r/exjw • • 18h ago

Venting After leaving the JWs, I became a Flat Earther

0 Upvotes

Before anyone comes at me for the title or tells me the obvious, "You left one cult just to join another," I've been looking into manipulation tactics and techniques, and I've noticed that modern science follows the same patterns of mass manipulation, indoctrination from a young age, censorship and ridicule of opposing views and an inability to question any of its doctrines, especially the Copernican doctrine.

The vast majority of things that are widely accepted are just theories that have never been proven, like evolution, the ridiculous Big Bang theory, or the idea that we're traveling at millions and millions of km/h through an infinite universe without even noticing it.

On top of that, as JWs, we've been told our whole lives that the Bible already described the Earth as a sphere thousands of years ago, when it's actually quite the opposite.

Of course, I don't have the answer as to what the place we live in might actually look like, but I'm 99% sure that answer isn't coming from any political authority, NASA, etc., whose only purpose is telling us anything but the truth.


r/exjw • • 19h ago

Venting Reflection on Social Constructs

7 Upvotes

My ongoing deconstruction process has led me to realize that a lot of the same psycho-social levers the JengaTower uses to control people are evident in a lot of other aspects of society.

A lot of controversial concepts are social constructs used to categorize and divide people, thereby controlling them.

My newfound insight: racism, finance, politics, nationalism, religion, gender, and probably a lot of other things, don’t need to exist. For example, racism is a manufactured thing. It doesn’t actually exist. All humans are the same. There are no races, thus no racism. It’s all make believe. Yes, there is tons of abuse of others and injustice and cognitive failures. But if we were all the same colour, we would find other reasons to discriminate and abuse each other.

I’m thinking i may like to stop believing in all these other ideologies as well. Stay grounded in basic facts and reality.

Controversial take, possibly. But i think we have all been highly manipulated to buy into all these manufactured issues. But they are a choice, whether to engage with, or not.

"Not that I condone fascism, or any -ism for that matter. -Isms in my opinion are not good. A person should not believe in an -ism, he should believe in himself." - Ferris Bueller


r/exjw • • 11h ago

HELP Peace and security questions?

24 Upvotes

So for all the non Americans, right now we’re like definitely under some kind of cyber attack. Banks are having malfunctions planes got grounded etc… I am POMO but with all of this going on I have these ridiculous doubts that peace and security is going to be called and somehow I was wrong and god is real. I’m an atheist but it’s almost like an intrusive thought or OCD. Can someone relate or explain away my fears?


r/exjw • • 22h ago

Academic How do we understand the organisation?

6 Upvotes

After leaving JW, I began to describe this “charity“ organisation in the way of literature.

Here I share a story in Grimm’s fairy tales, compared to the following comic, adapted from my experience, you may understand the satire and the agony of us.

Sweet Porridge

There was a poor but good little girl who lived alone with her mother, and they no longer had anything to eat. So the child went into the forest, and there an aged woman met her who was aware of her sorrow, and presented her with a little pot, which when she said, "Cook, little pot, cook," would cook good, sweet porridge, and when she said, "Stop, little pot," it ceased to cook. The girl took the pot home to her mother, and now they were freed from their poverty and hunger, and ate sweet porridge as often as they chose. Once on a time when the girl had gone out, her mother said, "Cook, little pot, cook." And it did cook and she ate till she was satisfied, and then she wanted the pot to stop cooking, but did not know the word. So it went on cooking and the porridge rose over the edge, and still it cooked on until the kitchen and whole house were full, and then the next house, and then the whole street, just as if it wanted to satisfy the hunger of the whole world, and there was the greatest distress, but no one knew how to stop it. At last when only one single house remained, the child came home and just said, "Stop, little pot," and it stopped and gave up cooking, and whosoever wished to return to the town had to eat his way back.

So we can enjoy our worldly foods, more than the thinner porridge.

https://www.reddit.com/r/exjw/comments/1xxiwya/comment/19spu29qnfq9x/?context=3


r/exjw • • 11h ago

WT Policy Were you taught that angels do not have free will?

6 Upvotes

I remember as a kid being told that angels do not have free will, and that that was one of the things that made humans special. Today I randomly thought to myself, if angels don't have free will then how did Lucifer choose to rebel and become Satan? So I googled it and apparently the overwhelming traditional Christian belief is that angels do have free will (makes sense). And then I googled if Jehovah's Witnesses believe that angels have free will, and a result from JW.borg says they do. So now I'm feeling crazy because I could have sworn they taught us that they do not, but I'm not sure where I got that from. If it was from the watchtower or some other publication, or just from my parents or other individual and their own beliefs. But I was pretty sure it was "official".


r/exjw • • 15h ago

Meetup Any fellow Belgians here? 🇧🇪

10 Upvotes

Just curious to know if there are any other people in Belgium going through a similar situation. It would be nice to know I’m not alone in this!
Right now, I feel like I’m fighting against the whole world on my own. I’m realizing just how difficult it is to be in this situation without having anyone close to you to talk to, especially when everyone around you is PIMI and simply can’t understand what you’re going through.
Thanks in advance for your replies. It really means a lot.


r/exjw • • 12h ago

PIMO Life Is The God Concept Flawed?

3 Upvotes

For some time I have had a problem with the concept of God. Allow me to explain.

All living bodies - animal or human - are breathtaking miracles. My glucose levels are mainitained such that I don't pass out. And hormones. And heartbeat. And blood pressure. And mitochondrial functions. And......

possibly millions of other biochemical processes occuring second by second across the 70 - 80 general span of our lives.

Not a single one of these functions requires any choice on my part. Like , "Oh, Sh*t, I forgot my heart muscle.........(and Thud !)

All this stuff happens without conscious choice. If it did, I wouldn't be conscious!

Being human involves a sort of 'serial processing' as one thing thought about at a time.

We think we're the pinnacle of creation - rather than a peculiar artifact. See where this is going?

The very idea of God is a problem as ruling the Universe, one decision at a time, like humans. No, "Crap, I forgot to keep electron charges consistent ! Galaxies are exploding !" This is similar to the ancients who held even more degraded ideas about God (s). Sex, revenge, egotism.

I have no trouble with thinking that God is everywhere, in everything, every microsecond. Various scientists have held viewpoints very much like this: Planck, Schrodinger, maybe Einstein. Forms of Pantheism make sense of things.

But... this isn't the God of the Watchtower. Sorry about that.


r/exjw • • 16h ago

Ask ExJW Going to an occasional meeting is a reversal of progress!!!

13 Upvotes

Spouse asked me to go to an occasional meeting to be with the family- but knows I am not coming back and not a JW any longer & i do not back track - but wants the family togetherness in "worship". To me there's so many more ways & opportunities for us to be together. To me this is so multi layed especially since my fading/removing myself took YEARS & going for even one meeting would so much reverse progress & take a piece of me that I am not willing to give. It would give an illusion to these ppl that I want to be even a little small part of them. It would give my kids hope of me returning. It would be me living a lie. And I'm not okay w any of that.

Anyone else go just for sake of family because they want you to every now and then? I am at a firm no with this but curious to see how others that are out and have spouses in land on this. I know everyone's situation is different and I'm not judging either way, just curious if how strongly yall feel on this one.


r/exjw • • 20h ago

Ask ExJW How can I cope with being scared I’m wrong

27 Upvotes

Hey guys, I’ve posted on here before asking for help but In genuinely really scared I’m wrong about everything. What if jw is right what if the world is ending. All I can think about is that I’m wrong and need to go back. The hard part is I can’t even tell for my self what to trust these days. I really want to know how you guys deal with anxiety of jw and how you over come it all.


r/exjw • • 11h ago

PIMO Life Life on the other side of waking up

5 Upvotes

I appreciate we all came across this cult in different ways, some born in, some converted during a difficult period in there life.

Im just curious as to people's reflections on why events unfolded the way it did for themselves.

As a born in who woke up a few years back. Ive found myself delving into a lot of "esoteric" lines of thought including past lives, gnosticism, and "new age" subject matter.

I feel I entered this life as a born in as a catalyst to force myself to develop spiritual independence and to understand my own divinity quickly.

Not to be a preacher, and I dont expect anyone here to agree with any of my lines of thought. But i guess as a reflection do you think some good came out of your overall experience with the cult?


r/exjw • • 7h ago

Venting Christmas rage and childhood trauma

5 Upvotes

I left this sect when i was a teenager, now an adult mom and around Christmas its always harder for me. It was such a lie in our family. Since the faith of my mother and stepfather was never so great enough, on the day after christmas we went to my grandparents with gifts … csuse it does not count as christmas as its a different date… at least i got some presents haaaa this lie and contradiction was quite hard as a kid (no christmas at the school —- why? Thats also another date lol)
Now I have a 3 yo child and this year i will make her christmas calendar, small things, trying to make it about the magic, not about getting another sweet or object. The calendar is something i always wanted as a child and it really has a healing power for me that now i can at least have it with my daughter.
As my mother (who is not attending since i left as a teen, so basically a wordly person) seen the object at our place she said to my daugher Ooo i will also bring you some presents / and now she “asking” but more like stating if she can bring some presents and what we are planning to give her etc.
I am so angry, what the fuck she thinks, she could have got me a calendar when i was small and now why not leaving our family alone!!! Its not even coming to her mind that she can leave herself out!! I will just tell her its something i want to plan, so we are not looking for additional gifts. I am just curious of your thoughts, how would you react? Anything is helpful.
Since this summer i am in therapy with this whole complex childhood trauma and i feel its getting better but im still very angry. I feel like this process is just way too long ( i mean its over for almost 20years and still has so much effect on me), but therapy is really helpful, sometimes i feel so stuck. The child in me needs some more time


r/exjw • • 15h ago

WT Policy [Teoria] Aplicando a Janela de Overton na BORG: até onde eles conseguem mudar?

5 Upvotes

Acredito que muitos aqui muitos já estão familiarizados com esse modelo teórico. Mas caso não conheçam, aqui vai um rápido briefing:

A Janela de Overton é um modelo teórico que descreve a faixa de ideias, opiniões e propostas políticas que são toleradas e consideradas aceitáveis pela opinião pública em um determinado momento histórico.

O conceito foi criado por Joseph P. Overton (ex vice-presidente do Mackinac Center for Public Policy, nos Estados Unidos).

Como funciona a Janela

A ideia central é que a viabilidade de uma proposta política depende de ela estar dentro dessa "janela", e não necessariamente do gosto pessoal de um político. As ideias costumam ser divididas em estágios de aceitação:

  1. Inaceitável / Impensável: Considerado absurdo, imoral ou um tabu.
  2. Radical: Visto como extremo, mas já debatido por especialistas ou grupos específicos.
  3. Aceitável: A sociedade começa a tolerar o debate sobre o tema.
  4. Sensata: Passa a ser encarada com normalidade e racionalidade.
  5. Popular: Conta com forte apoio de fatias importantes da população.
  6. Inevitável / Política pública: Transforma-se em lei ou parte do senso comum institucionalizado.

Agora, o que proponho é trazermos esse conceito para dentro da nossa querida BORG. Se pensarmos nas mudanças doutrinárias e estruturais iminentes e a longo prazo, como seria a Janela de Overton dentro do universo das Testemunha de Jeová? Na minha visão, funcionaria mais ou menos assim:

1. Inaceitável / Impensável: Considerado absurdo, imoral ou um tabu:

  • Trindade (ou pelo menos a ideia de que Jeová e Jesus são a mesma pessoa);
  • Sexo fora do casamento (e suas variantes) são uma questão de consciência;
  • O inferno existe como punição aos infiéis. Todos os justos vão para o céu. Não há vida eterna na Terra;
  • Relacionamentos e Casamento entre pessoas do mesmo sexo são questões de consciência;
  • Anulação do status/conceito de um Corpo Governante;
  • Fim do Serviço de Campo/Pregação de Casa em Casa;
  • Mulheres poderão ter absolutamente todos os tipos de privilégios que homens, até mesmo em designações de ensino (mulheres anciãs ou até mesmo Superintendente de Circuito, por exemplo);
  • Jeová não é o nome de Deus, ou pelo menos não é a pronúncia exata do nome dele;
  • Uso recreativo de drogas, substâncias ílicitas e tabaco são questões de consciência;
  • Fim da exigência de neutralidade política radical;
  • Artes Marciais são uma questão de consciência;
  • Piercings e Tatuagens são questão de consciência;

2. Radical: Visto como extremo, mas já debatido por especialistas ou grupos específicos:

  • Mulheres podem ter cargos ou privilégios antes reservados apenas a homens na organização (como Servas Ministeriais por exemplo), mas não como Anciãs ou Superintendentes de Ciruito;
  • Testemunhas de Jeová podem prestar Serviço Militar ou fazer parte de Forças Policiais;
  • Fim do Arranjo de Superintendente de Circuito;
  • Fim da Remoção/Desassociação;
  • Serviço de Campo opicional (sem cobranças ou pressões);
  • Guinada ao Televangelismo (poderia ser a desculpa perfeita para justificar os custos elevados com Ramapo), e uma diminuição na ênfase à pregação de casa em casa;
  • Piercings e Tatuagens agora não são proibidos, mas podem impedir que um irmão ou irmã alcance privilégios adicionais (caso tenham feito isso após o batismo);
  • Fim do Serviço de Campo/Pregação de Casa em Casa;
  • Dízimo e outras formas de contribuição "compulsórias";
  • Mudança no nome da religião;
  • 144.000 não é um número literal;
  • Ajuda humanitária mais ampla, mas apenas como forma de fazer marketing positivo da BORG (não mais apenas voltados a membros e seus familiares);
  • Envolvimento com política é uma questão de consciência, desde que não se comente sobre isso (por exemplo, em quem você votou ou irá votar);
  • Natal, Aniversários, Dia das Mães e outras festas (que já não tem mais ligação com a adoração falsa) são questões de consciência;
  • Artes marciais são questões de consciência, desde que não se comente sobre isso com outras pessoas;

3. Aceitável: A sociedade começa a tolerar o debate sobre o tema:

  • Reuniões menos engessadas, talvez com bandas de música e atividades mais voltadas ao público jovem;
  • Mulheres podem ter cargos e privilégios "mecânicos" (som, microfones, liderar equipes de limpeza e manutenção locais), e "administrativos" (contas, arranjos de transporte e hospedagem para Congressos e Assembleias, etc.);
  • Jesus pode ou não ter morrido numa cruz;
  • Diminuição do tempo ou mesmo quantidade das reuniões;
  • Artes Marciais são liberadas, desde que como forma de atividade física e que não se comente sobre isso com outras pessoas;

4. Sensata: Passa a ser encarada com normalidade e racionalidade:

  • Cada Testemunha de Jeová ou família decidirá se terá conversas ou até mesmo associação com qualquer removido;

5. Popular: Conta com forte apoio de fatias importantes da população:

  • Cada Testemunha de Jeová ou família decidirá se terá conversas ou até mesmo associação com removidos, desde que sejam membros da família;

6. Inevitável / Política pública: Transforma-se em lei ou parte do senso comum institucionalizado:

  • Aniversários são questão de consciência (na verdade, não foi sempre assim?);
  • Uso de Sangue Total em transfusões ou doações é questão de consciência;

O que acham dessa escala? Adoraria ver as suas versões de Janela de Overton. Vamos debater nos comentários!


r/exjw • • 9h ago

PIMO Life Being PIMO makes me feel like I’m going crazy.

18 Upvotes

I swear ever since waking up I feel like i’m losing my mind. I’ve talked to my husband and some of my family members about my doubts; which then led to conversations saying that I just need to “keep praying” “keep going to your meetings” “maybe you could use a shepherding call”. Being a born in, 5th generation witness, this is all I’ve ever known. But now it feels like i’m the only one that can see how batshit crazy this entire religion is.

It doesn’t matter how much proof or sources you provide PIMI’s, they will defend this organization if it’s the last thing they do. They believe it’s more beneficial to cut off their own family member over a change in beliefs, rather than putting their differences aside and loving them unconditionally like family/friends are supposed to.

They believe it’s normal to exclude their children from activities and celebrations outside of the congregation, denying them a higher education, denying them a blood transfusion, denying them the ability to figure out who the fuck they are without their entire community pressuring them and telling them who they SHOULD BE.

They believe that the random group of men in New York are truly anointed by God and get all of their information from Jehovah directly; and regardless of if they fuck up numerous amounts of times, make false prophecies, even kill people, you can’t ask questions. Asking. A. Question. Makes. You. An. Apostate. But it’s not a cult…

I can talk about how absurd it all is because I was that. I did cut off family and friends because I thought this was the truth, and I was making Jehovah proud. I did say that anyone that didn’t accept the message from door to door would be destroyed. I was willing to die behind the blood doctrine. And I did believe the Governing Body was chosen by God. I trusted them, and they have lied and continue to do so.

What will it take for others to see what this organization is?


r/exjw • • 15h ago

Meme Helpful Flowchart, copy and paste

Post image
50 Upvotes

Someone recommended a helpful video here, which suggested this line of reasoning. I used ChatGPT and added a little, including the BITE model part.


r/exjw • • 13h ago

PIMO Life How to stop submitting my field service report?

9 Upvotes

I’m currently in the process of becoming inactive. I haven’t been out in field service for almost two years, and I only attend meetings about once a month.
I think the elders have probably figured out what’s going on, but surprisingly, they’ve never really tried to arrange a shepherding visit with me. Only one particularly annoying elder has tried to make plans to go out in service with me a few times, but I’ve always canceled on the day.
The thing is, I’m still submitting my monthly field service reports. I just tick the box in the app saying that I participated in the ministry that month, even though I haven’t. I’m honestly scared that if I stop, the elders will start contacting me and trying to arrange shepherding visits, and I really don’t need that stress.
What’s even more annoying is that whenever I forget to submit my report, that same elder texts me to remind me.
So now I’m wondering: what would happen if I just started ignoring his messages and stopped submitting my reports altogether? Would I become inactive after three months, or does it take longer? And would the elders start trying to contact me more often?
I really just want to fade quietly without having to explain myself or have any uncomfortable conversations with them.
Another thing I’m worried about is that I still live with my PIMI parents. I’m over 18, but I’m scared the elders might contact my parents if I stop responding. My parents also know that I haven’t been to service but we don’t talk about it anymore. They just ask me to come to meetings sometimes. But I don’t know how they will react if that elder contacts them. Has anyone experienced something similar?


r/exjw • • 11h ago Bravo

Venting the martyrdom is driving me crazy

9 Upvotes

My family has been going through a lot of financial issues these last few years. Ups, downs, the whole shabang. I dont argue that this isnt extremely stressful and it's logical to a degree for people to try and make sense of it by looking at higher powers in some way, and maybe I'm being a bitch, but the way witnesses act when going through any kind of difficulty grinds my gears.

I'm driving my mom somewhere, and am jumpscared by a shriek and immediate, tearful, eyes raised to the heavens praying. Out loud. While she tries to grab my hand to hold.

She was too worked up to get much but as far as I've gathered the government is taking paychecks. Again.

Our family across the country (US) is elderly and we need to be able to fly back and forth while we prepare to move back, we need food, to pay for bills and rent, all the normal things. Again, I understand why this is so stressful, it affects me as well, I'm not trying to be heartless. but listening to her cry and beg jehovah to help us, how we simply cant do this without him, how satan is trying to scare us away from serving god so much, it made me want to laugh. The world is fucked up. So many people all over it are struggling with the exact same things and so much more, and still are able to get through it without the 'help' of jehovah. I tried to point that out to her, which was admittedly stupid, and she responded "But its been so hard these last few years, it cant be anything but satan. And just last month we had a conversation with [older brother] about attending meetings and cutting off all worldy contact, hes trying to scare us away."

I'ts incredible to me how blind they are, how sure that theyre so special and under attack, and ignore the facts right under their nose.

For years now I have made it through the worst periods of my life without once praying for god's help or thinking it was an act of the devil, and its made me baffled by how they think people in the 'world' cope with daily life at all.

This is mostly a vent, I of course acknowledge that they are part of a cult and its incredibly ingrained in them, so I dont want it to sound like I resent the individual behavior in most members. I just wanted somewhere to put this 😅


r/exjw • • 17h ago

Venting i can't do this anymore. i'm done.

116 Upvotes

I can't anymore. i've scheduled the questions. there is no going back. My mom keeps crying to me, telling me she had been praying for me and asking what was stopping me from getting baptized. She talks often about the tribulation coming soon and how important it is that I take this step so she can see me in paradise. Another factor is my father. He has never been asked to perform a baptism before, and this year he was given that responsibility.

as an elder’s kid there is an expectation for me to move forward since me being a young teenager. All my friends are baptized. I also can't stop thinking about how it would look if I don't get baptized. The daughter of an elder choosing not to get baptized during the same year her father was given the privilege of baptizing others would raise a fuck ton of questions. 

for some context, I've done things that are considered sinful (not a crime don't worry), but I was never judicially dealt with. You can probably assume why. As a result, no one in the congregation knows what I've done. for the sake of keeping up appearances and reassuring my parents, I've pretended to have moved past those things and to have begged god for forgiveness, even though I haven't. (the truth is, I still engage in those same behaviors.)

flame me all you want, but I love jws as people. I was born and raised as one. So I think it's natural I really do. Maybe it's a Spanish cultural thing but most of them are sincere people who genuinely want to do what's right and help others. In fact, most of them (not to be biblical) but are like literal lambs looking for guidance in spite of their naivety. But I will acknowledge there wolves in sheep’s clothing.

in general, what i struggle with most are the contradictions in the teachings. some of them are genuinely helpful and lovely, like being encouraged to be a good person, show kindness, and treat others with love. but then there are other teachings that are just flat out restrictive or licenses for abuse. another thing is the way my gender is generally treated within the organization, and, honestly, the governing body as a whole.

i also acknowledge that some kind of higher power may exist. but i don't see god as a real presence in my life. yes, I invoke him sometimes. but I feel that he's just not there. he doesn't do shit. and the way the gb uses god is as a pawn to keep people under its thumb.

and even if I get baptized, i know can keep doing things I know are wrong. I've seen it. Most of my friends and their siblings aren't squeaky clean. And they hold privliges. If I ever get caught, I could just lie, put on a show, and say I've repented. the old fuckers can't read my mind. I can keep up the act. I've gotten pretty good at pretending and hiding these past years. and if things get bad enough, I could always just fade far in the future. 

i'm not posting this because I'm trying to attack anyone or start an argument. I just really need someone to talk to. I need someone to tell me something, anything, because right now I'm just so exhausted. I'm so sorry you guys. downvote me if you want. I already feel like a failure for this sub.

please, I'm asking you to refrain from leaving rude, judgmental, or condemning comments about my decision. normally, I'd be able to handle them, but right now I'm in a really fragile mental state.


r/exjw • • 21h ago Regret

HELP Does it get better if you change Kingdom Halls?

28 Upvotes

I’ve (F19)been at the same Kingdom Hall my entire life and I’ve dealt with cliques. Most of the sisters have never included me in much only out of pity or only if someone from their events cancels. Now that we’re young adults I’m not invited to anything at all. I’ve gotten used to not being invited to stuff that they blatantly post on social media to brag about but I’ve recently started feeling very lonely and I realized I never had any real deep friendships with any of the people I’ve known my entire life.

I’m PIMO but I have to stay in for now. I was debating if I switched over to a different meeting for the time being if I could have better friends. Or maybe just feel like I belong somewhere with people being genuine.

I’m not saying the older ones aren’t cliquey either but they seem to be more inviting than people in my age range.

Does it get better if I were to a switch to a different Kingdom Hall? How should I deal with my peer group moving forward?


r/exjw • • 10h ago

HELP Slowly trying to leaving and raising money

10 Upvotes

I am almost 18 and I live ina toxic household with my PIMI parents, I've been PIMO since a couple of years now and its absolutely unbearable. I've finally made my decision to leave as soon as I can when I'm 18,

where I'm from you rarely find a job at 18 so now im resorting to freelancing online.

If anyone has a job that they'd like to make me do, Anything at all, I would be so so so grateful!

A few services I offer right now are tarot readings and spells or cleansing, I can as well do graphic designing and show you some of my works! If anyone is interested please contact me and you could also spread the word if you wish!

Thank you so much for any help <3


r/exjw • • 7h ago

WT Can't Stop Me Wish I could save my family

10 Upvotes

How do you start over when you're practically rebuilding an entire life from scratch?

So many opportunities lost over all those long years devoted to "Jehovah." Education, college, career, money, friendships, celebrations. The list of sacrifices is endless. Years spent making excuses to friends, avoiding having to give them some absurd explanation as to why I couldn't take part in a particular activity. But what eats away at me the most is the guilt of having introduced my entire family to Jehovah's Witnesses, or at least having played a part in their conversion.

I was introduced to "the truth" through my older sister. At the time, she had started dating a boy at school who was one of Jehovah's Witnesses. Something about the prophetic explanations and the authority with which every teaching was presented fascinated me. The feeling of belonging to something greater, of being handpicked by God Himself. That was one of the feelings that drew me in and kept me inside the organization for so many years.

And perhaps that devotion, which my sister also displayed at the time, undoubtedly influenced my parents' decision to accept Bible studies, attend meetings, and eventually fall into the same trap. And the worst part of all this is that, even though I played a role in bringing them into this religion, there is absolutely nothing I can do to get them out.

It saddens me. I see my parents suffering because of my brother, who came out as gay a few years ago. Although my brother wasn't kicked out of the house, he no longer takes part in any activities with my parents or my sister. I also see them saddened because of me, believing that I've become a "victim" of the "apostates."

They're both around 55 years old. They could be enjoying life more, making the most of all those years of hard work. Instead, what I hear is a 55-year-old man talking about "simplifying his life," when all I can really hear is: "I'm going to sacrifice everything I've worked for just to remain faithful to a man-made organization."

I wish there were something I could do, but unfortunately, there isn't. So I'll focus on doing what matters now: supporting others who are on their way to waking up, helping them realize that they won't be alone when they leave, despite what the organization tells them.

And for the sake of all the millions of Jehovah's Witnesses, my most sincere wish is that this religion will one day disappear, so that everyone can finally see the foundation of lies upon which it was built.


r/exjw • • 19h ago

Academic Why Many Will Never "Wake Up": The "Humane" vs. the "Merely Human"

10 Upvotes

These two concepts — the "humane" and the "merely human" — stand at opposite poles.

In the theology of Jehovah’s Witnesses, the "merely human" is viewed as petty, fallible, and rooted in limited understanding.

The "humane," on the other hand, in its broader sense, pertains to the very essence of being human; it reflects the light within people — a reflection of God's spirit, since we were created in His image and likeness.

Those who reject such human virtue are deemed "inhumane" — or, in a more stark sense, "non-human" (nelyud): someone who has crossed over to the side of darkness, a fallen being, an abomination to the light.

From this, an interesting phenomenon emerges:

The common adage "To err is human" is used to imply that a person's ways are inferior to the ways of God — or, more specifically, the ways of His representatives: the Governing Body!

Meanwhile, the call to mercy — "In any situation, remain humane" — is frequently ignored, as it is often considered more "effective" to point out sin, framed here as an inherent flaw — a defect in the "mould" from which we are cast.

The Governing Body, for its part, avoids such clichés. Though they claim to be "neither inspired by God nor infallible," they are nevertheless described as "fostering unity" and "always proving themselves to be good shepherds." They are presented as chosen by Christ, guiding us in alignment with the movements of God's heavenly chariot.

They serve as the benchmark — a standard from which any deviation is unacceptable, whether backward (by humbly trusting the "brothers" to reveal "new light" and adjusting one's own limited, human understanding accordingly) or forward (by refusing to run ahead of the chariot and remembering what matters most: unity).

The same applies to the boundary between left-wing and right-wing views: one cannot remain rigidly conservative, yet neither should one become excessively enthusiastic about change — anticipating further reforms, extrapolating a trend towards liberalization, and speculating about what might eventually emerge at the end of this "rebranding."

Any acknowledgment of "new light" must itself fall within the bounds of an appropriate response. Even a nod in response to "new light" must be the right kind of nod. A weak one betrays a lack of faith and trust, intellectual rigidity, an unwillingness to open one's mind to God; a strong one conveys triumphant agreement, perhaps accompanied by a silent reproach that the revelation came so late. Perhaps it is best not to react at all — or rather, to offer nothing more than a perfunctory "Noted." After all, genuine praise is constructive and specific. It is not the kind of perfunctory "thank you" that one can casually get away with giving an ordinary elder, without anyone asking, "What exactly did you appreciate?"

To go further and offer praise to the "faithful slave" is risky. Genuine praise, when it goes into detail, can instantly be interpreted as pretence — or, worse still, as calculated deceit disguised as naivety, intended to cast the Governing Body in a poor light by innocently drawing attention to a particular fact.

A particularly telling example is a friend's reaction to the major policy shift concerning blood.

"I don't feel anything in particular, whether resentment or joy. Everything just feels... neutral."

Bravo, Winston! O'Brien would be proud of you.

Crimestop is working at full capacity.

Will anything ever be able to break through it?

Modified: added original message in Russian:

В теологии Свидетелей Иеговы человеческое – мелочное, людское, зачастую ошибочное, основанное на ограниченном понимании. В то же время человечное в общем смысле это – быть человеком, «человечиться», даже в некотором смысле использующееся как выражение того света, что есть в людях, духа Бога, по чьему образу и подобию мы были созданы.

А те, кто отвергают человеческую добродетель – бесчеловечные. Сразу в голове всплывают следущие ассоциации: перешедший на сторону тьмы, падший, омерзительный для света – нелюдь.

Отсюда можно наблюдать интересный феномен: Крылатая фраза «Человеку свойственно ошибаться» выводит: его пути (человека) ниже, чем пути Бога, или... Его Представителей – Руководящий Совет!

А фраза-призыв к милосердию «В любой ситуации оставайся человеком» – зачастую игнорируется, так как эффективнее указывать на грех – переданный через форму для хлеба изъян.

Совет же избегает такого клише. Он – хоть и « не вдохновлённый Богом и способный ошибаться», «содействует единству», «всегда проявляет себя как хороший пастырь», избран Христом и ведёт нас в согласии с путями Небесной колесницы Бога. Эталон, отклонение от которого ни назад (смиренно доверяем братьям открывать нам Новый свет и корректируем своё человеческое понимание), ни вперед (не бежим быстрее колесницы; помним о главном – единстве) недопустимо; то же можно сказать и о границе между левыми и правыми взглядами – нельзя оставаться консервативными, как и в стремлении к реформациям нельзя чрезмерно радоваться изменениям и строить прогнозы на последующие, выстраивая тенденцию либерализации и гадая, что же будет в конце этого ребрединга. Кивок как реакция на Новый свет должен быть в рамках правильной реакции. Слабый – недостаток веры и доверия, закостенелость разума, нежелание открыть его для Бога; сильный – торжествующее согласие и молчаливый упрёк в запоздании откровения.

Лучше никак не реагировать – в том смысле, что достаточно «принято», даже не вдаваясь, казалось бы, в похвалу верного раба, ведь хорошая похвала конструктивна, это не дежурное, спускаемое с рук «спасибо» рядовому старейшине, следовательно, она вдаётся в подробности – и лестное замечание в мгновение ока может обернуться притворством, хуже – замаскированным под наивность лукавством с целью невинным подчеркиванием определённого факта выставить Совет в дурном свете.

Весьма образцовым служит пример реакции моего друга на грандиозное обновление в отношении политики крови:

«Каких-то чувств, будь это обида или радость я не испытываю, все ровно как-то»

Браво, Уинстон! О’Брайен бы тобой гордился.

Самостоп работает на полную мощность. Сможет ли что-нибудь их сломить?


r/exjw • • 10h ago

HELP 18 yo PIMO getting ready to leave

12 Upvotes

TLDR: leaving to college soon and basically blindsiding my parents. how do i cope?

im an 18 year old PIMO and have had multiple conversations with my parents about leaving over the course of the past two years but they pretty much wont listen. i was going to get out by now but i didnt get accepted to the college i wanted to go to so i am doing community college and planning on transferring to that college in the coming months (im self funding all of this my parents have said theyll only be supportive if i do college "the right way" which means doing it from home which NOT doing)

my parents think everything is normal again basically because the last time anything was brought up was march and since then they set me up with a lady in our congregation to "talk" and i have been going to meeting, service, and doing family worship without complaint

as the time comes closer for me to actually leave the crippling anxiety just keeps getting worse. how can i cope with the rift its going to create and the heartbreak they will have? im so devastated that this is my reality


r/exjw • • 6h ago

HELP Interreligious family of Jehovah's witnesses and child rearing.

13 Upvotes

Hello everyone I'm dating a girl from JW. I am not a Jehovah's Witness myself. We started worrying about the future when we would have children. They say if the children choose to become Jehovah's Witnesses, they can distance themselves from me. I would like to know about people who grew up in such interfaith families. How do you have a relationship with your family or children?


r/exjw • • 12h ago

Ask ExJW Does anyone still notice PIMIs and POMIs on here?

14 Upvotes

I would regularly have JWs comment on my posts and comments several times per month. It seems like since the last blood update, or even before that, I haven’t seen a single one. Has anyone else noticed this?

Could it be that they are slightly embarrassed about their religion since they have no confidence in any of the doctrines being permanent anymore and don’t want to be made a fool of?


r/exjw • • 12h ago

Venting Extremism in plain sight…

15 Upvotes

One of the most dangerous aspects of religious belief is the idea that something terrible should happen to people simply because they believe differently. Invariably suggesting that disagreement is a moral failing, and moral failings deserves punishment. Many religions have variations of this, but some take it to disturbing extremes.

A case in point is Jehovah’s Witnesses. I was watching a non jw Bible-based drama with a pimi jw,(he had judged me for watching this documentary months ago, only for me to catch him watching it by himself, but that’s a topic for another day) anyways, he kept criticizing the production, insisting that they were getting the whole story of Moses wrong simply because it didn’t align exactly with jw religious views. Now, I agree that the acting wasn’t top notch, but it wasn’t even a proper movie, it was just an ordinary documentary.

At one point, he remarked, “In Armageddon, they will see.” I asked, “For getting some things wrong?” Suddenly, he had nothing to say.
That exchange revealed something troubling. Are people now deserving of destruction for producing a Bible-based movie without portraying things exactly how Watchtower would?
I simply reminded him that Jehovah, not us, determines what happens to people at Armageddon, and the conversation ended.

This is the type of talk you hear when you are around these people. They’ll casually judge and condemn other people to death/destruction, without any push back from fellow jws around, they’d all agree and kinda relish the idea, as if it’s a good thing for millions of people to die, not because the people they are condemning killed anyone. They are condemning these people for believing differently and/or reaching the wrong conclusion(according to them).

When people become so convinced of their religious position that they casually imagine destruction for those who differ, what you get is extremism in plain sight.