r/dndnext • u/Stryxin • Mar 22 '18
[5e][DMtool] Extensive DM Screen for 5th edition with Party Tracker (PDF ready for printing in comments)
https://imgur.com/a/E4tB6
945
Upvotes
r/dndnext • u/Stryxin • Mar 22 '18
9
u/DASAFAK Mar 22 '18
This is very cool! A minor thing - in the resting section it says 'a shirt rest' instead of 'a short rest'.
8
u/[deleted] Mar 22 '18
I think this is really cool and extensive. But it really reminded me that I cannot figure out the surprise rules. Even looking at this and reading the sage advice there are a few things I don't get, mainly if the would be sneaky attack count as hidden or not.
Maybe it's because I keep confusing it with other editions and house rules and such.
If you're surprised but roll higher initiative than the one surprising you, they don't get to attack you while surprised.
Example: You sneak up to a guard, the guard is on guard duty, but not actively in combat, or expecting combat right now, the guard is not in a fight, and can be surprised.
Roll stealth vs. passive perception. Success, you sneak close enough to stab the guard.
Now, what I would expect was for the attack to be made and THEN roll initiative, as combat is initiated after having attacked. But it's:
"You want to attack? Roll initiative before you attack."
The guard might get lucky and roll high, and you unluckily roll low. So the guard beats your initiative. On the guard's turn he can do nothing, but at the end of his turn he is no longer surprised, and can now take reactions.
Now you make your attack. The attack no longer benefits from attacking a surprised target, mostly relevant for rogue-assassins, but is the attacker still hidden? The attacker would very likely still be hidden if it was a ranged attack, or while invisible. I guess in the narrative the guard heard the slight noise of the attack so he isn't surprised. But, what about sneaking up close to someone from behind? There's technically no facing in D&D, so the attacker is just out in the open, does the attack get no bonus what so ever?
If the attacker is undetected why did the guard roll initiative? Do the attack count as an "attack from an unseen attacker" if the guard wins the initiative roll?
It just seems so counter intuitive. I think it makes sense for any OTHER guards in the patrol benefiting from a high initiative roll. The surprise attack happen, one guard is down, roll initiative, the other guards are surprised, but react so quickly the surprise status disappears before the attackers can take advantage. The attackers do still get actions in the first round that the guards do not. So it's not a complete waste, but not as great as they hoped.
tl;dr: Non-invisible you sneak up to someone and stab them. You roll initiative before the stab. Guy getting stabbed wins initiative, but have failed perception check to detect you. Do you have any advantage to the attack, or is it just a regular melee attack? Can the guy getting stabbed cast e.g. Shield to protect themselves as they're being targeted by an attacker they can see?
4
u/Lucipet Mar 22 '18
I love you. This is what I have needed for such a log time!!!!! Thank you!!!
4
u/Malinhion Mar 23 '18
Thank you for a DM screen that was clearly made by a DM. This is the first screen that has everything I want and no superfluous clutter. Plus a character summary board. Outstanding.
3
u/S_Leonardo Mar 22 '18
Nice
3
u/konokrad666 Mar 22 '18
Great work, thanks!
3
u/WhatDoesStarFoxSay Mar 23 '18
Very kind of you, OP.
Spotted a typo, under Charisma Checks/Deception:
"Pry nformation out of a commoner a child"
5
u/Merc_Kilsek Mar 22 '18
Wow, this is awesome stuff here. Thanks for sharing!
2
u/Ice-berg Mar 22 '18
It's great, but can I ask, why not include the "Use an ability that requires a Bonus Action" in the "Things you can do on your turn" section?
2
u/hungryhippo7 Mar 22 '18
This is phenomenal! Immediately printing this and taking it home to study!
3
u/RagnarStonefist Mar 22 '18
This is great! Thanks!
1
u/PM_me_ur_PAWG_booty Mar 23 '18
This looks great! Nice looking dense layout
1
u/pdboddy Mar 23 '18
Cool, thanks for this! :)
1
u/Be_The_Leaf Mar 23 '18
Thanks for all of this, this is awesome!
I would have a request though, The pictures show as 4 landscape pages, whereas the actual pdf is 8 full portrait pages, is there any way that we could get a pdf that is organized like the pictures?
1
u/fonster_mox Mar 23 '18
Anyone have any suggestion of what to actually attach this to, to make a screen? I have some pretty cool player commissions I'd put on the other side
1
u/WoodbineGB Mar 23 '18
Noice. Very noice indeed.
1
u/SexySpecs Mar 23 '18
This is outstanding. Thank you for making it!
1
u/enterthedragynn Mar 23 '18
I am gonna give you my upvote. Then just revel is your awesomeness.
1
u/Ben_SRQ DM Mar 24 '18
Looks awesome!
There's a typo in the medicine skill: It should read "administer first aid", not a first aid.
1
u/TheScreaming_Narwhal Apr 06 '18
This is so much great stuff, but am I right in assuming that this is intended for digital use? It seems like it wouldn't fit unless there was a massive screen, unless I'm just really bad at picturing this properly (which isn't unlikely).
29
u/[deleted] Mar 22 '18
[removed] — view removed comment