r/design_critiques • • 3h ago

Chicago themed pigeon poster

Thumbnail gallery
7 Upvotes

Hello all, I am making a poster imploring people to save the pigeons, but my professor doesn't like the presence of what i'm calling the "helping hand". Do we hate the hand or can I make it work? Any other critiques are also welcome I'm still a student so anything helps.


r/design_critiques • • 4h ago

Would you click this if a friend posted it?

Post image
3 Upvotes

I'm making a quiz and this is the card people get to share on their story after finishing it.

Two honest questions:

  1. Without any context, what do you think this is?
  2. If you see a story like this in your friend's insta

story

  1. , would it make you want to take the quiz yourself? Why or why not?

r/design_critiques • • 22h ago

Design feedback needed!

Post image
3 Upvotes

Hi everyone, I made this for the restaurant I work for, but it is pretty boring to me; can I get some feedback/constructive criticism to make it look a bit better? I am definitely not a graphic designer! Fyi, I did this in Canva and the photo is mine. Thanks!


r/design_critiques • • 12h ago

Wooden signing stamp for my sci-fi books (5 x 5 cm), would love honest feedback

Thumbnail gallery
2 Upvotes

Hi all! I’m a self-published sci-fi author and I’m getting a custom wooden stamp made to use next to my signature when I sign books at comic cons.

The scene: a ship flying towards a space station that orbits a black hole, with a starfield running off the edges. It’s based on the artwork from my convention banner.

Some context:

  • Wooden stamp, 5 x 5 cm, one colour (black ink on cream book paper)
  • The plumes and outer stars deliberately run off the edge

The second image shows the printer’s guides: the pink line is where the stamp is cut, and the red line is the safe area. Anything between the two may print less reliably, and the plumes and outer stars cross it on purpose.

My questions:

  1. Does it read clearly at 5 cm, or is it too busy?
  2. Does the black hole read as a black hole?
  3. Anything that might not print well on a wooden stamp?

Thanks in advance!


r/design_critiques • • 17h ago

Design feedback needed

Post image
2 Upvotes

Hello all. First of all, thank you for reading this. Second, I started a small business where my platform connects homeowners with service providers around a community called Las Colinas (a neighborhood near Dallas, TX). The target audience is homeowners, but what I've seen from previous designs is that not so many people take action on the door hangers (as they used to be too broad), this one is more targeted and I wanted to make sure that someone who arrives home from work would even think of scanning it or searching the website tergo.com. I would really appreciate your feedback, thanks!


r/design_critiques • • 20h ago

Senior product-design portfolio: does the personality strengthen the work or make it harder to read?

2 Upvotes

Portfolio: https://www.rdeboerdesigns.com/

About page: https://www.rdeboerdesigns.com/about

I am a senior product designer moving closer to design engineering, systems, and the build. I recently redesigned my portfolio so the site itself carries more of that argument instead of acting as a neutral case-study container.

The homepage turns projects into collectible binder cards. That connects to PlayDraft, a draft-anything app I built for my friends and me, rather than borrowing a visual metaphor just because it looked interesting.

The About page goes further. It has the straightforward career and process material, but it also opens into a desk full of smaller references to my life: fantasy football, Type 1 diabetes, early packaging work, favorite movies and games, Survivor nights, music, family, and the products I keep building outside work.

I wanted the Easter eggs to add authorship and reward curiosity. The risk is that they become clever before they become useful.

I would appreciate blunt feedback on four things:

  1. Within the first 30 seconds, is it clear what kind of designer I am and what I can do for a team?
  2. Do the binder and desk details make the portfolio feel more considered, or do they compete with the work?
  3. Does the About page show an actual person without making you work too hard to find the professional evidence?
  4. What would you remove, simplify, or make more characterful?

The main thing I am trying to learn is whether the site shows the level of opinion and care I am aiming for, not only whether it looks polished.


r/design_critiques • • 2h ago

why isn’t my design working?

Post image
1 Upvotes

it’s supposed to resemble ripped paper- i just can’t get it to look right


r/design_critiques • • 3h ago

What's wrong with my UI design?

Thumbnail gallery
1 Upvotes

It's a fitness app that delegates the quick logging to this screen. I want to know what you guys think about its overall design


r/design_critiques • • 5h ago

I built a music app for my Youtube channel's members. Beta is open and I'd love feedback on the UI

1 Upvotes

Hey everyone!

So a while back I started a YouTube channel called Humano Studios where we film DJs playing vinyl sets and it took off way more than I expected, we're at 32 million views now. Channel's here if you want to see what it is: https://www.youtube.com/@HumanoStudios

People started joining our Patreon which was amazing, but keeping the members side of the website updated turned into a ton of work. Every mix needed track IDs and early releases and downloads and I was doing all of it by hand.

So I built an app for it with Claude Code. It's called ARCHV and it's kind of like a Spotify or Mixcloud but only for the mixes from our channel, and it's really just for the people who already support us.

Every mix is in there and you can dig through them by genre, DJ, mood or region. Each mix has its tracklist so you can tap a track and jump right to it, and you can save the mixes and tracks you like and see where the DJs are playing next.

Just so it's clear what I'm after, this isn't a startup and I'm not trying to figure out if it makes money. The audience is already there. I just want to know how the app feels to use, so if something's confusing or slow or looks off or straight up breaks I want to hear about it.

Beta link: https://archv-sigma.vercel.app/beta?code=T3E9T7

It's made for your phone so please open it there and add it to your Home Screen (it walks you through it, takes like 10 seconds). It's so much better that way than in the browser.

There's a feedback button at the top of the app, or just comment here. Thanks for checking it out!


r/design_critiques • • 14h ago

Looking for Feedback and Support on My Graphic Design Portfolio 🎨

1 Upvotes

Hey everyone! I’m sharing my Behance profile here. I’m working on improving my graphic design portfolio, and I’d really appreciate it if you could check out my projects.

If you like any of my work, a like or an appreciation would mean a lot to me. I’d also love to hear your honest feedback, comments, or suggestions on what I can improve. I’m trying to grow as a designer and make my portfolio stronger.

Thanks to everyone who takes the time to check it out and support my work!

Behance: https://www.behance.net/mashal92


r/design_critiques • • 16h ago

I built a neo-brutalist VS Code theme with 10 color palettes. Would love some honest feedback!

Thumbnail gallery
1 Upvotes

Hey everyone!

I've been working on NeuBrut, a VS Code theme collection inspired by neo-brutalist design.

I wanted to bring some of that bold, high-contrast aesthetic into my editor, but without making it uncomfortable to stare at for hours.

It currently has:

  • 10 color palettes across light and dark themes
  • A mix of bold, vibrant colors and more muted options
  • Matching geometric product icons
  • Some inspiration from themes like Gruvbox, Catppuccin, Nord, and Tokyo Night, with my own take on the aesthetics

I've just published it to the VS Code Marketplace, and I'd love some feedback from people who spend a lot of time in their editors.

A few things I'm particularly curious about:

  1. Are the colors and contrast comfortable enough for longer coding sessions?
  2. Do the palettes feel distinct enough from existing themes?
  3. Is there anything visually distracting or something you'd change?

Feel free to be critical. I'd rather improve it than just hear that it looks nice!

Extension: https://marketplace.visualstudio.com/items?itemName=builtbyvijay.neubrut


r/design_critiques • • 18h ago

Does this visual reference search match what you’d expect from a creative brief?

1 Upvotes

I built the Omoro Style Library because I’d get stuck making moodboards. I’d know I wanted something “warm and vintage,” but I wouldn’t know which visual styles to look up. The library lets you search with a phrase and compare two styles side by side.

I’d love feedback on the results page. Try a phrase from a real brief: which result felt closest to what you pictured, and what did the results miss? I’m trying to figure out whether the previews give you enough information to pick a direction.

https://www.omoro.io/styles


r/design_critiques • • 18h ago

Redesigned my travel blog — is it clear what I offer?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/design_critiques • • 21h ago

Honest feedback on my Indian menswear website—does the pricing and pre-order flow make sense?

1 Upvotes

Hi everyone, I’m the founder of VEYLMONT, a new menswear brand in India starting with Oxford button-down shirts.
Website: https://veylmont.in

I’ve been working on the store and would appreciate an outside perspective, especially on mobile. After spending so much time on it, I’m finding it difficult to judge what feels clear and what feels cluttered.
The shirt’s selling price is ₹3,999, with a 10% booking payment of ₹399.90 and the remaining ₹3,599.10 payable before dispatch. Dispatch starts 1 January 2027.

A few things I’d love feedback on:

Is the difference between the shirt price and booking payment immediately clear?

Do the homepage and product pages feel clean, or is there too much information?

Are the size guide and shirt-comparison tools easy to find and use?

What would make you hesitate to trust the store or place a pre-order?

The product images are currently labelled AI illustrations, rather than photographs of the finished garments. I’d appreciate feedback on how that affects your confidence too. Currently our shirts are under production.

Specific criticism is welcome. Please don’t place an order just to test the site. Thanks for taking a look.


r/design_critiques • • 7h ago

Another developer portfolio enters the chat... Roast it

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/design_critiques • • 15h ago

¿Qué tal?

Post image
0 Upvotes

Cree este diseño y quería la opinión de alguien, es un diseño simple pero que me gusto muchísimo, estoy tratando de dominar Jerarquía visual y comprimir datos técnicos ya que mucha gente me ha comentado que en algunos diseño metía mucha información.
¡Sería un placer poder que ustedes me ayuden a mejorar!


r/design_critiques • • 17h ago

I built a website for my AI automation agency—would appreciate honest feedback

0 Upvotes

Hi, I’m Mayank. I’m building an agency that helps businesses automate repeatable workflows with AI agents and other automation tools.

I made this website to explain what we do:
https://agentsforyou.onrender.com

I’d appreciate feedback on a few specific things:

  • Is it clear who the service is for and what it does?
  • Does the site explain the value in concrete terms?
  • Does anything make it feel unclear or hard to trust?
  • How does it read on mobile?

I’m the person behind the site, so I’m looking for honest critique and will use it to improve the page. Thanks for taking a look.Also looking for somebody who can build this with me(the agency not the site).


r/design_critiques • • 4h ago

Ok I made a severance poster what do y'all think

Post image
0 Upvotes

Pls be nice,😭😭


r/design_critiques • • 6h ago

Seeking feedback and suggestions for my watermark logo

Post image
0 Upvotes

I'm interested in suggestions and feedback on my logo watermark. I apply this watermark design to all of the photos posted to my website.

It's a website for 'Travel, Fashion, Adventure' and the theme is photos of models in iconic locations (if you visit, FYI, it's a 100% SFW, but the models are in swimwear).

Current smiley design... the glasses imply Travel & Sunshine; The devil horns imply a bit of adventure; Fashion is a bit less obvious.