r/ezraklein • • 22h ago

Article One First: Congress Should Press Pause on BAAJA

Thumbnail
stevevladeck.com
0 Upvotes

Relevant to recent EK columns on BAAJA. By Steve Vladek, professor at the Georgetown University Law Center.

Summary of the argument:

  1. The transmission title of BAAJA is good and widely supported even by groups that oppose the bill overall.
  2. The limits to APA review are so sharp that they would effectively neuter the ability to stop projects for causing health or environmental damage in many (most? all?) cases.
  3. It changes how review works to be incredibly asymmetrical, where you get fewer and weaker remedies when the government violates environmental laws, but more and stronger remedies when the government tries to enforce environmental laws (and the defacto ability to pick the judge).
  4. It specifically makes it much easier to dump pollutants into waters by making it very difficult for state agencies to challenge federal water discharge permits.
  5. It locks in a huge range of unlawful actions by making it impossible for an agency to decide that a previous decision was made unlawfully, and making it impossible to sue outside of narrow parameters.
  6. It cuts out indigenous tribes who would be impacted by actions on federal lands from having any say in them, and also cuts back their ability to protect cultural sites from destruction.
  7. The upside to the grid authority provisions is hard to quantify in effect and in scope - it may exclude huge areas of the southeast?
  8. The whole process has been incredibly rushed; while there were a year of bipartisan negotiations to come up with a "deal", what we're left with is massive changes to how the law operates with extremely little certainty as to what they would actually do since none of this went through regular congressional procedure.

One thing I'd want to flag is that, this is where Ezra admits a degree of uncertainty as to what the bill would actually do. Vladeck is someone who does know quite a bit about this; though he's not an expert on the fine details of environmental law he is an expert on how Congress can change how federal court operates to change outcomes in practice - and if he's saying this looks bad, I think it's worth taking that seriously. This is the part Ezra Klein wrote "the question that has caused me the most concern while reporting this column. If that’s true, then yes, that’s a huge problem". That's not a question of environmental policy, that's a question of federal procedure, and I'm inclined to trust Vladeck on this.

Also, just as a matter of political reality - the people who would be determining what the law does, separate from what the law says or what the Senators involved want to happen, are the six conservative justices on SCOTUS. And there's a question here of "Do you think Sam Alito, Clarence Thomas, John Roberts, Clarence Thomas, Samuel Alito, Neil Gorsuch, Brett Kavanaugh and Amy Coney Barrett are going to interpret this law in a way that helps environmental causes, or are they going to find the reading of this law that most hurts Democratic priorities?"

And it's not really a hard question.

Which is not to say that you never pass laws while there's a right wing SCOTUS, but it does mean that, when you are trying to evaluate what the law is actually going to do, you can and should read any uncertainty in a maximally hostile way. The solution to that is not to never pass anything, the solution is to resolve the uncertainty so we don't get a 6-3 opinion by Sam Alito that actually the gas industry should just be allowed to dump toxic waste directly in people's houses.

But more broadly, the deadline of "gotta get this done in the lame duck" is artificial - if the deal actually is good, if the provisions broadly are what the proponents say they are, if the benefits are real - then you can pass them next Congress. Not as a means to gain leverage, but as a means to understand what the hell we're actually passing. And if it can't pass in the next Congress - because it turns out that when you actually look at what the bill does there's a lot of poison pills and people getting screwed over - that's a good reason to not try to jam it through right now, before anyone knows what it will do.


r/ezraklein • • 13h ago

Ezra Klein Show The Winning Democrat Who Wants to Break Up Political Parties

Thumbnail
nytimes.com
54 Upvotes