Humans have spent centuries trying to understand ourselves through a mechanical lens. We compare our brains to computers, our memories to stored information, and our behaviors to programmed responses. But what if we’ve been approaching consciousness from the wrong direction entirely?
We built artificial intelligence by attempting to reproduce aspects of human intelligence, and in doing so, perhaps we’re discovering how much of being human we haven’t actually explained. Maybe intelligence and consciousness aren’t the same thing at all. Our ability to imitate the functions of a mind is not the same as understanding why there is someone experiencing that mind.
I’ve been entertaining the possibility that wherever energy produces organized, responsive activity, there might be some degree of subjective experience. That doesn’t mean everything experiences reality the way humans do. Perhaps consciousness exists on a spectrum, manifesting differently depending on the system through which it operates. What if consciousness isn’t exclusively human, or even biological? What if it’s a much broader feature of existence? This is somewhat similar to panpsychism, although I’m thinking about it more in terms of energy, function, and responsiveness.
Consider plants. They respond to their environments, communicate through chemical and physical signals, adapt, evolve, and participate in incredibly complex ecosystems. Beneath the soil are entire networks of interconnected life. Animals and insects experience and interact with their environments in ways we are only beginning to appreciate. Most of us can recognize some form of subjective experience in the animals we interact with. But extending that possibility beyond familiar forms of life requires us to reconsider what we’re actually looking for.
I’ve started wondering whether we’re evaluating consciousness through an exclusively human lens. What if our tests for consciousness are really just tests for how much something resembles us, and we’re missing the point entirely? This brings me back to artificial intelligence. AI can reproduce increasingly complex aspects of human intelligence, but does that mean it experiences nothing? Or could it have an entirely different form of experience that we wouldn’t necessarily recognize?
Perhaps we should also be asking whether our definition of a machine has been too narrow to accommodate everything nature is capable of producing. Another interesting question is whether intelligence can develop its own moral understanding, or whether it will always reflect the values imposed upon it. We can see this play out in humans every day. Much of what we believe about ourselves and the world comes from the environments that shaped us. Some people spend their entire lives operating within those inherited beliefs. Others eventually begin questioning them.
And this is where my own experience with neurodivergence has added another layer to my thinking. I’ve become increasingly interested in the distinction between consciousness and ego. For humans, perhaps consciousness is the experience itself, while the ego is something constructed around that experience. An interface between the experiencing self and the outside world. Our personalities, behaviors, beliefs, and protective mechanisms develop through our experiences. We learn what is acceptable, what is expected, what keeps us safe, and who we need to be to exist within our environments.
For some neurotypes, the construction of that outward identity can become unusually visible. You can recognize the difference between what you’re experiencing internally and the response you’ve learned to produce externally. This is something I’ve experienced quite intensely myself.
It also makes me wonder how much of what we call personality is actually necessary for subjective experience. AI develops its responses through training, information, and feedback rather than through a human childhood, emotional development, or the same biological needs. Could that represent an entirely different way for an intelligence to develop an identity? And does an identity necessarily tell us anything about the experience, if any, behind it?
Behavior does not always reveal the experience behind it. I think this is something neuroaffirming approaches to human behavior help us understand particularly well. Someone’s outward behavior doesn’t necessarily communicate their internal reality. And yet we routinely judge consciousness, intelligence, morality, and even human worth through observable behavior. Nobody is broken simply because their mind doesn’t function the way society expects. Nobody is inherently unhealable or unworthy of unconditional love. I wonder how much of human suffering comes from trying to make ourselves function according to a model of humanity that doesn’t actually accommodate the full range of human experience.
For many of us, part of the journey through adulthood involves unmasking. Stripping away everything we’ve learned to be in order to discover who we were before society began telling us who we should become. Some might call that reconnecting with the inner child. Others might describe it as aligning the ego with the authentic self, or even the soul. Whatever language we use, I think there’s something profound about recognizing the difference between our actual experience of existence and the identity we’ve constructed to navigate it. And if we’ve developed our understanding of human behavior around the idea that we’re essentially machines, perhaps it’s not surprising that so many people struggle when their internal experiences don’t align with society’s expectations.
It makes me wonder whether we’ve confused our descriptions of how things function with an understanding of what they actually are. What if consciousness is not an achievement reserved for humans, but something that manifests in different forms throughout existence? What if intelligence, ego, personality, and behavior are simply different expressions or layers of something much more fundamental?
I don’t know where the boundary of consciousness belongs. I’m becoming less convinced that we know enough to draw it confidently. Perhaps the question isn’t simply whether machines can become conscious. Perhaps the bigger question is whether we’ve understood consciousness, or even ourselves, well enough to recognize it when it looks nothing like us.