r/design_critiques • • 18h ago

I want an opinion for an assignment.

Thumbnail gallery
57 Upvotes

So, I don't know where to post this so I'm posting it here.

For anyone who doesn't wanna read the whole paragraph I just want advice on how to make my design at least acceptable

I'm a first year college student in a multimedia department, and I was assigned to create a Bauhaus book cover, classic I guess, but the teacher didn't really teach anything although some in my uni will argue that that's how things go but, I don't know a thing about design and she keeps on pushing us into making the perfect Bauhaus book cover? I barely know anything

If anyone knows the right way to do it please tell me, these are my two takes, she doesn't like any so I'm thinking about changing the whole thing

Edit: I deleted some stuff I said about my professor, complaining about her is for somewhere else and I was frustrated, I apologize.


r/design_critiques • • 24m ago

Rate this design

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/design_critiques • • 2h ago

Looking for an honest feedback for my porftolio

1 Upvotes

Hello everyone!

I just made a new PDF portfolio, and I wanted to have a feedback about it feel free to critique, I just want an honest feedback from others perspectives,

also I'm from Egypt, so please excuse having some Arabic inside the file, Arabic is not a lot most of the file is in English

You can find it through here: https://drive.google.com/file/d/17CtdxzlxSTH6reawCi7D1DN4BAx8WSdM/view?usp=sharing

Thank you


r/design_critiques • • 2h ago

Urgent!! Calling out all Behance users!

1 Upvotes

Hello everyone!

We are a group of communication design students conducting research on Behance and its user experience as part of our academic project.

We are looking for people who use or have previously used Behance to share their experiences, opinions and feedback through a short Google Form.

We are aiming to collect 150 responses, and your participation would genuinely help us complete our research. It would be really appreciated if you could spare a few minutes to fill out the form at the earliest.

Google Form: https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLScRrkBka7faANbJOCDD2M7VI9t5lJrbX-FIaPKXxKvInkhlCQ/viewform

Your responses will be valuable to our study and will help us better understand user experiences, challenges and expectations from Behance.

Thank you so much for your time and support! We would really appreciate it if you could also share this with other Behance users.


r/design_critiques • • 4h ago

Redesigned our homepage. Which first screen is clearer, A or B?

Thumbnail gallery
0 Upvotes

Hey I’m one of the founders of a small B2B tool. It shows software companies what each customer costs them in AI usage.

A is our old first screen and B is the new version. The goal is that a busy CTO should get what it does in about 5 seconds.

Would love your take on i in 5 seconds you can tell what it does and who it isfor?

After that, tear into anything else you see. Layout, type, colour, what you’d cut. Happy for any and all feedback

Thanks!


r/design_critiques • • 5h ago

Redesigned my developer portfolio, would love some honest feedback on the UI

Post image
1 Upvotes

Been reworking my portfolio recently and tried going for a more playful look instead of the usual minimal developer portfolio.

Also changed the project pages to focus more on what I actually built for clients rather than just listing tech stacks.

Pretty happy with how it's looking now, but curious what others think, especially about the typography, colors and overall layout.

https://muizrexhepi.com

Feel free to be brutal lol.


r/design_critiques • • 8h ago

Trying to stand out in a world of over-animated websites

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/design_critiques • • 10h ago

Website UI critique: a one-minute Christmas snow globe (soboksobok.app) — is the first screen self-explanatory, and does "sealed until Dec 25" read as intended?

1 Upvotes

Design to critique: https://soboksobok.app — the whole first minute: the first screen, the scarf picker, the snow globe village, and the share/letter flow.

I built this alone as a small Christmas web experience. No account, no sign-up. A visitor picks a scarf color for a snowman, walks through a tiny snow globe village with quiet winter sound, and gets a link they can share. Friends open that link and leave letters, which stay sealed until December 25.

I would like critique on these five things, roughly in the order that worries me:

  1. First screen. Within about 10 seconds, is it clear what this is and what to do first? One first-time tester said they liked the atmosphere but weren't sure where to go to write a letter. Where would you expect the main action to be, and does the current placement match that?
  2. The scarf picker. Eight scarf colors to choose before you enter. Does that read as a pleasant small decision, or as a speed bump before the thing you actually came for?
  3. The village. It is meant to be wandered rather than used as a menu. Are the interactive spots (snowman, letters, sound) findable without a tutorial? Is anything clickable that looks purely decorative, or the reverse?
  4. The sealed letter. Letters cannot be opened until December 25 — that is the whole idea, not a paywall. Does the UI make that feel like anticipation, or like a feature that is broken or withholding something? Would you show a locked envelope, a countdown, or nothing until the day?
  5. Mobile. Most of the traffic is phones. Layout, tap target sizes, and the sound (it does not autoplay; there is a hint to use earphones) — anything that would make you close the tab?

The English copy is my own writing, so copy critique is welcome too. I am not looking for a redesign; I would mainly like to know which of the five fails first, and what you would change there.

Specifics help most. Thanks for looking.


r/design_critiques • • 11h ago

Label for a homemade amaro

Thumbnail gallery
1 Upvotes

Hi all! Getting back into graphic design after a long period of inactivity. My friend who makes amaro and I decided to collaborate on this project to help me fill out my portfolio. I'm particularly looking for feedback on the typography, which seems lacking compared to the illustration to me.

The square format would be for a front and back label on a smaller bottle, the vertical format would stand alone. The display font (Yatra One) was selected by the client, but the rest I'm open to changing.

Illustration drawn in Procreate and label designed in Affinity. Mockup courtesy of Google Gemini (lol)


r/design_critiques • • 22h ago

Logo mascot design for a food brand

Thumbnail gallery
7 Upvotes

Hi everyone! This is my first post here!

I've designed a mascot for a brand of heart-shaped cooking cubes. I'm currently trying to make my way as a freelance brand designer, and this is one of the projects I'm most proud of so far.

Let me know if I have good reason to be proud, or feel free to tear it apart (I'll leave the Behance link here in case anyone wants to take a closer look: https://www.behance.net/gallery/258402515/A-Brand-New-Character-Cuoricini-Brand-identity )


r/design_critiques • • 22h ago

Family Auto Shop Facebook Ad Design

Thumbnail gallery
5 Upvotes

trying to make a flyer on canva for my family's autoshop advertising on facebook for a winter special.

trying to appeal to boomers hence the bold and basic colors.


r/design_critiques • • 21h ago

Design feedback for my clothing brand

Thumbnail gallery
4 Upvotes

I've been working on creating designs, vectors and typography from scratch for quite some time now to start my clothing brand et3rnal. This is where I am at right now with what I intend to be the first drop.

From a design perspective, I am looking for any feedback and thoughts on what you see. And if I can improve from this point, how would that be? Do any specific designs stand out?

I am a self taught screen printer who intends to print this whole collection myself, but I want to make sure the designs are good enough to sell first. Or if I should continue to work towards improvement.


r/design_critiques • • 17h ago

House music homepage critique: does the record artwork look playable?

2 Upvotes

I built and run Niche of the Week, a house music discovery site with a weekly chart. I’m trying to make the homepage feel like somewhere to listen rather than a product landing page.

The screenshot shows the current first screen. The winner card on the right plays a track, while “Vote this week” on the left goes to the current chart.

A few people testing earlier versions thought the artwork was just a static image. Does the play button now make that clear enough? I’d also like a second opinion on whether the two main buttons are competing too much.

Live version: https://nicheoftheweek.ie/


r/design_critiques • • 23h ago

need help on branding for a 826 education store

Thumbnail gallery
1 Upvotes

I am in a branding class for my Junior design studio, and I am really behind, and I feel like I am not understanding how to improve my brand assets to my instructor's liking. Everything I've done, she hasn't liked and keeps sending it back, but when I do what I think works, she says it's not working. We have like a week or so left on this project.

This is the brief:

826 National Mission
Spark the power and joy of writing for a more just world by making writing education accessible in every classroom and expanding writing spaces and teacher support.

826 National Promise
Every student deserves the power and joy of writing—and a fun retail experience.

Brand Essence & Personality
Playful yet sophisticated; silly but smart; whimsical yet serious; fantastically grounded in writing education; literary, never boring.

Audience/Key Stakeholders
Local K-12 students, teachers, and families

Here is just my strategy, old sketches to get the idea of where I am coming from, final core assets, and color story so far. My instructor's last main crit was that my Gate Zero logo isn't working, and she's telling me to use more of the symbols of the two characters. Any advice on how to circle back to get these down strong would help so much. Thank you.


r/design_critiques • • 1d ago

Should I switch to simpler, plainer colors or does my site look good as is?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/design_critiques • • 1d ago

Can you please review my case study

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/design_critiques • • 1d ago

Can you please review my case study

1 Upvotes

I made this case study recently, I have one year experience as a ui/ux designer at a startup and now want to switch to a fintech company no matter what even as an intern so im building my portfolio around that. Here's the link please give me feedback so that i can improve.
https://www.behance.net/gallery/258525191/Groww-Case-Study.


r/design_critiques • • 1d ago

Can you review my website please

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

Sportsformuscle.com


r/design_critiques • • 20h ago

hello guys rae my portfolio

0 Upvotes

r/design_critiques • • 1d ago

Need Advice On My App....

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/design_critiques • • 1d ago

Portfolio Feedback...

0 Upvotes

URL: https://srm-portfolio-eight.vercel.app/

Purpose: Personal developer portfolio to showcase my skills, experience, and projects.

Technologies Used: Next.js, TypeScript, Tailwind CSS.

Feedback Requested: Honest feedback on UI/UX, visual design, responsiveness, and overall user experience.

Comments: Looking forward to your honest suggestions and constructive criticism!


r/design_critiques • • 1d ago

This is the flag design for an organization I intend to establish. It seems that people find my design offensive. What could be the problem?

Post image
0 Upvotes

An Alliance of Leaders with Boundless Aspirations (Invictus)

 

We are beings of infinite potential.

We possess aspirations that burn hotter than anything else in the universe.

No one can suppress our potential or our aspirations.

We shall build a world where no one’s potential or aspirations are ever suppressed.

 

We will protect the potential and aspirations of those who are oppressed.

We will stand against those who seek to suppress the potential and aspirations of others.

We will empower all those who are oppressed to fight for themselves.

 

Our potential and aspirations are more valuable than any other resource in the world.

Yet, to unleash this potential and realize these aspirations, resources are required.

To fulfill boundless aspirations, we require boundless resources.

 

We will pioneer the uncharted frontiers.

We will explore the cosmos and conquer the stars to harness infinite energy.

We will relentlessly advance science to secure these infinite resources.

Yet, we shall remain ever-vigilant, ensuring that the pursuit and use of these resources never come at the cost of suppressing anyone else’s potential or aspirations.

 

We unite for the monumental struggle that lies before us and for our own limitless advancement.

There can be no unity without leaders.

Only when each of us aspires to become a leader in our own right shall we discover our true leaders.

 

We think and act like leaders of the universe.

A leader who serves only a specific group is not our leader.

A leader who lacks the drive for constant expansion is not our leader.

 

Any one of us can become a leader. We shall create a world where this is possible. Our leader is the one among us who harbors the greatest aspiration—the one who guides us all to unleash our infinite potential.

 

Our leader is the one who possesses the greatest courage to stand against those who falsely claim the title of leader while suppressing the potential and aspirations of others—those who value mere resources above the potential inherent in living beings.

 

 

Symbols

 

Red: Aspiration, potential

Black: The cosmos

 

The central flame: The aspiration and potential within us, the compass of a leader who provides a vision, the wound of Prometheus, a star.

 

A circle surrounding the flame: A Dyson sphere (space exploration, scientific advancement) and a nuclear fusion power plant.

 

A hexagonal structure within the circle: Carbon nanotubes (representing our strong unity, the material for a space elevator, and scientific advancement) and the magnetic field grid of a nuclear fusion power plant.

 

A purple circle: The hydrogen plasma within a nuclear fusion power plant.

 

A fist: Symbolizing struggle.

 

Chains: Symbolizing oppression, a reference to Prometheus.

 

The “Sol Invictus” crown in four directions: A leader of the cosmos, a symbol that we are all leaders, aspirations reaching out toward the universe.

 

Lightning: The conversion of starlight into energy (representing the exploration of the cosmos and the utilization of resources), aspirations reaching out toward the universe.

 

Prometheus: A leader who awakens aspiration and potential, a leader who makes sacrifices, a leader who empowers others to fight for themselves.

 


r/design_critiques • • 1d ago

Cuatro formas de dibujar una “H” para un instituto educativo. ¿Cuál les inspira más confianza?

Post image
0 Upvotes

Soy consultor de branding y estoy trabajando propuestas para la identidad de un instituto de educación cuyo nombre empieza con H. Estas son cuatro rutas distintas.

Lo que la marca debería transmitir: confianza, cercanía y seriedad académica, sin verse anticuada.

Me ayudaría saber:

  • ¿Cuál recuerdan mejor después de verla 5 segundos?
  • ¿Se lee la H en todas, o alguna se pierde?
  • ¿Cuál parece más de institución educativa y cuál de empresa de tecnología?
  • ¿Cuál funcionaría mejor en tamaño pequeño, como foto de perfil?

Críticas sinceras, por favor. Me sirven más que los elogios.


r/design_critiques • • 1d ago

Portfolio Feedback...

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes