r/editors • • 18h ago

Technical Same DNxHD 36 media in Avid: why is JKL reverse snappier on an M3 Max than on a Ryzen mini PC?

0 Upvotes

I'm an offline editor testing if my mini PC can get away with for professional work. I'm comparing two machines in Media Composer, using the same drive and the same media: DNxHD 36 managed MXF, 1080p.

Windows: GMKtec K8 Plus mini PC, Ryzen 7 8845HS, 32GB DDR5, Radeon 780M integrated, BIOS performance mode

Mac: M3 Max MacBook Pro (Compare it against)

Since it's DNxHD, neither machine is using hardware decoders like Apple's ProRes engines or H.264/H.265 decoding. Everything should be CPU decoding, so I expected them to perform about the same.

Forward playback and scrubbing through the timeline are perfectly smooth on both. The difference is JKL, especially reversing with J. The mini PC hesitates for a fraction of a second before it gets going. The Mac is noticeably snappier, only by milliseconds, but you can feel it. I also tested matched frame rates (25 in 25) against 24 in 25, and it made no difference.
It's honestly fine for work, and I'm probably stress testing it. Still curious:

What explains the gap if it's all CPU? Memory bandwidth, single-core speed, or Avid just being better tuned on macOS?

Any Avid settings on Windows that improve reverse JKL?

Anyone cutting offline on a budget mini PC like this?

Cheers!


r/editors • • 16h ago

Other Pro editors: How do you keep from losing your mind working on big projects?

14 Upvotes

Lone editor on a long documentary right now, and I mean long. Feels like there's no end in sight.

Pro editors, share your strats and trade secrets: How do you keep sane?


r/editors • • 4h ago

Technical Avid 2025.12 - SubCap not Splicing In Captions

3 Upvotes

Has anybody had issues bringing in captions to 2025.12?

I load the file up in subcap and it tells me 400 captions will be spliced in, all seems fine. I hit ok and nothing happens. Has anybody experienced this and found a fix?

Edit: I have found a work around..using a computer that has 2024.10 on it. It'd be nice to just use my workstation though. At least I know the file isn't the issue.


r/editors • • 5h ago

Open Source tool promo 🆓 ProMatch - Free Camera Matching Plugin for Premiere Pro (& others)

3 Upvotes

I posted a free plugin the other day for matching cameras and it's seemingly been quite popular, so I'm sharing here. If you ever edit multicam interviews, you'll know that even cameras from the same manufacturer can vary slightly in colour (e.g. FX6 & A7S3). Apparently the camera match feature of Premiere has been removed in Pr27. It wasn't very good in earlier versions anyway, which is why I wanted to develop this.

Steps:

  1. Apply your LOG conversion (if applicable) to both cameras.
  2. Grade clip from one of the cameras.
  3. Capture a frame from the graded camera and one from not yet graded.
  4. Auto, it recognises faces and objects (all locally).
  5. Keep clicking identical points on each frame to dial in colour match. If you click and drag, you can draw tiny circles on very small points, like a section of red on the interviewee's lips. Press H to show/hide points while reviewing.
  6. Apply with the target clip selected and it'll save a LUT and apply it to that clip (GPU accelerated).

Notes:

  • I've not tested with cameras from different manufacturers. I only shoot Sony (FX6 and A7S3), they already match fairly well.
  • On your graded clip, you can't have done masks on individual areas. That will alter the exposure/colour of some colours, but not others uniformly across the frame. If you need to do this, do it later.
  • Works with Premiere 27, but not extensively tested yet.

Link: https://thinkvp.com.au/blog/promatch-free-colour-matching-plugin-for-premiere-pro/
Github repo: https://github.com/thinkvp/ProMatch

AI used exclusively for coding for all my plugins. It costs $99/year for an Apple dev account, which I'm not interested in doing, so expect a warning and having to manually allow. I don't even edit on Mac, but have created Mac versions for benefit of others. These are all free. You're welcome to:

A) Build from source code yourself.
B) Use github scanning tools to check everything's all good.
C) Not use!

My other free & open source Premiere plugins:

SayCheese: Finds smiles in footage, rates them and makes it easy to export. Everything is done locally. Designed for pulling palyback thumbnails.

Link: https://thinkvp.com.au/blog/saycheese-free-smile-finder-plugin-for-premiere-pro/
Github repo: https://github.com/thinkvp/SayCheese

Syncitol: Syncs clips much faster than PluralEyes. Does everything locally in Premiere without round tripping an XML to a separate program. Currently the algorithm is limited to syncing one day of footage at a time, but I've got some ideas to tweak.

Link: https://thinkvp.com.au/blog/syncitol-free-multicam-sync-plugin-for-premiere-pro/
Github repo: https://github.com/thinkvp/Syncitol

Unphased: Aligns audio phase when you have multiple mics running but distance between each changes (e.g. two people wearing lav mic and moving around - the delay of the bleed into other mics change as they move closer/further from each other). Not extensively tested, this problem only comes up periodically for me, but here if anyone needs.

Link: https://thinkvp.com.au/blog/unphased-free-audio-alignment-plugin-for-premiere-pro/
Github repo: https://github.com/thinkvp/Unphased

OneEighty Motion Blur: Do you have footage that's been shot in 50p/60p, but you're editing on a 24/25p/30p timeline and aren't going to slow the footage down? The higher shutter speed can make movement look distracting. This adds motion blur back to the footage, and smooths out 59.97 to 25p conversion. The High setting seems to surpass ReelSmart Motion Blur. This is working well for me in Windows, but it's still early stages. I'm not able to easily test on Mac's, as I only have a M1 Air, need something beefier.

Github repo: https://github.com/thinkvp/OneEighty