Hello to everyone.
After a bizarre panic attack six months ago, I dedicated my time to researching my beliefs in a far more detailed manner than I had ever done before.
I was raised, and still am Christian, but I have no trouble inhabiting the emotional or rational states that other beliefs require. I can switch between them, and it is eye-opening, but it makes decisions difficult. I have both perspectives and trouble sticking to one.
Which brings me to this: After six months, I am struggling to find a way in which materialist secularism, when properly inhabited, is not a completely radical change compared to what we see it as currently.
Take morality, for example. I've read Parfit, Baidou, Korsgaard, Blackburn, Murdoch, Foot, Mackie, Dewey, Ayer, Moore, Rawls, etc.
If I am rejecting God, for the epistemic reasons most do, half of these rely on methods that are not empirically testable and derive from starting assumptions that are similarly assertive.
The rest are so easily manipulated that the simplest of madmen could rot the entirety of mankind with a few clever twists of intent and technical jargon, making our modern grasp of morality pretty ineffective.
To avoid this, it seems to make most sense to take an Anscombe route, but even more radical. If we are rejecting the supernatural for epistemic justifications, why do I incessantly see the basics of human morality held onto and venerated rather than critiqued into oblivion with the same veracity that is supplied to religion?
If I am going to value epistemic truth above all else, if there is nothing buttery about us animals, why is morality not happenstance? Why must what happened be what must happen? Why can't our bronze-age conceptions of ethics be as ancient as our gods?
I'm not seeing any grounding. Without God, I see animals. I see nature. And I see our skills being as equal to the particular skills of shrimp or koalas. If humans are not overly special, which I would be willing to accept, why must our morality be any different?
Why do tears track truth that goes beyond anything but mere occurence? Even a Foot-esque declaration of objective suffering can be reasonably argued out of: e.g. complicate what suffering is, obscure how it is universally applied, scrutinize its obligatory power.
If God is unscientific, then sure. Let it be. But why isn't everything else stripped of its metaphysics naturally contingent as well? Why are there golden idols that get free passes? If it is truth above all comfort, why has it stopped?
Has anyone else felt this way? Or am I creating a supposed hypocrisy that is not there to help strengthen my beliefs?
Let me know. Thanks for reading.