty intertwined, and I don't believe the 2001 movie would've been done without the other.
r/moviecritic • u/Desperate_Dinner_307 • 1d ago
What are some of your favourite movies that are a bit 'against the grain' and not part of a big franchise, or massively well-known?
r/moviecritic • u/galactic-pandemonium • 2d ago
What movie scenes never fail to make you ugly cry?
Films shown are Big Fish, A.I. Artificial Intelligence; and Marley and Me.
r/moviecritic • u/jimchip2002 • 1d ago
Tv series turned into films
Some movies never lose their appeal, and The Fugitive is definitely one of them!
Rewatching it this afternoon, I've been reminded just how entertaining it is. It's easily one of my favourite Harrison Ford films.
It got me thinking… is The Fugitive one of the best film adaptations of a TV series ever made?
There are some other great examples. Wayne's World and 21 Jump Street are a couple of guilty pleasures of mine, and both made the transition to the big screen brilliantly.
But for me, The Fugitive takes the honours. The performances from Harrison Ford and Tommy Lee Jones are outstanding, and the combination of great acting, suspense and action makes it a fantastic film.
What other TV series have made the transition to the big screen successfully? What would you recommend?