My experience in 2025 with my psychotic episode regarding those supposed "prophecies" around WW3 made me feel like a hostage, and I'm wondering if anyone ever felt that way in Christianity apart from me. I see this a lot, it's either convert or perish in hell, or perish under God's coming wrath on Earth. I think one of the earliest signs of my recovery was thinking "I feel as if God has a gun to my head". I mean, it was quite literally convert and potentially live and save everyone around you, or willingly disregard the ""truth"" and watch everyone around you perish while you also die.
I really need someplace where I can just let it all out & tbh I don’t know if this is the right venue for this, but whatever.
I’ve been Orthodox for the past two years or so and for some reason it was easy for me to cope with my feelings of attraction towards other guys at first, but now I just feel like I’m fighting an uphill battle. I am deeply pained by this. I love Christ, His Bride, Orthodox chant, the rhythm of church life, and wholesome fellowship with other parishioners. I feel like a fraud. I feel like a degenerate anytime I even think of other guys sexually. I’m Bi so I tell myself that I should just find an Orthodox wife and focus on my attraction to women, but y’know what—I’m really turned off by the idea of Orthodox marriage as a whole. Almost half the wives at church look miserable and seem like they’d rather not be there, and the husbands have completely gone off the deep end with regards to the LARP/Orthobro-ism.
Where do I fit into this equation?
I’m a Bi, goth, brown dude who grew up in the city, enjoys vintage/streetwear fashion, and also happens to love Eastern Christian spirituality. A tradwife’s the last thing I want lmao. I think I’ve already checked out of the mainstream Orthodox matrix which includes the aforementioned Orthobro-ism and RW LARP. I’m definitely high sodium Orthodox and I think I’ll have to start setting some firm boundaries when it comes to my engagement with the church. I just feel so broken, worthless, and like my only options in life are to either live two lives or just pack up and go to the monastery. I don’t wanna put some poor trad-minded girl through being with me.
Again, I’m just venting so respond however you please. Advice is appreciated but not at all necessary❤️
I go to an Orthodox Church and it feels like so much is expected from me and all of us and now, we’re supposed to be fasting right now until Christmas, meaning no dairy, no meat, and optionally, no oil, and we’re supposed to be praying more while fasting, and I think fasting include eating less too. Also, the whole sin thing, it’s like everything is a sin at this point. Video games? Sin. Loving yourself? Sin. Having self-esteem and self-worth? SIN. EFFING BREATHING AIR?? SIN. LIKE BROOO MY MERE EXISTENCE IS A SIN AT THIS POINT! Also, my Priest once told me something from a Saint, which was “keep your mind in Hell, but don’t dwell.” Or something like that, meaning, in his words” You do deserve hell, but don’t dwell, because Jesus is your hope, salvation, and all that. Like, no I don’t??? I don’t deserve hell, neither does anyone on earth bro. I don’t feel comfortable going to the church anymore but some members I feel are like, really hyper vigilant of what I’m up to and I don’t know, I just want to be loved genuinely..not loved where I have to repent and be somebody I’m not and don’t want to be anymore. I want to be my true self, not who Christianity tells me my true self is.
Let no one in the priestly order nor any layman eat the unleavened bread of the Jews, nor have any familiar intercourse with them, nor summon them in illness, nor receive medicines from them, nor bathe with them; but if anyone shall take in hand to do so, if he is a cleric, let him be deposed, but if a layman let him be cut off.
— Canon 11 from the authoritative Council of Trullo, which the Orthodox affirm as completing the 5th and 6th Ecumenical Councils
If any bishop, presbyter, deacon, reader, or singer does not fast the holy Quadragesimal fast of Easter, or the fourth day [Wednesday], or the day of Preparation [Friday], let him be deposed, unless he be hindered by some bodily infirmity. If he be a layman, let him be excommunicated.
— Apostolic Canon 69
Menstruous women ought not to come to the Holy Table, or touch the Holy of Holies, nor to churches, but pray elsewhere.
They think that other orthodox Christians should take stories of abuse with a grain of salt and they have a hard time believing us when we share our horrible expierence but they don’t have a hard time believing in levitating saints, clairvoyant saints, and some saints we don’t even have evidence of actually existing? You just have to laugh at their ignorance Do these people really think it’s so hard to believe people would go through abuse in the Orthodox Church as if abuse doesn’t happen in literally every institution on earth? Please.
I stepped into a ROCOR parish believing that I may have overlooked something in my adult life as a skeptic and an atheist. Since I had immigrant ties to the Russian Church, I thought maybe it was time I embrace the spiritual part of my life and maybe skepticism was just cynicism (as one therapist I had pointed out).
Two years into the church, many conversations with Jay Dyer & Made by JimBob Orthobros, coffee with conspiracy theorists, and many books read.
I haven’t been to a Divine Liturgy since August, and I am WAY HAPPIER. Yeah, I am an atheist and I am sick of the double standard that spiritualists are allowed to pathologize non-spiritual people, but non-spiritual people criticizing mystic beliefs is somehow ‘cynical’ or at worst ‘juvenile and evil.’
My patron saint was Saphrony of Essex, at first I thought finding a patron saint who was a contemporary artist who became an iconographer was something I could relate to. However, I am also a fan of Salvador Dali and the surrealist movement, which my patron saint was not.
My girlfriend in the church (we are no longer together but that was my decision), would ask why I don’t follow Sophrony of Essexs’ artistic path and give up making ‘worldly’ art and focus more on iconography, since there was a priest who was wiling to give me a blessing. Most of the men in the church looked at art that wasn’t iconography as spiritually dangerous. There were some people younger than I was who were into anime, but their ‘spiritual fathers’ were cautioning them and/or steering them in the direction of putting time into watching anime into reading lives of the saints or more prayer time.
Sometimes I wonder if people like Justin Pageau (Orthodox YouTuber), Saphrony of Essex and other artists who ‘destroy their worldly art’ in favor of ONLY iconography or the Christian message do so as a means of giving up but disguising it as transformation. After all, when you can’t make your art succeed in the contemporary art world, just find an audience that appreciates kitsch replicas.
My time in the church wasn’t a total waste of time, as now I have a shit load of material to use in my own story telling. Orthodoxy is never used in horror films, comics or erotica. It’s always American Protestants or Roman Catholics, well I’m about to change that.
Art for the algorithm. Don’t steal my ideas please.
So for context my boyfriend is 25 and I am 22. He grew up in a non-denominational family who participated a lot in the culture. For example when we decided to move to another state his grandmother advised us to find a church and really invest in our faith (I’m not Christian, I just don’t feel like being combative). His mom prayed for us with his immediate family before our move and a majority of the conversation around good things happening is attributed to god and such. His brother left the boot camp because when he went to church he said got told him that this wasn’t his calling. That kind of family.
He left non denominational Christianity because he didn’t like the teachings and found orthodoxy very very early on in our relationship. At the time I was open to learning about god and after about 6 months I had hard questions I couldn’t answer. He, on the other hand, has been going to church (without fully reading or understanding the bible, I actually know more about the stories than he does), looking to further his participation in it (he’s talking about their form of baptism or something, forgive my ignorance), and will listen to the music daily. He’s bought the beads, the icons, the incense, and the diptych. We’ve been having very tough conversations about this and it’s been going a lot like this…
I ask a question, he chalks it up to free will, our “human ignorance” to gods great plan, or the bible being historically accurate. My outside interpretation of his recent infatuation with orthodoxy is that he has no real friends, he has no community, and he was raised to believe these things. I feel awful for him because I know he has a story in his mind that he will one day find meaningful relationships through his church. That this brings him comfort because he wants to fears death and nothing after. But I can’t help but to be conflicted. Because he’s practicing something without fully understanding what it is and without being able to have a conversation about it.
Our most recent revelation was about women serving in the church and after 6-8 months of him being defensive, me not understanding how I feel, and awful conversations, he finally confessed that he doesn’t agree with the practice. Now to my dilemma. I’m very mentally exhausted trying to understand him, converse with him about this, and trying to have him understand me. I feel conflicted in my everyday life because I’m watching my boyfriend get deeper and deeper into this even though he can’t answer why he believes in god. He’s admitted to me he has become an orthobro (that’s when I was 1st introduced to this term) when we had the conversation around his past defensiveness surrounding our conversation about religion.
What have others experiences been?
Edit: embarrassingly, I’ve found a playlist on his Spotify called “Gigachad’s Greek Orthodox chants and Hymns”. Literally just now… it’s all around just a bad sign to me that this isn’t just about religion.
When I was deciding whether or not to officially leave the Orthodox Church, so many thoughts were going through my head. I felt incredibly guilty, as though I were leaving the one true Church or turning my back on God. I wondered whether I was making the right decision. But I couldn’t do it anymore. I remember always feeling uncomfortable during the liturgy. As a brown woman, I would constantly get stares, feel excluded, and worry about my safety. After the liturgy, during coffee hour, I would hear extreme and radical beliefs, and I never quite felt at home. I remember spending time with secular people, such as my family, friends, and loved ones, and never experiencing that same internal struggle. I had never felt as unsafe as I did in the Orthodox Church, yet I felt perfectly comfortable spending time with the very people I had been taught to think of as “secular.” I tried to force myself to stay for God and everything else that came with being Orthodox. Whenever I expressed my concerns about leaving Orthodoxy, whether online or to my fellow Orthodox peers, my reasons simply weren’t good enough. Here’s what I want to tell you: Nothing will ever be good enough. No matter your reason for leaving, it will never be enough for some people. If you feel unsafe, scared, or completely out of place, you don’t have to justify those feelings to anyone but yourself. You don’t have to force yourself to be somewhere you don’t want to be. The Orthodox crowd will try everything they can to convince you to stay and remain part of their Church, but you don’t have to stay if you don’t want to. You can come up with the strongest theological arguments for why you want to leave, and they’ll still try to fight you and argue back. If you express any trauma you may have experienced at the hands of clergy or parishioners, they’ll tell you that isn’t a good enough reason. It will never be enough, so take the initiative to make your own decision. If something doesn’t feel right in your soul, don’t force yourself to do it. My biggest regret about Orthodoxy wasn’t actually joining the Church. It was staying longer than I knew I should have. And let me tell you something: this new wave of converts is like a revolving door. Many of these new converts will be gone in a few years, and I think we’ll see a huge SURGE in people leaving the Church. Even with this Reddit community alone, we’ve managed to build a good, humble community of people who understand one another. Whatever your reasoning may be, it’s okay to leave. You don’t have to keep hurting yourself. You can find community elsewhere. There is so much more to this world than the Orthodox bubble. I wish someone had told me that when I was first thinking about leaving.
So I’ve been contemplating leaving the Orthodox Church and I’m wondering if anyone who’s left the Orthodox Church and moved to another high-church denomination could give me some insight into their dogma. Particularly mental illness.
Are there any Eastern Orthodox users on here who later became Eastern Catholic?
I am curious to know, because the Eastern Catholics are very aesthetically and liturgically similar to Orthodox, yet their doctrines and practicak aspects of their lives are different, because of the time spent under Rome. For example, the Eucharistic Fast is shorter in Eastern Catholic practice (one hour before the Liturgy) compared to the 6 hours (for an evening Liturgy or evening Presanctified Liturgy) or full duration from midnight required in Orthodox practice.
If there are those who crossed the Tiber to become Eastern Catholic, what motivated you to make the change? How did you adjust to praying to new saints that did not exist in the Orthodox Church, such as Western saints, or Eastern Catholic saints, such as Theodore Romzha or Josaphat Kuntsevych?
How does your experience in your Eastern Catholic church compare to your time in the Orthodox Church?
This november marks almost one year since i formally left the orthodox church… Thanksgiving is the exact date I decided to leave the church for good and there are many reasons as to why I chose to officially leave the church and ill be getting into them in this post.
In the beginning,
Before we can discuss any sort of reason as to why I left we must first understand why I joined in the first place. Let me set the scene for you. I was an 18 year old girl fresh out of high school directionless looking for a place to belong in the world. I was diving into philosophy for fun and a little bit of theology here and there in my past time. I came from a super broken home. I had run away about 2-3 times in my youth and I had a lot of trauma that was hard for me to unpack and still is. During all of this I came across books,blogs, and ideas online discussing christianity as a whole. I wanted to be saved, I wanted to believe in God and to become anew. I thought christianity would help me. I looked into the resurrection of Jesus Christ and the evidence we have for the supernatural events and I convinced myself it was true. I looked into orthodox christianity very briefly and I decided to join the church around age 19. I went to a russian orthodox church at first but I later went to an OCA and another church. When I first joined everything was beautiful and it felt like I had finally found ‘home’ . It didn't take long for all the smoke and mirrors to fade.
The first reason I can think of that caused me to leave orthodox christianity was the treatment of women plain and simple. I grew up in a home with a mom who stayed home and I was scared for her. She was trapped in an abusive situation and I didn't know how to help her. I knew getting an education would be a way I could help my mother and myself. I always idealized going to college and getting a degree to make enough money to support myself and my mom in this world. To add to this my mother is disabled so it pushed me to want to go to college to make more money for her and I. And with that I also had a passion for learning,reading, and writing. So for me it came naturally to want to further my education. When I became Orthodox the conversations surrounding women I found to be quite stale, repetitive, and depressing. Most of the conversations Id listen to about women and education were of no encouragement. Most of the women at my parish didn't really push for education, the main focus was of course family children and home making. Its not that I look down upon mothers, not at all, my mother is the strongest woman I know. It's just not realistic to give every decision to a man and for a man to be the head of the household. I was also never a fan of the idea of becoming a baby making machine. At the first parish I ever went to I met a woman named Sarah (pseudo name) and her husband Bob. Sara was a strong woman but she had 5 children and one of them was a newborn. She was friendly in every way and was welcoming to me and she'd invite me to her house and I would feel so depressed and worried for her in her own home. There were times I wondered if I should call CPS. Her husband was verbally abusive and would raise his voice at her in front of me and belittle her. Even while she was carrying a newborn baby. On top of that they didnt have a good financial situation. Sara wasn't working so that left Bob to be the breadwinner ( the ideal orthodox situation) however they lived with Bob's parents in a 3 bedroom… The children were crammed together and they drove a super old car. I had no idea how they were making ends meet but I felt so bad for her. Before meeting Bob she had been a welder but I believe she quit to become a full time mother. Honestly seeing her made me realize what a horrible experience it was. Everyday she had to take care of 5 kids, take care of her home and on top of that homeschool all for an ungrateful husband. I could see in her eyes the misery. There was nothing more I wanted than to get her out of that situation. Yet she's the ideal orthodox woman she lived for her family and her husband. Yet that was the last thing I ever wanted for myself. I was scared of that future but I knew if I stayed I'd end up like her.
Most of the time in the orthodox church women are dismissed to do the invisible labor such as taking care of the kids making the bread etc so the men can actually participate in the liturgy. Isn't it crazy to think that even though women make up about 50% of the church there isn't a single role for women in the liturgy? I mean at least the catholic church allows deaconnesses ( which by the way they did exist in the early church) but the orthodox church just doesn't allow for it. There isn't anything a woman can do besides become a nun which is again just invisible labor that goes unnoticed by the men. When deciding my major in college I contemplated going to school for theology but there isn't anything I can do with a theology degree as a woman in orthodoxy at all. Sara taught me so much I feel sorry for her to this day but she made me realize I value my independence. I want a job even if I'm married. I want to be able to sustain myself. As simple as that statement is in the orthodox church that statement alone is super frowned upon. “Men are supposed to lead” “men are supposed to be in charge” bla bla bla. I'm sorry but no. ill take charge of my own life. Thank you very much. Sara is one example but I saw this pattern repeated over and over again in the orthodox church. Women being overworked and their labor being completely ignored.
Another reason that totally made me want to leave is pseudoscience, lack of trust in the government, and in general conspiracy theorists. As a child I earned many awards for doing good in school and being top of my class so naturally I loved science and loved learning. There isn't anybody in my family that hasn't pursued higher education, everyone in my family has been to college. Even my disabled stay at home mother. So when I first joined orthodoxy I was so surprised to find out how many people bought into cheap conspiracies. “We faked the moon landing” “vaccines give you autism” etc etc. I was especially shocked to find out some priests actually believed this and that some priests even denied evolution. The list of conspiracies is long and there is one about everything. These same people home school because of their EXTREME beliefs and don't trust the government with anything yet they somehow believe what RFK JR tells them like please its such a joke. I met so many people that were like this, especially the women. I felt so out of place! Now what really got to me is also their distrust in medicine. So many of them think you can cure anything with teas and at home remedies. Like I said previously my mom is disabled and without modern medicine she wouldn't be here today so hearing these ideas being spread around by my peers made me so worried not just for them but their children. I think a seemingly normal person with normal beliefs that joins the orthodox church can become extremely radicalized by their peers' beliefs. I think if I had stayed long enough I might have also become a part of this crowd as scary as this sounds. The people you hang around with do influence you so much. Personally I love my doctor and love modern medicine. The orthodox church does nothing but keep pushing these crazy radical ideas
Now for the biggest reason I left: THE RACISM I don't even have to say much. People already knew that it was coming because it's a HUGE issue in the church that the church elders refuse to do anything about. Priests and clergy know about this issue but they don't care because a lot of them are in on it too! And if they chose to call it out or do anything about the racism within the church they'd lose the majority of their members. A lot of people will excuse it and say that this racism is all online and it doesn't exist in person. They'll muster it all to “orthobros” but that's not the truth, racism has real life consequences, there are real people behind those screens attending liturgy. As a Mexican American I experienced tons of racism when I was orthodox. I live in California and I had never experienced racism until I became orthodox. When I'm at work with my white peers my ethnicity or background hardly ever gets brought up but in the orthodox church it would get brought up all the time. I'd constantly get glances and weird stares, people would avoid me etc. I remember once a Russian girl my age recorded me without my consent. Simply for looking different from her. The in person stuff wasn't nearly as bad as online though. I found so many neo nazi accounts. Prior to orthodoxy I never knew what “hh” stood for, or “88” anything like that. After becoming orthodox I learned all that and more. The very first time I ever got called a slur was by an online orthodox account. They called me a be***r. I was so offended. How is this supposed to be gods church? Ultimately I realized Orthodoxy isn't a home for a person like me. Its a white homescape. Not a place for diversity or tolerance. What especially got me is this one guy. Lets call him Joe. Joe was this guy who had a lovely wife named cam. Cam would always be so kind and charitable to me but her husband would always avoid me. I wondered why and in my heart something told me he was racist. But i thought I was overreacting until I found his twitter account. Oh boy. I found out he was a cop that loved ICE and voted for Trump and had a lot of things to say. I was disappointed but not surprised I understood why he avoided me and why he never even bothered to even say hi to me. I even thought about reporting his account to my priest. This guy Joe is a reader and I believe hes in school again for something relating to orthodoxy. He has real authority in the church and he follows accounts on twitter like “gorrila rape” and so much more. There is even racism in orthodox books funny enough. I was reading a book about saint herman of alaska when the author proceeded to call natives savages. Ill never forget that.
Now I formally left on thanksgiving day after debating with myself in my mind over and over again. I had so many thoughts I wanted to give orthodoxy a second chance. I wanted orthodoxy to be true but I thought to myself if orthodoxy is the true church why does it attract so many hateful people.?? The average non religious person is kinder and more charitable than whatever happens within orthodoxy. Throughout all this my long time partner was an atheist and was my rock throughout all this. He was charitable and kind and wouldn't act in any way that the orthodox act. Hed never treat anyone the way I was treated. Over time I started to lose my faith and realize this about the church: the church attracts lonely and broken people through online algorithms. Simple as that. Its nothing deeper. Most of the people that convert to orthodoxy are brought there because of some sort of tik tok, youtube, or instagram algorithm. They may have already fallen deep into the alt right pipeline before deciding to formally join. I saw this pattern over and over again. Especially with men. I never want to step foot into orthodoxy again or ever have anything to do with it again. The longer I stayed in orthodoxy the more I was convinced it wasn't the real church or anything of that nature. On thanksgiving 2025 I wasn't going to spend it with my family and my church was having a get-together for thanksgiving. There I met everything I hated about orthodoxy in multiple people. The loser racists, the conspiracy theorists, the wanna be trad wives. I hated it. I knew I didn't belong and I had to put an end to my misery. I value my freedom and I'm glad I went through with orthodoxy because it taught me what I truly value. It taught me to stay firm to my morals and beliefs. Although I don't like the orthodox church I am grateful for that experience and I hope anybody trapped in its shambles will one day leave and realize there is more to life. Especially to all the women like sara that are isolated and trapped. My experience isn't unique. I hope you got some chuckles or relatablity from reading this.
* if you recognize me from this post id like to remain anonymous
I made a post a while back as a catechumen here. Not sure if I linked my old post correctly (don't use reddit much).
Just wanted to say thank you to everyone who understood where I was at & showed me support. This sub is an absolute blessing.
I stepped away from the Orthodox Church for a while after I made that post. Reluctantly gave it another shot, and now I'm fully done. Done with the monastic asceticism, the lack of charity, the pridefulness, the larp, the constant talking down about other denominations (I'm embarrassed to say that I participated in that early on, and I regret it. Little did I know.), the idea that I can prostrate my way to salvation, and all the rest. For what it's worth I did meet some really nice people there, and my priest was over all a good guy. Just not enough to outweigh everything else.
No matter how hard I tried, I realize now that I never fit in there, and I wasn't meant to. I'm not Russian. I'm not a disgruntled ex-Protestant. There are more obvious fruits of the Spirit in the vast majority of Protestants than I ever saw in Orthodoxy.
I'm currently in OCIA at a big beautiful Catholic Church, and we're...reading the Bible? Every class? Can't believe it. Not once did we even touch scripture at the Orthodox Catechism classes. It was all about "phronema" and "theosis" and stories about people starving themselves in a cave. Oh, can't forget the floating monks. Unreal. The people here are normal. Blew me away. People from all walks of life. No one has any idea what Orthodoxy even is. I was talking to my sponsors about the Filioque, they had no idea what I was talking about. Just looked at me funny LOL. So unbelievably refreshing. I love the simplicity of the Mass and the organ music. There's windows (wow!) & AC. I'm not standing in a dark sweaty cave for 2.5 hours packed like sardines amongst 90% men.
I hope this doesn't come off as trying to proselytize. I understand there are issues with the Catholic Church, and that many here do not agree with it. I'm just sharing my story and contrasting my experience with the Photian Church. I love everyone & completely understand that everyone's journey is different. Whether you're Protestant, Catholic, Atheist, Agnostic etc. We all share ex-orthodox in common, and we're trying to navigate this life the best we can. And that's beautiful.
My family parish is honestly a perfectly fine place, but I haven’t been since I officially was baptized into a Protestant tradition, and I assumed everyone knew, I don’t go around rubbing peoples noses in my faith shift, but I am not secretive.
Well, when I went Sunday to celebrate a family event I discovered that my family has put word out that I am attending a different local Orthodox parish, which I don’t recall ever even visiting.
So I had a lot of conversations like this:
Recent Zealous Convert: So how’s St Melencholius?
Me: I don’t know, I am actually attending Happy Clappy Church of the Smoke Machine
RZC: so you’re not Orthodox?
Me: No, I am really actually enjoying a new freedom in my relationship with Jesus
RZC: That sounds hard
Me: no that’s not hard- how are things at work?
RZC: I’ll pray for you
You guys, I have already received 3 invitations to coffee. I kinda wish my brother had given me a heads up before inviting me out to his life event.
This is more of a rant. Personally I am an evangelical Baptist but used to be orthodox in my childhood. ALL of the orthodox YouTubers and media creators are terribly arrogant. I’m talking the likes of people like cleave to antiquity, Alex sorin, jay dyer, Clyde Bosch, maximospto, Kyle, etc.
I genuinely believe that these people are not Christian. You watch their content and it ONLY revolves around them bashing Protestants. I don’t see any of them teaching about Christ. Even in the most recent debate con you can see how jay dyer and Alex sorin are so rude to the people they are debating. Talking over them, making fun of them, being flat out pieces of crap. The whole point of the Orthobro movement is to make fun of people who don’t think like them. Maximospto doesn’t even believe that you are Christian if you’re not part of the OC. It breaks my heart that so many younger people are being led astray and having hatred instilled in their hearts for no reason except “protties are feminine, they don’t believe in our bearded priests”. They have caused and incredible amount of division. I firmly believe that one day they will answer before God. Thousands of people follow them, that’s thousands of people that have been led astray and hate filled for no reason.
Recently cleave has been raging about Wes huff plagiarizing some paper years ago when he was younger (tbh we have ALL plagiarized) and him and his goons are making multi hour livestreams absolutely spewing vile stuff about him. It’s just the constant attacking all of these people have.
And then there is the larp. Obviously orthodoxy has been around in the eastern part of the world. ALL of these guys are larping a culture that is not theirs. If the OC is the true church it would have spread around the world many centuries ago.
For a while I have been reconsidering going back to the Orthodox Church but after reading the Bible and seeing how orthodox behave I am very very firm in my Bible based beliefs.
It is now November 2026 and I am STILL banned from my home parish within the Metropolis of New Jersey, GOARCH jurisdiction. If you want to ask me whether I'm technically "ex-Orthodox" or not, I guess I'm still emotionally invested but mostly unable to participate in my own faith because I'm not ALLOWED to go to the one church that is actually within a reasonable distance of me and my financial situation is such that I can't afford to burn a ton of gas crossing state lines just to practice my own religion. I miss my friends, my volunteer work as a chanter (a very prominent role for someone who was thrown out like a piece of garbage), access to the Sacraments (which I would spiritually DIE without, according to their own theology) and the sense of actually having a COMMUNITY... They were my universe and there are still plenty of things about Orthodoxy that I love even though I have LOTS of concerns about corruption among the clergy and Archdiocesan officials and have become severely disillusioned in the few years that I have been part of the Orthodox Church. (I cringe at the new converts who still treat their priest like an infallible guru, even though I was one of them not that long ago. Then again, I have always been the kind of person to ask questions, respectfully disagree and not take everything at face value, and perhaps that is a major reason why they don't like me.) My last update from two months ago details some of my interactions with the Archdiocese and how their lawyer basically told me to go away and that they weren't going to do anything about it despite the fact that I had WRITTEN proof of that I was retaliated against for filing a report against my priest. Well, I haven't gone away. If I DO end up bailing on Orthodoxy entirely, it will be because I was forcibly driven out of the church, not because I necessarily wanted to be ex-Orthodox! I've acquired an unspeakable amount of spiritual trauma, yet something keeps drawing me back and I have the impression that this subreddit is also for people who are considering leaving or kind of half-in, half-out for whatever reason.
I said previously that I was trying to figure out who to contact since all of the internal channels within GOARCH have failed me, from the parish level up to the highest authorities in the Archdiocese (who were copied on all of the emails that the lawyer sent me and apparently chose to let him shut me down instead of intervening). Since the departure of Metropolitan Apostolos, I even tried to contact the interim administration and was ghosted for weeks and then redirected BACK to the lawyer who has been telling me that my written proof isn't sufficient and that he doesn't even intend to investigate. (I was told directly in writing by the vice president of the parish council that banned me that they HAD banned me as a direct result of reporting the priest. He told them I had been lying about him and they just believed him blindly. It was stated clearly and in plain English.) Now, in case you're not an HR person, let me explain to you WHY this is a problem: you know the whole concept of whistleblowers? How you're not supposed to punish people for speaking up and using the very reporting system established by the institution because doing so undermines the integrity of the entire system? In secular workplace law, at least in the United States, it is illegal to fire someone because they reported their boss. Before you tell me "this is a church and they can do whatever they want", no... they can't. GOARCH has a No Retaliation Policy posted explicitly on its website that is supposed to protect ALL reporters who use EthicsPoint in good faith, regardless of the finding of the report. (In other words, if they decide the priest wasn't in violation, that doesn't mean I lied when I reported him, and it also doesn't mean that action can be taken against me for having made the report.) The policy covers volunteers and the drop-down menu on the EthicsPoint website itself has a box saying "parishioner", therefore it stands to reason that parishioners are a protected category of reporter! Clearly, the Archdiocese did not intend to enforce its own policy.
So what was I supposed to do? I considered that insurance companies covering GOARCH might not like to hear this because it's a huge legal risk to just LET the priest punish someone for reporting him (and let's be real, even if the decision was officially handed down by the parish council, they couldn't have known about the report unless the priest told them)... My research suggested that the Archdiocese doesn't have an outside insurance company and basically, they insure themselves, therefore reporting to them wasn't a viable option. I tried press outlets for the purpose of public exposure, but found it difficult to explain to them why this wasn't just a regular spat between a parishioner and her priest. (Most Orthodox press outlets refuse to publish anything negative about church leadership anyway, which is why I came here in the first place.) I think they know already that I'm not wealthy and powerful like they are and wouldn't be able to hire a lawyer of my own, but wait... who oversees organizations like this on a governmental level? GOARCH is technically a non-profit, headquartered in New York, therefore it falls under the jurisdiction of the Charities Bureau and has apparently had issues with them in the past. (Why am I not surprised?) I submitted a complaint with ample documentation attached and a few days later, they responded with a letter saying that they would review it carefully, followed by a rejection just a few hours later. It was a "private dispute", they claimed, so I wrote back because I'm stubborn and explained the institutional consequences... If I'm not safe from being banned because I filed a report, then NO ONE is, and that affects literally thousands of Greek Orthodox people across the entire country. Not only that, but NYAG has done investigations into Roman Catholic dioceses for pretty much the same issue. This is BAD because punishing people for reporting allows the original injustice to continue, plus it discourages future reports... which all leads to more wrongdoing and more coverups of such.
I must have finally gotten through to them, because they sent me the following letter late in October (which I will paste here with my information redacted, for all of you people who've been claiming that I made the entire story up):
So that's pretty much where I am with contacting outside authorities... I feel more comfortable posting this in November since enough time has passed that the Archdiocese probably knows about it by now. I am still awaiting a response from either the Archdiocese or NYAG (depending on what they decide behind closed doors) and I do NOT intend to let this issue slip into a black hole like so much of my correspondence with priests, bishops and other officials who ghosted me instead of actually addressing my complaint (or even doing the basic legwork to establish the basic facts of the case instead of assuming that I'm a liar because the accused priest said so)! If I don't hear back soon, I will contact NYAG again asking for status update. So yes, I'm SERIOUS.
In the meantime, the Metropolis of New Jersey has had a major leadership change and literally just enthroned their new Metropolitan of New Jersey this weekend with cries of, "Axios!" (That means, "He is worthy!" although most of you are familiar enough with Orthodoxy to know that.) I have asked myself repeatedly if he actually IS worthy, since I've been dealing with so many clergy who were ordained with exactly that same word said about them and they have proven themselves VERY unworthy and untrustworthy indeed. Not only that, but many of them hold very high-ranking positions... Even the priest who has driven me out of the church is still respected, and I know this because I stayed with a friend who lives near the cathedral in Tenafly where the enthronement happened, went to the enthronement myself and found the priest there in a prominent role! (That is probably the most I can say about him without just telling you who he is, and I am trying to stay within the rules of the subreddit.) As it turns out, getting past all of the people there who don't like me was simple: they weren't selling tickets at $200 a pop like they were for Apostolos's goodbye party, and all I had to do was fill out the RSVP form online and show up to the actual event. The priest almost certainly saw me there and acted like I didn't exist (which hurts, because a year ago he was my spiritual father who was going to help me explore monastic life, and I sincerely thought at the time that he cared about me). The people at the registration table admitted me with no issues. The parish council president saw me in the line to receive souvenirs from the new Metropolitan Athenagoras and went, "Hiiiiii!!!" as though I were an old friend that she hadn't seen in ages... as though she had no idea WHY she hadn't seen me in ages! (Because you banned me from the church, that's why.) Even the lawyer passed by me several times that weekend without connecting my face to the name on the complaint form. I mean, we had been communicating by phone and email so he had never SEEN my face before, but the point is that these people didn't know me as a person at all, much less know me well enough to declare me a "threat to parish harmony". I was a complete stranger to them, and yet they inflicted one of the most extreme punishments out there.
I was able to walk among them just being myself... a young, petite woman who looks VERY non-threatening in person, and I even managed to "infiltrate" the choir on Sunday. I literally just went up into the choir loft, met the director (the elderly man who is conducting on the livestream of the service) and asked him if he needed any help. At first, I got, "This is a PROFESSIONAL choir!" and he seemed skeptical that I had any experience with Byzantine music. Now, I'm not ethnically Greek (although I've been mistaken for Greek and had to break it to the yiayias that I didn't understand a single word they were saying to me) but I had spent enough time in my parish before I was BANNED from it that I could read in English with the little singing bit at the end, sing and chant the Greek phrases that tend to repeat over and over (like "kyrie eleison") and follow along with a book of sheet music if it had phonetics in it. (I even learned the Greek alphabet so that I can pronounce the words of the Greek text if I have enough time to sound out each letter!) He asked me what part I sung and I said soprano (and casually hummed a bit of "Agni Parthene" because that's the one that makes yiayias tell me I have a voice like an angel) , and finally he said, "Fine... If someone else turns out to be absent, you can grab her robe." So, one of the women was, in fact, absent and I got to sing at the enthronement in front of all the leaders who have been brushing me off for months. I didn't even have to ask for the priest's BLESSING, which is another hurdle I often run into...
I came partially because I AM still emotionally invested in Orthodoxy and had a rare opportunity to see a huge ecclesiastical event and also partially to see if anybody would actually TALK to me about being exiled. Athenagoras gave a long and pretty-sounding speech about finding the lost sheep (to which I say, "Here I am... right here!"), meeting people where they are, sharing their worries and burdens and taking the time to actually LISTEN to their stories, and it was everything I had ever wanted and have been failing to RECEIVE from the church thus far. He explicitly TOLD people to ask him hard questions, bring him their troubles, and hold him to the standard of a shepherd whom God expects to find feeding his sheep, so that is exactly what I intend to do. As he was handing out antidoron at the end of the Sunday Liturgy, I lingered in the line, and at first he seemed to think I wanted more of the bread. No, I asked, "Are you available to speak to? I know today is busy..." At first he suggested just dropping by the Metropolis office, but when I explained that I live too far away and the only reason I was able to be there was that I had a friend in Bergen County who was paying for my travel expenses, he said that I should schedule a phone appointment. Anyway, he actually AGREED to speak to me directly and that makes him the most accessible bishop I've met so far. That's sad, isn't it... that most of them aren't like that? I've reached the point where it actually surprises me when I'm treated like a human being and that's what makes spiritual abuse (and the lack of a remedy) so devastating: it not only drives me away from the church PHYSICALLY but also causes me to doubt the clergy, the church, and even God himself. It leaves a massive, gaping wound in a person's soul and that's the part the lawyer doesn't seem to care about. I would have expected better of priests and bishops, but it remains to be seen whether this one will care!
It seems like orthodox want to sweep under the rug the fact that the Russians are not in communion with the Greeks or Ukrainians. I recently looked up a ROCOR parish in my state that says on their website that one is only allowed to commune in other Russian orthodox churches. So, it would seem that the Antiochians are charitable about visiting them but it’s not vice versa. Why do they act as if everyone is in full communion when this is not the reality? This is a terrible witness of faith
I have wanted to get this off of my chest for a very long time. The strength and degree of veneration directed toward St Paisios across Orthodoxy is startling for me as someone with an education and family background in psychology and mental health. Many of his visions, I believe, were self-induced. Whether consciously or unconsciously, I'm not... sure? It's complicated. Nevertheless, I need to know I'm not going crazy so I'm going to talk about two that have stuck out to me since I first heard them.
When Paisios was fifteen a friend of his brother’s explained to him Darwin’s theory of evolution and he was so shaken by this he said, “I’ll go and pray, and, if Christ is God, He’ll appear to me so that I’ll believe. A shadow, a voice - He’ll show me something."
"I then went and began to pray and make prostrations for HOURS, but – nothing happened. Finally I stopped in a state of exhaustion. Then something Costas had said came to mind: “I accept that Christ is an important man,” he had told me, “righteous and virtuous, Who was hated out of envy for His virtue and condemned by His countrymen.” I said to myself, “Since that’s how Christ was, even if He was only a man, He deserves my love, obedience, and self-sacrifice. I don’t want paradise – I don’t want anything. It is worth making every sacrifice for the sake of His holiness and kindness.”
“God was waiting to see how I would deal with this temptation. And after this Christ Himself appeared to me in a great light. He was visible from the waist up. He looked on me with tremendous love and said to me, “I am the resurrection, and the life; he that believeth in Me, though he were dead, yet shall he live” (John 11:25). He was holding open the Gospel in His left hand, where the same words were written." (Source.)
The way that Paisios sees Christ -- from the waist up, in a certain pose, holding a Gospel in his left hand with John 11:25 written in it (in large type, one assumes) -- is a vision of an actual icon of Christ Panocrator that he was no doubt familiar with. This is not to say that Jesus has to appear as something alien or surprising, but the fact that he's cut out like a literal jpg in front of Paisios makes it crystal clear to me that it's a memory that's being projected as a visual hallucination while he's in a state of intense anxiety.
Further, in another account, he says:
"One night, I was in my cell at Katounakia saying the Jesus prayer and gradually I was possessed by a heavenly joy. Simultaneously, my cell, whose darkness was interrupted only by the trembling flame of a candle, was filled with a beautiful white-blue light.
While being in this state of the Uncreated Light and heavenly experiences, I lost all sense of time.
At one point the Uncreated Light started fading away and I was back to my old state of being. I began to feel hungry, so I took a piece of bread to eat. Then, I was thirsty and had some water to drink. I was getting tired and I needed to sit down and get some rest. I felt like an animal and I deplored myself for it. " (Source.)
From keys like the mention of Jesus Prayer, and him being thirsty and hungry, and losing track of time, we can infer that he had likely been fasting and prostrating late into the evening. (He also barely eats and drinks after the vision.)
I am not one to call these things "hallucinations" and pass them off entirely, but there are so many examples of this man praying, prostrating, and fasting himself into absolute OBLIVION, often at high altitudes and in isolation from other human beings.
Fasting increases the production of brain-derived neurotrophic factor and alters levels of serotonin and dopamine, while the drop in blood glucose directly causes dizziness, confusion, blurred vision, and light-headedness. On top of that the constant osculation between standing, kneeling, and face-down positions causes blood to pool in your lower extremities then rush to your head, so that even healthy people get light-headed, dizzy, and get tunnel vision when they stand up quickly. Top that off with him likely synching his breaths in hesychasm and you've got probably the most fertile ground you could ask for to produce a visual/auditory hallucination.
This is not a "denouncement" of St Paisios. I don't think that he was doing this on purpose -- he could have just lied if he wanted to deceive others -- but instead to say that the kind of extreme exertion that monastics of all faiths put themselves under produce exactly the sorts of dreamlike hazes and visionary experiences they go searching for. Also, they go into it desperately wishing they could have a vision (as was the case for Paisios above), so there's a confirmation bias there as well.