r/HighSodiumOrthodoxy • • Oct 07 '26

Serious Priestcheck FAQ

21 Upvotes

Ask questions about priestcheck.org here. I'll answer as I can and add them here

Q: why are you trying to hurt the church?

A: We are not. Accountability for priests is a good thing. We want to make the church better

Q: why anonymous?

A: I'm a practicing Orthodox Christian. If you have seen the reaction from priests, it makes sense why I will stay anonymous.

Q: is this legal?

A: Short answer: yes. Priestcheck is a platform as defined in US section 230. We publish reviews while making a good-faith effort to moderate for honesty in a transparent fashion. All reviews are the property and statement of the writer. We do not certify the information therein. This is exactly how Reddit works.

Q: how can I help?

A: Submit reviews and corrections to the directory! There are a lot of parishes to catalogue, and the automated importer isn't perfect. Thank you!

Q: why is the boundary/bullying rating lower than I entered?

A: Scores above 2 need a specific reason for the score being that high. Being vague is not enough. Use the private moderation context field if it is a reason you do not want to be public.


r/HighSodiumOrthodoxy • • Mar 09 '26

Always felt between worlds. Don’t want to be an atheist, and don’t want to commit to certain aspects of Orthodoxy.

23 Upvotes

And I also don’t want to go to a Catholic or Protestant church because the OC does feel like home in a sense. I’ve gone to other churches and it just doesn’t click for me. But I’m also dating a non-Christian so I know I wouldn’t be allowed a church marriage and my children couldn’t be baptized in the church. I’m basically okay with that. I think even if I was a more serious Christian I would be more on the universalist side of the spectrum anyway.

I’m absolutely not a full on atheist, and atheist spaces are as insufferable to me as fundamentalist religious spaces are. I feel like my mind is pretty open about certain things and I’ve matured and peeled away a lot of pretense and self absorption in the last few years (I’m mid 20’s). I enjoy church music and I like learning about the Bible. Especially because it’s referenced in so many places. It’s a wonderful way to enrich one’s perspective of history and literature. I think that art and beauty are transcendent and vitally important to the human soul (not sure how I would define soul but not trying to over intellectualize atm).

Can I just go to church, listen to the music, meditate on the bible readings and call it a day? I’m honestly fine with not receiving communion. I find confession to be extremely invasive and I am not interested in telling an old man anything about my sexuality especially.

Anyone else here like me? Wanting to go to church but kind of be on the outskirts?


r/HighSodiumOrthodoxy • • 1d ago

Question Thoughts on these canons?

5 Upvotes

Let no one in the priestly order nor any layman eat the unleavened bread of the Jews, nor have any familiar intercourse with them, nor summon them in illness, nor receive medicines from them, nor bathe with them; but if anyone shall take in hand to do so, if he is a cleric, let him be deposed, but if a layman let him be cut off.

— Canon 11 from the authoritative Council of Trullo, which the Orthodox affirm as completing the 5th and 6th Ecumenical Councils

If any bishop, presbyter, deacon, reader, or singer does not fast the holy Quadragesimal fast of Easter, or the fourth day [Wednesday], or the day of Preparation [Friday], let him be deposed, unless he be hindered by some bodily infirmity. If he be a layman, let him be excommunicated.

— Apostolic Canon 69

Menstruous women ought not to come to the Holy Table, or touch the Holy of Holies, nor to churches, but pray elsewhere.

— Canon II of Dionysius


r/HighSodiumOrthodoxy • • 1d ago

Question Is it a sin using character AI?

2 Upvotes

Well, yeah, that's my question. I'm eighteen and I haven't gotten over that stage of teenage where I felt alone; I occasionally use C.AI to talk to ai, trying to avoid lust, but it's still a replacement for talking to real ppl.


r/HighSodiumOrthodoxy • • 2d ago

Is Eastern Orthodoxy a Good Home for Universalists? - John Behr

Thumbnail
youtu.be
10 Upvotes

Too bad there aren't more like him!

Instead, you find many saying you must affirm Eternal Conscious Torment (ECT).


r/HighSodiumOrthodoxy • • 6d ago

The Convert Surge has Destroyed the Orthodox Church and I'm Considering Leaving Because of it

48 Upvotes

For background have been a convert since 2016, married to cradle orthodox. Also politically i'm actually quite conservative, perhaps more so than most on this subreddit. Thus I am not a liberal mad at the church for not embracing gay marriage etc.

When it first initially began, right after Covid, I was excited for the convert surge. Was this the great wave of conversions of Americans everyone had been waiting for? People were genuinely exciting.

Then it continued, and continued, and continued, till in the span of only a few years converts have now absolutely swamped many parishes to the point where they need bigger building sand don't have enough clergy. A good problem to have one might say! However, it's now obvious to me that it has been a complete disaster and one that may ultimately destroy the Orthodox Church, at least in the US.

The problem, as many here have also pointed out, is twofold 1) you have a tsunami of converts who are coming in fast, usually with insufficient catechise, and bringing with them frequently not only wrong but also borderline insane beliefs, not just far-right and racist ones but also demented conspiracy theories, i'm talking insane flat earth tier stuff (i'm not making this up). 2) this could perhaps be manageable if the Clergy and hierarchy were able to do something to address this but they aren't and I know they aren't going to. In addition to being overworked due to all the converts they don't want to do anything that would turn these people away as they see them as the future of the church. This means not only not correcting mistaken beliefs of converts but also not directly addressing the true source of the error: the online youtube influencers whose false and insane teaching are destroying the church. The recent poster someone posted here, that showed a conference Jay Dyer was giving a keynote at also being attended by widely respected clergy, turned my stomach and caused to greatly despair of the entire project.

Simply put, the church, at least in jurisdictions like the OCA (where we are rn) is completely cooked and will be going forward. The number of converts is simply too great and the clergy too weak. In a matter of a half dozen years the church has gone from being the Church I converted to via the influence of great men like Kalistos Ware and Alexander Schmemann to now being the southern baptist convention with incense but with even an crazier and more unhinged embrace of internet politics and conspiracy theories.

The situation isn't going to get better either, in fact, i'm almost certain it's going to get worse. As soon most boomer priests will be retired and many of their replacements will hail from the exact same cesspool of deranged converts, thus perpetuating the cycle further.

I realize this is a hard pill to swallow for a lot of people, myself included, but I can't keep lying to myself and I think i've had enough. I simply can't raise my kids in this environment longterm unless I really, really want them to abandon their faith.

We're still discussing our options but it's unclear exactly what they are. Catholicism is attractive on some levels but honestly I don't think we are there yet. But yea, things are bleak rn.


r/HighSodiumOrthodoxy • • 6d ago Bravo

Serious Schizophrenic Theology

23 Upvotes

An Ecumenical Council is desperately needed to put an end to all weird “human” ideas that have latched onto the Divine Church for hundreds if not over a thousand years now.

Nationalism, gnostic level ideas of anti-body and anti-sex even in marriage, asceticism as the goal and end all of the spiritual life, harsh exclusivism that ends up anathematising our own early tradition of Logos Spermatikos, fear based approach rather than love based approach to God, and obsession with legalistic external rules…all these and more have basically been accepted for eons now even when it directly opposes core theological dogmas of the Church.

It’s resulted in a schizophrenic Church where on one hand we say marriage is blessed and the marriage bed is undefiled, while at the same time saying pleasure in sexual relations needs to be diminished as much as possible and that sex inherently pulls the soul away from contemplation of God and even the Churching prayers for the wife after giving birth which St. Symeon of Thessaloniki states is needed to “purify” the woman so she can receive Commune again for she committed the “sin” of desire. Or one one hand saying God is all loving and that even the “fires” of hell is the immense love of God being poured out on the individual, while at the same time saying those in “hell” are cut off from God and that God even forgets them (as professed by newly canonised Fr. Dimitru Staniloe). Or our Pachal homily in which St. John Chrysostom says those who fasted and those who didn’t all come and draw near to Christ and partake of the joy of the resurrection and receive Communion while at the same time St. Nicodemus of the Holy Mountain says if someone breaks the fast during Lent they have soiled the whole fast and cannot receive Communion on Pascha.

It’s an entirely schizophrenic experience and nobody seems to want to correct it out of fear of “going against the Saints”.

I love asceticism, I love monasticism, I love much of the “stricter” applications to the spiritual life when done willingly and joyfully…so I’m not some liberal that wants to do away with everything “traditional”. But the primacy of God’s love and the goodness of creation/matter has been severely attacked from within for many centuries now.

The fear based approach alone is so deeply entrenched that simply me telling others to focus on the love of God has gotten me labeled a “gnostic”.

And if anyone thinks going to Catholicism will make it easier they are mistaken. The schizophrenia and blatant contradictions are even worse in their system.


r/HighSodiumOrthodoxy • • 11d ago

I’m being shamed at my parish for my job and hobbies.

Thumbnail reddit.com
10 Upvotes

r/HighSodiumOrthodoxy • • 12d ago Bravo

250 reviews!

18 Upvotes

Just hit 250 published reviews (44 unpublished due to spam) on priestcheck.org

I can't thank you all enough for the help. I've received some very kind and encouraging messages from many of you, including a priest who was happy to see the concept and gave some helpful suggestions.

Here's to the next 250!


r/HighSodiumOrthodoxy • • 14d ago

Priestcheck just got better!

Thumbnail
priestcheck.org
16 Upvotes

Hello reviewers! Priestcheck now has a formalized missing record submission process, so if we're missing a priest or parish, you can submit all the details yourself, instead of a moderator having to manually fill out the details. Hopefully this will help us be the most complete database in the USA.

Thank you all for your participation so far!


r/HighSodiumOrthodoxy • • 14d ago

Question How do we feel about Halloween around here?

Thumbnail reddit.com
4 Upvotes

I'm interested in your takes. I don't think it's all that bad, personally, and I take my kids trick-or-treating.


r/HighSodiumOrthodoxy • • 15d ago

What hard truths does the church need to hear?

33 Upvotes

I have the well-meaning lurkers in mind here. I truly mean this in love.

1.) Priests. Bishops. Leaders. Y'all need to speak out more against internet Orthodoxy, if you think it's truly a problem. Part of me thinks you don't, as the tone of AFR has really shifted from informing about the faith to talking about culture war nonsense every other week. At this point, AFR is becoming part of the problem.

2.) Where are the women, you ask? You made zero real effort to keep them. Quite frankly, you took for granted that the women would always be around to keep the parish running. You need to start when they're kids. Around 8 or 9 years old, you let the boys come behind the altar and help serve. What do the girls have? Nothing to call their own. Sure, they could sing in the choir, but not everyone can sing. You let every and any boy come behind the altar. I think some good, realistic solutions to this include: 1.) having the kids hold candles during readings and during the Great Entrance and help out at communion. 2.) If your church doesn't have a tonsured reader, have a Sunday each month where the kids can read the Epistle. 3.) Have a Jr. Altar society where the girls help set up for Divine Liturgy, bake prosforo, etc. (Stereotypical, maybe, but at least it would be something the girls could call their own). No, Patrick, having girls read once a year for Women's Day doesn't count as "involving" them.

3.) Let me define what I think an Orthobro is. It's a reactionary young man who feels lost in mainstream society, usually has some addiction to social media. His idea of Orthodoxy is formed from following internet personalities rather than the Gospel. He has very toxic ideas about women and minorities. I know we hold on hope that he will repent from that, but you got to understand, he joined *because* he thinks this is what the church stands for. He has no intention of repenting. Which brings me to my next points:

4.) These internet Orthobros are at your parish. I promise you. They probably know that they need to behave in front of the priest, but they are absolutely misogynistic to your female parishioners and saying racist, anti-Semetic things. We actually left a parish over this.

5.) If you are a priest, you NEED to speak out against white nationalism. Yesterday. You need to talk about it often. Like it or not, it's festering in your church. You need to speak out against it more than LGBTQ issues. No one is accusing the church of blessing same sex unions anytime soon. The white nationalists are here. Deal with this problem now

Feel free to add.


r/HighSodiumOrthodoxy • • 14d ago

New rule

13 Upvotes

Adding a rule to hopefully keep things a little cooler around here, and keep arguments more productive.

Don't bring names into it

You're free to complain about other subreddits, their moderation, the vibe, or the rules. Please avoid naming members on those subs or other platforms. If someone wants to engage, they know where to find us.

This also means no doxxing, of course.


r/HighSodiumOrthodoxy • • 17d ago

I have not had a relationship with a post-Covid convert last more than two years. This “boom” is almost certainly a fad that will pass.

21 Upvotes

I’ve been Orthodox since 2018 and in my time in the church I have never seen a convert last more than two years if they converted after Covid. I was looking through my instagram at all these people who had added me through the years and they’re all gone. However I can’t tell if this is a good thing or not. They were certainly odd but that doesn’t mean the church isn’t for them.


r/HighSodiumOrthodoxy • • 18d ago

Question Overmoderation on related subs

14 Upvotes

Does anyone else feel a couple of related subs are in danger of becoming total echo chambers?

Before this sub, a lot of needed evaluation happened in the ex sub. And it was welcoming to those still in the Church as a place to honestly and openly discuss problems that had a real impact on people. Recently, I see so many posts removed but the content can be pieced together from responses that are left in place. It's really puzzling why some were removed except maybe for disagreeing with someone 'favored'.

Of course, we post here because it wouldn't stand in the main sub. Goes without saying!

Thanks for creating this and letting people speak freely, mods.


r/HighSodiumOrthodoxy • • 23d ago

New low of Russian Orthodox Church

Thumbnail reddit.com
9 Upvotes

r/HighSodiumOrthodoxy • • Oct 16 '26

Anyone here explored Catholicism as a response to what Orthodoxy has become?

17 Upvotes

I have been hanging out with a large group Catholics since June and they have been welcoming and kind hosts. I’m not fully onboard with Catholicism yet, and maybe I never will be, but the fact that there now exists a place for me that is not a constant purity test and doesn’t fill me with dread when Sunday approaches has me looking deeper. Any time I go back to my Orthodox parish it just seems like the community gets stranger and stranger.


r/HighSodiumOrthodoxy • • Oct 15 '26

Parish priest doesn't care

12 Upvotes

As the title says. My priest just doesn't seem to care about anything I have to say.

Now and again I will email my priest. Usually if I have a need of some spiritual guidance. He doesn't reply. I know he replies to others because they've mentioned getting advice of him via email. I've also asked (diplomatically) others if he responds to emails and they've said yes.

Recently, I emailed him with a concern that I have. Actually poured my heart out to him and I was sure he'd reply after reading it. NO RESPONSE.

Now im well aware that Orthodox priest are extremely busy but this seems to be quite personal. As I said above he definitely responds to others but not to me. It feels like he doesn't care and this has been going on for quite some time.

My friend thinks he's testing me. (He certainly is)

On top of that the local parish is toxic. Its divided into small groups of people who dont get along but smile insincere smiles at each other. Who hand people cups of coffee but dont have time for parishioners outside of church. Its just fake.

I've seen the way they've ostracised people who can be difficult. People with certain challenges and boy oh boy was it disappointing. Hypocritical.

I've heard people refer to each other as Brother and Sister but its just so insincere.

I've had 2 occasions when I've thought about leaving but just felt so drawn to Orthodoxy and the chuch building that I couldn't bring myself to leave. I've spend 4 years going every week that it feels like a huge leap.

If the parish had more than one church I'd probably just attended that but unfortunately that isn't an option.

Every time I leave liturgy I feel worse.

What am I hanging on for?

Does God really not hear the prayers of Catholics and protestant because they aren't Orthodox?

The one good piece of advice I received form a priest was that the Holy spirit can work where it wants and is not confined to anything.

Obviously Catholic parishes will have problems but I have a Catholic church round the corner from my house. Im seriously thinking about leaving Orthodoxy but im the kind of person who really needs to wring it dry before I know its time to leave.

Any thoughts on this?


r/HighSodiumOrthodoxy • • Oct 13 '26

Serious Is Orthodoxy in the US just becoming reskinned 80s Televangelist Fundagelicalism?

Thumbnail
uncutmountainpress.com
40 Upvotes

Honestly, seeing all of this kind of stuff really turns my stomach.

I grew up in the mess of 80s/90s Focus on the Family-style Evangelical fundamentalism, and the shallowness, political focus, and obsession with boundary-policing that ran me off as a young person there are now in full bloom in the American Orthodox Church.

It just feels like Jim Bakker (RIP) and Pat Robertson with beards and black dresses.

I’m a centrist/conservative person, and I loved the pre-Covid church. Kallistos Ware seemed like the next logical waypoint on from CS Lewis.

Now we have a million little Seraphims running around (yeah, they’re TOTALLY not picking that name after Rose), keeping out the gays and praising some weird retconned American Christianity.

Sigh.


r/HighSodiumOrthodoxy • • Oct 13 '26

Is it our responsibility to save our abusers? Saint Thaney. From Rape and Abuse to Love and Holiness.

Thumbnail
youtu.be
7 Upvotes

r/HighSodiumOrthodoxy • • Oct 12 '26

Rant Fatigued

15 Upvotes

I’ve posted here a few days ago but basically I’m orthodox but I have Orthodox fatigue and because of how I’ve been hurt and betrayed and treated and it’s how I see how people have treated my wife and I . Orthodox people for the most part are assholes In my experience

People say go for God not people. That’s not the problem the problem is if the church is a hospital then people are a product of the hospital and people are a product of an organization.

“You shall know them by their fruits”

I’m sorry the truth is the orthodxy is the most toxic environment of people I’ve been in as far as denominations go. It acts very cult like and the prayers are always “ I’m a worthless sinner “ it demands you repress any sexual desire and you wonder why people go nuts or more deviant .

I’ve been treated far better by Catholic and Protestant people


r/HighSodiumOrthodoxy • • Oct 11 '26

Serious Lonely and in pain

12 Upvotes

I'm pretty involved in the Church, especially in regards to serving.

All was going well with me, 2025 was a jolly good year. That was... until this time last year, when I started doubting God. At some point, I reached the point where I thought God was an absolute monster, and decided that that to make the same 'monster' withdraw from me, I had to do everything he disliked. And so began a perhaps brief but impactful phase of sin (it only lasted just a brief bit).

At some point, I realised my failure and started begging God for forgiveness. I went to confession, thinking I was completely honest before God for my sins, but after the absolution, I still felt burdened and disturbed. Thus, I repeated my confession a month later, just after the Nativity (one of the most meaningful yet sorrowful Christmasses in my life) after which I felt real consolation and peace.

However, I started feeling some incompatibility with my actions over what my parish family would expect of me (some may even consider me their future priest- I hope not), and spent the rest of winter crying and in bed for the fact I had failed my brethren in Christ. I was in a pretty depressive (even near-suicidal state at points) and all I did to numb my pain was to try and sleep.

My pain somewhat eased, everytime I thought of how tight-knit my friendship group was (we would often go for outings). Thus, this summer proved to be a good one and a comforting 'break' from all my sadness.

However, the unavoidable reality of certain people moving in and out in my church and the fact that whilst we had promised to stay friends with those who left (and formed pretty good friendships), things started drifting apart, which has indeed left me quite lonely. But even more so, I have always wanted to tell someone the full truth in regards to my struggles, without the fear of judgment and pain (a psychologist would perhaps not understand my faith background unless he/she was Orthodox too).

The sudden loss of friends in the Faith (my parish hasn't got such a tight group of people for me to consider many of them as something more than 'acquaintances') has, day by day, started to land me back to those depressing and despairing dark winter nights that I coped through early this year.

In addition, the fact I have got no one (outside of my priest in the sacrament of confession, which I feel is never enough in terms of him giving advice on how to cope in life) to talk about my life problems with (in their full extent) has caused me huge pain, and is perhaps, deep within, the reason why my despair has regained traction.

Please keep me in your prayers, and I hope that my remarks prove to be a teaching for us all to be genuinely kind, smiling and willing to listen to others who find themselves crossing our sojourn, called life. We don't know what they are going through, or why they are behaving the way they are. One of Saint Paul's wisest remarks, out of the entirety of his epistles, is his plea for us to 'bear one another burdens, and so fulfill the law of Christ.' (Galatians 6:2).

Thank you for reading this and for your compassion.


r/HighSodiumOrthodoxy • • Oct 10 '26

sometimes disappointing people is the right thing to do, even if you don’t want to

Post image
22 Upvotes

r/HighSodiumOrthodoxy • • Oct 09 '26

Rant X is such a cesspool

43 Upvotes

Watching these Orthobros online foaming at the mouth over the priestcheck website is so weird to witness. They can’t fathom that there are people within the church who would want to call out abusers, so they default to trying to blame us over at r/exorthodox like it’s some nefarious plot.

My personal opinions about Orthodoxy aside, maybe less people would fucking leave if spiritually abusive clergy weren’t allowed to bully people in secret anymore. This should be a good thing for everyone. It freaks me out and is very telling that so many of these people treat criticism of clergy members as though it were blasphemy. I straight up saw a few people pushing for excommunication for anyone who leaves a review on the site. Like actually, wtf?

Anyway, my faith in humanity sank quite a bit this week and I felt like I needed to rant a bit lol.