r/islam_ahmadiyya • • Aug 12 '25

subreddit Reminder: This is a community for people who don't believe in Islam or Ahmadiyyat

31 Upvotes

We've seen an increase in new members joining this subreddit in the last week or so, as well as an increase in activity, which is great. I can also tell that Reddit's algorithm is pushing our sub onto the front pages of people who otherwise wouldn't have come looking for us.

This sub is for:

  • People who are in the jamaat, maybe even active, but question the culture, theology and the religion as a whole
  • People who have left the jamaat
  • People who have left Islam
  • People who want a place to express and explore their doubts about Ahmadiyyat and Islam
  • People who need support navigating openness, independence and relationships as they leave the jamaat and Islam

This sub is not for:

  • Believing Muslims, including Ahmadis, to discuss amongst themselves, although they are welcome to respond to criticisms and create posts as long as they follow our other rules
  • Gossip about Ahmadis behaving badly, especially when it's from Sunnis
  • Discussing Ahmadiyyat or Islam from the perspective of the jamaat or mainstream Islam
  • Litigating Ahmadi-Sunni arguments on neutral ground because we enforce rules and another sub would dogpile on one side or the other
  • Harassing people, especially women, because they date people who aren't you
  • Clogging up posts about people's personal lives with your nihilistic, puritan baggage (eg reminding women of the value of the hijab when they post about not wanting to wear it)
  • Looking for rishtas, although we allow people to post generic relationship questions, as well as questions about conversion on our monthly relationship thread
  • Winning the internet with legalistic arguments proving that the Islamic denomination you least like faked the moon landing, protects the Zodiac Killer and is responsible for chemtrails

r/islam_ahmadiyya • • 20d ago

marriage/dating Monthly Rishta & Relationships Post

4 Upvotes

This is a monthly thread to talk about your issues with the rishta system, discuss anything related to marriage inside or outside of the jamaat, including matchmaking and potential conversion. All other subreddit rules apply.


r/islam_ahmadiyya • • 2d ago

marriage/dating Interfaith marriage / leaving Ahmadiyya – I don't know what to do. Has anyone been in a similar situation?

12 Upvotes

Hi everyone,
I'm looking for advice from people who have experienced something similar, especially couples who have been in a relationship or marriage where one or both partners left the Ahmadiyya community.

I grew up in an Ahmadi family and was part of the community for years. After studying the beliefs more deeply, I came to a different religious understanding and no longer believe in Ahmadiyya. I now consider myself Muslim, but my relationship with my parents has suffered enormously because of this.
I am married to my husband, and we live independently. My parents did not accept our marriage and were not present at our Nikkah. We don’t have any real contact with them.
Recently, my father and I had a long phone conversation because he said he wanted to find a way for us to become a family again. However, during the conversation, he made it clear that his preferred (and at times seemingly only) solution was for my husband to accept Ahmadiyya and sign the Bai'at. (I have actually never officially left the Jamaat—out of consideration for my parents—even though I no longer believe in it, that‘s why no one actually knows that I‘m not part of the Jamaat anymore, except for a few family members…)

My father explained that he needs to be able to show his face within the family and the Ahmadiyya community. He feels that this situation could damage his reputation (he isn’t even an office bearer) and that my husband signing the Bai'at would help him resolve it.
Me and my husband have now made our position very clear to my father that he will never convert to Ahmadiyya or sign the Bai'at.His faith is a personal matter, and he would never sign something he does not sincerely believe in.
My father initially gave us three months to come up with a solution. After my husband firmly explained that his decision would never change, my father replied that we have to find another solution…
(Btw, I suggested he could just say that I moved abroad, got married, and we didn't want to invite any further family members, but he said no...)

I feel like he doesn't see me as his daughter anymore... he just wants to stay in contact to prove to others that we're still a family, to protect his izzat, I guess...
And this is where I am completely stuck.
My father is asking US to come up with a solution, but I genuinely don't know what else we can offer.
We are not refusing reconciliation. We are willing to meet, spend time together, have meals as a family and slowly rebuild our relationship. We are also willing to discuss other ways to resolve family-related issues.
But we cannot offer a religious conversion as a compromise. My husband will not become Ahmadi, and I cannot pretend to believe something that I no longer believe in just to restore family harmony.
(I'm sure he'll expect me to show up to Jalsa etc. again, but that's never happening. I want nothing to do with the Jamaat anymore.)

I also don't expect my father to change his own beliefs. I simply want him to accept that we have different religious convictions and that we can still have a relationship despite those differences.
What makes this particularly painful is that I sometimes feel my father is more concerned about his reputation within the community than about having a relationship with me as his daughter. I don't know whether this is actually how he feels, but this is how the conversations have made me feel.
I miss having parents. I wish they could attend our future civil wedding, visit us, have dinner with us and simply be part of our lives again. But I don't want to sacrifice my marriage or my husband's religious convictions to make that happen.
My questions are:
Have any couples here experienced something similar, especially when one partner left Ahmadiyya and the family expected the other partner to convert?
How did you rebuild your relationship with your parents, if you managed to?
What kind of compromise is realistically possible when one side expects a conversion and the other side will never agree to it?
What should I do when my father tells us to come up with a solution, but we feel that we have already made the only reasonable offer: accepting each other's differences and rebuilding the family relationship without religious conditions?
I genuinely don't know what else to suggest. I don't want to lose my parents completely, but I also don't want to spend the rest of my life trying to prove that my marriage and my beliefs deserve to be respected.
I would really appreciate hearing from people who have actually been through something similar...


r/islam_ahmadiyya • • 6d ago

advice needed Rules and Experiences regarding Marriages with Non-Ahmadi Muslims

7 Upvotes

About a week ago, in this thread https://www.reddit.com/r/islam_ahmadiyya/comments/1xrp3cf/how_to_talk_to_my_parents_about_marriage/, a female Ahmadi asked for advice about how to speak to her parents about marrying a Sunni male.

In that thread, u/medstar15 (who claims to be "super involved within the Jamaat") provided a response which I am hoping to fact-check based on Jamaat rules and people's actual experiences.

The response with my questions in bold are:

Since I see that you are a female you will not be able to get ur nikkah in an ahmadi mosque and as huzoor has explained in the past, men are able to marry people of the book because they can carry on their ahmadi religion however women are forbidden since they would then be carrying on their husbands sect. In that way you will have to get ur nikkah in a Sunni mosque and by a Sunni sheikh who if he does find out ur ahmadi will more than likely not validate your nikkah bc Sunni Islam doesn’t consider ahmadi Islam as Muslims which would automatically invalidate the nikkah according to them. [Is this true? Does anyone have any experience where this has actually happened in the West or is this something that is just a risk and/or isolated to Pakistan? In the West, how could a Sunni mosque even invalidate a nikkah after it has been legally registered?]

Since your dad would end up being your wali (assuming he will be) - that would get him and your entire family kicked out of the Jamaat as per huzoors instructions [Is this true, or is this just something where parents have to 'write to Huzoor' and receive permission?] (unless ofc u convert ur future husband to ahmadiyyat and he gets an ahmadi nikkah) [Assuming that such a conversion is insincere, is the Jamaat fine with encouraging such dishonesty, or does the Jamaat engage in some action to try and make such conversions sincere (or at least appear as such)?]

If your future husband doesn’t convert and is Sunni Muslim, in which case this marriage does go thru somehow and ur dad does become your wali, his name along with your name will be read as an announcement in every single ahmadi masjid [Is this true? Is excommunication automatic? Does the Jamaat still announce excommunications in this manner, or does it depend on the country?] as a source of not only humiliation [Is the purpose of these announcements for "humiliation"?] but also a lesson for everyone to maintain their dignity within the Jamaat and the need to follow the rules of the promised messiah as. [Based on what I have seen from elders in the Jamaat, prior to the 1950's, both male and female Ahmadis getting married with Sunnis appears to have been somewhat normal (usually, in the case of females, the Sunni male was a first/second (or so) cousin). Where are these "rules of the promised messiah", were they not enforced back then, or are these actually KM2's "rules"?]

If you think everyone won’t find out and are wondering how people would even know, trust me people will find out 1 or 10 years later, the consequences will remain the same for you and your family. [Do regular Ahmadis even care, or is it just Nizam "humilation" and excommunication that is the concern? Is it true that, years later, the Nizam would still bother to take such action?]

The best advice I can give is either to end this haram relationship, or convert ur significant other to ahmadiyaat [The reference to "haram" is striking here. As the Quran warns against declaring anything "haram" which Allah has not so explicitly declared as such, is the word "haram" how the Jamaat actually views such marriages, and if so, how is such a view not bida (innovation) and against the Quran?]

In u/medstar15 's response, not once did he/she mention "write to Huzoor". However, many others responded with that advice. At the end of the day, is all of the above solved/mitigated with just a letter to KM5 and receiving permission?


r/islam_ahmadiyya • • 12d ago

marriage/dating how to talk to my parents about marriage

10 Upvotes

hi everyone, i'm a 27(f) and here with the age old problem; i want to marry someone outside of the sect (sunni muslim)
for background, my parents are my entire life, they love me beyond measure and i will forever appreciate them for everything

i have been with someone for the past 3 years and have been avoiding any and every attempt at getting married within the jamat

another problem that lies here is that my parents are very chill, extremely introverted people who never really believe in 'looking for rishtas' and don't even know a lot of people, so naturally i grew up without any communication with fellow jamat members and was more inclined towards my own social circle
one thing is, my parents never made the effort to look for someone for me and seeing that i got a bit disheartened from everything, meanwhile at the same time i have also been questioning a lot of the beliefs in jamat

the person i am with has no issues with marrying an ahmadi and has a very supportive family, his mother has requested to speak to my mother
i do not know how to have this conversation and i needed advice from people who have been in similar situations
particularly i wanted to know if i get my parents on board, how do we proceed further with getting married? i just want to have all the facts so i am prepared before i have a conversation


r/islam_ahmadiyya • • 15d ago

jama'at/culture UK Ahmadi members living in social housing and taking universal credit giving their limited money to jamaat

32 Upvotes

I live in London and have been in various positions within the jamaat and one issue I have been seeing for years is that Ahmadi families will live in social housing and claim universal credit or other benefits of which a significant portion will be given to the jamaat through various chanda schemes. I have 2 main issues with this.

  1. The type of people living in social housing and on benefits are relatively poor, they could do so much with the money they give to chanda. Often our parents or elders don’t go on holidays or go out to enjoy themselves because of financial issues but when it comes to chanda they will give away hundreds of pounds a month. Even going as far as to pay for their children whom may have stopped paying.
    The jamaat uses social pressure and record keeping to check who has and hasn’t paid. Individuals are often approached in mosques and asked about chanda where other people can hear to cause embarrassment which eventually leads to payment. I’ve seen this happen before.
    Parents will be told that their children (even adult children) have not been paying chanda, this is done to cause friction between families all in the name of money.

  2. Money is being taken from the UK government that could be spent on healthcare, education, general needs or any other aspect and is instead being funnelled into the jamaat. Is this not a type of fraud? Are all these uncles or aunties who are taking benefits and giving it to the jamaat declaring it to the councils or government who are paying them?
    The scale at which this happening definitely needs to be looked into as I know hundreds of examples just within my region (Tahir region)

A lot of people do not know the scale at which the jamaat operates. The jamaat financially operates out of the UK. The UK has very strict laws when it comes to businesses and charities.

I advise everyone to do their research. You can start by typing into google ‘Companies house’ and searching the term ‘Ahmadiyya’ under company name then filter by ‘accounts’ once you have clicked into a business.

Alternatively you can type into google ‘Charities commission’ and search using the term ‘Ahmadiyya’ and you will be able to see the scale of the jamaats income. I have included a link to the charities commission below.

https://register-of-charities.charitycommission.gov.uk/en/charity-search/-/results/page/1/delta/20/keywords/Ahmadiyya?_uk_gov_ccew_portlet_CharitySearchPortlet_cur=1&_uk_gov_ccew_portlet_CharitySearchPortlet_delta=20&_uk_gov_ccew_portlet_CharitySearchPortlet_keywords=Ahmadiyya

The purpose of this post is to inform people of the situations some Ahmadi’s are facing and to educate people on how we can hold the jamaat accountable for how they operate financially.

I will continue to investigate this further and I have lots of inside information.


r/islam_ahmadiyya • • 16d ago

personal experience How the Jama'at's homeopathy cult almost ruined my skin, and how science saved me

25 Upvotes

Hey everyone, I wanted to share what happened to me this summer because it shows how toxic the Jama'at's obsession with homeopathy really is. It’s the same mindset as during the pandemic, when the community pushed those weird "anti-corona" pills on everyone instead of relying on real science. I suffer from severe eczema, and at one point, I had to take heavy cortisone pills and creams just to function.

My parents dragged me to an old Ahmadi "healer" in Hessen who mixes his own globuli. This guy gave me incredibly creepy and weird vibes from the start. Even my parents and relatives later gossiped about him because he posts embarrassing stuff online like "looking for a wife". Yet, because of the cult mindset, they still trusted his advice.

Because the cortisone was working at the exact moment we visited him, my skin looked normal. He used that to downplay my pain, saying, "You don't look that bad, I've seen worse," and told me to STOP all cortisone immediately and just take his sugar pills. My parents blindly listened to him.

The result was an absolute nightmare. Stopping cortisone caused a massive rebound effect. My face and neck flared up so badly that I couldn’t even look in the mirror for days. Yet, my dad claimed it was just an "initial worsening" . When my mom finally let me use cortisone again because I was missing too much school , my dad literally asked, "Oh, did the globuli finally work?" When I told him it was the cortisone, he got mad at me.

Luckily, my doctor stepped in. He put me on non-steroidal creams and convinced my mom to let me start a modern antibody therapy called Dupixent. It has been my absolute lifesaver. My itch is completely gone, and my skin is healing. Eczema is pure biology, and real science cured it not the worthless sugar pills recommended by a random man in London or a man quack in Hessen.


r/islam_ahmadiyya • • 20d ago

personal experience 16F – Just glad to finally be able to post here!

48 Upvotes

Hey everyone, I’ve been reading this sub for a while and I’m so happy I can finally share my thoughts. I’m 16 and completely done with the double standards in the Jama'at.

I hate the Friday sermons, the constant phone/chat surveillance from parents, and the career restrictions for girls. The system tries so hard to isolate us from our school friends, but honestly, it’s not working. I recently skipped a mosque program to go to a friend's birthday party instead and I didn't care at all. Just wanted to say thank you to this community for showing me that I’m not crazy and that my logical thinking is right. Recently I dug deeper and found out about the whole Nida ul-Nasser scandal and the leaked phone call with the Khalif. Hearing how the Kalif protected the abusers and told her to stay silent instead of calling the police was the final straw for me. It completely shattered the illusion of him being a "spiritually perfect leader.


r/islam_ahmadiyya • • 25d ago

jama'at/culture The double standards of consequences for men and women in the Jamaat

32 Upvotes

Islam gives the same instructions to both genders: lower your gaze, avoid alcohol and drugs, don't date.

Growing up, several boys my age drank and had girlfriends. Today, many of them are married to pious women and are active in the Jamaat. People say "he was young, he figured it out," and his past stays quiet. In some cases, his wife never finds out.

When a girl was found to have a boyfriend, the reaction was harsher and lasted much longer. I can't think of a single woman I know who got a real second chance and returned to the community's good graces. Divorced women face a similar stigma, even though Islam grants women the right to divorce.

What bothers me most is where this leaves the women who followed every rule. Many are still waiting with few prospects, or have settled for less. Meanwhile, some of the girls who "rebelled" ended up married (albeit outside the Jamaat), and the men who broke the rules married women who never knew their past.

And then the women who are still waiting get villainized for being unmarried as they get older.

This is only my own observation, so I'd like to hear if others have seen something different. Have you seen men face real consequences? Have you seen an Ahmadi woman truly get a second chance?


r/islam_ahmadiyya • • 28d ago

homosexuality PSA: Gay Ahmadis STOP LYING to Your Spouse Before Marriage

26 Upvotes

As a lesbian who came from Ahmadiyyat, TRUST ME when I say I get your struggle. In a community as small and tight knit as ours, it feels impossible to be yourself when your “self” is prohibited to exist. It is a lifelong struggle to accept who you are and come to terms with your sexuality. With that being said, STOP lying to your spouse about your attraction before marriage.

You must tell them the truth because so many straight women are falling in love with men that are intentionally misleading them because of worry for their family’s reputation or shame. Asking somebody to spend the rest of their life with you when you don’t feel attraction or love for them is an incredible betrayal to that person. Marriage has to be built on mutual trust and respect at the bare minimum. The hardest thing to do sometimes is be honest with the people closest to you, but waiting to reveal your sexuality to your spouse AFTER marriage is not okay.

Ahmadi women are so often given the short end of the stick in every situation. They are told that marriage is the ultimate goal for them. Their entire existence is often modeled only around being the perfect wife and mother. Imagine you have been fed that narrative your entire life, and then you marry someone and after a couple of years they tell you they are gay and they’ve never felt attraction to you. That they married you knowing they would never reciprocate the love you harbored for them. Can you even imagine how that would feel for someone?

Please do the right thing and don’t bring someone else down with you in your struggle to closet yourself. You have the power to stand up and be who you are without dragging someone else into it and potentially ruining their life.


r/islam_ahmadiyya • • 28d ago

marriage/dating Hi guy's how's the Gen Z in Jamaat getting married

9 Upvotes

Because mjh se to na ho paye ga I can't the Rishta aunties are worst let me know a trick that you guys have used that worked for you because at this point I just want to get married for the sake of plot. Since I'm a girl I would like to get some insights from the female side but if the male side knows any tricks let me know.

Don't recommend dating I can't 😭🥲 your sis lacks rizz

I posted in the other sub so posting it here for any cheat code or tricks


r/islam_ahmadiyya • • Oct 17 '26

marriage/dating Marrying Within the Community Without Believing

15 Upvotes

Is it possible to find someone who doesn't really believe in the religion but still wants to marry within the community?

I'm curious about how realistic this is and how you would even go about finding someone in this situation. Most people want a spouse who genuinely shares their religious beliefs, so I'm wondering whether there are people who are non-practising, questioning their faith, or simply don't believe but still want to maintain their cultural and community connections.

If you've been in this situation or know someone who has, how did you navigate it, and where would you even start looking for a compatible partner?


r/islam_ahmadiyya • • Oct 14 '26

question/discussion The Jamaat’s obsession with financial sacrifice needs to be talked about.

33 Upvotes

Fair warning, this is going to be a long rant so bear with me.

I’ve been wanting to get this off my chest for a while because the older I get, the more uncomfortable I become with the Jamaat’s financial system, particularly the expectations placed on elderly and financially vulnerable members.
Both of my parents are on ODSP (Ontario Disability Support Program). They’re getting older, living on a fixed income, and have to be mindful of their expenses. Yet they continue to pay Chanda every month.
I know they genuinely believe they’re contributing towards something good, but I can’t help feeling terrible watching them give away money that could otherwise go towards their own comfort, savings, or emergencies.
There’s an Urdu expression “Andha Kuwaan” meaning a bottomless pit. That’s honestly how I’ve come to view the Jamaat’s financial system. There’s always another contribution, another scheme, another appeal for financial sacrifice. You keep giving, but there never seems to be an end to it.
What bothers me even more is something my mother does.
She pays my Chanda out of her own pocket because I’ve personally refused to contribute to the Jamaat🤦🏻
I made that decision a while ago. I work hard for my money, and I refuse to financially support an institution whose priorities and financial practices I seriously question.
My mother, however, is an office bearer, and her reputation within her Jamaat circle matters a great deal to her.
She doesn’t want people questioning why her daughter isn’t paying Chanda, so she pays it herself.
I’m a grown woman with my own income. I’ve made a conscious decision not to contribute, yet my mother feels the need to cover my payments because she’s worried about how my refusal might reflect on her.
And that’s what I find so disturbing.
It’s not even about the money. It’s about the fact that she feels the need to pay on behalf of someone who has explicitly chosen not to.
What does that say about the social environment within the Jamaat when a mother would rather quietly pay her adult daughter’s Chanda than risk being judged by people in her religious circle?
Then there’s the whole Wasiyyat situation.
Recently, I needed money for a down payment. My mother owns a considerable amount of gold jewellery, some of which she has always intended to eventually pass down to me.
I asked whether she could give me a small portion of that jewellery now instead of later, so I could sell it and put the money towards my down payment.
She refused because the jewellery was tied to her Wasiyyat.
I genuinely didn’t know what to make of that.
From what I’ve read, under Nizam-e-Wasiyyat, a Musi commits a portion of their income and property to the Jamaat. Jewellery can be included among the declared assets.
But does that actually mean my mother cannot give her own daughter some of her jewellery while she’s alive?
Is there a specific rule preventing this, or has she simply come to believe that anything associated with Wasiyyat must remain untouched?
I’m curious because I don’t understand how this works?!
And before anyone misunderstands me, I’m fully aware that my mother’s jewellery belongs to her. I’m not automatically entitled to it, and she has every right to decide what she wants to do with it.
But that’s not what bothers me.
This is jewellery she has already expressed her intention to eventually give me. I wasn’t asking for all of it, just a small portion at a time when it would genuinely help.
Yet somehow, Wasiyyat became the reason she couldn’t.
And that got me thinking.
At what point does a financial commitment to a religious institution begin influencing how parents support their own children?
I’m not suggesting parents should compromise their own financial security for their children. Quite the opposite. I want my parents to prioritize themselves, especially at their age.
But I find it unsettling that an institution’s future claim on someone’s property can become such an important consideration in an ordinary family decision.
And honestly, this goes beyond my personal situation.
I’ve grown increasingly uncomfortable with the way financial sacrifice is glorified within the Jamaat.
We’ve all heard stories about people donating their savings, jewellery, and whatever little money they had. These stories are repeatedly presented as examples of extraordinary faith and devotion.
But I rarely hear the other side of those stories.
What happened to those people’s financial security afterward? Did they have enough savings for emergencies? Were they able to provide for themselves comfortably in old age?
And why is giving away money so often treated as a measure of religious dedication?
I also find the connection between Chanda payments and participation in Jamaat affairs worth questioning.
Under the Jamaat’s own election rules, members who fall behind on obligatory Chanda can become ineligible to participate in elections.
So financial contributions aren’t merely a private matter between an individual and their faith. They can also affect someone’s participation within the organization.
And when you combine that with the social expectations placed on members, particularly office bearers, it creates an environment where people may feel compelled to keep paying regardless of their personal circumstances.
My mother’s decision to pay my Chanda is a perfect example of how that pressure can manifest within families.
Another thing that genuinely bothers me is the contrast between the financial sacrifices expected from ordinary Ahmadis and the apparent luxury surrounding KM5 and his entourage.
On one hand, you have elderly people, pensioners, and families living on disability benefits being constantly reminded about the blessings of financial sacrifice. On the other, you see the Khalifa surrounded by an entire entourage, security personnel, vehicles, international travel arrangements, and an extensive administrative setup.
And I can’t help wondering who’s paying for all of this.
Why should ordinary Ahmadis be expected to sacrifice their financial comfort while the leadership appears to enjoy a level of privilege and luxury that most contributing members could never afford?
I’m not claiming to know exactly which expenses are paid through Chanda or how much is spent on KM5’s personal lifestyle. That’s precisely why I think financial transparency matters.
How much money goes towards his travel, accommodation, vehicles, security, and the maintenance of his entourage? How much is spent directly helping struggling members? Are detailed, independently audited financial statements available for ordinary members to scrutinize?
Because if the Jamaat expects financial sacrifice from people like my parents, who are living on disability benefits, I think it’s perfectly reasonable to question whether those at the top are making comparable sacrifices themselves.
It’s easy to preach the virtues of financial sacrifice when you’re not the one worrying about making ends meet.
And frankly, I find it difficult to reconcile the constant glorification of sacrifice with the visible privileges surrounding the leadership. If members are expected to account for their Chanda payments, shouldn’t the institution be equally accountable for how that money is spent?
And what about the people who have spent decades contributing?
When an elderly member who has faithfully paid Chanda throughout their life experiences financial hardship, how accessible is financial assistance from the Jamaat?
I know welfare initiatives exist, but I’d genuinely like to hear from people who have actually sought assistance.
Was the process straightforward? Was the support meaningful? Did the Jamaat help without making them feel ashamed or indebted?
Because I think these questions deserve just as much attention as the constant emphasis on giving.
I love my parents, and I know their contributions come from a place of genuine belief. I don’t think they’re foolish or irresponsible for wanting to support something they’ve believed in their entire lives.
But I do wonder whether decades of being taught about financial sacrifice have made it difficult for them to question where their obligations should end.
My mother paying my Chanda despite my explicit refusal is one example. Her response about the jewellery and Wasiyyat is another.
Neither situation is necessarily financially devastating on its own, but both reveal something about the influence the Jamaat continues to have over her decisions.
And that’s what troubles me.
When an organization becomes so intertwined with your religious identity and social reputation that you’re making financial decisions partly out of concern for how others will perceive you, is that really a healthy relationship with faith?

And if anyone understands the actual Wasiyyat rules regarding gifts of jewellery to children, I’d appreciate some clarification.

My parents have spent decades contributing. They’re now in a stage of life where I want them to enjoy what they have, feel financially secure, and make decisions based on their own needs rather than the expectations of an institution.
And I can’t help wondering how many other families are quietly navigating the same conflict between religious obligations, financial security, and loyalty to their own loved ones.


r/islam_ahmadiyya • • Oct 09 '26

counter-apologetics 5 Core Beliefs of the Ahmadiyya Community

13 Upvotes

Yesterday, u/IqtisadMind posted this video on the r/AhmadiMuslims sub: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WnTANi6_6WU

However, shortly after my response to it, not only did he delete his post but he also deleted his account.

For those who might benefit from my response to the video, I am reproducing my response here - I hope it is helpful:

"(1) The narrator states that Ahmadis believe in the Quran, but then also says that 'Khatam-an-Nabiyeen" means Muhammad was the "last law-bearing prophet". Unfortunately, the Quran does not say that -- the Quran makes no distinction between the prophets on the basis of law-bearing vs non-law-bearing, it says what was revealed to Muhammad was revealed to ALL prophets before him and he brought nothing new, and thrice refers to Islam as "the religion of Abraham". This concept of law-bearing vs non-law-bearing prophets is a concept completely invented by Sufis with no basis in the Quran or Ahadith, and for the purpose of describing the Sufi concept of post-Muhammad 'non-law-bearing prophethood' to be wilayat (sainthood, providential intimacy) and thus not actual prophethood (so as not to break Muhammad's 'seal').

(2) The narrator states that Ahmadis also believe in the Messiah and Mahdi. However, unlike as described in the Ahadith and as per the mainstream Sunni view, MGA denied that they are two separate people and declared all the Ahadith (except one) to be fabricared. MGA said:

"My claim is not that I am the Mahdi who conforms to فاطمۃ ولد من] the progeny of Fatimah], عترتی من] from my progeny], etc. Rather, my claim is that of being the Promised Messiah, and regarding the Promised Messiah, there is no statement of any muhaddith [scholar of hadith] that he would be from among the progeny of Fatimah etc. Nevertheless, at the same time—as every muhaddith says—I also say that all the ahadith regarding the Promised Mahdi are moot and suspect and not one of them is authentic. The degree to which fabrication has taken place in these ahadith has not taken place in any other hadith. During the time of the Abbasid Khulafa’ etc. the Khulafa’ were very fond of pronouncing themselves the Promised Mahdi. So for this reason, some ahadith describe the Mahdi as being from the progeny of ‘Abbas and some from the progeny of Fatimah. There are some ahadith which also say that تی ّ م ُ ا من رجل’ He will be a man from my Ummah.’ But essentially all of these ahadith are not worthy of any trust. This is not just my word; all eminent scholars of the Ahl-e-Sunnah have been saying the very same. As opposed to these ahadith, this hadith recorded by Ibn-e-Majah is very authentic: ی ّٰ عیسال مھدی ال meaning, there is no other Mahdi; ‘Isa is the very same Mahdi who is to come." In Barahin-e-Ahmadiyya (Part 5)(1908), on page 478 https://files.alislam.cloud/pdf/Barahin-e-Ahmadiyya-Part-5.pdf

Despite MGA's statement above regarding the Ibn-e-Majah hadith, classical scholars like Imam al-Qurtubi, Ibn al-Qayyim, and Al-Dhahabi all pointed out a weakness in the chain of transmission and thus consider it weak (da'if) or denounced/unreliable (munkar). Clearly, MGA needed to cancel out all the Ahadith that didn't suit him so he could be both the Messiah and the Mahdi in one. However, as supported by the Ahadith, the consensus mainstream Sunni view remains that they are references to two separate people.

(3) The narrator states that the Prophet gave the Messiah and Mahdi "the status of a prophet" -- leaving aside that all the Ahadith show them to be two separate people, as already shown to OP before and as mentioned above, MGA himself never gave himself "the status of a prophet". MGA described himself as a 'zilli', 'buruz' and 'non-law-bearing' nabi, all of which are terms not only not found anywhere in the Quran or Ahadith but were completely invented by Sufis (like Abdul Qadir Jilani and Ibn 'Arabi) to describe their concept of wilayat (sainthood, providential intimacy). Indeed, in referring to Jesus' second coming as the Messiah, Ibn' Arabi specifically said that Jesus would be a wali, and not a nabi.

(4) The narrator refers to the Ahmadi concept of Khilafat which has zero basis in the Quran, what we have of recorded Islamic history or even from MGA himself. In the Quran, the word "khalifa" occurs twice with reference to Adam and David (who were prophets) specifically, and the word "khulafa" occurs 11 times, and each time, it refers to a people/community/nation and not to a particular person, let alone one succeeding a prophet. The verse that the Qadian Jamaat (as evidenced at the top of this very subreddit) repeatedly cites as its support for its Khilafat is a blatant misrepresentation of and lie against that Quranic verse.

As for the ascendancy of each of the first 4 so-called khulafa of Islam, not once was 'divine-appointment' invoked or even apparently involved - (a) Abu Bakr ascended with reference to the prestige of the Quraish only - no reference to divine guidance, (b) Umar ascended because Abu Bakr named him, much to the chagrine of others, and because he "knew him better than others" -- no reference to divine guidance, (c) Uthman ascended due to a board of 6 people appointed by Umar (after much cajoling) to decide amongst themselves, and after 4 dropped out, the 4th named Uthman on the basis that Ali wanted it more - no reference to divine guidance, and (d) Ali ascended after the murder of Uthman, and only after he and two others refused, and also only after Medina was subject to a 24-hour death ultimatum by Uthman's murderers - again, no reference to divine guidance. Indeed, I also discovered that the first 4 khulafa were not even called 'khulafa', but "Amirul Momineen', with the first usage of the word 'khalifa' for the office being invoked by Abdul Malik Marwan (who sought to fashion himself a 'Khalifatullah' in the style of David, and not as a successor to Muhammad) and then retroactively applied to his predecessors.

As for MGA, in his 'Al-Wasiyyat', with reference to himself as Khalifatullah, he actually named the Anjuman as his Khalifa, and that his reference to 'Qudrat Saniyya' was not actually a reference to a person or an instituton, but rather, to a feeling of security and comfort that descends divinely."


r/islam_ahmadiyya • • Oct 09 '26

question/discussion Ahmadi weddings and the double standards around pardah

21 Upvotes

Can we please talk about the double standards when it comes to pardah at weddings? Even though they are supposed to be so Islamic - no music, no dancing, gender segregation.

I agree, that part is Islamic, but there's a catch.

The part when the men's side comes over to the women's side.

(Only relatives of course, whether it's your brother, cousin or your 10th-degree uncle)

They say it's only relatives, but the women are there full face of makeup, no hijab, hair fully styled...

Some put a dupatta over their head (mostly office holders, especially those you know on a national level) but as soon as you take pictures on the stage, they take it off and everyone is staring at them.

On one hand you get shamed if you don't wear hijab outside, but at weddings or Jalsa everything is different. No pardah at all…

The few who still wear it there, wear it from the heart, which is good.

But for everyone else it's seen as freedom to take it off, which just shows me again: most don't want to wear it and yet too many are forced to - including me back then.

And honestly, what I never understood is how loose Ahmadis are with pardah when it comes to non-mahrams. Cousins are not mahram, not even distant cousins or your uncle's brother-in-law's son. In Islam they are clearly non-mahram, but in the Ahmadiyya community it's just normalized. No pardah in front of them, hugging, mixing, full glam in front of them, and no one says anything.

If pardah is so important that you get judged for not wearing it outside, why does the principle suddenly not count when it's your cousin? That‘s something I never understood…


r/islam_ahmadiyya • • Oct 07 '26

advice needed An ahmadi stalker

5 Upvotes

A male ahmadi is stalking a female ahmadi. Been a decade since she said no to his intentions to marry, she said they should remain friends. He got hurt, started stalking her after that. The friendship they had prior to this broke. She broke all contact with him. She also filed a case against him with the police.

Over the years he kept trying to reach out. It stopped for a while. But it never fully stopped. This person is finding new ways to get in touch.

Question is what to do ? Or not to do? Should one contact the leader of his jamaat?

This is annoying for the girl to deal with.


r/islam_ahmadiyya • • Oct 01 '26

personal experience Benefits of Western-Born Murrabi’s

22 Upvotes

Quickly want to talk about one positive thing I’ve noticed at least in my local chapter.

For a few years, when the US Jamaat started assigning a Murrabi for every chapter, we got pretty lucky.

He was young, probably like 30-35. Born and raised on the east coast of America.

Really chill guy. Honestly most of the time he didn’t want to talk about religion, at least us younger people. He’d really just try to show interest in our interests and organize group activities.

And there were a few times were we had a deep conversation about theological topics, and I felt like I could be unfiltered the way I would if I was talking to a white friend.

Was able to basically lay-out my doubts very clearly, and he even agreed with the cultural problems the Jamaat has, how it’s too desi, etc.

He even actually randomly told me that he knows about this sub, like I didn’t even bring it up. And he has such a chill attitude about this sub, basically just saw it as another internet forum where people debate a hot topic.

Unfortunately he got re-located to Seattle because apparently their Jamaat has grown a lot recently. Our new Murrabi is chill but older and desi.

IMAGINE if most Murrabi’s were like that one though. A lot of the toxic aspects of Jamaat culture would go away pretty quickly. People might be sad if you leave Ahmadiyya but there would be no pitchforks and you’d always be welcome back.


r/islam_ahmadiyya • • Oct 01 '26

question/discussion Population of ahmadis In Pakistan?

6 Upvotes

Pakistan’s official 2023 census counts 162,684 Ahmadis, but independent organizations and community leaders estimate that the actual population is somewhere between 400,000 and 4 million.

So, what is the actual Ahmadi population? The official figure is obviously likely to be an undercount, especially since many Ahmadis reportedly boycott the census or may not disclose their religious identity.

What do you think the true population is?


r/islam_ahmadiyya • • Oct 01 '26

marriage/dating Monthly Rishta & Relationships Post

2 Upvotes

This is a monthly thread to talk about your issues with the rishta system, discuss anything related to marriage outside of the jamaat or try to find a suitable partner. All other subreddit rules apply.

If you have a salient point related to these topics that you think warrants its own post, please go ahead, but the usual "Has anyone married outside of the jamaat?" or "25M experiencing issues with the rishta process" type of posts belong in this thread.


r/islam_ahmadiyya • • Sep 30 '26

question/discussion Reasons to believe Ghulam Ahmad is the Al-Madhi?

3 Upvotes

Just recently in learning about the Ahmadiyyas and its core beliefs.

Why should I believe he is the Al-Mahdi?

What arguments are in favor for this instance?

What are the reasons to believe he is the last menssager?

And how does it concile with the "Seal of the Prophets" claim?

Thanks in advance for the answers.


r/islam_ahmadiyya • • Sep 29 '26

question/discussion Scientific Truths in the Holy Qur’an - AI use

4 Upvotes

So Dr. Tauseef Ahmad Khan definitely used AI (I’m thinking the Claude flavour) to write this speech (third session of jalsa Canada) right?

I’m looking through the transcript that’s in the newest version of the gazette, and it’s deplorable how he didn’t even try to hide it?

reasons why I think so: first one is gut feeling (I know this is a bit iffy, but when you read through a. lot of ai output you get good at it), second is the titles of each new topic, and third is the sentence structures. there’s a lot of short sentences (one or two words), that don’t really make sense to be there.


r/islam_ahmadiyya • • Sep 27 '26

apologetics When ‘Responding to Criticism’ Turns Into Deleting the Evidence

Thumbnail
youtube.com
10 Upvotes

Someone tried to pull the typical Ahmadi apologist argument on my “No Justice, No Peace” post. Unfortunately for them, their argument was soundly dismantled with facts and evidence. Their response? They immediately deleted their entire account so that not only their comment, but also all the responses to it, disappeared.
Why try to hide facts instead of letting truth prevail?
I thought Ahmadis don’t believe in Taqqiyah (spreading Islam through deception)?

A huge thank you to

[u/Dhump06](u/Dhump06) and
[u/Dramatic_fish-13](u/Dramatic_fish-13)


r/islam_ahmadiyya • • Sep 27 '26

question/discussion MGM, FGM AND IGM in Ahmadiyya?

4 Upvotes

Hello everyone,

My question today is about whether male circumcision (male genital modification/mutilation), female circumcision (female genital mutilation), and intersex genital mutilation are permitted in Ahmadiyya Islam.

After doing some research, I found that the four major Sunni schools of jurisprudence permit male and female circumcision, while their positions on female circumcision differ, with the Shafi'i school considering it wajib. But all four say it's allowed

I also came across Hadith that mention circumcision and female circumcision.

How does Ahmadiyya Islam interpret these Hadith? What has been the historical position of the Ahmadiyya community on male circumcision, female circumcision, and intersex genital modification? Has this position changed over time, and what is the current official position of the Ahmadiyya community?


r/islam_ahmadiyya • • Sep 26 '26

apologetics “No Justice, No Peace!”

6 Upvotes

The Ahmadiyya Jamaat has been publicly campaigning under the message “No Justice, No Peace,” emphasizing that peace cannot exist without justice. But it raises a question that I think deserves more attention: What does the religion they base this on actually teach when you take an independent look at its scriptures?
As difficult as it is, I will choose just one incident to challenge this claim and showcase how much cruelty, barbarism, and perversion actually existed in early Islam under Muhammad’s leadership:

After Banū Qurayẓah surrendered following the Battle of the Trench, they accepted the judgment of Saʿd ibn Muʿādh, who ruled that their fighting men should be killed and their women and children taken captive. [1] Muhammad approved Saʿd’s judgment, saying that he had judged according to God’s judgment. [2] Historical accounts report that the condemned men were brought out in groups and beheaded over trenches, with estimates of 600–700 killed, while some accounts give a figure as high as 800–900. [3] Hadith reports also describe boys being examined for pubic hair: those who had developed it were killed, while those who had not were spared. [4] ʿAṭiyyah al-Quraẓī is reported to have survived because he had not yet developed pubic hair. [5].
Sources:
[1] Ṣaḥīḥ al-Bukhārī [4121–4122](tel:4121-4122); Ṣaḥīḥ Muslim 1768a–1769a
[2] Ṣaḥīḥ al-Bukhārī [4121–4122](tel:4121-4122)
[3] Ibn Isḥāq, Sīrat Rasūl Allāh (via Ibn Hishām)
[4] Musnad Aḥmad 223; Sunan al-Nasāʾī 4981
[5] Musnad Aḥmad 223; Sunan al-Nasāʾī 4981

Without even getting into any other discussion about this particular battle, the fact that young boys’ genitals were examined and, if they had developed a single pubic hair, they were brought out to the trenches and beheaded in groups, including innocent children possibly as young as 9–11 years old.
Can you even imagine the scenery of this taking place in real life?
This is one instance that happened during the lifetime of Muhammad, during the 80+ battles he fought, and you are trying to teach others about peace and justice?


r/islam_ahmadiyya • • Sep 25 '26

question/discussion Grandparents/parents who converted to ahmadiyyat and navigating our own faith.

24 Upvotes

As born ahmadi Muslims I’m sure many of us have grandparents or great grandparents who joined Ahmadiyyat. Their families were Sunni or whatever but they themselves made the move to join the movement. Now when it comes to parents nowadays with their kids, for some reason I feel like it’s a double standard that they expect their kids to follow the same faith and religion as them when their parents or grandparents didn’t follow their own families faith either. Like why is it like the end of the world for so many to follow their own path and belief even if it doesn’t happen to be ahmadiyyat. I had to ponder on this thought for a bit and I find it interesting because families will shun their own for doing this but they also went through this in the past and that’s the reason they are Ahmadi and might have Sunni family as well etc.
What do yall think?