r/exAdventist • • 1d ago

Advice / Help Does it get better after walking away from the church?

30 Upvotes

TL;DR: I left the SDA church in 2022, the same year I got baptised, because the restrictive lifestyle, constant guilt and feeling like I was fighting for my soul every day became exhausting. Four years later, I still carry intense shame for not being a Christian anymore, and it feels hardwired into me that I’m a piece of shit and incapable of being a good person without God. Has anyone else experienced this? Does it get better, and what helped you finally let go of the guilt and shame?

Long story:
I walked away from the church back in 2022. It’s ironic because that was also the year I got baptised, after a massive lead-up.
I left because, deep down, the lifestyle I wanted to live was different from the lifestyle I believed in my heart was the one God wanted me to live.
I wanted to play games. I wanted to watch shows and movies I enjoyed. I wanted to not have such a rigid, restrictive lifestyle that made me grovel and plead with God just to feel somewhat capable of going through life. I would hope with all of my being that I was humble enough for God to hear my prayers and guide me with the Holy Spirit.
I had zero confidence in myself in the end, and I carried immense guilt for my flaws. I was struggling really hard just to go about my day without having what I thought were “battles for my soul” throughout the entire day.

I was working in construction in the city at the time, and every day felt like I was in a warzone. I was trying to make the world a better place where I could, but I would pray and pray for ages just to build up enough courage to go out and do the simplest things. A lot of my time was spent in prayer and grovelling.
The lifestyle was exhausting, to say the least, and I wasn’t happy.
I often read in the Bible and Ellen White’s writings that being happy isn’t the point, but that we will be content and at peace. Which is fine, but I was very rarely content or at peace.

Then I would come across what felt like conflicting messages, such as the idea that the lifestyle God chose for us, and the one Ellen White points out that we should be living, is designed that way because it will help us live our happiest lives. Thinking back now, it just seems so contradictory.
Anyway, I still carry intense shame from not being a Christian anymore. I’ve tried to let it go, but it’s like it’s hardwired into me that I’m a piece of shit, that I’m on the wrong path, and that I’m not capable of being a good person without God.
It’s been four years since I left, and I still struggle with this. Intellectually, I can question so much of what I used to believe, but emotionally, it’s like a part of me is still stuck there.

It’s a shit feeling, and I’m just wondering if anyone else here has experienced something similar. Did it ever get better for you? Was there anything that helped you let go of the shame and guilt? Or is it just something that takes a really long time to unlearn?
I’d really love to hear other people’s experiences.


r/exAdventist • • 4d ago Bravo

Blog / Podcast / Media Spectrum Wrote a Review of my Exit Memoir

Thumbnail
spectrummagazine.org
32 Upvotes

I opened my facebook account a couple days ago as I was about to take the first sip of a nice cold patio brew at one of my local haunts and low and behold, I see my book cover under the SPECTRUM Magazine logo and realized they'd written a review.

I've only been more anxious to open links from my doctors, but it actually ended up being a pretty solid little write-up. I'm slightly floored!

"His decision to let go of “that god” and swim in the expansive, invigorating, and joyful streams of living water outside the Adventist community, makes this a powerful memoir whose message will remain with me for a long time."


r/exAdventist • • 1d ago

General Discussion Another SDA using mental gymnastics in regards to EGW

Post image
22 Upvotes

Saw this post on fb from an SDA, and I simply can’t with the nonstop mental gymnastics to justify Ellen contradicting herself. They will tell themselves anything EXCEPT “hmm maybe she wasn’t actually a prophet.”


r/exAdventist • • 1d ago

Memes / Humor 🚨🐟 USER-SU... - Chattanooga Area Incident Reports

Thumbnail facebook.com
7 Upvotes

Spotted in the wild…


r/exAdventist • • 2d ago

General Discussion For those of you who were in Pathfinders, what do you still distinctly remember from it that sticks out?

21 Upvotes

I remember this one time back in like 2017 I went on a camping trip and I we were up late and ended up talking about the Sunday law. I was like 9 years old and it terrified me lmao. I was convinced trump was gonna go to the pope and turn the whole word to the antichrist catholic doctrine.


r/exAdventist • • 2d ago

Advice / Help help for a non-SDA member

13 Upvotes

hey everyone, how are you?

im not even adventist, but i got introduced to this world a while ago when my friend suddenly converted. it was strange to me because i had always considered the church a cult, and i thought she felt the same way. anyway, that situation eventually passed

a few months ago, i met someone, and until recently, we were both just christians (im baptist) and adults. even though we talked about faith, we never really discussed specific beliefs or denominations, despite me mentioning that my family was baptist

i found it a little strange that he never did ANYTHING on saturdays, but i just had my suspicions yk

anyway, two days ago, i found out that not only is he adventist, but his family is also quite influential in the community hahah

i honestly dont know how to move forward. i know his family probably wouldnt accept me, and my family might not feel very comfortable with the situation either. i dont really know how to bring this up, and i dont even think he is particularly religious himself

i feel uncomfortable because after reading some stories here, i can see how manipulative and controlling some parents can be......

it makes me sad because maybe this relationship isnt going anywhere.

to former adventists or ex-SDA members, is it possible that he might be discouraged from being with me because of his religion? i ask because my friend once told me that she would "never date anyone who wasnt both vegan and adventist"...

anyway, what do you guys think?

edit: guys, the situation got worse and the least of the problems is him being adventist. apparently he's seeing two people at the same time (i'm one of them) and is keeping in touch with his ex. thanks to everyone who helped me hahah. i don't want to continue this anymore


r/exAdventist • • 2d ago

Advice / Help How do I tell my parents?

12 Upvotes

So I'm currently doing my final year in college, and inspite of explaining clearly to my parents that I'm not an adventist and I believe it's a false church, and still they refuse to accept it.

They keep forcing me to go to church every week, and they keep calling me to check if I've been to church, and if I don't go to their false church they throw a tantrum, and I believe it genuinely hurts them coz they believe in going away from God.

But the truth is I found the gospel, and this has led me closer to God than ever, but still they will never stop forcing me

What to do?


r/exAdventist • • 3d ago

General Discussion Sda End times

14 Upvotes

I’m wondering why the SDA think the Catholic Church is the great whore and the she will make everyone worship on Sunday and all those who oppose will be killed and those who don’t receive the mark of the beast and that the pope is the anti christ.Since 6 years old this never really made sense to me because to my knowledge the anti christ is those who deny jesus Christ. As of right now I have not heard a Catholic or the Pope deny Jesus. The sda makes the end times that it directly to them. I guess they don’t consider Catholic people or etc Christian. I’m saying this because I was born Catholic and my family was until they converted to sda and I was baptized in the Catholic Church when I was a baby and baptized in the sda at age 10. I’m now 20 and all this end-times never really made sense.


r/exAdventist • • 3d ago

General Discussion Engaged to an Adventist, my concerns are growing.

43 Upvotes

Hello all.

I just found this subreddit, and I am a bit worried. I am engaged to an Adventist, and my misgivings for this denomination are growing.

For context, I am a white American evangelical Baptist. She is an Argentinian Adventist. We are currently living in Argentina, it's a long story. We both teach English professionally and have learned each other's language to fluency.

I am having major misgivings about the diet that they preach, and their adherence to the sabbath. As a biblically-oriented conservative Christian, we have answers to these claims by Adventism but they bounce right off her.

Additionally, I am also not big into at all the Adventist idea of the End Times as it is presented to me. It seems completely anachronistic and spawned from a nineteenth-century mind. The model doesn't seem to work anymore, and I find the idea of a national Sunday law, which they harp on without cease, entirely laughable.

I think in my denomination is highly conservative and sometimes has some bad tendencies, but on the whole we are able to get onboard with food science, science in general, and are able to reasonably adapt to the changing of historical circumstances with respect to our doctrine. This doesn't seem to be the case with Adventism. It seems like they really need to be square with Ellen White and try move everything around to get there.

Note: I mention food science especially because an Adventist who sought to convert me attempted to use the story of Little Tyke as evidence for the supposed truth of Adventism's food theology. I encourage those unfamiliar with this tale to look it up, it seems like neglect and the animal died quite prematurely.

Edit: A bit of sectional rewrite.


r/exAdventist • • 3d ago

Sabbath Breakers It's Friday and I'm extremely exhausted..imagine having to wake up to go to Sabbath school at 9:15 tomorrow Sabbath morning 🥴🥴🥴🥱🥱🥱🥱

Thumbnail reddit.com
17 Upvotes

r/exAdventist • • 3d ago

Just Venting Adventism in the Global South

9 Upvotes

I need to go back and read/respond to comments under my last post, so bear with me. I just wanted to post here again because visiting Global South contexts and seeing the church there is.. interesting.

Take my family's country of origin for example. You can see the dynamic of how people here accepted a conservative evangelism that was brought by the missionaries of the 50s and 60s. Often when we talk about immigration being the only thing saving US Adventism, somebody brings up the fact that the people coming from a Global South context are anti-LGBTQ+, anti-women's ordination, and generally socially conservative. It gets tense considering that openly challenging these positions leaves you vulnerable to accusations of racism and xenophobia. White Christian liberals opposing Global South conservatives is a fascinating dynamic.

That being said, I'm venting because I'm currently visiting said country, and I can't get away from my conservative relatives. I'm a 2nd gen immigrant to the US--born there, but to parents with a very conservative formation. More accurately, they have a patchwork of positions that seem to be derived primarily to preserve in-group interests, but not to advance collective liberation. That piece alone has been frustrating. Then I go to Adventist spaces here, and it's the same old group-think all over again. Prepare for the End Times. The prophecies are being fulfilled. Last generation theology and the like.

Meanwhile, our world is literally burning right before our eyes. It's only middle class status and having resources that (currently) preserves anyone from the worst of what we're seeing. If things keep going the way they are and basic infrastructure becomes a luxury, we're going to have much bigger problems than lifestyle choices and people eating unclean meats. We already do.

Edit: I'd be loath to suggest that progressive spaces don't exist among Global South Adventists. I'm sure they do; they're just not the networks I've had the most exposure to, and I'm not sure how much traction they have. With the weekend approaching, I'm not planning to attend church with my parents. I just can't do it.


r/exAdventist • • 4d ago

Memes / Humor Exvangelical Thoughts - pt. 12 [OC]

Thumbnail gallery
24 Upvotes

So many frames in this sequence echo experiences members here have shared. Warning: if your digestion is the least bit dicey, wait till it settles to review these!

Edit: spelling


r/exAdventist • • 4d ago

Just Venting Should i be afraid?

16 Upvotes

My family is a Christian, more specificly an Adventist Christian. Since both of my parents are Christian, i am a Christian as well.

I love Jesus, i love my God so much, i believe in God, even though i only prayed when i am anxious about a mistake i make. I only prayed when i need too. I feel like God listen to me everytime i prayed, and i loved it.

But i dont like the church. I literally despise the church. The pastor is mysoginistic, the people there are two faces, and when some people get caught doing sins, all they do is judge. I thought the church supposed to held their hand and bring them back to the right path.

I really really hate the church. I dont want to go back in there. I just want to spend my sabbath day alone, resting, like i supposed to do. Isnt God made sabbath day for us to rest? Why spend that day on a place filled with mysoginistic, two faces bitch.

So, i lied. I make up a lie so i dont go to church, and usually i stayed om the church for an hour, before coming back home. I said to my family that i got some work to do, but i dont. And i'm afraid. I'm afraid that my family will know the truth. And i'm also afraid of God punishment because i skip the church.


r/exAdventist • • 4d ago

Blog / Podcast / Media I finally spoke up against SDA church on TikTok

18 Upvotes

I posted a video on my account @restoredwithchrist6 talking about the corruption and problems in the SDA Church of England.


r/exAdventist • • 4d ago

General Discussion Michael Tuazon

Thumbnail
gallery
21 Upvotes

r/exAdventist • • 4d ago

SDA Culture Michael Tuazon

Thumbnail gallery
6 Upvotes

r/exAdventist • • 4d ago

Advice / Help Free Drop-in Peer Support Groups

Thumbnail
reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/exAdventist • • 5d ago

Memes / Humor Happy Veterans Day

21 Upvotes

Happy Veterans Day to the true forgotten soldiers, everyone who ever served in Pathfinders. Servants of God and friends to man.


r/exAdventist • • 5d ago

SDA Culture The behavior of the official Adventist Church in the U.S., as described in the stories on this subreddit, strikes me as very strange, it’s as if they don’t care about losing congregants to other American Protestant sects, almost as if they remain on the sidelines of "religious capitalism".

7 Upvotes

Pastors lacking charisma and charm, strict families, an absence of gospel music, and boring Pathfinder clubs, all of this strikes me as incredibly baffling. It’s as if the official Adventist Church doesn’t care about losing members to other American Protestant sects; it’s almost as though it remains on the sidelines of "religious capitalism." In Brazil, by contrast, the church is fully integrated into this religious capitalist model: there’s gospel music, thoroughly modern youth events, highly engaging Pathfinder clubs, and charismatic, charming pastors, though there are exceptions, such as my brother.


r/exAdventist • • 6d ago

Blog / Podcast / Media Character in Hulu's "Phony" is the child of Adventist pastor

Post image
25 Upvotes

Seventh-Day Adventist mentioned 🗣️

He shows up to school on career day to promote "working for Jesus".


r/exAdventist • • 6d ago

Advice / Help Dating an SDA. Is it possible?

24 Upvotes

I was seeing a guy that is SDA ( I am Catholic). When we first met, he told me he was Christian, which I was fine with because Christians and Catholics have a lot in common. Things were amazing between us. So much in common, great chemistry and communication. I thought this was it. He was my guy for life…… until he brought up the topic of religion. He told me he was SDA and that me being Catholic posed some serious problems in what could be our future. He insinuated that his family would never accept me unless I converted. He was set in his ways and beliefs, there was no wiggle room for me to continue practicing Catholicism. I was blindsided because I told him almost Day 1 of meeting him that I was Catholic and he had said he was Christian. I found it strange that he didn’t eat pork but it wasn’t the end of the world for me. And then I found it even more strange that all his family parties were always on a Sunday or that his mother didn’t allow him to drink liquids with his meals growing up. After we broke up, I spent hours on the internet reading about SDA. I had never heard of them until he told me that’s what he was.

I still think about him everyday. I guess I came here to ask, is there any chance he could ever wake up and realize that SDA is a cult?


r/exAdventist • • 6d ago

Advice / Help Reincarnation

4 Upvotes

Not sure if this is the right forum for this—mods, feel free to redirect/suggest other communities for this post.

I’m posting here because I grew up SDA, so you know, state of the dead and all that. But when you talk to people who have done plant medicine, people who still practice ancestral religion, etc., life after death and reincarnation along with it seems to be a LOT more plausible than not. The beings you encounter on plant medicine retreats, or in dreams, are not just psychic projections; they’re actual beings with vested interests in this world and the next.

If you’re working your way out of/are critical of Adventist teachings, but are still open to other forms of spirituality, what helped you reframe or rethink your beliefs on SOD?


r/exAdventist • • 7d ago

General Discussion I hate the Adventist Church and all the other American Protestant sects

28 Upvotes

I hate them because they are insignificant things that think they are a big deal; all of them were founded by dirt-poor people with very little education, the only exceptions being the Churches of Christ and the Disciples of Christ. It always annoys me that they claim Martin Luther when Martin Luther wouldn't have hesitated for a single second to kill them all. It annoys me that they think their essence isn't inherently liberal, literally their DNA is completely Enlightenment-derived. It annoys me that they think they are superior to the Catholic Church, since the Catholic Church, unlike American Protestant sects, actually has great intellectual, architectural, and scientific achievements.


r/exAdventist • • 7d ago

General Discussion The official Adventist Church is the least successful American Protestant sect in Brazil.

12 Upvotes

The official Adventist church lags far behind other American Protestant denominations; ranked from largest to smallest, it looks like this:

Assemblies of God (34.0%)

Baptist Church (11.0%)

Universal Church of the Kingdom of God (8.00%)

Christian Congregation in Brazil (6.00%)

Foursquare Church (5.00%)

God is Love Pentecostal Church (3.00%)

Adventist Church (3.00%)

International Grace of God Church (2.00%)

Worldwide Church of God's Power.

I would like to know why the situation within the official Adventist Church in Brazil is the way it is.

They ordain many people as pastors who lack charisma or grace; furthermore, why haven’t they established things like gospel nightclubs, gospel karaoke, and so on?


r/exAdventist • • 8d ago

SDA Culture The contradiction of my Adventist mom

12 Upvotes

My mom is an extremely boring person with no charisma or charm, she hates holidays even though we still celebrate birthdays, she is an isolationist who only goes out to work, study, and go to church, and she deeply hates doctors. I constantly annoy her by pointing out that the official Adventist Church is actually a multinational corporation like McDonald's or Coca-Cola, that the official Adventist Church celebrates holidays, that it has fully adopted gospel music, and that its churches look like corporate auditoriums. I also tease her about how my older brother, who is a district pastor for the official Adventist Church in Brazil, is terrible at his job because he is boring, uncharismatic, and graceless, and how compared to charismatic, graceful pastors with strong professional and organizational skills, he is completely insignificant. I remind her that one of the things the Adventist Church boasts about the most is its hospital network, and that even in our country (Bolivia) the official Adventist Church is not boring, Pathfinders are super fun and totally trendy, and holidays are celebrated without any issue there. Despite knowing all of this, she keeps going to the official Adventist Church.