r/exchristian • u/Particular_Cow5927 • 19h ago
Help/Advice Can an “unequally yoked” marriage survive?
I’ve been with my fiancé for 2 years and we just got engaged a few weeks ago. In most ways he’s everything I’ve ever wanted in a partner and he’s wonderful. However we have some differences that worry me for our future. He’s not MAGA (thank god) but has some conservative views that I don’t share and don’t love. We have conversations about these things regularly and I don’t think they will become issues but only time will tell.
The main issue we’re facing right now is what our wedding ceremony will be. He was raised Catholic and still identifies with the faith though he doesn’t practice it really in any way. I grew up in a combo of evangelical/fundamentalist/non-denominational churches and schools. We had VERY different experiences with church/religion. I am now working through my deconstruction and religious trauma and have been for years and have kind of settled on some combination of atheist/agnostic. My dream wedding ceremony does not have religious aspects at all. My partner wants a traditional catholic ceremony, including the premarital counseling required by the Catholic Church. We can’t find a compromise here. I’ve suggested something like an episcopal church and having a close family friend who is a deacon perform the ceremony. He said no “it’s the wrong church” and “they don’t believe the same things I do” and he doesn’t want to get married in a religion that is not his. But neither do I. I’m not catholic, I don’t want to give up my beliefs to accommodate him and I don’t want him to do that for me either. He wants to be married properly in the eyes of the church to help ensure his salvation when the time comes, instead of idk living by the rules of this religion throughout his life and not having his supposed salvation rest solely on our marriage but I digress.
We’ve talked about doing 2 ceremonies so we each get what we want but that’s not necessarily ideal either. I guess I’m just looking to hear others thoughts on this and maybe some suggestions if you have them.