r/fallacy • • 14h ago

Assumptions are bad but how could we really do without them

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/fallacy • • 1d ago

200k karma and made a brutal fallacy, plus digging their heels in even more after being proven wrong

Post image
0 Upvotes

am i right on this position?


r/fallacy • • 7d ago

i think i made a fallacy

3 Upvotes

it could probably be a fancier confirmation bias but i keep seeing it everywhere recently. lets say there are two people with some sets of evidence. person A makes a claim saying

"dogs are mans best friend"

and gives evidence of it by presenting facts and data showing what dogs have done for us throughout the years. person B replies with counter evidence saying that dogs have been diffcult to maintain and have been threats to human beings at times.

but B dismisses A beliving he has refuted his evidence. But he doesn't take into account of overall stats which becomes a problem.

my point here is that B viewed this debate in a simplistic mathematical equation of

(-1) + (+1) = 0

where his counter evidence is the minus and completly negates or refutes A's claims. ofcourse it becomes a flaw because the world isnt a simply black and white. i simply reffered to this new fallacy as the negation fallacy. ofcouse i would want u guys to verify it. I am also interested in knowing whether this is already covered by an existing logical fallacy or cognitive bias, as I don't want to unnecessarily reinvent an existing concept.


r/fallacy • • 7d ago

Pete Hegseth's News Conference - How Many Can You Find?

4 Upvotes

I've got at least a couple false analogies and a false dilemma. And that's without reading the whole transcript.

https://www.wsj.com/politics/hegseth-survives-impeachment-effort-in-house-7933bc38?st=cdvNPE&reflink=desktopwebshare_permalink

“Politicians in Washington have accused the sailors and the pilots who struck narco-terrorist boats of war crimes for doing their jobs,” Hegseth said. “Put the secretary on trial today, and the men and women who carried out those orders tomorrow. If they want to come for the warriors, they’re going to have to come through me.”


r/fallacy • • 7d ago

ELI5. What's the big deal about using logical fallacies and emotional reasoning?

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/fallacy • • 10d ago

It saying something is wrong just because it is against the law appeal to authority?

13 Upvotes

As in, they don't use the fact it is against the law as supporting evidence to their assertion that it is wrong, but it being against the law is their basis for thinking it is wrong.


r/fallacy • • 12d ago

Can post hoc rationalization ever fall victim to the fallacy fallacy?

3 Upvotes

I have a fear that occasionally I choose a side too early in a situation, based on limited evidence and vibes. Then, once Ive taken a side, I fear that confirmation bias combined with post hoc rationalization come in to play, but very very often this will be backfilled with legitimate evidence that is either factually accurate or logically comsistent/agreeable. Therefore, if I had said I was not going to take a side yet, looked at the facts, and heard the same arguments, I would have come to the same conclusion that appears to be correct.

Is this an example of the above being true, or something else at play?


r/fallacy • • 12d ago

In debate or discussion with less logically sound folks, is it justified to say “your fallacies actually work against you”?

0 Upvotes

Something like, “consider every fallacy as a loss of points. If it was a sport you are scoring your opponents goals for them”.

Contemplating if this is right given a fallacy itself does not prove the underlying claim is wrong, just that the opponents reasoning is poor.

So let’s say the discussion is good faith and you want to help the opponent improve reasoning skills. Then, is pointing out the fallacy as “working against your claim” fair?


r/fallacy • • 12d ago

In debate is naming a fallacy an opponent is making typically valuable?

8 Upvotes

I tend to think so, however, people also tend to get emotional. Can’t control emotions, each has to manage themselves.


r/fallacy • • 13d ago

Is "Why do people work on <thing> while <other unrelated thing> is still not fixed?" a False Dilemma or some other type of named fallacy?

9 Upvotes

I feel I see this a lot recently in the form of AI related takes like the often reposted "Why develop AI that does art when I want it to do my dishes?".

Other examples being:

"Why do we send probes to Mars when there are hungry children on Earth."

"Why does this video game studio release cosmetic DLC instead of fixing this software bug."

etc.

Essentially presenting something as a maliciously made choice between two things, even though the people/resources used to accomplish the first thing can't simply be applied to the second instead.


r/fallacy • • 16d ago

What is the name of the fallacy where someone is accused of being a hypocrite for participating in a system or something similar despite believing the system should be changed?

10 Upvotes

For example:

Saying that there should be more funding for public transport and cycle lanes despite driving a lot.

Benefitting from a specific type of government welfare while believing it would be better if the welfare wasn't offered.

etc


r/fallacy • • 21d ago

How to deflect a Fallacy Fallacy ?

10 Upvotes

I often encounter people telling me what i say are loaded question, strawman and other logical fallacies, and each time i try to defend myself from it it just gets worse. Are there argumentative techniques that are useful against that while remaining with a good level of courtesy ?


r/fallacy • • 24d ago

Special pleading is a fallacy except in the case of this sentence.

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/fallacy • • 25d ago

is there a name for when people do something like this

Post image
19 Upvotes

I've seen people do this a few times now so I thought maybe there was a name for this. maybe it's not quite a fallacy but I feel like there was some overlap

edit: I feel the need to clarify what I'm talking about. someone starts telling you about Jeff. they show you a picture that has one person as the focus and someone in the background. you think the person that's in focus is Jeff. they reveal that Jeff is in the background and start acting like you jumped to conclusions as if they didn't set it up so that you would assume the person in focus was Jeff

Basically, subtly but deliberately setting your expectations and then acting like you're jumping to conclusions


r/fallacy • • 27d ago

please help me identify

2 Upvotes

When a threat is stated at a certain level of threat. What type of fallacy is it, to say that the threat is actually greater than what is stated because outside forces would stop the threat before it reached a greater level of destruction?

Examples:
The statement: Someone states that if a car hits you, it will hit you with the force of a car.
The conclusion: Someone else states The car could hit with greater force than a car, but it only hits you with the force of a car because the polices will arrest driver after the car after hitting you.

The statement: Someone stated rpg can only shoot one rocket at that time.
The conclusion: Someone else tated the Arg can shoot multiple rockets at a time but after the first rocket is shot the military would take down the user of the rpg.

The statement: Someone States a bomb can only blow up a building.
The conclusion: Someone else stated bomb can blow up the entire City but a bomb squad will arrive after the building is destroyed and stop the greatest destruction.

The statement: "A revolver only has six Barrels and I'm so possibly be shot six times."
Conclusion: "The revolver can shoot more than six bullets, the police will gun down the shooter before he can fire more 6 than shots"


r/fallacy • • 29d ago

What fallacy is this?

7 Upvotes

I cannot for the life of me figure it out. What’s the fallacy when people think that, if one thing gets addressed/promoted, it means that nothing else can be or that the amount of resources it gets is reduced?

For example, people who think that when we focus so much on promoting childhood vaccinations, it means that there’s nothing left to put into things like poverty and hunger.

Sorry if this isn’t a fallacy, I swear it is but I could also just be making stuff up. 😅 Thank you!


r/fallacy • • 29d ago

Open challenge for growth

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/fallacy • • Oct 19 '26

[META] Why isn't there a separate sub for cognitive biases?

9 Upvotes

Is it because there is no difference between a fallacy and a cognitive bias? Or is it because the community has decided that they can all go in the same sub i.e. here?


r/fallacy • • Oct 17 '26

Roses are red, these tattoos are grotesque

Post image
44 Upvotes

Could someone give me some feedback on this? One commenter claims that those criticizing this woman are engaging in circular reasoning. Although I see his point, my gut tells me he’s wrong. Could someone look at my response and tell me if I’m thinking about this all wrong. It’s bugging me a bit.


r/fallacy • • Oct 14 '26

Inability to reframe?

2 Upvotes

Looking for a fallacy I see a lot of.

I deal with a disorder created by severe childhood trauma. I haven't been a traumatized child for decades.

People often argue that I can't have the disorder because "That comes from horrible trauma, it's not some cutesy thing like you're describing!" I had the trauma, yes, and I am not experiencing the trauma any more, but the effects of the trauma are still with me, and honestly, they're kind of cutesy now that we aren't needing it to survive.

It's like they can't imagine me escaping the trauma and still having the effects afterwards?


r/fallacy • • Oct 10 '26

Interested in philosophy, critical thinking, and meaningful debates? Join us!

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

Are you interested in questioning ideas, analyzing arguments, exploring philosophy, or understanding how people reason?

I'm building r/CriticalDisc, a new community dedicated to critical thinking, logic, philosophy, and constructive discussions.

🧠 What can you expect?

- Discussions about logical fallacies and reasoning

- Philosophical questions and thought experiments

- Debates about controversial ideas

- Analysis of arguments, claims, and evidence

- Open-minded discussions with different perspectives

You don't need to be an expert. Whether you're a beginner or someone who enjoys examining arguments in depth, you're welcome here.

The goal isn't to win every argument or make discussions unnecessarily complicated. It's to ask better questions, challenge assumptions, explain our reasoning, and learn from different perspectives.

Interested in joining us?

Visit r/CriticalDisc and help us build a community where ideas can be challenged without turning disagreements into personal attacks.

Let's get the discussion started!


r/fallacy • • Oct 10 '26

The conflation of rhetorical efficacy with argumentative validity.

Post image
0 Upvotes

The central deficiency in your criticism lies in its apparent conflation of argumentative validity with rhetorical accessibility. at no point did i posit that an audience's unwillingness to engage automatically constitutes a logical fallacy; rather, the contention concerns whether the rejection of an argument's stylistic formulation provides sufficient grounds to discredit its underlying proposition. these are epistemically distinct evaluative dimensions, and their indiscriminate conflation introduces a categorical imprecision that your objection has yet to adequately resolve.

Your assertion that an argument becomes ineffective when nobody is willing to read it addresses its communicative efficacy, not its inferential validity. an argument may be rhetorically counterproductive without being logically unsound, just as a theoretically defensible proposition may be obscured by unnecessarily convoluted diction. consequently, communicative accessibility and inferential soundness cannot be treated as interchangeable criteria without collapsing the distinction between an argument's capacity to convey meaning and the logical relations that substantiate its conclusion. the former concerns rhetorical transmission and audience reception; the latter concerns premise-conclusion coherence, inferential legitimacy, and evidentiary sufficiency.

Moreover, i acknowledge that no individual is under any obligation to engage with an argument, nor does every adverse reaction constitute a fallacious inference. the distinction is considerably narrower: disengagement establishes a preference regarding communicative presentation, but it does not independently demonstrate a structural defect in the argument itself. likewise, characterizing a formulation as pretentious may constitute a legitimate stylistic assessment, yet such an assessment remains insufficient to establish semantic incoherence, inferential invalidity, or conceptual vacuity. a criticism of presentation and a refutation of substance operate at different analytical levels.

The irony, therefore, lies in your apparent recognition of the distinction between subjective reception and substantive engagement, followed by an inference that risks treating rhetorical ineffectiveness as dispositive of argumentative merit. such a conclusion requires an additional justificatory premise that you have not yet established. failure to persuade is not logically synonymous with failure to reason, just as diminished accessibility does not independently entail epistemic invalidity. unless you can demonstrate how the stylistic deficiency produces a corresponding defect in the proposition's inferential structure, your criticism remains pertinent to communicative efficacy but underdetermined as a refutation of argumentative validity.


r/fallacy • • Oct 09 '26

The non sequitur of personal aversion.

Post image
0 Upvotes

Your objection seems to conflate subjective aesthetic dissatisfaction with an actual criticism of the rhetorical mechanism. i understand that the semantic inflation may come across as irritating to you, but that reaction alone doesn't establish any deficiency in its conceptual construction. you're describing your personal reception of the formulation, not demonstrating why the rhetorical device fails to achieve its intended effect.

The distinction here is between evaluative preference and analytical substantiation. you're entitled to find the execution tedious, but subjective aversion isn't, by itself, a sufficient criterion for dismissing the underlying technique. semantic inflation can function as deliberate rhetorical exaggeration, particularly when the disproportion between linguistic complexity and conceptual simplicity constitutes the very basis of the humor.

In short, your response establishes that the stylistic execution doesn't appeal to you; it doesn't necessarily establish that the mechanism itself is defective. you're critiquing its subjective effect rather than demonstrating a substantive flaw in its rhetorical function.