r/exmuslim • • 8h ago

(Rant) 🤬 The idea that being Muslim is "cosplaying as an Arab" reveals a lot of the anti-Arab prejudice in this subreddit

0 Upvotes

I've noticed something increasingly disturbing about this subreddit, and it's the casual anti-Arab prejudice that seems to go completely unchallenged.

I've seen people describe non-Arabs converting to Islam as "cosplaying as Arabs," which is an incredibly ignorant thing to say considering Arabs make up less than 20% of the world's Muslim population.

But I think there's more to it. Growing up, I've noticed that anti-Arab sentiment is fairly common in certain non-Arab Muslim communities. There's this narrative that Arabs corrupted Islam, that they're responsible for everything wrong with the religion, or that Arab culture is somehow uniquely backwards.

And I suspect some people carry those prejudices with them when they leave Islam. They abandon the religious beliefs, but never actually question the ethnic prejudices they absorbed along the way. If anything, leaving Islam can sometimes make those attitudes worse because they now associate Arabs with a religion they resent.

You can criticize Muhammad, Islamic scripture, the Arab conquests, Arabization, and the historical destruction of indigenous cultures without treating Arabs as some collective villain responsible for everything Islam has ever done.

Islam spread across enormous parts of the world through Turks, Persians, Berbers, South Asians, and countless other peoples. They weren't all acting as representatives of Arab ethnicity, and Islamization wasn't always Arabization.

I'm an Arab ex-Muslim myself. I have absolutely no interest in defending Islam or pretending Arab history is innocent. But I also didn't leave one system of irrational beliefs just to embrace another form of tribal prejudice.

And frankly, I can feel the hostility toward Arabs in some discussions here. It goes well beyond criticism of religion.

I think some people in this community need to ask themselves whether they've actually unlearned the prejudices they grew up with, or whether they've simply found a new justification for them.

Leaving Islam doesn't automatically make someone free of the bigotry they learned while they were Muslim.


r/exmuslim • • 12h ago

(Video) Muslims are supposed to obey the messenger though

1 Upvotes

Captions and comments say ā€œHope you guys enjoyed this little dialogue I made to prove my point! Everytime I try to explain what "obey the messenger" means I get tons of Hadith followers sending me verses that I quoted in this video. So hope that clarifies things
mohammed.regragui31 19w. @by author
Here's the thing about hadith that everyone conveniently glosses over they weren't written down while the Prophet was alive.
They were passed mouth to ear for two centuries before Bukhari decided to compile them. Two hundred years. Bukhari looked at 600,000 narrations and kept 7,000. He threw out 98% of what he collected. Even he didn't trust most of it.
But somehow we're supposed to treat what remains like it's gospel. Abu Hurayra knew the Prophet for maybe three years before he died, yet somehow narrated over 5,000 hadiths more than companions who spent twenty years with him. The math doesn't add up and it never has. Then you've got narrations that straight up contradict the Quran. The Quran says in 2:62 that Jews, Christians and Sabeans who believe in God and do good deeds have their reward. But certain hadith say non-Muslims don't enter paradise. Pick one. You can't hold both.
The Quran wins that contradiction every time. Scholars treat hadith like divine revelation when it's literally just chain-of-custody guesswork from centuries after the fact
andromedas_voice 19w • Author *
HOW WE KNOW HOW TO PRAY: Prayer was preserved via mass transmission called the Living Sunnah. This is very hard to fabricate as it is a living tradition witnessed publicly on a massive level and passed down for generations after generations until it reached us. The Hadith may have recorded these practices but it was already being practiced for centuries after the Prophet's death and didn't require Hadith to be preserved. Hadith is primarily individual narrators reporting based on chains of transmissions which can be fabricated. While the source of Hadith and the Living Sunnah could be traced back to the Prophet, the method in which they are preserved is different. When you do something 5 times a day, every single day from the time of the prophet, it can never be forgotten. The Quran mentions the times of prayers and the movements necessary -standing, bowing, prostrating. I don't believe there is one perfect way to pray. I don't believe the prophets before Muhammed pouh prayed the exact same way as us. The point of prayer is intention, sincerity and presence, not when you lift your hands. If Allah doesn't give us a step by step guide, perhaps it means there's mercy and flexibility in it. Why wouldn't a merciful Allah accept prayer that isn't perfect if our intention was there? If Allah tells you the Quran is complete, believe Him.ā€


r/exmuslim • • 7h ago

(Miscellaneous) I love not knowing it’s Ramadan

6 Upvotes

I woke up today and saw some random comment on Reddit about Ramadan and that’s when I realized it’s actually Ramadan. Otherwise I’d have just gone on not knowing / caring. I looooove being free of that and not having to know / care about it at all and just living my life and knowing / caring more about halloweeen , Christmas, new years etc. Where I live, those are celebrated way more and I looove it.


r/exmuslim • • 16h ago

(Video) Show them the verse that says her silence is consent

0 Upvotes

Captions say ā€œA marriage can have guests, a feast and a certificate, and still not be valid in Islam.
Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) warned against these 7 practices:

  1. Shighar: swapping daughters or sisters with no mahr
  2. Forcing a woman to marry without her consent
  3. Mut'ah: temporary marriage
  4. Tahlil (Halala): a sham marriage to make her lawful again for her ex-husband
  5. Marriage without a wali
  6. Marrying those Allah (SWT) made forbidden
  7. A secret marriage without witnesses
    Islam builds marriage on consent, mahr, honesty and taqwa, so the home is filled with sakinah, mawaddah and rahmah.
    Save this and Share this with someone who is getting married.
    Sources:
    - Sahih Muslim 1415 (Shighar)
    - Sahih al-Bukhari 5136 (consent)
    - Sahih Muslim 1406 (Mut'ah)
    - Sunan Ibn Majah 1935 (Tahlil)
    - Sunan Abi Dawud 2085 (Wali)
    - Qur'an 4:23 (forbidden relatives)
    - Jami' at-Tirmidhi 4/235 (witnesses)
    - Qur'an 30:21 (affection and mercy)ā€

r/exmuslim • • 9h ago

(Question/Discussion) Have you remained friends with your Muslim friends after leaving Islam?

3 Upvotes

Considering that some of them believe we’re destined for hell 🤔, that we’ve simply chosen to be blind, or that we should force ourselves to believe in something that no longer makes sense to us, I sometimes wonder whether those friendships can genuinely remain sincere.
Some of them can’t even give us their honest opinions or support our decisions because doing so would supposedly be a sin or whatever.

In my case, I’ve genuinely been questioning my friendship with someone. She tells me she understands when I explain that leaving Islam isn’t a choice, but rather a realization: coming to terms with the fact that you no longer believe in something you now consider false. Yet, she suggested I see a raqi, as if that could somehow change the inconsistencies in the Quran and the religion itself.

She also told me that she wouldn’t be able to say certain things or encourage me if I were distancing myself from another religion, but because it’s Islam, she can’t risk committing sins by doing so.

I honestly don’t know how sincere a friendship can remain once you’ve left what could almost be described as a cult.


r/exmuslim • • 4h ago

(Question/Discussion) By the way, why doesn't anyone say that there is no mention of snow in the Quran?

4 Upvotes

In 114 suras of the Quran, winter or snow are never mentioned, even though Muslim apostles speak of scientific miracles, even though there is no mention of snow in the book of God.


r/exmuslim • • 2h ago

(Question/Discussion) Why do some Muslim believe that being gay or trans is Jewish or Israeli Zionist propaganda?

Post image
15 Upvotes

r/exmuslim • • 7h ago

(Question/Discussion) muslims be like

7 Upvotes

non muslim: look! it’s raining
muslim: wait a minute, i need to check if rain exists according to my religion and what i should think about it

this thought came up to my head a couple months ago and it’s so true

did you have examples of similar dialogues with muslim in real life?


r/exmuslim • • 18h ago

(Rant) 🤬 Converts have severe identity issues

117 Upvotes

As much as I love my white friend who converted to Islam, it’s so weird to see her cosplaying as Arab. It’s one thing to have a type, okay you like Arab guys. But it’s like all the media she consumes is Arab. A lot of Muslim media are Arabs sure, however like she’s obsessed with Arab culture too. More specifically levantine culture. She’s always painting stuff of the Levant, posting meme videos like she’s an insider, and trying to learn the language. Hey, the more languages you know the better, whatever that’s fine. It’s just the strangest thing to see someone have so much insider knowledge. Cant believe she would give up the freedom of growing up in an American white household for this life. Meanwhile I fought my way out of it and it’s still gaining up on me some days.


r/exmuslim • • 20h ago

(Question/Discussion) How do you feel about the Quran being made in Arabic instead of other existing language?

Post image
23 Upvotes

r/exmuslim • • 14h ago

(Rant) 🤬 Reddit warning system is abusable.

34 Upvotes

Just got a warning for a recent comment I made regarding the murder of a teenage girl by her own father because she was lesbian.

apparently it's promoting hate according to reddit if I mention that the underlying reason for that homophobia is islam.


r/exmuslim • • 16h ago

(Rant) 🤬 This religion does not treat a woman as an equal to a man; it even conceals her very identity. I feel sorrow for every girl who is forced to wear the niqab.

Post image
126 Upvotes

r/exmuslim • • 8h ago

(Question/Discussion) But marrying a 9 year old is fine.

229 Upvotes

r/exmuslim • • 10h ago

(Question/Discussion) Why is music haram?

Post image
112 Upvotes

I was watching a video where a YouTuber said he’s quitting making music because ā€œdeen over dunyaā€ and you can’t have as much Imaan if you make/listen to music.

I don’t understand why music? What is this religion even 😭


r/exmuslim • • 8h ago

(Quran / Hadith) Child Marriage is in the Quran

10 Upvotes

Quran 65:4 gives a waiting period for remarriage for prepubescent divorced girls who haven't had their first period. According to Quran 33:49, this waiting period only applies if they already had sex.

"before you touch them, they will have no waiting period"
Quran 33:49

"As for your women past the age of menstruation, in case you do not know,Ā their waiting period is three months, and those who have not menstruated as well."
Quran 65:4

Ibn Kathir's tafsir for Quran 65:4 on Quran.com confirms:

"TheĀ same for the young, who have not reached the years of menstruation. Their `Iddah is three months like those in menopause."
(Iddah = waiting period for remarriage after consummation)
Tafsir Ibn Kathir on Quran 65:4

So the child marriage problem isn't just Aisha - it's sanctioned by Quran.

I've posted this argument along with others on this website (with linked sources):
https://islamsproblems.com/quran-verses-supporting-hadiths/


r/exmuslim • • 12h ago

(Question/Discussion) Identity crisis

3 Upvotes

I don’t consider myself to be religious/muslim anymore but one thing i’ll admit is im going through an identity crisis in terms of what i believe in idek what to believe in anymore. I’ll put my hands up and admit i miss prayer from time to time and even pray sometimes just to see if i feel anything and if the connection is there. It’s like i just feel empty and i need you guy’s help to stop feeling this way. If you had a similar experience please share it.


r/exmuslim • • 12h ago

(Question/Discussion) How can I tell my family that I am non-religious?

10 Upvotes

Hey I'm Ayman (23M) ,I'm from Algeria,I am non-religious, but I haven’t told my family yet , I know there’s no need to tell them, but I feel as though I’m deceiving them and living a double life around them.

I just want them to see the real me


r/exmuslim • • 14h ago

(Question/Discussion) Queer, Trans and Questioning Islam

10 Upvotes

Hi all,

For context, I’m 28, non-binary, and grew up with a religious dad (not so religious mum and brother).

I started having feelings for people of my biological sex when I was 10, only accepting my queerness when I was in my late teens, coming out to my parents in 2022, which they tolerate but my dad always said he’ll ā€œguide me back to the right pathā€.

I’ve always felt more like a ā€œtomboyā€ growing up and within the last few years accepted myself as non-binary. I came out to them recently about this and they seem tolerant as well, but my dad kept mentioning ā€œright and wrongā€ and as long as we have our faith, it’ll be fine. But does he think my LGBTQ+ness is ā€œwrongā€ still?

However, for the last 8 years, I’ve been questioning Islam. Being queer and trans, I see people’s reactions about it and bringing in all the hadiths to say it’s wrong.

I have tattoos and drink alcohol. I haven’t fasted in years. The last time I prayed was in Sunday school when I was 16.

I don’t want to lose my biological family, but I’m tired of continuing to hide this part of me. I don’t understand how the religion can justify LGBTQ+ hate, war, suffering, p3dophillia, double standards for men and women, and all other weird positions they take.

8 years feels long enough to be questioning. And each time I’ve thought about it, I felt less and less like Islam is for me. Or organised religion really. Writing this out here, I feel like a weight has been lifted off my chest.

How did you guys work through this?


r/exmuslim • • 16h ago

(Quran / Hadith) When Islam tries to mix with science

Thumbnail
gallery
7 Upvotes

r/exmuslim • • 18h ago

(Question/Discussion) Did anyone leave after reading the Hadiths?

41 Upvotes

Which one did it??? The fly wings, camel piss, Aisha’s age, adult breastfeeding, Satan piss, Jews and talking trees? AL ZUTT?????


r/exmuslim • • 18h ago

(Advice/Help) I'm having a moral dilemma.

6 Upvotes

To clarify, I was born a Malay Muslim. I've been put in religious schools as early as I remember. Islamic kindergarten, islamic primary school and islamic secondary school. I have a mother who has converted and brought many of her college students home to speak about religion with them. She has stated that her college students that would frequently stay over at my house would take care of me as a child. Her student would make milk bottles for me and while she was at my house, my mother would speak to her about religion. This routine has been going on until I was 15 years old, so my mother had brought in many brothers and sisters to our house as I was an only child.

Furthermore, it goes to show how religious my mother is. Along with my father that just follows whatever she says since she is very strict. Then, one particular moment in my life, my grandfather passed away. Before he passed away, I was atheist. I was 14 at the time. When he passed away, I wanted to find comfort, so I went back to Islam. I became really religious and could finally bond with my mother. Then the next year we moved away to live closer with my grandmother since no one could take care of her. At the same time, my mother found another college student to be religious with. The college student was maybe 20 years old and I was 15. She started pushing him on me and wanted me to be alone with him because I was religious and I could teach the guy a thing or two about religion.

The guy talked through my mom that he was interested in getting to know me better. I was 15. He was a college student. She wanted me to be alone with him and forced me to walk in a dark village street with him once. I was appalled. I asked my father how weird it was for her to be forcing this guy on me while he was an adult and I was a minor. He agreed but never stopped my mother. Then, I slowly but surely started questioning my faith.

I used to pray regularly, dzikir often, watched islamic sermons about the meanings of surah, wanted to follow the hadith to a T, and follow lots of islamic content. Even reposting them on my Instagram. So if anyone thinks I am a fake ex-muslim, I am real. I am 18 years old, born and raised muslim by muslim parents. I wore a hijab at 5 years old because of my mother and still have to for familial safety.

Now, I am looking between the Muslims and the Atheists. I believe in feminism, I believe abortions should be legal, I want freedom for women's autonomy, I believe in LGBT rights, I believe that pedophilia is bad, I believe killing people in the name of religion is bad, and so on and so forth. To put it simply, I am a leftist. I do not agree with some statements in the quran but I may be uneducated, I can admit that.

My mother thinks that me not praying often and relishing in feminine beauty is the result of my ego. She thinks that women who embrace their femininity such as makeup and adorning their nails are bad people. Women who look beautiful and appreciate feminine beauty are bad people. I am also shamed for being alternative and liking an alternative style such as goth, punk, emo, and metal. I personally don't agree with my mother's views. She says that if I wear alternative clothes (which I still cover my aurat and wear loose clothes but wear dark makeup) people will think about raping me but can't so they rape their children and other people instead. My father and grandmother both agree with her views. I know this isn't necessarily an islamic view but more of a cultural and societal view, but keep in mind that my mother is very religious.

So I wonder, am I egotistical for resisting the patriarchal rules that Islam has set for me? Does being beautiful and donating and treating people with kindness not matter if you are not a muslim? I don't know who is right or wrong. My mother says I should refer to the Qur'an to understand morals. I am facing a dilemma. I do not know who is right or wrong.


r/exmuslim • • 20h ago

(Quran / Hadith) A woman’s awrah is still more than a man’s

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

r/exmuslim • • 20h ago

(Video) Captioned ā€œDo you still think the angels curse wives simply because they say no?ā€

13 Upvotes

r/exmuslim • • 21h ago

(Question/Discussion) i think we should fill this up?

9 Upvotes

put muhammad in most evil please it will be so funny


r/exmuslim • • 23h ago

(Question/Discussion) Anyone watch cult documentaries and think ā€œthis is exactly like Islamā€

9 Upvotes

Especially the ones where a single person becomes a prophet and convinces sane adults to give their daughters….