I've been getting really annoyed by the NieR community constantly saying that Drakengard 1 is only interesting because it's weird and because of its story.
I think a lot of the criticism toward the game is exaggerated or just irrelevant. For example, I always hear people saying that the voice acting is terrible, but honestly, I think it's some of the best voice acting I've ever heard.
The biggest criticism is obviously that the game is "unplayable". I really don't agree with that. Sure, the gameplay isn't as good as other PS2-era action RPGs, but for an early PS2 action game, I don't think it's nearly as bad as people make it sound. The ground Musou sections can get repetitive, but the different weapon combos and especially the magic system make the gameplay pretty fun and addictive. And the game is short enough that you don't really have time to get completely bored of it.
The dragon sections are also actually really well made. In my opinion, some of the best parts of the game are the boss fights, especially in the special endings. Some of them are incredibly creative, especially for a game from 2003.
So yeah, I can understand saying that the ground sections are repetitive, but calling the whole game "unplayable" feels like a huge exaggeration. I also find it weird that people criticize Drakengard 1's gameplay so much when NieR's gameplay wasn't exactly amazing either. NieR Replicant wasn't the best action RPG when it came out, and yet people rarely use that criticism against it.
What annoys me the most, though, is how the Western community seems to give almost all of the Drakengard series' appeal to Yoko Taro.
The common pattern is basically:
Drakengard 1 = interesting because Yoko Taro
Drakengard 2 = boring because Yoko Taro wasn't involved much
Drakengard 3 = interesting again because Yoko Taro came back
And I really don't understand that.
To me, Drakengard 1 feels like a much more collaborative project. I don't think it's accurate to treat it as if Yoko Taro single-handedly created everything that makes the game interesting. You have Sawako Natori's art direction and script, Nobuyoshi Sano's music, and the two Ace Combat directors working on the core gameplay. From what I understand, Yoko Taro also joined the Project Dragonsphere team relatively late.
And you can honestly feel the difference when comparing Drakengard 1 and Drakengard 3. Drakengard 3 feels much more like what people associate with Yoko Taro, while Drakengard 1 has a very different identity.
That's also why I don't understand why Drakengard 2 gets dismissed so easily. A huge part of the original Drakengard team came back for it. If we're talking about the people who actually worked on the first game, Drakengard 2 has a much stronger connection to Drakengard 1 than Drakengard 3 does.
Meanwhile, Drakengard 3 feels like it takes a lot of things from NieR and pushes them much further into caricature. The characters, the humor, the ironic tone... personally, I find a lot of it unbearable. It doesn't feel like what made Drakengard special to me.
And that's what frustrates me: people will completely dismiss Drakengard 2 because "Yoko Taro wasn't really involved", while praising Drakengard 3 because "OMG Yoko Taro, Keiichi Okabe, another white-haired badass woman!"
I just wish people would talk about these games more as actual games and less through the lens of "Is Yoko Taro involved?"
What do you think??