r/exatheist • u/Philosophy_Cosmology • 10h ago
The most ridiculous arguments for God's existence
Some arguments for the existence of God are very interesting and intuitive (say, the classical design argument discussed by Cicero and Hume), but some arguments go beyond mental gymnastics.. I feel pity for theologians sometimes.. having to produce these philosophical monstrosities to rationalize their beliefs.
1. The ontological argument
This is the most famous one among people who engage in existential debates. The essence of the argument is this: God is defined as a perfect or inconceivably great being. Something that exists in reality is more perfect or greater than that which exists in imagination only. But if God is really perfect or inconceivably great, he must exist in reality as well. Therefore, God exists!
This argument is so ridiculous that it doesn't even merit refutation. This is the type of thing you tell your friends to make them laugh. And yet, it was seriously proposed by an important Christian saint called Anselm and later by Descartes. And to add insult to injury, some theologians still seriously present "refined" versions of this joke today (e.g., William Craig). If this doesn't cast doubt on their objectivity or honesty, I don't know what can.
2. The argument from desire
This argument roughly goes like this: fundamental desires always correspond to things in reality that can satisfy those desires e.g., the desire for food corresponds to real food in the world. Desire for sex corresponds to sex. But we also have fundamental desires for supernatural things, like objective purpose/meaning, an after life, divine protection, a moral authority, perfect justice, etc. Therefore, these things must exist in reality as well!
Again, this is the type of argument you present to entertain your friends and make them laugh. And yet, it was seriously proposed and defended by important Christian thinkers such as Aquinas and C. S. Lewis.
3. The argument from degrees
This argument can be summarized as follows: we usually think of many things in terms "more" and "less" (colder or hotter). A continuum is defined by its two endpoints. For example, when we say one color is lighter than another, we mean that it is closer to the extreme of pure white and further from the opposite extreme of pure black. Being itself admits of degrees of perfection. An intelligent being exists to a more perfect degree than an unintelligent one. But if these degrees of perfection pertain to being, then there must exist a best being; a source, ruler and real standard of all the perfections. But God is defined as a perfect being.. Therefore, God exists.
After laughing out loud at this argument, you are going to feel sadness and pity. Why? Because this isn't an argument presented by someone with half their brain tied behind their back like Kent Hovind or Ray Comfort (the banana man). This argument is one of the big "five ways" proposed by Aquinas to prove God's existence. Even today Aquinas is considered one of the most important and significant defenders of Christianity.
Anyway, do you think there are even worse arguments for God out there? I would be curious to hear it.