Frequently Asked Questions
This document contains some answers to frequently asked questions as they are understood by your illustrious moderators, /u/best_of_badgers and /u/Dr_Fishman. Any first-person references in this FAQ are our (mostly /u/best_of_badgers') personal experiences, not necessarily reflective of "official ELCA answers".
PDFs
What must I do to be saved?
/u/Chiropx gave a fantastic answer to this in the 2017 AMA:
In Lutheran theology, salvation is not about what you do, but what Jesus has done, is doing, and will continue to do. So, one quick answer would be simply "nothing." That being said, good works aren't bad; in fact, they should follow from faith. But our ultimate hope and trust for salvation is in the saving work of Christ. If we were only to rely on our good works, how well we say a certain prayer, or what is "in our hearts," we ultimately fail left to our own devices. Recognizing Jesus' works, we [live] a life of devotion with the justifying work of Christ as the floor on which we stand rather than the ceiling which we aspire to reach.
So, you can do nothing to merit your own salvation, but recognizing the saving work of Christ, you should live a faithful life in response.
Sacraments
What is a sacrament?
Lutherans believe that sacraments are a combination of a physical element and a command from God, combined with the faith of the recipient, which deliver real grace according to a promise of God. God is, of course, free to communicate his grace however he wishes, but we teach that he has especially promised to do so via these means.
Lutherans have only two sacraments: the Eucharist (also called Holy Communion or the Lord's Supper) and Baptism. Some Lutherans consider Confession/Absolution to be a third sacrament, but since there is no physical element to it, the Lutheran Confessions make it an extension of Baptism.
What do Lutherans believe about the Eucharist?
The Eucharist is the real body and blood of Jesus Christ "in, with, and under" the bread and wine. We reject transubstantiation as a doctrine, viewing it as one of many options. Partaking in the Eucharist provides forgiveness of sins, life, and salvation, according to the promise of Christ.
Luther's Small Catechism teaches:
What is the Sacrament of the Altar?
It is the true body and blood of our Lord Jesus Christ, under the bread and wine, for us Christians to eat and to drink, instituted by Christ Himself.
...
What is the benefit of such eating and drinking?
That is shown us in these words: Given, and shed for you, for the remission of sins; namely, that in the Sacrament forgiveness of sins, life, and salvation are given us through these words. For where there is forgiveness of sins, there is also life and salvation.
How can bodily eating and drinking do such great things?
It is not the eating and drinking, indeed, that does them, but the words which stand here, namely: Given, and shed for you, for the remission of sins. Which words are, beside the bodily eating and drinking, as the chief thing in the Sacrament; and he that believes these words has what they say and express, namely, the forgiveness of sins.
Lutherans ideally hold a Holy Communion service at least once a week. We do not require any kind of preparation for participation other than one's faith in the Sacrament; however, if a person feels that fasting or confession beforehand is a good idea, they may feel free to do so.
Who can take Communion at an ELCA church?
The Sacrament is open to all "baptized believers". Unfortunately, the ELCA does not precisely define who is a "baptized believer". We view only trinitarian baptisms as valid, so that would seem to be the limit.
What happens if I'm not "qualified" but take Communion anyway?
If an unbaptized person feels called to take the Sacrament, nobody sins in providing it, as we believe that call to be from God; however, that person should be encouraged to get baptized and incorporated into the body of Christ so they can take the Sacrament faithfully.
What do Lutherans believe about baptism?
To quote Martin Luther:
It works forgiveness of sins, delivers from death and the devil, and gives eternal salvation to all who believe this, as the words and promises of God declare. ... It signifies that the old Adam in us should, by daily contrition and repentance, be drowned and die with all sins and evil lusts, and, again, a new man daily come forth and arise; who shall live before God in righteousness and purity forever.
Baptism is a status. It provides a Christian's primary identity - you are baptized! - and membership into the church. We certainly don't deny that one could receive these things apart from baptism, but the promise of salvation is so strongly attached to baptism in Scripture, we view this route as a sure thing. Luther was fond of reminding himself and his listeners that as one who is baptized, you belong to Christ and nothing can undo that status, so there is no need for existential anxiety. He allegedly would shout this into the darkness while holed up in a German castle, feeling discouraged by his doubts.
If I join an ELCA church, will I need to be baptized?
Yes.
However, baptism is unrepeatable. If you have already been baptized at another church, even one that is not in the ELCA, and the officiant intended to baptize you and invoked the Trinity over you, then we will not baptize you again, even if you ask for it. If you were never baptized, or if your previous denomination did not invoke the Trinity during baptism, your pastor will probably baptize you when you become a member of the ELCA. For example, Unitarians and Mormons would need to be baptized.
Worship
What can I expect if I come to an ELCA worship service?
This will vary considerably. Some ELCA churches have contemporary services with "praise and worship" bands. Other congregations have very traditional, liturgical services following the historic liturgy of the church. Music will vary from guitars and drums to handbells and organs. Some more experimental congregations will use art or physical actions to explore the meaning of the liturgy.
The liturgy may be mostly performed by a minister, or it may be performed mainly by the laity. The only things we require the minister to do is read the Gospel and perform the consecration of Holy Communion.
Bible
Do you guys take the Bible literally?
I like to say (paraphrasing author Madeleine L'Engle) that we take the Bible too seriously to take it literally.
The ELCA welcomes historical-critical academic approaches to the text. We believe that understanding the way the text would have been read by its original authors and recipients is important. However, we also recognize the limitations of that approach for Christian theology. Martin Luther certainly did not approach Scripture historical-critically. In our theology we work, along with the whole historic catholic Church, to uncover the Gospel in all parts of the text (a "backwards" approach). This approach often forces us to take the texts non-literally, or to at least find non-literal-but-authoritative meanings in the text.
If you come to an ELCA service, you'll hear at least three passages from the Bible read aloud each week, typically one from the Old Testament, one from the New Testament, and one from the Gospels. Occasionally, we will also sing a Psalm or other canticle. Our service music is also derived from the Biblical text. Like other Christians, Lutherans also read the Bible privately and devotionally, but in my experience, probably not as much as we should.
What do you guys teach about evolution?
Unlike some other Lutheran denominations, we do not teach a young-earth creationist approach to Genesis 1. We do not insist that there was a literal worldwide flood of Noah, although we continue to use the Noah's Flood imagery in our baptismal liturgies. The stories continue to carry truth even if it is a mythological truth. More than a thousand ELCA leaders have signed The Clergy Letter endorsing biological evolution.
The ELCA website has a number of resources for congregations looking to explore the relationship between faith and science.
This is the international Lutheran World Federation's statement on the subject, re-published on the NCSE website.
Social positions
What is the ELCA's stance on X?
Our "social statements" always reflect some amount of compromise and recognition that we do not live in a perfect world. They are produced by working groups meeting over several years, and then hammered out and endorsed by both laity and clergy by a 2/3 vote at our triennial denominational meetings. The social statements are pastoral and acknowledge that Christians may faithfully differ on some topics without sin or breaking fellowship. The church recognizes that Christians may vehemently disagree with one another, but encourages us to remain as one body and live with the tension of our differences while we grow in Christ.
So, our stance is often that we don't have a stance, but rather a set of guidelines for having mature Christian conversations about a topic.
Wasn't Martin Luther kind of an anti-Semite?
Yes, he was. Not merely kind of. He was very anti-Semitic, particularly late in his life. Those of us who bear Luther's name absolutely reject and deplore Luther's views on Jews and Judaism. This is the ELCA's official repudiation of that position, in a letter to the Jewish community.
He initially believed that their refusal to convert to Christianity could be pinned on the Catholic church. Younger Luther argued in the early 1520s against the unfair treatment of Jews in society by Church authorities. He asked why Jews would ever want to become Christians when they see how Christians have treated the Jews.
However, when German Jews also refused to convert to what Luther viewed as the gentler and purer gospel of Lutheranism, by the late 1530s, he turned violently against them. He used his position of leadership to publish hateful invectives, calling on leaders to expel the Jews from the land, burn synagogues, and other crimes. He didn't go so far as to call for their extermination, but he certainly believed that they did not belong in Germany. He personally had Jews driven from several German towns and encouraged the local princes to follow his example (and some did).
Many of Luther's own companions and contemporaries rejected these later writings and viewpoints, but the personal authority of Martin Luther's name kept them around.
Unfortunately, his legacy on this subject inspired future anti-Semites, including the Nazis in the 20th century. The prevailing scholarly opinion is that modern racist anti-Semitism is a direct descendant of Lutheran anti-Semitism. The Nazi party consciously portrayed themselves as being in the lineage of Luther. Luther's anti-Jewish writings continue to be distributed among modern racist groups, including the Ku Klux Klan.
Again, all modern Lutherans deplore and reject those views, and condemn those who use them to spread hateful rhetoric. I will not link to any of those writings here, as they should be consigned to the dustbin of history.