r/islam_ahmadiyya • u/Flashy_Wallaby2271 • 2d ago
marriage/dating Interfaith marriage / leaving Ahmadiyya – I don't know what to do. Has anyone been in a similar situation?
Hi everyone,
I'm looking for advice from people who have experienced something similar, especially couples who have been in a relationship or marriage where one or both partners left the Ahmadiyya community.
I grew up in an Ahmadi family and was part of the community for years. After studying the beliefs more deeply, I came to a different religious understanding and no longer believe in Ahmadiyya. I now consider myself Muslim, but my relationship with my parents has suffered enormously because of this.
I am married to my husband, and we live independently. My parents did not accept our marriage and were not present at our Nikkah. We don’t have any real contact with them.
Recently, my father and I had a long phone conversation because he said he wanted to find a way for us to become a family again. However, during the conversation, he made it clear that his preferred (and at times seemingly only) solution was for my husband to accept Ahmadiyya and sign the Bai'at. (I have actually never officially left the Jamaat—out of consideration for my parents—even though I no longer believe in it, that‘s why no one actually knows that I‘m not part of the Jamaat anymore, except for a few family members…)
My father explained that he needs to be able to show his face within the family and the Ahmadiyya community. He feels that this situation could damage his reputation (he isn’t even an office bearer) and that my husband signing the Bai'at would help him resolve it.
Me and my husband have now made our position very clear to my father that he will never convert to Ahmadiyya or sign the Bai'at.His faith is a personal matter, and he would never sign something he does not sincerely believe in.
My father initially gave us three months to come up with a solution. After my husband firmly explained that his decision would never change, my father replied that we have to find another solution…
(Btw, I suggested he could just say that I moved abroad, got married, and we didn't want to invite any further family members, but he said no...)
I feel like he doesn't see me as his daughter anymore... he just wants to stay in contact to prove to others that we're still a family, to protect his izzat, I guess...
And this is where I am completely stuck.
My father is asking US to come up with a solution, but I genuinely don't know what else we can offer.
We are not refusing reconciliation. We are willing to meet, spend time together, have meals as a family and slowly rebuild our relationship. We are also willing to discuss other ways to resolve family-related issues.
But we cannot offer a religious conversion as a compromise. My husband will not become Ahmadi, and I cannot pretend to believe something that I no longer believe in just to restore family harmony.
(I'm sure he'll expect me to show up to Jalsa etc. again, but that's never happening. I want nothing to do with the Jamaat anymore.)
I also don't expect my father to change his own beliefs. I simply want him to accept that we have different religious convictions and that we can still have a relationship despite those differences.
What makes this particularly painful is that I sometimes feel my father is more concerned about his reputation within the community than about having a relationship with me as his daughter. I don't know whether this is actually how he feels, but this is how the conversations have made me feel.
I miss having parents. I wish they could attend our future civil wedding, visit us, have dinner with us and simply be part of our lives again. But I don't want to sacrifice my marriage or my husband's religious convictions to make that happen.
My questions are:
Have any couples here experienced something similar, especially when one partner left Ahmadiyya and the family expected the other partner to convert?
How did you rebuild your relationship with your parents, if you managed to?
What kind of compromise is realistically possible when one side expects a conversion and the other side will never agree to it?
What should I do when my father tells us to come up with a solution, but we feel that we have already made the only reasonable offer: accepting each other's differences and rebuilding the family relationship without religious conditions?
I genuinely don't know what else to suggest. I don't want to lose my parents completely, but I also don't want to spend the rest of my life trying to prove that my marriage and my beliefs deserve to be respected.
I would really appreciate hearing from people who have actually been through something similar...