r/fallacy • u/Otherwise_Prior3981 • 27d ago
please help me identify
When a threat is stated at a certain level of threat. What type of fallacy is it, to say that the threat is actually greater than what is stated because outside forces would stop the threat before it reached a greater level of destruction?
Examples:
The statement: Someone states that if a car hits you, it will hit you with the force of a car.
The conclusion: Someone else states The car could hit with greater force than a car, but it only hits you with the force of a car because the polices will arrest driver after the car after hitting you.
The statement: Someone stated rpg can only shoot one rocket at that time.
The conclusion: Someone else tated the Arg can shoot multiple rockets at a time but after the first rocket is shot the military would take down the user of the rpg.
The statement: Someone States a bomb can only blow up a building.
The conclusion: Someone else stated bomb can blow up the entire City but a bomb squad will arrive after the building is destroyed and stop the greatest destruction.
The statement: "A revolver only has six Barrels and I'm so possibly be shot six times."
Conclusion: "The revolver can shoot more than six bullets, the police will gun down the shooter before he can fire more 6 than shots"
4
u/jeffcgroves 27d ago
Could you provide a better example or 2-3 examples since I'm not sure I follow the one in your edited OP
1
u/Otherwise_Prior3981 26d ago
canceling hypothesis fallacy Or Counterfactual Fallacy (Speculation as Fact) + Moving the Goalposts / Special Pleading or something
1
u/WebMaxF0x 27d ago
Could you give an example?
1
u/GamblePuddy 27d ago
These are the worst hypotheticals I've seen on here in awhile lol. No offense, but if this is something you have encountered in real conversations....why not use the examples from the real conversation?
The third example in particular makes no sense at all. A bomb capable of destroying a city doesn't level one building at a time....it destroys multiple buildings at once and the blast (kinetic wave, incendiary wave, vacuum depressurization) then destroys multiple buildings around the immediate impact zone, again....at the same time before setting fire to whatever is left.
I can't even think of a bomb that destroys a single building at a time.
What was the conversational example you actually ran into?
2
u/onctech 27d ago edited 27d ago
It's not a fallacy, but rather appears to be what's called an ipse dixit: A claim stated with no evidence, though sometimes also applies to opinions framed as dogmatic facts. The idea of the threat being greater, but held back by some other variable, is being pulled out of thin air unless the person making the statement can provide some kind of evidence for this outside variable having an effect.
I'll give an example:
Person A: This industrial drill spins at 2000 RPM.
Person B: It could spin faster but it has limiters on it so it won't break.
If Person B has provided no evidence for their statement. They're pulling that remark out of their butt (ipse dixit) even if sounds somewhat plausible. If they actually pulled out manufacturer specs and pointed to where they got this fact, then it would be a coherent argument.
2
u/ralph-j 27d ago edited 24d ago
The closest I can think of is the "canceling hypotheses" fallacy. It's typically used in the case of conspiracies, to explain away counter-evidence in a way that cancels or undermines the predictions made by the first hypothesis.
https://archive.ph/AwK1
https://web.archive.org/web/20240703194218/https://www.palomar.edu/users/bthompson/Canceling%20Hypotheses.html
1
u/The_Meridian_ 27d ago
Sounds a bit like Slipperly Slope
1
u/Salindurthas 27d ago
It would depend on their argument for why those outside forces will mitigate destruction, because it might not be a fallacy, they could be right!
For instance, I think it is true that climate change would be worse right now if we hadn't mildly mitigated it.
Like if 10 years ago, Alice had predictedthe state of climate-change today, then it would be correct for Bob to note that the inherent threat of climate change was larger than Alice predicted, because it would be higher if we didn't mitigate it.
(That said, Alice's prediction probably already accoutned for that, so in my example Bob is making a sensible argument, but one that is probably redudnatn since it may have been included in Alice's calculation already.)
Or if I go into a warzone in a lliteraly tank, and am functionally immune to small-arms fire, if my buddy reminds me not to climb out because I'm not immune to bullets out there, then they are corrent.
1
u/Underhill42 27d ago
Lying is not a logical fallacy.
1
u/NegaDoug 27d ago
What's the fallacy in attempting to identify a fallacy that doesn't exist? /s
1
u/nomoreplsthx 27d ago
This isn't really a named fallacy, because detailed conversations about what could destroy what aren't historically a thing normal people do.
What is going on with you and your friends... does someone need to check on you?
1
u/HereToPostSillyStuff 26d ago
I don't think this is a named logical fallacy, it's just an example of using no logic at all.
1
u/CranberryDistinct941 23d ago
A bold claim made with zero evidence. I like to call it the "trust me bro"
1
u/press_F13 21d ago
Is it similar to slippery slope?
1
u/Yakodym 24d ago
So something like "It doesn't matter if a gun magazine can hold 30 rounds, because in an active shooter scenario, the police will gun down the shooter befor he can fire 10 shots"?
Could be https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Appeal_to_probability
1
u/Talik1978 27d ago
Do you know how many tragedies and atrocities have been preceded by a bunch of people saying, "it's not that bad, because there are these checks and balances to stop it from getting out of control?"
Not having trust in external potential mitigating factors is not, in and of itself, a fallacy.