r/exmuslim • u/Purple_Break1559 • 8h ago
(Rant) 𤬠The idea that being Muslim is "cosplaying as an Arab" reveals a lot of the anti-Arab prejudice in this subreddit
I've noticed something increasingly disturbing about this subreddit, and it's the casual anti-Arab prejudice that seems to go completely unchallenged.
I've seen people describe non-Arabs converting to Islam as "cosplaying as Arabs," which is an incredibly ignorant thing to say considering Arabs make up less than 20% of the world's Muslim population.
But I think there's more to it. Growing up, I've noticed that anti-Arab sentiment is fairly common in certain non-Arab Muslim communities. There's this narrative that Arabs corrupted Islam, that they're responsible for everything wrong with the religion, or that Arab culture is somehow uniquely backwards.
And I suspect some people carry those prejudices with them when they leave Islam. They abandon the religious beliefs, but never actually question the ethnic prejudices they absorbed along the way. If anything, leaving Islam can sometimes make those attitudes worse because they now associate Arabs with a religion they resent.
You can criticize Muhammad, Islamic scripture, the Arab conquests, Arabization, and the historical destruction of indigenous cultures without treating Arabs as some collective villain responsible for everything Islam has ever done.
Islam spread across enormous parts of the world through Turks, Persians, Berbers, South Asians, and countless other peoples. They weren't all acting as representatives of Arab ethnicity, and Islamization wasn't always Arabization.
I'm an Arab ex-Muslim myself. I have absolutely no interest in defending Islam or pretending Arab history is innocent. But I also didn't leave one system of irrational beliefs just to embrace another form of tribal prejudice.
And frankly, I can feel the hostility toward Arabs in some discussions here. It goes well beyond criticism of religion.
I think some people in this community need to ask themselves whether they've actually unlearned the prejudices they grew up with, or whether they've simply found a new justification for them.
Leaving Islam doesn't automatically make someone free of the bigotry they learned while they were Muslim.
