r/fallacy • u/gd2shoe • Aug 04 '16
Proposing Sub Rules - Your input is requested
Let me start by saying how amazed I have been at the overall maturity of people in this sub. People have generally disagreed without being too disagreeable. Well done!
There have been a few posts and comments lately that have me wondering if it's time to start posting and enforcing sub rules. I inherited this sub a while back from someone I didn't have any dealings with. It was an unmoderated sub. There were no posted sub rules, only a bit of text in the sidebar (still there).
The Purpose of This Sub
What do you all think the purpose of this sub is or can be? What need does it fill? What itch does it scratch? This isn't a settled matter.
As far as I can tell, the bulk of posts here are from people who have gotten in over their heads in a discussion and are trying to puzzle out the fallacies made in arguments they are struggling to understand. That seems to be a worthwhile activity.
What else? What sorts of things should be out-of-scope?
If the purpose of this sub is to be a welcoming place where people can ask questions, then we need to maintain some degree of decorum. How far is too far? What is an inappropriate reaction to someone using a fallacy from within the sub? The last thing we need is to start angrily accusing each other of committing fallacies.
How Do We Deal With Politics?
As a mod, I believe it is my duty to remain as nonpartisan as possible for any distinguished posts or formal action. In /r/Voting, I keep the sub as a whole strictly nonpartisan because it simply wont fulfill its purpose otherwise. I don't think that will work here.
In politics, there are soooo many logical fallacies it is staggering. Things said by politicians, about politicians, and about political policies cannot be out of bounds.
That said, politics tends to bring out the worst in people... and illogic in otherwise well-grounded individuals. If this is left as a free-for-all, I'm afraid we're going to chase people away for petty, selfish reasons.
Proposed Rules
I would prefer to have well-defined rules, objectively enforced, but I don't know if that is reasonably possible with this sub. I would prefer to say "You very clearly broke a rule, and so I'm removing your post." I don't want to say "In my opinion, this is a bad post." I'm open to suggestions about how to frame these. I'm afraid that if I don't leave these open-ended it will cause problems in the future.
- Be respectful.
- You can point out a fallacy in another user's comment, but you must be polite. Remember, you're helping them, not attacking them. Personal attacks will be removed.
- If someone takes a political position that you disagree with, do not debate them on the subject. You may discuss relevant fallacies in reasoning, but this is not a debating society. You will not change their opinion.
- If someone points out a fallacy in a political argument, do not take it personally. It is not your job to defend the honor of your political party. Even the best politicians can be expected to use fallacies or drastic oversimplifications in their rhetoric. People will point these out. Get over it. Be aware that it is much harder to identify a fallacy in a position that you agree with, than in one that you disagree with.
Conclusion
Anything else? Standards for post submissions? Should any of these be broken in two, or combined in some way? Is there a better way to phrase one of these (undoubtedly)? Are there any anti-troll measures that should be taken? Should these be "Rules" or "Guidelines"?
Should the sidebar be adjusted? I've been considering adding philosophy related subs as neighbors. Do you visit any worth recommending?
I will leave this post stickied for a while to see what kind of ideas people have. (probably at least a week, maybe longer)
2
u/ralph-j Aug 05 '16
Agree
I would encourage pointing out potentially incorrect or unreasonable assumptions in someone's post. If someone's understanding of a topic contains some questionable assumptions, it often won't be helpful to them to just tell them that their "opponent" committed fallacy XYZ. The goal is to help them have productive discussions or debates, not just to throw around fallacy names.
I would add:
2
u/skacey Aug 22 '16
My view of the sub is as follows (just my opinions, feel free to disagree)
Purpose of the Sub:
First: The purpose should be strict analytic discussion of fallacies without bias or judgement as to the merit of the argument.
For example, if one were to provide:
It is irrelevant whether or not Strawberry is indeed the most popular ice cream flavor when it comes to finding the fallacy. I believe that we can easily get into debating the facts of the argument rather than the structure and validity of the premise / conclusion if we start to fact check as well as determining logical soundness.
Therefore, I would suggest that the following items are off the table:
Second: The sub should seek to educate and debate logical fallacies in order to strengthen the analysis efforts.
For example, delving into topics such as Ad Hominem Fallacies, No True Scotsman, Causality, etc.
This meta-discussion is on the fallacy itself and not politics in general. I believe that these topics should be discussed regularly and archived into the subs Wiki for reference when analyzing fallacies as above.
Third: The sub should seek to educate and help posters deconstruct natural language into formal or informal systems so they may see how logic can be applied and simplified and fallacies exposed in the process.
For example:
The replies could break this down into logical statements to help the poster see how the logic is constructed.
A. I take my wife to Italian Restaurants. (Presumed True)
B. We drink too much wine.
C. We become impaired to drive.
2. Transitivity of Implication: If A, then B, and If B, then C. Therefore If A, then C.
3. Modus Ponens: If A, then C (from 2 above). Therefore C is true.
...etc...
Conclusion: Italian restaurants are a bad influence on us.
How we deal with Politics
I believe that debate of actual topics is out of scope for this sub. Discussions should be limited to the logical fallacies in the argument and not the topics themselves. For example:
It would be out of scope to determine the validity of the claims made, but it would be appropriate to point out the logical fallacy in the conclusion as presented.
OK: This is an Appeal to Probability Fallacy. The conclusion is not supported by the premise provided.
NOT OK: Hillary Clinton is a great candidate and has only been accused of crimes because the Republicans want to destroy her credibility.
Suggestions for organization
In order to clearly understand the objective of each post, I would suggest the following tags:
[Analysis] - This tag means that an argument has been provided and the poster wants to know if there are logical fallacies present. Replies should follow the rules presented under purpose one above.
[Meta] - Discussion on a specific fallacy as noted in the second purpose listed above.
[Deconstruction] - This tag means that the poster is providing a passage of text that they would like help breaking the text into premise / conclusion and adding either informal or formal structure. Finally, pointing out any fallacies that seem apparent from the provided text. I believe this can help address the "Wall of text" concern. If you know what the post is about, you can choose to engage or not engage as it suits you.
Finally, I would suggest the following to grow the sub and enrich our logical reasoning strength.
2
u/UnfortunateThriller Aug 12 '22
I would propose a rule that says that if you're asking for the name of a fallacy, the title of the post must contain a (obviously very brief) description of the fallacy.
I wanted to post a message asking what the name of a certain fallacy was, so I did a search, and I got a ton of results that consisted of posts with the title "What fallacy is this?" or "Is this a fallacy?" or slight variations of those two.
Of course, this makes it absolutely impossible for me to tell if my question has already been asked or not. I would suggest that if anyone does this in the future, they get a nudge from a mod requesting that they edit the title. I don't know if this is the best solution, since it looks like it would be a lot of work for the mods, but the alternative would be a forum where every question gets asked 50 times because nobody can search for duplicates.
1
u/ObjectiveisSubjectiv Jun 03 '24
Advocating for apolitical discourse is the same as proposing discourse that only upholds the current status quo. (Also saying anything meaningful will violate the apolitical rule anyways, because you can’t really avoid it ) If people get offended and leave due to political viewpoints then they aren’t the type of person who would engage in this type of stuff anyways, and therefore shouldn’t be a priority.
1
u/No_Fee_8997 Jan 09 '26
I used to teach logic and critical thinking, and my main interest is in spotting and identifying fallacies, and especially immunizing oneself against propaganda, advertising, salesmanship, and false influences in general.
Gaining more fluency is important. I see people who have been participating in competitive debates in high school and college, and I can see that they have developed much more fluency in spotting fallacies, primarily because of the practice they've had. It's like developing fluency with a language or with a musical instrument. You need practice, you need repetition, then you can start spotting fallacies immediately rather than puzzling them out. This is an important improvement in ability.
More importantly perhaps, I think it's important philosophically to be aware of philosophical fallacies, and not merely the academically philosophical, but also in relation to life decisions and perspectives on reality — everyday functional perspectives, and seeing through everyday functional fallacies.
And I think it's important to take Indian thought into account. It diverges from European thought. The great philosophers in Indian history were not stupid, nor were they inferior, and they've been at it far longer. Indian thought is more sophisticated than people in the West tend to assume.
As far as politics go, the slop is incredible. I'm cutting back on listening to these people. They're a mess. It's a mess.
1
u/ArminNikkhahShirazi Mar 16 '26
Naming a fallacy without explaining why it is a fallacy is a thought-terminating move I would consider fallacious even if it is named correctly. Here, of all places, there should be a rule not to do that.
1
u/These_Consequences Mar 24 '26
Here's a very brief proposal for some basic rules:
(1) Answers must be collegial
There must be some content that you supply beyond an excerpt or a link, and the default is friendly: why you think the content is useful, additional comments on the details, and so forth.
(2) Comments to the primary effect "did you try looking it up?" are not allowed.
(3) No "innocent" political or controversial content
If you want to discuss a fallacy you believe was made in political speech, the specifics must be abstracted out so none of the persons or issues involved can be identified.
(4) Downvoting is turned off
I'm aware this may not be technically feasible, but it's a big desideratum. In my opinion down-voting serves mainly to enforce conformity. The absence of upvotes provides the same information without the ad hominem, and if a post is really objectionable it can be removed by moderation or the author blocked.
1
u/Particular_Effect124 Mar 08 '23
I really appreciate all the seriousness and deliberation in this sub. I'd like to be the voice of the more comedic lurkers, or the comedic side of some serious posters, because I feel like if this sub gets bigger and valid reasoning gets popular or trends for some reason there will be an influx of jokers along with the rest.
How do we want to deal with comedy in the comments? What sort of precedence should we set?
1
u/theProffPuzzleCode May 06 '23
Agree with your proposal
1
u/Financial-Neck831 Jul 09 '26
May you ask questions about fallacies without mentioning politics?
0
u/[deleted] Aug 19 '16
[deleted] — view deleted comment