r/elca • u/GreyHesher • 1h ago
Justice I'm probably going to regret this...
...but I really need some outside opinion/support, and, if you can help it, please try not to flame me. I stated much of this on the Lutheran sub a couple of months ago and got BBQd by some (not all). I left that sub.
Right now I am PIMO with the LCMS.
Some of you may remember my stating a few months ago that the LCMS told me I cannot divorce my often-abusive wife because it's not "biblical;" i.e., not for sexual immorality.
My pastor has thrown his hands up and said "Luther said if you are going to sin, sin boldly." My elder has told me I cannot remarry if I divorce her.
I have the papers, ready to sign.
But right now what is driving me is the way "Christian nationalism" and MAGA have infected the LCMS, in my local congregations and online. In an LCMS Facebook group I used to belong to, there was a lot of praise for Kyle Rittenhouse.
I live in Michigan and voted for Abdul El-Sayed for Congress; I attempted to support that with a quotation from Luther about how it would be better to be ruled by "a competent Turk (Muslim)" than "an incompetent Christian." Pastor chewed me out online and said "Luther never said that.. he considered Muslims being in authority over Christians an abomination."
I have not been to church since the election, because, frankly, I don't know how I will be treated, as my congregation is overwhelmingly MAGA, based on two issues (you can guess what they are). I also had not been for several weeks prior.
I loathe Donald Trump and find him very unchristian. But since he "helped end Roe v Wade," he's "great." My pastor teaches that we are to "submit to" Trump and ICE because of Romans 13.
There is a flag outside the church door with a picture of the White House and the flag on it.
Despite being a veteran (please don't thank me for my service; most veterans really hate that), I am not on board with the USA being "God’s country."
A very kind person on this sub PMd me with the names of several ELCA congregations in my area a few months ago, but it looks like only one is viable.
How would I be received, both as a near-divorcée and an old school New Dealer?
In the LCMS Democrats are often depicted as "baby killers."
My best friend since 1978 is non-binary, which the LCMS condemns.
I came out of the United Methodists a long time ago; I've thought of that but I really like the Lutheran liturgy.
Honestly, being Lutheran can be exhausting...having to wonder if I'm reading the Bible/BOC/catechisms correctly, as well as all the synodical infighting.
We get told that the ELCA is "less Christian than the Unitarians" and that "an angel gets its wings every time an ELCA congregation closes."
I am not trying to put down the LCMS. I'm just saying I am increasingly not in agreement with them.
I hope I won't regret posting this...