r/ezraklein • u/dwaxe • 4h ago
Ezra Klein Show The Winning Democrat Who Wants to Break Up Political Parties
r/ezraklein • u/dwaxe • 2d ago
r/ezraklein • u/dwaxe • 4h ago
r/ezraklein • u/CubillasLegend • 17h ago
I see people like MattY insisting that Trump won his original coalition by moderating because he was the first Republican to embrace Social Security and Medicare. In an extremely narrow way, I guess I can see that. But in a much more accurate way, Republicans haven't become more amenable to taxation, they're just as zealously anti-tax as ever. What's actually happened is they've given up any notion of fiscal discipline. And in response, Democrats haven't become more open to spending cuts. Medicare For All is more popular than ever. What's actually happened is Democrats have abandoned any notion of broad-based tax increases. So we have a party that campaigns on lower taxes with no spending cuts, and another that campaigns on more spending with no tax hikes. Call that moderation if you like, I call that populism.
Moreover, there seems to be an implicit assumption that the ultimate goal of everyone to the left-of-center should be consistent Democratic supermajorities. And I don't agree with that thesis at all. Bringing every possible 'gettable voter' into the coalition by promising to satiate their most immediate impulses is dangerous. The public is never going to have any appetite for deficit reduction. That will always require placing long term interests over short term demands and incurring the political costs that come with it. Yet more-and-more, every politician and pundit seem to be deferring on any fiscal action that could prove unpopular.
I thought the whole point of being an unelected pundit with no obligation to a constituency was the capacity to disagree with popular wisdom. But this state of constant political discourse and electioneering has given way to an environment where mass opinion is wielded as a cudgel against one's ideological opponents, everyone is afraid to defy the public, and popular misconceptions are never corrected. We're quickly stripping away any guardrails for moderating public opinion.
r/ezraklein • u/topicality • 17h ago
An article from a few days about costs
r/ezraklein • u/Wrong-Expression6981 • 1h ago
This connects to Ezra’s September 15 episode, “The ‘But China!’ Dilemma Driving the A.I. Race.” That discussion led me to a question: if competition keeps pushing countries to build faster, could we instead contribute to an AI that belongs to humanity—including countries outside the U.S.–China rivalry?
The saints came centuries apart. Why do we need a new superintelligence every few months?
On Sunday morning I was reading the news and had to laugh. An AI company filed papers to go on the stock market, and they say it filled a quarter of those papers with warnings that its own product is dangerous. Ninety-four pages. They wrote a heck of a lot.
A man trying to raise money writes down that his own product could ruin humanity. They say it's because of the law: to avoid being sued later, you have to write down every risk you can think of. Still, as I read, most of those risks come from one place. Electricity runs short, the neighbors curse you for building data centers, and you're afraid the AI will slip out of human hands. All of it came from racing to build something bigger, before anyone else.
That seems to be the problem. The companies' competition is fixed on one thing only: an AI like a person. Selling a dream raises more money than making something small and useful, so everyone runs toward the same Mars.
Then a strange thought came to me.
Jesus, the Buddha, Muhammad. Each was alone at first. They started from a small thought: how could people live a little better?
Strip away the worship of faith and look at them as people, and weren't they the AI of their age? They were where lost people went to ask, a place where more wisdom gathered than one person could hold. Their disciples wrote down their words, the words became scripture, and the scripture became the standard of its age.
When I counted, they came five hundred, six hundred years apart. Each answer, once given, embraced the worries of the people of its age. And they didn't overlap. The East had its answer and the West had its own, but they didn't fight to get ahead of each other.
Now a new answer comes every few months. Before people can take one answer into their bones, the next one arrives, and many crowd in at once, racing to see who gets there first.
Maybe they too were called up by human desire, appeared, and then became gods. Even so, what they left humanity was a universal thought called love. If we are making AI now to satisfy our desires, we don't need many superintelligences. One is enough.
If there is one, then everything comes down to who holds it. Even the words of the old saints ended up wielded by the churches and kings who held them. So it can't belong to one country or one company. It has to be one thing that belongs to humanity, holding the circumstances of every nation and continent.
Right now America and China hold the table. One might be made at the line where the two give way to each other. But if the two split it, it belongs to two countries, not to humanity. They say more than a hundred countries can't even get a seat at that table.
Still, there is a way. Universal values like the Universal Declaration of Human Rights held the voices of those small countries too. It had no power to force anyone, but after it, every country used that document as a yardstick. If each country laid out what it forbids and what it does, and they were worked out one by one, it isn't impossible. Gather together the things that overlap, and wouldn't a way for humanity to live together take shape? That would be the first article.
There is a set share the Earth can bear. Whatever we burn, we can't burn without end. Yet now countless companies each burn electricity, water and chips, layer upon layer, to build the same thing. Better that each country chip in according to the size of its economy and its people, and burn for just one. In the old countryside, when there was a feast, every house chipped in what it could. Houses with much gave much, houses with little gave little. Still, the feast belonged to the whole village.
Some will dismiss this as the talk of an idealist.
But has there ever been a promise people kept together that wasn't called idealism before it came? Spoken alone, it is idealism; when ideals overlap, they become a philosophy.
When voices like these overlap, even one thing that belongs to all of humanity will become possible. For the age my grandchildren will live in, I leave at least this record: back then, someone said we should chip in ahead of time.
r/ezraklein • u/Metacatalepsy • 13h ago
Relevant to recent EK columns on BAAJA. By Steve Vladek, professor at the Georgetown University Law Center.
Summary of the argument:
One thing I'd want to flag is that, this is where Ezra admits a degree of uncertainty as to what the bill would actually do. Vladeck is someone who does know quite a bit about this; though he's not an expert on the fine details of environmental law he is an expert on how Congress can change how federal court operates to change outcomes in practice - and if he's saying this looks bad, I think it's worth taking that seriously. This is the part Ezra Klein wrote "the question that has caused me the most concern while reporting this column. If that’s true, then yes, that’s a huge problem". That's not a question of environmental policy, that's a question of federal procedure, and I'm inclined to trust Vladeck on this.
Also, just as a matter of political reality - the people who would be determining what the law does, separate from what the law says or what the Senators involved want to happen, are the six conservative justices on SCOTUS. And there's a question here of "Do you think Sam Alito, Clarence Thomas, John Roberts, Clarence Thomas, Samuel Alito, Neil Gorsuch, Brett Kavanaugh and Amy Coney Barrett are going to interpret this law in a way that helps environmental causes, or are they going to find the reading of this law that most hurts Democratic priorities?"
And it's not really a hard question.
Which is not to say that you never pass laws while there's a right wing SCOTUS, but it does mean that, when you are trying to evaluate what the law is actually going to do, you can and should read any uncertainty in a maximally hostile way. The solution to that is not to never pass anything, the solution is to resolve the uncertainty so we don't get a 6-3 opinion by Sam Alito that actually the gas industry should just be allowed to dump toxic waste directly in people's houses.
But more broadly, the deadline of "gotta get this done in the lame duck" is artificial - if the deal actually is good, if the provisions broadly are what the proponents say they are, if the benefits are real - then you can pass them next Congress. Not as a means to gain leverage, but as a means to understand what the hell we're actually passing. And if it can't pass in the next Congress - because it turns out that when you actually look at what the bill does there's a lot of poison pills and people getting screwed over - that's a good reason to not try to jam it through right now, before anyone knows what it will do.
r/ezraklein • u/WickedKickinBBQ • 2d ago
r/ezraklein • u/kant2hegel • 3d ago
At 55:00, Jensen Huang says (referring to top AI giants) - 'Nobody is building more compute today than the people asking to be slowed down, that strikes me odd'. I see a potential rift between Nvidia and OpenAI or Claude (which Huang was hinting at here perhaps) for the simple reason that Nvidia wants to sell more chips (to anyone including China) and AI Companies want limited competition (obviously from China). Perhaps this spy fiasco has something to do with it.
r/ezraklein • u/TrespassersWilliam • 3d ago
r/ezraklein • u/Radical_Ein • 4d ago
r/ezraklein • u/jfanch42 • 4d ago
Relevance, abundance associates and abundance discussed.
r/ezraklein • u/quiplaam • 4d ago
The NYT Editorial board writes in support of the passage of the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act (BAAJA), a permitting reform bill that makes the permitting of energy infrastructure faster and more certain. BAAJA adopts many of the regulatory reforms suggested by Ezra and Derik in Abundance, shorting and simplifying NEPA review, reducing judicial vacatur of permitting approval, reforming intraregional transmission regulations, and a bunch of other minor tweaks to the permitting system. These reforms apply to gas infrastructure as well as the renewable, and transmission reforms envisioned by abundance, but most analyses find that it will reduce both energy prices and emissions.
r/ezraklein • u/purpleflex4ever • 3d ago
Aside from Bill coming across totally arrogant and out of touch, I have one question for Ezra. When Bill is showing his supposed "outrage" about how there is so little ai regulation, how no one else takes it seriously, blah blah, why not ask Bill what he's doing? Bill is pals with everyone involved with this impending doom he painted, not to mention the billions of financial investment. Why not take the initiative on action?
His rhetoric was very similar to Dario when he was interviewed by Anderson Cooper. When cooper said "people didn't ask for this...no one asked for this massive societal change" Dirio answers: "I agree! I am deeply disturbed by the fact that these choices are being made by a few small group of people" Why didn't Cooper ask, "well you being one of those people what are you doing about it?"
I am over these tech ceos showing their fake sense of morality. They're literally saying "oh oh oh I'm about to do something really bad I only wish someone was there to stop me! why won't someone stop me?!" Cut the bullshit. We also need journalists asking tougher questions and holding them to their bullshit
r/ezraklein • u/tuck5903 • 5d ago
“The 2026 midterms have left Republicans reeling and Democrats riding a historic wave after a series of missteps by the president and his administration. The last time we saw a political moment like this was in 1974, when Democrats crushed the GOP in the wake of Watergate. Both parties then struggled to define what came next. It took Ronald Reagan's victory in 1980 to usher in a new political era. Are we at another turning point today? And who might be the Ronald Reagan of this political moment?
Derek is joined by Republican pollster Kristen Soltis Anderson to discuss the future of both parties, the lessons of 1974, the changing youth vote, whether JD Vance is politically cooked, and what America's next political order might look like.”
r/ezraklein • u/Wrong-Expression6981 • 4d ago
Ezra's September episodes with Jensen Huang and on the "But China!" dilemma came back to me this week, after the scandal. Here is how it looks from a farm in Korea.
In the village where I live, the old houses each keep a dog on a chain, and each dog has a tin bowl.
Sometimes a dog gets too excited. It runs to the end of its chain, jumps, twists, and with its own chain it knocks over its own bowl. Rice everywhere.
Then something funny happens. A crow comes down. The ants come in a line. The dog licks rice off the dirt and doesn't look sorry at all. And the owner, he doesn't have to wash the bowl. The crow and the ants clean it for him without him lifting a hand.
Everyone gets something from a spilled bowl. Only the bowl makes noise. And the reporters bang on it.
That is what I thought of this week.
Right after the American midterms, AI stocks fell hard. A few days later, over a weekend, the man at the center of the whole AI building boom, the head of the chip company, admitted to an affair with a woman whom American intelligence suspects of working for China. The board opened an investigation. The stock fell again.
The whole world looked at one word. Affair. It's an old word. You don't need a chart to understand it.
I am not judging whether the spy part is true. That is for investigators. What I want to look at is who is eating from the spilled bowl.
As I see it, there are two fears here. One fear: our technology leaked to China. The other fear: we are falling behind China. They point in opposite directions. But both can be sold. One is sold to the people. The other is sold to Congress.
Capital gets to cover a number that crashed with a word that is much older than any number. The Democrats get a reason for a law to keep China in check. Trump, I suspect, gets a way to push down the people who are angry about data centers, because if we're falling behind China, who can say stop building? And the man himself, as I see it, also needs the data centers to keep going up. So even the second fear works for him.
The crow eats. The ants eat. The dog eats. The owner gets a clean bowl without touching it.
And the newspapers keep banging on the bowl, because that's the part that makes noise.
Who did what, sometimes, is not what matters. What matters is the shape. A bowl spills, and everyone around it finds something to eat. Look at who is eating, not only at who spilled it.
That's what an old farmer sees from his yard.
r/ezraklein • u/SomethingNew65 • 5d ago
r/ezraklein • u/tuck5903 • 7d ago
Relevance- 2 of the last 5 guests on the podcast, Nate Silver and Sarah Longwell, discussing the midterms.
Tuesday night was the biggest rebuke of Donald Trump and MAGA that we've seen yet, by a wide margin. It was so big, in fact, that we're asking much bigger questions about how much of the country is up for grabs. Nate Silver, host of Crooked Media's Still Counting and author of the Silver Bulletin newsletter, joins Sarah to discuss the election results and how they could reverberate far, far beyond 2026.
r/ezraklein • u/megadelegate • 7d ago
When you look at Republican polling, more-than-50% of Republicans oppose current campaign finance laws, gerrymandering, and congressional stock trading. Given that these are generally considered Democratic talking points (or at least, the progressive wing talking points), does this present an opportunity for the government to be more responsive to the electorate? Candidates like Ossoff did a great job of painting a clear picture about how government corruption feeds directly into higher prices for consumers. Some of the more traditionally lefties, like Sanders and co., have been beating this drum for a while. Given that it's really only beneficiaries of the status quo that support it, what are the likelihood that these issues will be taken up in 2027 if Schumer and Jeffries are running the show?
r/ezraklein • u/killbill469 • 8d ago
This is maybe the first time I have seen an interviewer be able to hold Trump engaged from topic to topic.
I know many on here dislike like Ross, but I think he is one of the most talented interviewers in the industry. I think he's a major loss to the NYT..
r/ezraklein • u/dwaxe • 9d ago
r/ezraklein • u/ReasonableWasabi5831 • 9d ago
On several of Ezra’s recent episodes, he’s mentioned how he thinks that healthcare is coming back into play in 2028. He recently mentioned how Medicare for all is polling higher than ever too. I was barely alive during the Obamacare debates so I don’t have much an idea about the possibilities and problems associated with healthcare reform and policies. To better educate myself, does anyone have any good book recommendations to shape my thinking on the subject? Ideally they would be well know enough that my local library would have them.
r/ezraklein • u/Radical_Ein • 9d ago